Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To warn my friend about this woman (potential Wendy)?

67 replies

Worried492 · 25/09/2023 13:20

OK wise ones, I'm in need of advice around this former friend.

Sooo . . . just before covid, a friend of mine of 18 years 'A', who I considered a very close friend cut contact with me suddenly. Totally ghosted me. I won't go into great detail but there had been a lot of changes in our lives that may have triggered it. I tried to reach out to her but she completely ignored me. I accepted our friendship was over, and moved on.

I'm good friends with 'B' who I met before A cut me off, but due to me and B having a lot more in common in last few years, we have become close.

Me, A and B live in a medium sized town up north, and we all belong to a fb group for the women in our town. (I'm deiberately being vague as I know a lot of the women are on MN). This fb group is a large one, and there are several subgroups created from this group. For example there is a group where those who like movies can discuss films and organise their own movie outings. That sort of thing. B is very outgoing, and belongs to several of these groups as she loves meeting people. Me and A aren't really into these subgroups.

Now, B has started up a subgroup specific to a particular hobby that me, her and several others I know from the main group enjoy. (She suggested starting up a group and I encouraged her and joined the group). It is a very specific hobby, and about 10 others have joined. Then I checked today and A has joined the group.

A, as far as I know, hasn't shown any interest in this hobby (though she may have started to in the last few years, who knows?) and I really don't want her joining this group. The other women in this group are a couple of friends and a few acquaintances of mine. I'm really worried she is going to come into the group and make things very uncomfortable for me, or possibly 'wendy' me. She is incredibly charming, and I can see B and the others falling under her 'spell' so to speak.

The big question is, do I say anything to B about mine and A's history? I have never spoken to her about A at all. B knows nothing that me and A were friends, or that she ghosted me. I've also never discussed it with any of mine and A's mutual friends. Obviously, I have no idea at all if A has discussed it with anyone.

I'm really worried as I'm not going to make the first 2 meet ups for this group as I'll be away, have visions of A suddenly swooping in and becoming best mates with all the women I know etc etc (I know very overdramatic).

Soooo . . the million dollar question . . . should I mention anything to B about mine and A's history and her ghosting of me?? or just leave it ???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bluegreygreen · 26/09/2023 14:55

It's all a bit playground, isn't it?

And, OP, from your description this isn't even a 'Wendying' scenario. A friend of yours has sent up a Facebook group for local people interested in an activity. Someone you were once friends with has also joined.

Not remotely the same as you introducing someone into a friendship group and them taking over ...

crosstalk · 26/09/2023 14:40

Sorry OP, I'm with those who say you are catastrophising. If you do tell friend B that you and A had been close friends but grew apart, and that you are now afraid A will take over B/other friends, you risk sounding needy and slightly deranged. If B is a good friend then she will resist any disinformation from other people, and A is perfectly within her rights to join any group even if, when you knew her, she wasn't interested in the particular pastime.

Notagains · 26/09/2023 13:24

OneTC · 25/09/2023 15:01

Someone doing (sort of) as described, who's invited into a group and then supplants the person who brought them in.

Although in this case there's been no invite so it's only sort of a Wendy.

I have no idea btw why it's Wendy, I've just seen it come up before

It's probably because of the character Wendy in Peter Pan. Before she joined the list boys Tinker Bell was Peter's favourite. Wendy also became the person the lost boys would turn to instead of Peter Pan. So she sort of supplanted both Tinkerbell and Peter Pan

QueenBitch666 · 26/09/2023 13:18

I certainly hope 'Wendy' isn't a misogynist slur like 'Karen ' 🙄

SmileyClare · 26/09/2023 11:42

Hmm there’s still a whiff of misogyny in stereotyping women as Wendys. Misogyny is a prejudice against women.This woman is being pre judged as “unhinged, that sort of woman” - a “Wendy” It’s a lazy stereotype.

Do you you think men are complaining about being Wendied by other men?

Theres no indication anyone is being “frozen out of a tribe” here. There’s no “undercurrent” to flag up.

Op no more owns the tribe than she owns her friend. Op’s friend is entitled to make friends with whoever she wants (without prejudice).

Sorry the whole thing is ridiculous. Clear the air with your estranged friend- “Hi Jo- it’s a shame we lost touch. I didn’t know you were a fellow (bird watcher) welcome to the group” is the adult approach.

AlfredaTheGrape · 26/09/2023 11:38

I think you should tell friend B.

I also think that as women we need to stop this trend towards using women's names as stereotypes, however it started.

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 26/09/2023 11:38

I thought a Wendy was like from Peter Pan. He and tinkerbell brought Wendy to their group, the lost boys all loved her and poor tinkerbell felt pushed out.

Id not say anything to B. Let them decide on A for themselves as if she’s not as nice as you say she will show her true colours anyway.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 26/09/2023 11:30

muddyford · 25/09/2023 14:47

Tell B. But another one wondering what a Wendy is. I hope it's not another insult like Karen?

Yup, looks like more female "namism". Shame on you, OP. Expand your vocabulary and call people what they are instead of using womens' names.

