Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home education should mean one parent has no requirement to work under UC?

210 replies

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 08:11

I home educate but I’m in receipt of carers allowance so I don’t have to worry but many of the parents in the groups we attend have children with difficulties who couldn’t manage school and because they don’t get dla or are waiting for a dla claim (it takes months) they are under extreme pressure.

I know that some people plan to home educate and yes if its a choice for NT dc from age 4 then I can see why they’d be expected to fund that/work alongside but there’s a huge groups of parents struggling to home educate children with difficulties and it seems as if they aren’t recognised and supported ?

AIBU to think that if you’ve had to de register for a child who can’t manage school and you are engaging with your LA home education department (a lot of home educators refuse to engage so there should be something in place where UC have it verified ?) that you should be able to get UC with no requirement to work?

OP posts:
ketchup07070 · 25/09/2023 18:11

Possibly some funding could be given to home educated children for tuition, alternative school provisions and exams. Receipts would need to be shown, so it couldn't be abused. Although that doesn't give any money towards living costs, it reduces expense. As these children are not costing schools money, I think that would be fair, and the money would have to be spent on them so could not be abused by parents who just don't want to work. It might also cover some of the costs of sending children to alternative provision e.g. part time forest schools or progressive schools, allowing the parent to work.

cutegorilla · 25/09/2023 18:04

I'd rather all DC were provided with an education that suits their needs so that parents weren't pushed into home educating out of desperation.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/09/2023 17:57

People would start having kids to keep them at home and that would produce a very uneducated underclass of children who were denied education by their parents just to not have to work, and the state would have let those children down.

I agree with this. I understand the dilemma for people whose kids are really struggling due to SEND or other factors but I honestly think this would turn into a charter for neglectful parents looking for a get out of jail free. As it is there’s no proper oversight of home schooling. So many adults are desperate for an excuse not to have to work or play any part in society and kids would fall through the gaps.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2023 17:48

I would like to see better funding for carers, including for those who are caring for children awaiting a diagnosis of some kind. I think evidence from a medical professional should be required to release this funding but the application process needs to be speeded up so that people don't have to wait for months on end.

I don't think there needs to be specific funding for home educators per se. Unless there is some kind of medical evidence, who would make the judgement about whether a child can function in school or not, and what's to stop a workshy parent from withdrawing their child for all of the wrong reasons?

Separate from any funding questions, I do think there should be proper regulation of home education, for safeguarding reasons and to ensure that children are having their right to an education fully met. I have no idea why there is so much opposition to this idea in the home ed community. If people are doing a good job of educating their kids, I don't see what they have to hide.

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 17:46

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 17:14

Unfortunately we don't have the Finnish school system, we have the British one, which doesn't offer what you describe. I think your understanding of what proper home education entails is lacking. For one thing, they don't sit at home all day with mum and dad. The classes, clubs and workshops available could fill everyday, if that's what we wanted. My child is also in Scouts and a sports team. She socialises every day and deals with all sorts of people. She had over 50 friends come to her birthday party last week. Friends who she sees regularly. Trust me when I say that home educated children arent all sat at home, being sheltered from the real world. She began her GCSEs in year 5. She is thriving both academically and socially. She's not alone in that. I've never known a happier, kinder and more interesting group of children than the home educated children we know. They find their passion and can talk all day about it, because they are driven to learn about the subjects that interest them.

I know we don't, that's my point- in the context of spending money on establishing this as a system with robust regulation in place (which is what it would need) it is a waste of money and would be better spent reforming the education system that is not inclusive, that is results orientated, that does not necessarily encourage creativity!

Why did you DD begin GCSEs at 11? It seems unnecessary and results orientated. A homeschooled child doesn't have a monopoly on being passionate about a subject, my DS is 16 studying Politics 'A' level, reads around the subject and could chat to you for a very long time on current affairs. There is no way my DC who are 16 and 12 would want me to be their teacher or a facilitator of all their learning needs. My 16 year old wants to be at 6th form college, he wants to be at a place of learning, with teachers who specialise in subjects, with a library where he can get all the books out he needs on his subjects for free, where they have careers' advice, getting in to Oxbridge advisors, extracurricular sports teams and clubs, hanging out with people his own age in the school cafe, all of this is on tap and is part of belonging to something, it is really important for teenage development to have independence and be making your own way and your own decisions.

YewTree84 · 25/09/2023 17:41

I think it would open the floodgates.

Every other kid seems to have SEN these days.

