Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to fund teenagers fussy diet.

113 replies

confusedalso · 25/09/2023 10:39

My ds has been following some ex bodybuilder online and now wants to eat cuts of meat, 4 boiled eggs etc in his packed lunch.
He wants only fresh organic fruit and vegetables and has cut out all forms of sugar, gluten, dairy and any junk food or processed food.
He used to take sandwiches which are much cheaper and eat evening meals that the family eats but now he's reading all labels and refusing anything with a sauce or an ingredient he isn't eating at the moment.
AIBU to say I don't want to fund him eating like a king? he's eating so much meat that would have fed the whole family and I've never bought organic options before so the food bill has risen enormously at a time when the cost of living is high enough.
I understand him wanting a healthy lifestyle and that's good but I don't consider the meals I usually cook to be unhealthy but his diet is so restrictive.
He says he feels so much better on this diet but he doesn't have any food allergies it's purely a choice after following this ex bodybuilder on Facebook that advises people what to eat and what not to.
I feel as though his new lifestyle is somehow my problem because I have to change the way I've always shopped/cooked.

OP posts:
Puffed · 25/09/2023 13:16

Can you also go down the environmental route when talking about balance. Too much meat is terrible for the environment.

All organic food is also very ethically questionable due to the fact you need far more plants and therefore far more land to get the same yield of food. If we all insisted on eating organic it wouldn’t be possible to grow enough food for everyone. I’m also not convinced there’s proven health benefits to this.

Someoneonlyyouknow · 25/09/2023 13:13

Where possible serve the gravy/sauce separately so the whole family can still eat the same meal.
Sit down with him and show the difference in price between what you usually buy and what he wants, he needs to help fund the difference.
If you are preparing different meals he needs to be learning how to help with that too.

Nosleepforthismum · 25/09/2023 13:10

Honestly, I wouldn’t even be entertaining this. He’d be told he can do what he wants in his own home and he can buy what he wants when he’s earning but while he lives at home and not contributing to the household he will have to eat the family meals and contribute in other ways by doing chores. He’ll cost you a fortune if you pander to him.

TrashedSofa · 25/09/2023 12:53

I think anything that transfers some of the responsibility to him for making this work is a good idea. That could look like giving him a budget, suggesting he gets a job to fund the costs himself, learning about cheaper protein sources.

confusedalso · 25/09/2023 12:51

fearfuloffluff · 25/09/2023 12:34

Does the rest of the family eat healthily? Weight problems etc?

You could meet somewhere in the middle. Reduce carbs a bit, go for wholegrain a little bit more.

There are plenty of vegan/veggie athletes and sportspeople about, you don't need all that animal protein to be strong. And organic food is good for the planet but not sure if it has a benefit for the consumer really.

I'd also be talking to him about how social media can often distort reality, not everything you see on there is true!

I eat quite healthy, I have IBS so eat salads mainly but I cook the family things like cottage pie or casserole, chicken in a sauce with rice or a roast or pasta dishes etc but he won't eat these now because of the gravy or sauce having sugar or something in the ingredients.
He's 6ft something and very slim, goes to the gym and keeps active.
It's just so much more expensive to feed him now and to know what to cook as the rest of the family still want spaghetti bolognaise or lasagne so he's having something else.

OP posts:
MrsSlocombesCat · 25/09/2023 12:46

I would be very concerned if my 16 year old son was eating like this. At his age he needs carbs, and all the meat could lead to bowel cancer when he is older. He could also end up with side effects from a low carb diet such as leg cramps, constipation and bad breath. When I was 17 I started eating two boiled eggs for breakfast every day and after a few weeks I started getting stomach pains, writhing around on my bed. I had developed an intolerance to eggs, I don’t know if it was eating them every day but I have always believed so. I’m still unable to eat them. I would take him to the GP and explain what he’s eating so he can get medical advice that it’s not a healthy diet.

Kerantli · 25/09/2023 12:35

I read the main parts of this out to my partner, and he mentioned to suggest your son look for a youtuber called Simon Miller (SimonMiller316). He's a British Indie wrestler and body builder who is rather level headed and debunks quite a bit of what some American bodybuilders are currently saying.

He's a very positive influence (has almost influenced my partner to try and get to the gym, in addition to walking).

I also agree with PPs suggestion of getting a budget in place for him.

fearfuloffluff · 25/09/2023 12:34

Does the rest of the family eat healthily? Weight problems etc?

You could meet somewhere in the middle. Reduce carbs a bit, go for wholegrain a little bit more.

There are plenty of vegan/veggie athletes and sportspeople about, you don't need all that animal protein to be strong. And organic food is good for the planet but not sure if it has a benefit for the consumer really.

I'd also be talking to him about how social media can often distort reality, not everything you see on there is true!

HarpieDuJour · 25/09/2023 12:25

As well as the budgeting idea, I wonder if he could be encouraged to find content more closely linked to his career goals? There must be military fitness influencer types (former if not currently serving) who could give more sensible, balanced advice.

Dutch1e · 25/09/2023 12:00

I agree with the budget idea, especially after a good chat about the whole-family budget and a visual demo of what his preferred foods actually cost.

Soaked mung bean seeds have the same amount of protein as chicken breast but also pack in complex carbs and a lot of Omega 3. They're cheap and easy, as well as more appropriate nutrition for a growing lad. But they're not as tasty as bio-diamond-goldplated steak!

Edited for a typo

GingerIsBest · 25/09/2023 11:58

Your son needs to educate himself properly - perhaps buy him a subscription to a health magazine, look at books, or encourage a broader variety of people to follow on instagram.

Higher protein is not necessarily a bad thing, especially for people who are working to build muscle mass. Cutting refined sugars and UPFs is not bad either. And reducing carbohydrates is, for most of us, probably healthy as we don't tend to lead the kind of active lives for which large amounts of carbs are necessary (although for an active teenager, I'd say carbs are MORE necessary than, for example, 47 year old me sitting at a desk all day). But he needs to learn how to get those from a wider variety of sources because a) there are lots of other nutrients and things he needs that he won't get from just meat and b) there are cost factors at play.

eg, I am planning to make this bread sometime this week as a way to offer DS a high protein, more nutritious bread option as he also worries about just plain carbs in regular bread. And yes, we do quite a bit of things like chicken or mince which are easier, cheaper ways to up protein without the cost of things like steak.

Cooking organic is all very well and good - and if I had the money we'd do it too - but cooking from scratch, and lots of fresh fruit and vegetables is a great first step when money doesn't stretch to that. He needs to understand that.

High protein bread recipe | Jamie Oliver bread recipes

A high-protein bread recipe that's great for a pre-gym breakfast. Top with avocado, eggs, hummus, or any of your favourite toast toppings. It's a winner.

https://www.jamieoliver.com/recipes/bread-recipes/super-food-protein-loaf/

BarbaraofSeville · 25/09/2023 11:54

But it sounds like he's already taking it to the extreme by demanding a disproportionate amount of the family food budget for large amounts of meat and organic produce.

If he's 16, he can get a part time job to pay towards it. Even a couple of shifts a week will go a long way towards this and show him that money is finite and won't always stretch to everything he may want.

berksandbeyond · 25/09/2023 11:53

Give him the budget, I agree. And watch that he’s not getting mixed up in steroids 😬

CharlotteBog · 25/09/2023 11:52

I have similar going on with my 15 yo son. He just wants to eat chicken, rice and veg. He has cut back on asking to eat lots of red meat after I asked him to read up about bowel health.

He doesn't sound as extreme as your son, in that he will go out with his mates and then snack on whatever they snack on, and we do eat out.
I also asked him to read up about the risks of eating too much red meat.
He love the gym and plays football.
He also has protein shakes. He has been enjoying lots of berries during the summer and now I've had to explain that he'll need to find other fruit as berries out of season.

I didn't allow him creatine powder.

I have also read up about it.

I'm keeping an eye. I can afford it as it's just me and him at home.

What a turn around from the boy who would have gladly eaten nuggets and chips breakfast, dinner and lunch given half the chance!

Araminta1003 · 25/09/2023 11:51

Too much meat is not healthy. Tell him to learn to cook healthy veg protein dishes like chickpea and cauliflower curry etc. Lentil/vegan chilli that kind of thing. That is not expensive but very nutritious. Eggs are also only good for you in moderation. By all means high veg/protein diet is good, but it needs to be balanced properly and to avoid overspending requires understanding and lots of preparation.

confusedalso · 25/09/2023 11:50

I have looked at some of the content and this particular ex bb does extreme fasting which I have made clear at his age he won't be doing.
From what I understand he used some sort of steroids and fasts to heal his body but claims it's not for weight loss purposes.
Ds is a healthy weight and fit and active I do also think he's sensible and won't take it to the extreme.

OP posts:
Meeting · 25/09/2023 11:48

Yes to a budget.

Also bodybuilding at such a young age can be dangerous and have lasting negative effects so you might want to do some research on that.

Baldieheid · 25/09/2023 11:45

At 16 he could work in McDonald's. Ironic I know, but they paid my nephew well at 16, above min wage and he was well treated and looked after by his manager. Your son can then buy all the expensive food he wants.

TadpolesInPool · 25/09/2023 11:44

I would also encourage him to read around and get opinions from other people, not just one "expert".

For example the Zoe nutrition and science podcast has one dedicated to how much protein we need (less than we think) and also whether it needs to be eaten immediately after working out (no). Also about whether organic food is actually worth it. That one gives cheaper work arounds (frozen organic veg is a good alternative and cheaper as well as tinned) and says the food which doesn't absorb so much pesticide (to check but I think softer fruits and veg absorb more pesticides so the benefit of buying organic is greater).

Coniger · 25/09/2023 11:42

I follow this ex bodybuilder on instagram. He has good advice and yes we should avoid UPF but can be done cheaply. He is not saying everything has to be organic - it's very much what you can afford - he just advocates cooking from scratch. He talks about the "ideal" but it also has to fit in with your budget. If you can get past all his swearing, and understand that all change to a cleaner living lifestyle is good then he actually speaks sense. But yes I agree I would give your son a budget and let him understand how much it costs and how it can be done within a budget

Drummend01 · 25/09/2023 11:38

I really like the suggestion for giving him a budget and letting him buy his own food to realise the actual cost of things.

If he’s not old enough to work maybe he could do some jobs around the house, such as washing the cars to earn himself a fiver. Then he would learn that an hours worth of work would barely afford him a steak, hopefully then he would appreciate the work you do to afford the regular food shop, let alone his new diet

confusedalso · 25/09/2023 11:36

How old is your son?

He is 16 so yes still at school.

OP posts:
WhoamiWhoareyouOhNo · 25/09/2023 11:26

Not an immediate answer but do you have a garden? Hand him a fork and some packets of seed and get him to grow his own organic vegetables... I like to eat organic/ healthy but its just not affordable

BCSurvivor · 25/09/2023 11:26

How old is your son?
You say you're making him packed lunches, if he's school age I would think a very restrictive diet, very high in protein, may be quite damaging as his body is still growing.
If he is working, he needs to contribute towards his expensive tastes.

PenelopeTheShroudWeaver · 25/09/2023 11:21

I agree with the pp that it's worth checking there isn't any underlying issue with low self esteem, bullying etc

I would also be concerned that the person he's following seems to be giving advice based on fads rather than science (ie excluding food groups because they're branded "bad", advocating organic when there is no conclusive proof it makes any difference to nutritional value, etc.) Maybe a session with a registered dietitian with an interest in strength training would be helpful.

If he is serious about having a healthier diet, all the previous advice on getting him to budget is great. Try and direct him to cheaper protein sources like tinned tuna, pulses, frozen fish fillets, chickpea pasta (Aldi sell it) etc. If you can convince him to start eating some dairy, Aldi and Lidl both sell good value plain Greek yoghurt.