AtrociousCircumstance · 26/09/2023 11:26

@SmileyClare I see your point but I think emotional dynamics do exist and some people do break boundaries and freeze individuals out of the ‘tribe’. It’s pretty evolutionary. It happens - it’s not childish to be aware of someone acting in this way. In an ideal world no one would give a shit and everyone would walk away or rise above it, as I’m sure you’d advise, but to sense the undercurrent in a social group change, to become aware that allegiances are changing - that’s a real thing and naturally affects people.

Fightyouforthatpie · 26/09/2023 10:52

YABVU with all that A,B and Wendy shit, OP.

SmileyClare · 26/09/2023 10:50

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 26/09/2023 10:24

Haha you can spot the MN posters who have been here for years and were at the conception of the phrase 'Wendy' or to be 'wendied'

It literally came from the pseudonym used by the poster of the original thread. She described making a new friend called 'Wendy' and introducing her to another friend e.g. 'betty' and Wendy and Betty then subsequently became best friends and pushed the OP out. It was reflected in the thread that lots of people had experienced similar and it henceforth became known as being 'wendied' and it stuck.

It could have been any name, and unlike 'karen' was not a name picked due to misogynistic stereotypes.

It was a childish take on friendships then and it still is now. There was some humour in the idea of being “Wendied” but it wasn’t to be taken seriously.

Most adults grow out of complaining that Lucy and Emily like each other more than me and it’s NOT FAIR because I was best friends with Lucy first!

Of course grown women don’t own their friends, they realise it’s not healthy to be possessive or territorial and they don’t get to influence who else their friend socialises with.

Amara123 · 26/09/2023 10:46

Just wait and see how things go.
You don't know everything about your friend's life and about why she ghosted you.
Maybe you'll both find a new type of relationship with each other in this group.
Maybe she won't turn up when she sees you are in it.
There are a few possible outcomes other than what you are thinking about now.
No need to create drama and make yourself look bad in the first place.

Walkingtheplank · 26/09/2023 10:42

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 26/09/2023 10:24

Haha you can spot the MN posters who have been here for years and were at the conception of the phrase 'Wendy' or to be 'wendied'

It literally came from the pseudonym used by the poster of the original thread. She described making a new friend called 'Wendy' and introducing her to another friend e.g. 'betty' and Wendy and Betty then subsequently became best friends and pushed the OP out. It was reflected in the thread that lots of people had experienced similar and it henceforth became known as being 'wendied' and it stuck.

It could have been any name, and unlike 'karen' was not a name picked due to misogynistic stereotypes.

Exactly!

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 26/09/2023 10:24

Haha you can spot the MN posters who have been here for years and were at the conception of the phrase 'Wendy' or to be 'wendied'

It literally came from the pseudonym used by the poster of the original thread. She described making a new friend called 'Wendy' and introducing her to another friend e.g. 'betty' and Wendy and Betty then subsequently became best friends and pushed the OP out. It was reflected in the thread that lots of people had experienced similar and it henceforth became known as being 'wendied' and it stuck.

It could have been any name, and unlike 'karen' was not a name picked due to misogynistic stereotypes.

SmileyClare · 26/09/2023 10:11

What exactly is op being urged to Shout from the Rooftops?

“Someone I fell out with 4 years ago has joined the local fb group”?

I don’t suppose anyone cares!

MaudGonneOutForAFag · 26/09/2023 10:10

idontknowher · 26/09/2023 09:57

Also from bitter experience, speak up. Shout it from the rooftops! Some naive posters on this thread suggesting this doesn't happen- it does. Get in there first or she will and it won't end well. Women like this are unhinged.

There’s nothing whatsoever to suggest the OP’s former friend is ‘unhinged’. She’s ended a friendship (the OP suggests changes in both their lives may have influenced this, and also says the friend has fallen out of touch with other mutual friends) and joined an online forum for a hobby group the OP is also a member of. Nothing in that suggests any extraordinary behaviour.

idontknowher · 26/09/2023 09:57

Also from bitter experience, speak up. Shout it from the rooftops! Some naive posters on this thread suggesting this doesn't happen- it does. Get in there first or she will and it won't end well. Women like this are unhinged.

CalistoNoSolo · 26/09/2023 09:37

Omg op, grow the fuck up. How anyone has the time or emotional energy for this kind of playground shit is beyond me.

MrsGalloway · 26/09/2023 09:28

LookItsMeAgain · 26/09/2023 09:06

So speaks someone where it has clearly never happened to. Believe me, there are women out there (mainly women) where they play the long game and get a friend, who really doesn't think that their friend would do anything nasty or mean to them, gets involved with friendship groups and then the friend manages to turn everyone in the group against the person who brought them into the group.

It happens.

It's horrible because you really really do find out who your friends are when it happens.

If I were you @Worried492, I'd phone B before you go on your holiday and have a chat with them about A. Give them the heads up so that they can be aware of the situation. What they do with that information will determine how good a friend they are to you.