Education for this group is important, but I don't think home schooling is the answer.

Hubblebubble · 25/09/2023 17:37

Home education in this country needs a massive overhaul so that all children get their right to an education and regular safeguarding checks.

Hubblebubble · 25/09/2023 17:28

@underneaththeash this is exactly what my stepfather did with my sister. Thank god i still got to go to school.

LolaSmiles · 25/09/2023 17:17

@LolaSmiles I'm not saying unschooling isn't amazing, it really really is, but as you say, it takes a tremendous amount of work. Lazy parents who read online that leaving your kid to get on with it will reap massive results are deluded and it hurts me to see. It's heartbreaking
Yes I agree with you. It's piggy-backing on something that is difficult to do well and twisting it into something else.

They're kidding themselves if they think their child sitting in their room playing computer games and browsing socials is going to give them the breadth of experiences that children with non-lazy parents give.

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 17:14

Unfortunately we don't have the Finnish school system, we have the British one, which doesn't offer what you describe. I think your understanding of what proper home education entails is lacking. For one thing, they don't sit at home all day with mum and dad. The classes, clubs and workshops available could fill everyday, if that's what we wanted. My child is also in Scouts and a sports team. She socialises every day and deals with all sorts of people. She had over 50 friends come to her birthday party last week. Friends who she sees regularly. Trust me when I say that home educated children arent all sat at home, being sheltered from the real world. She began her GCSEs in year 5. She is thriving both academically and socially. She's not alone in that. I've never known a happier, kinder and more interesting group of children than the home educated children we know. They find their passion and can talk all day about it, because they are driven to learn about the subjects that interest them.

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 15:35

Saracen · 25/09/2023 15:34

I'm a long-term home educator and have often seen the problem you're describing, OP. It is heartbreaking.

However, it seems to me that you are suggesting an education-linked solution to the problem of a broken disability financial support system. If we are dreaming of systems which actually work, then rather than concoct a difficult-to-assess home ed support system, I think it makes better sense to simply offer support to all children with disabilities.

In short, if we imagine that it was straightforward and quick to get DLA awarded, and that carer's allowance paid decently, then parents would already have the financial resources to home educate their disabled children. Nobody would have to assess whether those children "needed" home education or whether the offered school placement was tolerable. The parents could just decide to home educate if they saw it was the best solution.

I agree with you , the dla delays are terrible at the moment. Maybe there needs to be a separate system (like LCRWA for UC is separate to PIP so something that recognises a child’s need to be home educated for Sen/medical that’s quicker to sort out than dla)

OP posts:
Saracen · 25/09/2023 15:34

I'm a long-term home educator and have often seen the problem you're describing, OP. It is heartbreaking.

However, it seems to me that you are suggesting an education-linked solution to the problem of a broken disability financial support system. If we are dreaming of systems which actually work, then rather than concoct a difficult-to-assess home ed support system, I think it makes better sense to simply offer support to all children with disabilities.

In short, if we imagine that it was straightforward and quick to get DLA awarded, and that carer's allowance paid decently, then parents would already have the financial resources to home educate their disabled children. Nobody would have to assess whether those children "needed" home education or whether the offered school placement was tolerable. The parents could just decide to home educate if they saw it was the best solution.

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 14:15

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 09:17

You are suggesting that parents who have been through the school system, aren't educated enough to facilitate their own child's education. Which, doesnt really help the argument of 'school is best'
By 'educated in the field' I assume you mean teacher training. Which is mostly about delivering the curriculum to a large number of children at once. Teachers are leaving the profession in droves because the system is failing. A large portion of them home educate their own children. It's easy to see why.

I certainly am suggesting that as every child in this country has right to an education, children of varying abilities and intelligence are admitted to that system and therefore leave with differing levels of education. Adults that are not very well educated are not going to be competent in providing an education in a home schooling context. Even if an adult is well educated, they may be wholly unsuited for the role. That's before you get to the issue of what a holistic education should entail, i.e there are many advantages in being socialised with your peers and even understanding how life is organised at a macro level outside of the domestic landscape.The Finish education system is the best in the world as it is inclusive, non competitive and has a student orientated approach, there is not a need for a big home schooling community, you have to ask why that is? When you have very young children you may think it is better to homeschool but I personally think teenagers having two myself need more than the company of Mum and Dad. They need to detach, learn independence, learn to deal with challenging people as opposed to their agreeable parents, how do they do that if their horizons are just the family home and a few people in a homeschooling group?

