Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home education should mean one parent has no requirement to work under UC?

210 replies

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 08:11

I home educate but I’m in receipt of carers allowance so I don’t have to worry but many of the parents in the groups we attend have children with difficulties who couldn’t manage school and because they don’t get dla or are waiting for a dla claim (it takes months) they are under extreme pressure.

I know that some people plan to home educate and yes if its a choice for NT dc from age 4 then I can see why they’d be expected to fund that/work alongside but there’s a huge groups of parents struggling to home educate children with difficulties and it seems as if they aren’t recognised and supported ?

AIBU to think that if you’ve had to de register for a child who can’t manage school and you are engaging with your LA home education department (a lot of home educators refuse to engage so there should be something in place where UC have it verified ?) that you should be able to get UC with no requirement to work?

OP posts:
unlimiteddilutingjuice · 25/09/2023 11:34

I've got every sympathy for the situation you describe.
I'm also Home Edding and recieving child DLA and Carers Allowance.

I agree with you. There's a lot of people in a similar situation having a really hard time from the Jobcentre.
And the only difference between them and me is that I managed to get my ducks in a row and my paperwork sorted before I started home ed.
I used to be a welfare rights advisor so I had a head start. A lot of people struggle.

I don't agree with your solution. I think it's a bit dangerous to introduce incentives to home ed. Because you'll get people pulling their kids out of school purely to get the Jobcentre off their backs. I'd actually be happier with everyone having the requirement to seek work removed, rather than it being a special privilege for home edders.

It sounds like you're suggesting (as a solution) that, rather than the Jobcentre check people are looking for work the Council check that people are home Edding properly. Controversially amongst home edders, I would welcome a bit more council oversight. But it would be super unacceptable to a lot of our community. Plus I don't think councils are nearly well enough resourced to actually do it. My council has one guy responsible for home ed. I'm actually trying to work with him right now to get my kid back into school. Getting him to answer an email is like pulling teeth.

I think the actual solution to the situation is:

  1. The social security system to be more reasonable, humane and efficient
  2. Councils to actually provide a proper education for SEN kids instead of leaving us parents to manage on our own.
GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 11:33

callingeveryone · 25/09/2023 11:25

Those arguing against any monitoring of home education are overwhelmingly white and middle-class. They don't actually care about the children being let down by their parents.

Do you think ethnic minorities on the other hand are begging for some oversight from the council? Desperate a well meaning white lady enters their home? Just in case their children are neglected?

I think you’ll find it’s the middle class British who both love monitoring people, and distrust anything different.

GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 11:30

Studswagger · 25/09/2023 11:18

Whether a child is involved in gangs or if they are learning to read, write and speak in English are safeguarding issues that schools monitor, so it makes sense that the LA home Ed people take over that duty for home Ed children.

If I’ve replied to your email in English, welcome you into my house in English and spoken to my children in front of you in English I will find it rude if you start asking me if I can speak or write in English. I’ll also presume you aren’t very bright.

If the parents of my sons’ black friends are repeatedly asked about if they are in gangs, then ask me too. Put it on the form for everyone.

I wouldn’t actually be against monitoring if they sent someone with knowledge of the curriculum and teaching methods. That would be useful. But until they send safeguarding checks into every household with children, to check no one is lying, I’ll be sending written reports.

callingeveryone · 25/09/2023 11:25

Those arguing against any monitoring of home education are overwhelmingly white and middle-class. They don't actually care about the children being let down by their parents.

Studswagger · 25/09/2023 11:18

GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 10:06

I may as well pop in the library or co op and tell them about it, for all the qualifications and input I’ll get. That annoys me. Tbf to my library actually they are good, they would be better education wise.

You are effectively opening your home environment to the pot luck of unqualified box ticking staff. A bit like the GP sending round the person who does the filing each year to look in your fridge. To check you haven’t lied about feeding your children. Pointless, and lots of potential to get it wrong. Box say green vegetables- yours are in a cool pantry, no tick.

The worst bit though is if you are the white educated with books out idea you are contributing to the box ticking and approval that feeds minority group discrimination. Many home educators are disabled, non-white, gypsies or in some way not the stereotype of what things ‘should’ look like. Visits at best lead to Micro aggression, like ‘is your son involved in gangs’ talks or ‘can write English’. The worse is they get actual harassment through school attendance orders. Normalising home visits AND the idea that their ideal exists marginalises other groups.

On the low end of the scale, I speak 5 languages, I’m a qualified teacher, as in my partner and have masters degrees related to education. Yet I have had extra monitoring and phone calls and negativity, along with other non English parents, from a London borough. I’m past the point where I want to explain every year to a member of staff with prejudices that I am as capable as the average parent. I’m not being offered support, guidance or input. Just pure rudeness. I had one visit years ago with a staff person training another, I ended up asking them to leave the way they spoke to me. That’s for a reasonably well off person in a clean and pleasant house. I’ve heard much much worse for others, getting school attendence orders threatened for much more and better evidence that’s I’ve ever provided.

If you invite them, yes it’s a pleasant little tick box. The next person, poorer and in a discriminated against group does the same it’s not. Maybe they have more books than you. Maybe they also write a better report. Maybe they have a tidier house. It does NOT mean they get treats as well as you in the comfortable light touch world of a nice chat and tea.

Whether a child is involved in gangs or if they are learning to read, write and speak in English are safeguarding issues that schools monitor, so it makes sense that the LA home Ed people take over that duty for home Ed children.

callingeveryone · 25/09/2023 11:12

Proposals like this always assume all parents are great and want the best for their children. That is not true.
If this happened some parents would deliberately withdraw their child from school saying they could not cope, so they did not have to work a tough minimum wage job.

Vikina · 25/09/2023 10:39

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 10:34

I am not devaluing teachers. It's not their fault that the system is failing. They say themselves that they aren't able to do the job that they signed up for, which is to teach children well. That's not their fault. It's the way this current system is designed.
I am speaking from lived experience when I say teachers are home educating their children. As somebody active in the HE community, I come across many HE parents who are former teachers.

Ah, sorry, just read you said that they are former teachers. In that case, as qualified teachers they are in a good position to teach their own children.

Vikina · 25/09/2023 10:38

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 10:34

I am not devaluing teachers. It's not their fault that the system is failing. They say themselves that they aren't able to do the job that they signed up for, which is to teach children well. That's not their fault. It's the way this current system is designed.
I am speaking from lived experience when I say teachers are home educating their children. As somebody active in the HE community, I come across many HE parents who are former teachers.

How can teachers be home educating their children when they are in school teaching other people's children?

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 10:34

I am not devaluing teachers. It's not their fault that the system is failing. They say themselves that they aren't able to do the job that they signed up for, which is to teach children well. That's not their fault. It's the way this current system is designed.
I am speaking from lived experience when I say teachers are home educating their children. As somebody active in the HE community, I come across many HE parents who are former teachers.

Thesearmsofmine · 25/09/2023 10:09

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 10:01

No I’ve home educated 2 of my children one through gcses and we had nothing but support from the LA they were actually very ‘hands off’ just wanting a yearly report /meeting and were absolutely nothing but supportive. The families I know through home ed groups are mostly new to it all and struggling

Well in that case you have been very lucky. Given that you are an experienced home educator, are you not aware of the issues many have had with the LA overstepping which has led to the advice to not have visits?
You must have been around the groups for a long time and so I am very surprised that you didn’t anticipate people weren’t going to be positive about home visits. It’s been the same stance for at least 10 years which is how long I have been home educating.

OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 10:08

@Spendonsend I agree it shouldn’t be necessary, but sadly currently DC whose parents enforce their rights get better support. It shouldn’t be like that and fails many DC, but the system isn’t going to change any time soon. Which is why I said parents should be supported to enforce their rights. There are many parents who, for a multitude of complex reasons, can’t or don’t feel able to advocate themselves or advocate alone &/or can’t or don’t feel able to access support services. Support should be improved and there needs to be more signposting parents to the right support rather than a solution that encourages LAs not the provide provision.

There are many problems with the SEN system, but IMO OP’s solution won’t solve that and personally, I think parents should be supported to challenge LAs and enforce their rights rather than accept LAs acting unlawfully. EOTAS can provide far more than the vast majority of parents can afford to fund EHEing. That is not a criticism of parents who EHE, more a statement of what EOTAS can include.

GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 10:06

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 09:34

And I don’t see why it was an issue it was a 20 min visit, she chatted to us both looked at work then said it would be the same in a year we can just send a report no need for a visit again unless we want one so I dont see what these groups are worried about

I may as well pop in the library or co op and tell them about it, for all the qualifications and input I’ll get. That annoys me. Tbf to my library actually they are good, they would be better education wise.

You are effectively opening your home environment to the pot luck of unqualified box ticking staff. A bit like the GP sending round the person who does the filing each year to look in your fridge. To check you haven’t lied about feeding your children. Pointless, and lots of potential to get it wrong. Box say green vegetables- yours are in a cool pantry, no tick.

The worst bit though is if you are the white educated with books out idea you are contributing to the box ticking and approval that feeds minority group discrimination. Many home educators are disabled, non-white, gypsies or in some way not the stereotype of what things ‘should’ look like. Visits at best lead to Micro aggression, like ‘is your son involved in gangs’ talks or ‘can write English’. The worse is they get actual harassment through school attendance orders. Normalising home visits AND the idea that their ideal exists marginalises other groups.

On the low end of the scale, I speak 5 languages, I’m a qualified teacher, as in my partner and have masters degrees related to education. Yet I have had extra monitoring and phone calls and negativity, along with other non English parents, from a London borough. I’m past the point where I want to explain every year to a member of staff with prejudices that I am as capable as the average parent. I’m not being offered support, guidance or input. Just pure rudeness. I had one visit years ago with a staff person training another, I ended up asking them to leave the way they spoke to me. That’s for a reasonably well off person in a clean and pleasant house. I’ve heard much much worse for others, getting school attendence orders threatened for much more and better evidence that’s I’ve ever provided.

If you invite them, yes it’s a pleasant little tick box. The next person, poorer and in a discriminated against group does the same it’s not. Maybe they have more books than you. Maybe they also write a better report. Maybe they have a tidier house. It does NOT mean they get treats as well as you in the comfortable light touch world of a nice chat and tea.

Foxesandsquirrels · 25/09/2023 10:02

@LolaSmiles I'm not saying unschooling isn't amazing, it really really is, but as you say, it takes a tremendous amount of work. Lazy parents who read online that leaving your kid to get on with it will reap massive results are deluded and it hurts me to see. It's heartbreaking

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 10:02

Home ed is completely different than parents helping their child with school home work. A home ed parents job isn't to stand in front of their child and deliver a lesson. It is to facilitate that child's learning. To provide them the tools and resources to learn. There have been many studies which show how children and people learn best. None of the best methods involve a teacher standing in front of 30 children. Theoretically, a HE parent would do a better job at 'home work' anyway, because we are actively involved in their education. In some respects we are learning together or at least being reminded of the stuff we learnt 20 years ago. My 11 year old is now doing their Spanish GCSE. I never spoke a word of Spanish a year ago and I'm still not that good now. My child is though.
It's a different way and it's not for everyone. The majority of the home ed kids I know are happy, thriving, well socialised, are being well educated and are free to pursue their interests. Sadly, I can't say the same for most of the school children I know.
I say all this as a parent of one home ed child and one schooled child.

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 10:01

Thesearmsofmine · 25/09/2023 09:48

Can you not understand that this isn’t the experience of everyone? It’s great that you had a good visit. But unfortunately many many local authorities overstep. I’m guessing you are fairly new to home education? Yet you think you know better than groups with members who have upwards of 20 years experience?

No I’ve home educated 2 of my children one through gcses and we had nothing but support from the LA they were actually very ‘hands off’ just wanting a yearly report /meeting and were absolutely nothing but supportive. The families I know through home ed groups are mostly new to it all and struggling

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 25/09/2023 10:00

@OvertakenByLego I do understand the law. But my point is many parents dont have capacity to go through the process whilst supporting their child. My husband had an actual nervous breakdown when we went through tribunal. And we didnt find lots of support out there. We got one call with IPSEA.

I think a system relying on the vulnerable party to enforce their rights is rubbish and totally see why some people give up.

I know the LA doing 5 hours of tuition was not enough. But my focus was on securing the long term placement from September. I didnt have the mental energy to enforce more in the interim. My head went 'i can get long term place right or short term place right'

im glad some people get EOTAS in a way that allows the parent to work though.

Foxesandsquirrels · 25/09/2023 10:00

@alldakatz wow. You win the asshole award for the year.

alldakatz · 25/09/2023 09:59

Wouldn't that be rewarding people for poor parenting? I'm not talking about parents whose children have serious medical issues and who qualify for carer's allowance, just the type of parents who haven't socialised their kids sufficiently for those kids to be in a classroom without being disruptive.

Studswagger · 25/09/2023 09:57

SisterMichaelsHabit · 25/09/2023 08:21

Sorry I disagree. Otherwise it opens the floodgates that there's no requirement to work before children are of school age. Or anyone who just feels like having their kids at home to avoid having to get a job. People would start having kids to keep them at home and that would produce a very uneducated underclass of children who were denied education by their parents just to not have to work, and the state would have let those children down.
While I empathise with your situation, home ed is a lifestyle choice and the government etc would construct the argument that you could use SEN provision (however inadequate that is in reality) eg a SEN school with qualified professionals instead.
And I do say that as someone who would love to keep the kids home and home ed them to cater for DC1's special needs.

It isn’t a lifestyle choice for me- there isn’t a suitable school for my child within an hour of home- and their needs mean they can’t do that much travelling every day. We have tried. And I’m in a position to pay if we could just find somewhere! If you like I can send you my postcode and you can try and find me one?

I’m not religious or into conspiracy theories, I’m post grad educated. I encourage the LA to come for their yearly visit. I allow the outreach school nurses to come to the house and do the checks he doesn’t have at school. I pay for tutors, I pay for clubs, I pay for him to do the one day outdoor education in a setting that he can manage, I pay for exercise books and textbooks etc. I read the entire national curriculum for each subject each academic year and adapt it myself to be accessible for our needs. I don’t do anything else except spend my days caring for my child and trying to make sure he gets a good education.

It would be a very odd ‘lifestyle choice’

KeepTheTempo · 25/09/2023 09:56

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 09:17

You are suggesting that parents who have been through the school system, aren't educated enough to facilitate their own child's education. Which, doesnt really help the argument of 'school is best'
By 'educated in the field' I assume you mean teacher training. Which is mostly about delivering the curriculum to a large number of children at once. Teachers are leaving the profession in droves because the system is failing. A large portion of them home educate their own children. It's easy to see why.

Of course you can come through the school system just fine and then not be equipped to teach your own children. Even a good A level in maths doesn't necessarily make someone equipped to help a struggling 6 year old understand addition. And a handful of passes as GCSEs definitely doesn't equip someone to help their child with more advanced concepts.

It's partly this devaluing of teachers' skills that make teachers leave the profession. And it's certainly not true that 'a large proportion' of them are choosing to home ed, when it's only around 1 percent of children home educated, and a good share of those kids are involuntary home ed due to issues with having no suitable provision.

LolaSmiles · 25/09/2023 09:56

Foxesandsquirrels
Genuinely child-initiated learning takes a huge amount of skill. I've read articles by some unschoolers and the parents blow my mind with the knowledge they share with their children. There's a culture of family learning and the parents support the children's interests. The more interests the children have, the more they find other things that catch their interests. It's not something I could do, but I take my hats off to the parents who unschool well. I don't think LAs understand the skill of this approach.

The issue is like you say, the people who don't do much, their children are left to their own devices (literally devices at times) and then they want advice on how to get the LA off their backs. These people will present it as the LA hating unschoolers when the LA reasonably want children to have appropriate educational opportunities.

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 09:49

if a child is unable to attend school because of disability and has no access to a specialist school then they would be in receipt of dla so parent would get carers.

If this is not the case the parent really should be classed as able to work.

My niece is severely disabled but has been at a specialist school since primary- she's now in a specialist college. Her mom gets carers so she doesn't have to look for work

Thesearmsofmine · 25/09/2023 09:48

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 09:34

And I don’t see why it was an issue it was a 20 min visit, she chatted to us both looked at work then said it would be the same in a year we can just send a report no need for a visit again unless we want one so I dont see what these groups are worried about

Can you not understand that this isn’t the experience of everyone? It’s great that you had a good visit. But unfortunately many many local authorities overstep. I’m guessing you are fairly new to home education? Yet you think you know better than groups with members who have upwards of 20 years experience?

Pheasantplucker2 · 25/09/2023 09:48

I fall into your category OP, and although I agree that there should be financial provision for those of us who are forced into a situation not of our choosing, , my experience of battling it out with the LA is that the people they employ, supposedly to support our kids, spend all of their time trying to get out of any financial commitment possible. I've just had to spend £3k on a tribunal to get a specialist provision for my eldest, who had been out of school for 2 years up to this point.

They made the calculated decision to fight me at tribunal, knowing that it was 99% certain I'd win, due to the complexities of my child's case, but by putting me through the stress and expense of a tribunal, it meant that the LA delayed funding the school place for a year. It is an open secret, talked about by all of the specialist provisions. It's criminal, and they fail to meet all of the legal timescales constantly, with no recourse.

Given that scenario, I cannot see how any council will decide that they can find the money to support SEND children who can't be in a formal school setting. You have to go down the tribunal route to fight for an EOTIS/EOTAS package, which they will then make impossible to deliver, and if they are providing a personal budget, will not pay you or the providers for months on end.

It's depressing and shameful treatment of the most vulnerable children in our society, but no-one who isn't affected cares or will prioritise this as a funding issue, so it's never going to improve.

Foxesandsquirrels · 25/09/2023 09:47

@MrsSchrute What I find interesting about this phenomenon of unschooling is that, for the most part, these families talk about how their kids learnt nothing at school and that's why schools are awful. But they make whole Facebook groups where they teach people how to word doing nothing into work. Eg how does going to the GP with your singling equal a maths lesson.

Swipe left for the next trending thread