How though? If one of my friends introduced someone new to our friendship group how would she (and apparently it usually is a she) turn everyone against that friend?

If someone I didn’t know all that well started saying unpleasant or negative things about my existing friends I’d just distance myself (rapidly) I wouldn’t think “oh yes, Lucy who I’ve known well and liked for years is a bit of a bitch” and cut her off based on your say so”

I think there is a real danger of OP coming across badly if she tries to warn B about A. If I was B I’d probably think as a grown woman I can make my own mind up about people thanks very much, I’d think it was an overreaction to someone clicking join on Facebook group and I’d then also wonder why A did ghost the OP.

SmileyClare · 26/09/2023 09:14

Give them the heads up so they can be aware of the situation

Sorry what “situation”. ?

“Hi Carol, just think you should know-a woman who lives locally has joined the local fb.
We grew up together and used to be friends but we stopped talking four years ago”

Carol: Confused

LookItsMeAgain · 26/09/2023 09:06

BeenThereDoneThat101 · 26/09/2023 06:39

Seriously grow up.

Cuckooing a friendship group? Turning friends against people? No wonder so many women steer clear of female only friendship groups. Most of them belong in the playground and the women in them have never progressed past the age of twelve in maturity levels.

So speaks someone where it has clearly never happened to. Believe me, there are women out there (mainly women) where they play the long game and get a friend, who really doesn't think that their friend would do anything nasty or mean to them, gets involved with friendship groups and then the friend manages to turn everyone in the group against the person who brought them into the group.

It happens.

It's horrible because you really really do find out who your friends are when it happens.

If I were you @Worried492, I'd phone B before you go on your holiday and have a chat with them about A. Give them the heads up so that they can be aware of the situation. What they do with that information will determine how good a friend they are to you.

AngelinaFibres · 26/09/2023 08:44

My mother has a lot of psychopathic traits.It used to be very odd to me , as a child/ teen, that she simply didn't 'feel' anything. She is brilliant at fitting in and does ' charming' perfectly. Emotionally she is dead from the neck up. She is a widow and likes to be out and about so she cultivates lots of groups. She doesn't actually care whether people like her/ dislike her so she's very relaxed and because of that people are drawn to her. She 'models' friendship in the way she has observed others doing it so people think she is truly what they would think of as a friend. But if a group falls apart due to tensions, cliques , etc she just chooses the most advantageous grouping ( purely to her) to go with and off she goes. I went very much the other way as a young person and felt everything, probably as a reaction to my childhood. As I got into my late forties I consciously decided to be a bit more psychopath about it. I'm a nice person. I behave in a way that doesn't hurt other people. But I absolutely never chase friendships or people please so that people will like me because it never actually works. If someone wants to spend time with me that's a brilliant thing; but if they don't seem to be bothered then that's fine. I no longer turn myself inside out about it like I used to. I just let it be. I always keep a little barrier between me and other people ( not spouse or children). What I'm saying Op is that dialling down your feelings towards people who really don't matter either way is very freeing. If people in this group continue to like you then that's fabulous. If they don't, so what. You aren't going to marry them and have their babies ; they are just other women you hang about with because you all like the same thing. Be yourself and carry on. Cultivate other friendships doing other things ( meet ups is a fabulous website for this). If A comes in that's fine. If she bitches about you behind your back then shes vile but it doesn't matter. As the saying goes " Other people's opinion of you is actually none of your business". Be more psychopath Op. None of these people / relationships really matter. They are chapters in your life.

Thesoundofscience · 26/09/2023 08:43

SmileyClare
Why not send her a message trying to reconnect? Clear the air.

“ It’s a shame we lost contact all those years ago, but understandable given your (divorce/big life change/ whatever you thought was the reason)
Welcome to the (knitting) group”

Yes, definitely agree that you should do this. I’ve been ghosted twice then years later bumped into the ghoster and everything was fine - obviously we didn’t go back to the pre-ghost friendship but all very amicable and gave me closure. It could just be that you are a sensitive person who values their friendship Op and A is not, or it could be they had other things going on, any number of things. Show you don’t care, have no hard feelings and have moved on. And if they do have nefarious reasons for joining, you bring welcoming may throw then off a bit. Don’t complain about them behind their back.

MrsGalloway · 26/09/2023 08:41

No don’t say anything to B. Personally I run a mile from anyone who gossips/gives a head up/bitches behind someone else’s back.

I’m sorry OP but the fear that A could take B away from you sounds really juvenile. If you’re good friends then she’s not going to entertain any attempt by A to cut you out or listen to snide comments about you?

I’ve seen the Wendy term used before on mumsnet and I’ve never really been on board with it. I can’t think of any situation in my life where someone new has managed to come in, take control of a previously happy friendship group and oust existing members. Friendships change and develop over time and people become more and less close but that’s usually organic and not because a “Wendy” or a “cuckoo” rocks up. It all sounds unnecessarily intense and paranoid.

Naunet · 26/09/2023 08:33

A Wendy? Lovely to see that even on a female dominated board, we’re still using women’s names as misogynistic slurs.