Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I’d had my kids the other way round

221 replies

Boyfirstthengirl · 25/09/2023 09:22

I feel bad saying this but I am from a family where I’m the youngest and a girl/woman (obviously …) and I have an older brother. We get on well enough now and I do have nice memories of us together as kids, it isn’t all bad. But he was always so rough when we were young, would beat me up, call me names and so on.

To be honest I don’t think my parents dealt with it particularly well as they’d get angry with us both Hmm although to be fair to them I probably instigated some of it but my memory is selective!

Anyway, I have a boy who is 3 in January. I also have a baby daughter who is 3 months and history looks set to repeat itself … he hasn’t taken to her at all and tries to hurt her a lot. I am very worried about having horrible family dynamics. I want to manage this as best I can but struggling with DS - I can’t seem to get through to him, I know he’s jealous but I can’t think what else I can do.

I know I’ll get slated for this but everyone I know whose eldest child is a girl is excited and happy about the baby. I feel like she’s in a really vulnerable position growing up and I have to protect her but that’s also going to alienate my son Sad

OP posts:
Dragonfly909 · 25/09/2023 15:29

Haven't RTFT but my 3 year old girl is incredibly rough and agressive both with us and her baby brother so I don't think gender makes a difference! That's not the issue.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 15:23

Say “the baby is frightened by what you just did so now I have to take her away to focus on her”

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 15:22

Yes, I know it’s not easy.
Does he laugh when you immediately remove the baby and yourself from his company - going to another room if necessary - and focus exclusively on the baby?

Boyfirstthengirl · 25/09/2023 15:20

Apologies, it was you! I didn’t realise you replied early in the thread. So yes, that doesn’t appear effective for us!

OP posts:
Boyfirstthengirl · 25/09/2023 15:18

@Coughingdodger - I don’t think it was, it was one of the first posts on here. In any event, I have tried what you’ve put above and it makes no difference. He just laughs. Likewise - I mean, this might end up sounding as if I’m being a bit arsey and I promise I’m not - as I’ve said I do agree with you on some stuff - but saying no? That’s pretty much the first port of call, surely!?

OP posts:
Julesrosti · 25/09/2023 15:09

If you read about the psychology of this, your children have the best potential. Girls have an advantage and eldest siblings have an advantage. That means an eldest sibling who is a girl has 2 advantages and a younger sibling who is a boy has no advantages. The girl is therefore likely to pull far ahead and the boy get left behind. An older sibling who is male and a younger sibling who is female both have one advantage each and therefore are a lot more equal.

Google it, it's interesting.

For help specific to your situation, maybe speak to the HV about concerns and things that might help?

ZickZack · 25/09/2023 15:02

Sorry, op. But you're projecting. There's nothing saying it'll be the same dynamic. My DS was 3 in July and I had his brother last January (so ds1 was 2 and a half). Ds1 loved his brother from the beginning and still does today. Give it time. Lots of patience and extra attention with your DS , he'll get used to the dynamic. Don't compare him to your brother.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 15:01

Personally I don’t feel that gentle chats are helpful in the moment. Just say NO!!!! and remove the younger child immediately.

Gentle chats imo can and should happen only when everyone is calm.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:58

It was me who said it. It means to respond extremely firmly and rapidly each and every single time. Loudly and clearly state what he did wrong and that you won’t tolerate it. Remove the younger child immediately and make an ostentatious fuss of her and her alone (the very opposite of what he would want to achieve).
Do it ad nauseam no matter how often it happens or how tired you feel.

When he is calm, draw him back in, make a fuss of him and praise him. One to one time etc.

When your DD is older let her know that she can come to you if there is any violence and you’ll put a stop to it. You won’t take a “boys will be boys” attitude to physical violence. (Likewise, if your DS is ever unhappy about anything he can talk to you and you’ll always listen and hear him).

Boyfirstthengirl · 25/09/2023 14:45

I’ve asked a couple of times now but no one’s answered that I can see - meant genuinely - what this coming down like a tonne of bricks looks like?

OP posts:
Diamondcurtains · 25/09/2023 14:44

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 09:29

I’d come down on your son like a ton of bricks - really go nuts - if he physically harms your DD. You can love him dearly and still lay down this law. You can also stop your DD from targeting him, as we all know that some younger and “weaker” siblings can be very provocative and sly. But you can still have this absolute no-touch rule.
You’ll be doing him a favour in the long run. I hear so many stories of younger siblings who hated their older DB growing up. And the adult DB is sometimes bewildered by their hatred and the distance that’s grown between them as no one ever told him he was doing anything wrong.

Absolutely this. I have 4 children. 2 boys, 2 girls. Older two are adults now and younger two are 16 and 17. I can honestly say they’ve never hit each other. Yes they occasionally bickered but never have any of them hit each other.

PollyPeep · 25/09/2023 14:37

@Boyfirstthengirl I've been following along and can't really see any of the bonkers posts you're referring to? Unless you're talking about people who disagree that your two year old will inevitably turn out to be a violent bully terrorising his little sister just because he's a boy, and just because he's currently a toddler who doesn't listen.

Querypost · 25/09/2023 14:35

I'm the eldest (male) and was always kind and caring to my 3 years younger sister as a child. It's about the child, not the sex.

Hotpinkparade · 25/09/2023 14:35

Funnily enough, I just assumed you were going to say your children were the other way round and you wished you'd had an older son/younger daughter - in my family the 'lore' is that this is the 'better' way round, as boy children are more chilled out and less domineering, whereas older sisters are bossy/over involved.

This certainly seems to be borne out in my family - I have an older brother who is my best mate, was pretty nice to me when we were kids but also left me to it a lot of the time - and in the next generation - only one older sister/younger brother and she makes his life hard work at times, very bossy and quite physical! The older brothers with younger sisters play when they're interested and wander off and do their own thing when they aren't.

Boyfirstthengirl · 25/09/2023 14:29

The most important thing imo is to have a zero tolerance approach to sibling-on-sibling violence.

I couldn’t agree more. I also do agree with a lot of what @Coughingdodger has said, though. I know there are girls built like Miss Trunchbull and boys who are elfin creatures but generally an older boy can hurt a younger girl more than the other way around.

Hopefully it will not come to that, and despite the bonkers posts there has been a lot of genuinely really helpful stuff here so thank you. I will try to send a few PMs as I know some of you will have spent a long time posting and it is appreciated!

OP posts:
Goldbar · 25/09/2023 14:25

There are only 2 and a half years between these children. Yes, it's not great if a ten or twelve year old boy is hitting his eight or ten year old sister, but neither is it the case that he's necessarily going to cause more damage than if it was girls of similar ages doing this. Nor is it the same as a child that age hitting a much smaller child of five or six (as might occur if there was a bigger age gap.

If he's still walloping his sister when he gets to 15, then the OP will indeed have a problem on her hands, but tbh the problem wouldn't be that much better if the boy was 15 and the girl was 17. And hopefully the OP will have stepped in before it gets to this point to ensure her DD's safety.

The most important thing imo is to have a zero tolerance approach to sibling-on-sibling violence.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:15

The gender stereotyping is not that it’s more likely that a boy will hit (although since we know men are more likely to be violent, it’s not unreasonable for the OP to be concerned - I’m unclear as to why some posters are rushing to say it’s wrong for her to wonder).

Anyway, the real problem for a sibling - the “stereotyping”, if you will - is that when an older brother does hit, it causes far more harm than when an older sister does.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 25/09/2023 14:08

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:02

Some posters are accusing her of gender stereotyping. Now that’s unhelpful.

Gender stereotyping a 2yo is unhelpful!

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 25/09/2023 14:08

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:01

In what way is it less helpful than telling her she’s worrying about nothing, that it’s ok for him to hit because someone’s older sister hit them and it was all fine?

Literally no one has said it’s ok for him to hit the baby. We’re all saying that this isn’t because he’s male but because he’s 2.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:02

Some posters are accusing her of gender stereotyping. Now that’s unhelpful.

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 14:01

In what way is it less helpful than telling her she’s worrying about nothing, that it’s ok for him to hit because someone’s older sister hit them and it was all fine?

KeepTheTempo · 25/09/2023 13:59

*older brother, not younger

KeepTheTempo · 25/09/2023 13:59

@Coughingdodger An older sister is unlikely (past a certain age) to inflict serious physical hurt on a younger brother within a couple of years of her age. He will not grow up physically terrified of her no matter how awful her behaviour. Not so when the DB is the older one

"past a certain age" is the key phrase here. This older child is 2 years old. Tiny.

Should they be allowed to do anything to hurt the baby? Of course not. Should their parent - or unhelpful posts like this - demonise this toddler as someone likely to cause the youngest one to be "physically terrified". Of course not.

This poor op obviously went through a lot of trauma with her own younger brother as a child, has only recently given birth, and is doing her absolute best as a parent of 2. She needs reassurance and support, not messages that cause her further stress and risk bad outcomes for a 2 year old.

ToDamp0rNotToDamp · 25/09/2023 13:48

I understand your concerns OP.

I am the youngest and have two older sisters. The behaviours you’re describing of pinching / pretending to be gentle and then hitting etc is exactly as my parents describe what they did to me. To be honest they beat the living bejesus out of my up until I was maybe 13 - now they’re my best friends in the entire world. Also glad to say their violent nature didn’t make it into adulthood ha!

The above is to say, don’t dwell on the order or gender of your babies as it may well have not have made a difference. You seem like a loving parent who is conscious of protecting both your children; I think that’s the most you can do in this scenario, unless perhaps willing to cough up £££ for a child behaviour specialist (though unnecessary as what you’re describing seems like typical toddler behaviour). Keep correcting your sons behaviour and encouraging gentle play, fingers crossed it comes with time. I’m sure there are going to be instances of your daughter getting hurt that will upset you, but babies and toddlers are far more resilient than we give them credit for.

My sisters gave me a good wholloping round the head with some wooden toys on my first day back from hospital - I can confirm it did not cause lasting damage 😄

Coughingdodger · 25/09/2023 13:36

The usual people boring on about gender stereotypes. They exist for a reason.

An older sister is unlikely (past a certain age) to inflict serious physical hurt on a younger brother within a couple of years of her age. He will not grow up physically terrified of her no matter how awful her behaviour. Not so when the DB is the older one.

So if - IF - the male child is hitting the younger sibling you have to be extremely tough on that behaviour while he is still young enough that you have control over him. For his sake too. You can be tough on the behaviour without being tough on the child.

How to do it? Be very rapid and very firm. Raise your voice. State clearly the unwanted behaviour and that you won’t put up with it. Remove the younger child immediately and fuss ostentatiously over the younger child (the exact opposite of what he intended).
Any time he’s not being violent, draw him back in and give him attention and praise. Repeat ad nauseam.

When your DD is older, let her know that she can always talk to you about any physical bullying and you’ll put a stop to it. (Likewise your DS can always come and talk to you too if he feels unhappy about anything)

You’re probably very tired and busy atm so everything seems much harder.