BlueVinca · 25/09/2023 13:46

In a 2 parent family there's no requirement for both parents to work, as long as one parent is funding things. In a solo parent family if a suitable school isn't being provided for the child's needs then I'd agree.

Studswagger · 25/09/2023 13:40

GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 11:30

If I’ve replied to your email in English, welcome you into my house in English and spoken to my children in front of you in English I will find it rude if you start asking me if I can speak or write in English. I’ll also presume you aren’t very bright.

If the parents of my sons’ black friends are repeatedly asked about if they are in gangs, then ask me too. Put it on the form for everyone.

I wouldn’t actually be against monitoring if they sent someone with knowledge of the curriculum and teaching methods. That would be useful. But until they send safeguarding checks into every household with children, to check no one is lying, I’ll be sending written reports.

None of those things mean that you are teaching your child to read or write in English though. All it shows is that they understand spoken English. For all the LA knows you might have decided not to teach them those skills for whatever reason. So they ask, and they ask to see evidence. They would do the same with any multi lingual home where the first language spoken isn’t English. It doesn’t mean they think you are thick/radicalised/lazy/neglectful, just that some parents are.

The same as when you take an injured child to the hospital or a child to the dentist to have teeth out they ask if you have social work involvement. They don’t think every parent is negligent or an abuser, but they know that some are, so they check.

The reality is that the kids that don’t get seen are the ones in the most danger- be that white middle class new age hippies who home Ed on principal or black families with SEN kids who are forced to because the system is shit. They should all be under equal scrutiny and that involves awkward questions.

FloweryName · 25/09/2023 12:30

This would just give councils an excuse not to find or fund a suitable school place and end up with parents under pressure to home educate when they don’t want to.

howshouldibehave · 25/09/2023 12:25

We have parents at school who only send them in because they are forced to through attendance meetings and threats of fines. Getting the children up and dressed and out the door every morning is far harder than letting them stay up all evening and lying in the next morning. I think this would be abused.

We had plenty of PP families who didn’t send their child in during the lockdown period (when they were entitled to a place) because if they didn’t, they could claim £15 per child per week for food for them. When you have 4/5/6 children-that’s a lot of money.

LakieLady · 25/09/2023 12:19

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 08:47

In theory, yes. In practice, what would happen is feckless parents would withdraw their children from school and say they're home educating when they're not.

I agree. It would be abused imo.

Thesearmsofmine · 25/09/2023 12:17

Ladyj84 · 25/09/2023 11:45

There are actually grants and funds available for home educated children up to a certain age. I come from a massive family of home educated and I'm about to start with our 3 youngest next year. The grants help towards books,trips etc similar to how most are free in a school up to a certain age

Where from? Would be interested in examples as I’ve never seen anything like this. The only funding I’ve ever seen is hard fought for and rare.

Ladyj84 · 25/09/2023 11:45

There are actually grants and funds available for home educated children up to a certain age. I come from a massive family of home educated and I'm about to start with our 3 youngest next year. The grants help towards books,trips etc similar to how most are free in a school up to a certain age

GeneralLevy · 25/09/2023 11:42

callingeveryone · 25/09/2023 11:36

@GeneralLevy I know the home-educating parents who lobby against oversight in England. They are an active organised group and they are virtually all whit and middle class.
Anyone who disagrees ends up being too intimidated to say anything against them.
And I am not white, so please do not patronise me about white people in authority.

Who are these people? Do they have a front? Who do they represent?
In London the groups are diverse

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 11:38

I will admit though as a poc myself (also we live in a council house and are not well off at all) I was very pleased my LA ehe officer was also a poc with very extensive SEN knowledge and extremely understanding. I do appreciate not all LA are as good as ours is

OP posts:
callingeveryone · 25/09/2023 11:36

@GeneralLevy I know the home-educating parents who lobby against oversight in England. They are an active organised group and they are virtually all whit and middle class.
Anyone who disagrees ends up being too intimidated to say anything against them.
And I am not white, so please do not patronise me about white people in authority.

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 11:35

*ripped

OP posts:
Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 11:34

I understand some people are very against visits but they also had a go at me about sending samples of work when I was in the fb groups - surely as part of a report some examples of learning would be a could of samples , I understand a lot of learning isn’t ‘on paper ‘ but some is even if a small amount why is it such an issue that I got ripened to shreds for sending work each year to show progress ? I was told I should have refused and only described the work

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread