Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to fund teenagers fussy diet.

113 replies

confusedalso · 25/09/2023 10:39

My ds has been following some ex bodybuilder online and now wants to eat cuts of meat, 4 boiled eggs etc in his packed lunch.
He wants only fresh organic fruit and vegetables and has cut out all forms of sugar, gluten, dairy and any junk food or processed food.
He used to take sandwiches which are much cheaper and eat evening meals that the family eats but now he's reading all labels and refusing anything with a sauce or an ingredient he isn't eating at the moment.
AIBU to say I don't want to fund him eating like a king? he's eating so much meat that would have fed the whole family and I've never bought organic options before so the food bill has risen enormously at a time when the cost of living is high enough.
I understand him wanting a healthy lifestyle and that's good but I don't consider the meals I usually cook to be unhealthy but his diet is so restrictive.
He says he feels so much better on this diet but he doesn't have any food allergies it's purely a choice after following this ex bodybuilder on Facebook that advises people what to eat and what not to.
I feel as though his new lifestyle is somehow my problem because I have to change the way I've always shopped/cooked.

OP posts:
Charlize43 · 25/09/2023 16:32

Peaceandquietfinally · 25/09/2023 16:21

Be careful with any young person becoming obsessive with 'healthy' eating!My daughter had ED orthorexia and she was very unwell. Google it if not familiar with the name.

Agreed. A friend of mine is like this. She's obsessed with macros (which I assume are like 1980s calories) and she has an App on her phone where everything needs to be scanned and tracked or entered manually before she can eat it.

To say that she is beyond obsessive is an understatement. I do think that Apps like this should be banned. I've seen her more than once seriously depressed by information from this App and to me it seems that she is setting herself up for some serious future mental health problems.

I do think some of the technology today seems so short sighted.

Peaceandquietfinally · 25/09/2023 16:21

Be careful with any young person becoming obsessive with 'healthy' eating!My daughter had ED orthorexia and she was very unwell. Google it if not familiar with the name.

TheMarzipanDildo · 25/09/2023 16:21

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 16:14

I'm amazed this is still a thing for people

Unprocessed red meat is not bad for you - it is GOOD for you.

Processed meat is bad for you, period.

Unprocessed red meat, like most food, is good for you in moderation but not in excess. Some of these body builder types are eating it several times a day (although chicken with every meal seems to be even more the thing).

Dixiechickonhols · 25/09/2023 16:20

If he’s not buying school lunch, drinks or takeaways then I’d include that in his budget.
I know when I was dieting my supermarket cost was up but I was zero on takeaway, lunch meal deals and eating out.
If he’s adamant he wants meat & eggs then I’d encourage him to look for pt work in those areas - local butchers has teen serving Saturday staff and my milkman who does the best free range eggs has a Saturday lad.
Yellow stickers were my go to for protein and fruit, is he willing to hunt.

5128gap · 25/09/2023 16:20

If he wants a whole foods high protein diet OP, point him in the direction of the vegan body builders out there and tell you can afford for him to eat those diets, but not the meat based ones. Then start serving copious amounts of cheap beans and lentils. If he's serious about his health he'll thank you for it. If not, as my nan would have said "That'll learn him!" 😂

Vegetus · 25/09/2023 16:19

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 16:11

@Vegetus

I presume you have seen some 'shorts' from Paul Saladino and made your conculsion from there. I'm not a super fan but I know what his core message is - processed seed oils are bad, UPF is bad, and you can be nutritionally optimised by eating beef, eggs, fruit & berries, honey and occasional organ meats. It's pretty basic stuff. It's really just the diet that humans evolved with. Strange how people get so worked up about it.

The seed oil thing is wrong for a start, he cherry picks studies, lies and was in business with the liver king selling supplements to kids impressed by an obviously enhanced physique which Paul claims not to have known.

I get worked up because he makes money spreading lies and his type of content is fueling a rise in Orthorexia.

Anyone who can say with a straight face plants are trying to kill you is a moron and should be ignored.

coxesorangepippin · 25/09/2023 16:16

Definitely some room for compromise. Spaghetti Bolognaise could easily fit into a healthy meal plan (where is the sugar coming from?

^^

Spaghetti = sugar.

coxesorangepippin · 25/09/2023 16:16

Lentil soup
Cottage cheese
Hardboiled eggs
Local apples

No fancy meat needed

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 16:14

ItsNotRocketSalad · 25/09/2023 16:13

To all those saying it is unhealthy, it really isn't unhealthy physically at all - how can eating whole foods be bad for you?

Do some research into all the red meat he's eating. It should worry you.

I'm amazed this is still a thing for people

Unprocessed red meat is not bad for you - it is GOOD for you.

Processed meat is bad for you, period.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 25/09/2023 16:13

To all those saying it is unhealthy, it really isn't unhealthy physically at all - how can eating whole foods be bad for you?

Do some research into all the red meat he's eating. It should worry you.

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 16:11

@Vegetus

I presume you have seen some 'shorts' from Paul Saladino and made your conculsion from there. I'm not a super fan but I know what his core message is - processed seed oils are bad, UPF is bad, and you can be nutritionally optimised by eating beef, eggs, fruit & berries, honey and occasional organ meats. It's pretty basic stuff. It's really just the diet that humans evolved with. Strange how people get so worked up about it.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/09/2023 16:08

I’d also agree be wary if it’s a slide into eating disorder territory. You may find he won’t eat rather than eat ‘wrong’ thing.
I’d try and see if you can compromise. Does he have a protein target? Then look at ways to get cheaper protein than eggs, meat.
At 16 he is old enough to work pt. Look for jobs that have perks like free food on shift, supermarket discount card etc.

Vegetus · 25/09/2023 16:05

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 15:57

@Vegetus there is a hint in your username that you might not be a fan of anyone eating meat

Live and let live eh?

I eat plenty of meat. Paul Saladino is a con man FFS!

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 15:59

He has chosen a very unhealthy diet which could be detrimental to his long term health. Do not agree to doing this, any more than you would agree to him living entirely on sweets.

LOLs

I am sure you would be fine with him going vegan though right?

Your quote about protein is genuinely hilarious

NoAprilFool · 25/09/2023 15:58

Definitely some room for compromise. Spaghetti Bolognaise could easily fit into a healthy meal plan (where is the sugar coming from? If he’s worrying about the natural sugars in tomatoes, I’d definitely be worrying he’s following some dodgy influencers).

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 15:57

@Vegetus there is a hint in your username that you might not be a fan of anyone eating meat

Live and let live eh?

Cowlover89 · 25/09/2023 15:56

MabelMaybe · 25/09/2023 11:11

Ask him to start looking at other sources of protein - greek yoghurt from Aldi, tofu, chickpeas, spinach etc. All cheaper than steak and eggs.

I don't see that going down well. Me personally would prefer steak and eggs over chickpeas and tofu. Love greek yogurt tho

Mischance · 25/09/2023 15:51

Go on cooking as you always do and he can eat what he wants of it.

"Extra protein intake also can lead to elevated blood lipids and heart disease because many high-protein foods you eat are high in total and saturated fat. Extra protein intake, which can tax the kidneys, poses an additional risk to people predisposed to kidney disease."

He has chosen a very unhealthy diet which could be detrimental to his long term health. Do not agree to doing this, any more than you would agree to him living entirely on sweets.

He is making a bad choice and you cannot facilitate this.

Cook as always, but buy a few more bits of fruit and veg - and brown rice to fill him up.

Ilikeyourdecor · 25/09/2023 15:45

I wanted to be veggie at his age. My Mum said fine but I'd have to cook it. I decided to continue eating meat.

So I'd give him a budget, and also request that he cooks for the family a few nights a week. I'd also take on board some of his ideas for cutting down on upf (swapping to wholemeal pasta, cooking pasta sauces from scratch, which are actually really easy, etc).

Vegetus · 25/09/2023 15:45

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 15:35

My DS did exactly the same - Paul Salandino was the one he really liked

I gave him a budget and he was able to make it work, quite easily. Minced beef, liver, heart and eggs are all relatively cheap. Combined with honey and fruit, he has a good mix of carbs, protein and fat. There is no 'cutting out a whole food group' it is just that some people are insistent you need grains, he begs to differ. To put a finer and grosser point on the table to prove that I know this - his guts are so good that he doesn't even fart and never leaves any form of mess in the toilet - all of which are the ultimate sign his 'guts' are good.

To all those saying it is unhealthy, it really isn't unhealthy physically at all - how can eating whole foods be bad for you? It is so insane that people think teenagers should be eating junk to be normal. My DS is 18 now and still follows it, he is very healthy - clear skin, bright eyes and never ill (or depressed!)

Honestly, I am laughing so much at how people can say that is unhealthy when most teenagers are eating piles of crap every day and no one says a word about that.

The budget worked for me OP.

I always hoped no one would be stupid enough to take nutritional advice from Paul Saladino but sadly I was wrong.

hamstersarse · 25/09/2023 15:35

My DS did exactly the same - Paul Salandino was the one he really liked

I gave him a budget and he was able to make it work, quite easily. Minced beef, liver, heart and eggs are all relatively cheap. Combined with honey and fruit, he has a good mix of carbs, protein and fat. There is no 'cutting out a whole food group' it is just that some people are insistent you need grains, he begs to differ. To put a finer and grosser point on the table to prove that I know this - his guts are so good that he doesn't even fart and never leaves any form of mess in the toilet - all of which are the ultimate sign his 'guts' are good.

To all those saying it is unhealthy, it really isn't unhealthy physically at all - how can eating whole foods be bad for you? It is so insane that people think teenagers should be eating junk to be normal. My DS is 18 now and still follows it, he is very healthy - clear skin, bright eyes and never ill (or depressed!)

Honestly, I am laughing so much at how people can say that is unhealthy when most teenagers are eating piles of crap every day and no one says a word about that.

The budget worked for me OP.

BigBoysDontCry · 25/09/2023 15:17

Cuttingout/down on sugar and processed food is all fine, switching white rice and pasta for wholemeal again all good. Using healthy oils rather than veg/rapeseed/sunflower oil, again all good.

However, you have a budget and he isn't earning so a compromise is needed.

Budget protein options include tinned fish, especially mackerel in olive oil or brine at about a pound a tin. Nuts, lentils all good too.

I agree with pps you need to watch that this doesn't become an obsession and develop into an eating disorder.

David325 · 25/09/2023 15:16

As someone into bodybuilding myself i recommend you get him those packs of 10 large for less than £2 from home bargains.

PenelopeTheShroudWeaver · 25/09/2023 15:16

Vegetus · 25/09/2023 14:51

Tell him to search for a guy called Mike Israetel. He's funny as well so should probably connect with your Son.

It's a much more nuanced view of health and fitness despite being a jacked mass monster bodybuilder.

Layne Norton is another useful follow on Instagram in particular and he has a PHD in nutritional science and debunks all the idiots like Eddie Abbew and Paul Saladino.

^ this !

Both of these are science - driven, and have relevant PhDs as well as successful track records as athletes and coaches.

Another great source of information is Eric Helms (equally well-educated as MI and LN), he has a podcast called Iron Culture which is interesting and fun to listen to

Vegemiteandhoneyontoast · 25/09/2023 15:12

I wonder if he'd eat faggots - from the butcher not those monstrosities made by Brains. Being pork and organ meat, they're packed with nutrients and they're a whole lot cheaper than steak. They're also filling and tasty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread