Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home education should mean one parent has no requirement to work under UC?

210 replies

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 08:11

I home educate but I’m in receipt of carers allowance so I don’t have to worry but many of the parents in the groups we attend have children with difficulties who couldn’t manage school and because they don’t get dla or are waiting for a dla claim (it takes months) they are under extreme pressure.

I know that some people plan to home educate and yes if its a choice for NT dc from age 4 then I can see why they’d be expected to fund that/work alongside but there’s a huge groups of parents struggling to home educate children with difficulties and it seems as if they aren’t recognised and supported ?

AIBU to think that if you’ve had to de register for a child who can’t manage school and you are engaging with your LA home education department (a lot of home educators refuse to engage so there should be something in place where UC have it verified ?) that you should be able to get UC with no requirement to work?

OP posts:
Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 26/09/2023 20:05

No I don’t agree. I think DLA/PIP should be better funded and paid to more who need it. I also think if people home educate they should be able to get a small grant from their LA to cover educational costs equivalent to what a school place educational finding would cost for the child.

Thesearmsofmine · 26/09/2023 20:01

Some people don’t agree with home ed, absolutely fine, I get it, 15 years ago I probably would have felt the same way. I have no problem with that viewpoint if if it’s researched or from experience.

However it is so tiresome when people who dislike home Ed come up with the most bizarre agreements against it that make no sense or are simply untrue.
The notion that home ed children are having their data shared online and used in ways that schooled children are not is frankly a load of rubbish. I have yet to see a single example of this given when asked, so it’s either a highly protected secret(doubtful) or just not true.

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 19:59

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:25

It isn’t actually that easy- yes you can just ignore the conversations about the LA, but what happens when you go to a group and someone says ‘can you you do x on Tuesday?’ and you say no, that’s when my child’s tutor comes… and before you can say when you can make it they have looked at you like you have just announced you brand your child and lock them in the cupboard.

I’ve given up trying 🤷‍♀️ what with that and the massive number of ultra religious people who won’t include my son because I’m a dyke.

You just say ‘I’m busy Tuesday’.

I actually used to work for the LA directly as an home educator and still get on with people, even being a former teacher. There’s just no need. Turn up at workshops or groups if you want but don’t confuse it with a social group for you. Kids can play. Have some down time or focus on your child, go home. I’ve been doing it for many years. Imagine if I said ‘Hi I’m Claire and I work for the council’ to everyone I met.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:59

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 19:32

You are doing it again- you don’t have a monopoly on information, education or knowledge.

I’m not ‘alluding to e-safety’! I am making the point, as have other posters, that data protection is NOT an issue that is specific to the home education community. It obviously, patently, absolutely, isn’t. You are completely obsessed with being the only person who can understand, whilst repeatedly failing to understand-it’s starting to get embarrassing.

I have no idea what ‘Ed tech’ you think we all use or why you think we share data about our children anymore than the parents of children who go to school…

Unless you genuinely believe that data protection isn’t an issue for anyone with schooled children then I don’t know what you think you are adding to this conversation.

The Edtech used by children who go to school is far more likely to be that which is recommended by the school - hence it has been checked out, therefore the risks if there were any, would be established via the due diligence and could be mitigated or not. Sorry but how would one parent do that? Hence the risks are much greater if Ed tech (Ed tech was just an example by the way, other uses of personal data exist) is used in a homeschooling context. There are universal data protection risks but does the average parent actually know what they are looking for, that doesn't matter as much if you are using school recommended Ed tech but if they haven't been recommended by anyone with specialist knowledge, how do you not see the risk is greater of problematic consequences!

Caffeineislife · 26/09/2023 19:58

It would be far better for better SEN provision to exist. More settings that are not classic school but more care farm, forest school, more ETOAS providers etc so that there is real choice for SEN parents. More acceptance of part time or dual registering by LAs and schools, so part time at school and part time at an alternative provision.

There are swathes of the home school community who are very against registers and monitoring for many reasons. There are also children (and to an extent parents) so traumatised by school that everyone is burnt out from fighting the system that for everyone's sake a period of unschooling is required to allow a reset. Registers and LA checking up can reopen old wounds for these families.

There are also the feckless of society who would abuse the uc system you propose given half a chance. They would claim to be home schooling whilst doing bugger all and damaging their children, denying them a right to an education because they are lazy. Even if checks are brought in they will find a way round it. Trust me I know someone who has purposely made themselves severely disabled (to the point of requiring a limb ampuation, purposely blinded themselves in 1 eye and purposely sabotaged their anal and bladder continence) in order to cheat the system. The sad thing is they "advise" others how to cheat the system to and see it as an absolute win.

Then there are the abusers who will absolutely take their victims out of the school system.

There are also the children whose parents have very poor mental health or severe health anxieties. School works as a support for these children. These children and their parents can be monitored and authorities made aware to support the parent.

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 19:49

@Goldenbear Which money is this? The UC that some home ed parents are already getting, that they don't want stopping? So are you arguing that this money should be stopped, the home ed kids gets sent back to school and the parents go back to work? Do you really think that amount would be enough to improve the school system even slightly? Home ed isn't funded by the government. There is no money being kept out of schools and spent on home ed kids. If anything home ed is saving the government millions. Is that being put into schools? Of course not! So data protection and an insignificant amount of benefit money, is your reason for being anti home ed. Yeah, sure it is.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:45

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 19:32

You are doing it again- you don’t have a monopoly on information, education or knowledge.

I’m not ‘alluding to e-safety’! I am making the point, as have other posters, that data protection is NOT an issue that is specific to the home education community. It obviously, patently, absolutely, isn’t. You are completely obsessed with being the only person who can understand, whilst repeatedly failing to understand-it’s starting to get embarrassing.

I have no idea what ‘Ed tech’ you think we all use or why you think we share data about our children anymore than the parents of children who go to school…

Unless you genuinely believe that data protection isn’t an issue for anyone with schooled children then I don’t know what you think you are adding to this conversation.

The absence of it, as with other areas of focus, regulatory bodies require organisations to make, 'IS' an issue for homeschooling, it is a regulatory void and that is relating to the specific issue of HSing.

You absolutely are describing e-safety concerns, you evidently don't have a clue by the language you are using and the lack of knowledge you have and neither would I expect you to unless it was your field of work. I absolutely don't have a monopoly on it which I have repeated again and again, I've signposted you to the ICO website and you could read up on the legislation, books, whatever but the very fact that you asking me to summarise this information in two sentences suggests your complete absence of knowledge in this area. You've said nothing to convince me otherwise!

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:35

dimorphism · 26/09/2023 19:20

Being badly schooled during Covid is not a safeguarding risk. An education risk, yes. They are not the same things.

I'm asking this question: what evidence is there that families that homeschool are proportionally more likely to pose safeguarding risks to their children than families with children in school.

I'm assuming there is no such evidence and this is just an assertion that people who have a vested interest in schools make.

I'm not pro- or anti- homeschooling. I think for some children it works, whilst others are better in school. However some people in government positions do seem to be very anti-homeschooling.

There are plenty of online providers of homeschooling materials now. If parents aren't well educated themselves they can access these. Some you have to pay for of course, so those who don't have any money will likely get worse resources. However there are also free resources. The LA / government could have a role in approving online homeschooling resources to help homeschooling parents, but to my knowledge do not do this. I do think that if a child is homeschooled due to trauma in school / inability of the school to meet the child's needs, then the LA should have some responsibility to finance homeschooling resources for that family.

If you are referring this reply to me, I haven't discussed the safeguarding concerns with any great depth, I've literally said about the education. Isn't the lack of good education bad enough though! It is a regulatory void which is the main issue with ploughing more money in to it. What about the children at school who are suffering in our current inadequate system but have no choice of being homeschooled - the money needs to go on all children not just some.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 19:32

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:06

Well no, sorry, again you've misunderstood as you are alluding to e-safety, that isn't what data protection is about. Schools have to by law carry out the due diligence that informs the protections they put in place to comply with data protection laws. You as a private individual don't have that obligation put upon you and won't be drawing up contracts, data sharing agreements, applying technical measures, have you obtained ISO certification for example? When you are looking at the privacy notice do you know what you are looking for to guarantee your privacy? No offence but I doubt it as you haven't understood the difference between e-safety and data protection! The risks are mitigated by organisations as they have specialist knowledge that they can apply in different areas of school life, like safeguarding, like data protection, like cyber security and professional expertise that is not going to be covered by one parent. Yes, parents can use their Ed tech for example outside of the safety net of school but are they likely to diverge from the ones checked out by the school and used to compliment the curriculum, probably not.

If it was as simple as you are making out there would be no need for my kind of job at all.

You are doing it again- you don’t have a monopoly on information, education or knowledge.

I’m not ‘alluding to e-safety’! I am making the point, as have other posters, that data protection is NOT an issue that is specific to the home education community. It obviously, patently, absolutely, isn’t. You are completely obsessed with being the only person who can understand, whilst repeatedly failing to understand-it’s starting to get embarrassing.

I have no idea what ‘Ed tech’ you think we all use or why you think we share data about our children anymore than the parents of children who go to school…

Unless you genuinely believe that data protection isn’t an issue for anyone with schooled children then I don’t know what you think you are adding to this conversation.

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 19:31

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:09

Ultimately, I'm not really going to provide free consultancy on the above, why would I?

My line of work has lead me to handling much more sensitive information that 'Jonny is doing in well in science' I understand data protection and home education (one of which your understanding is lacking in) The only data sharing that is done routinely in home ed, is with the local authority. There is no more risk to home ed children's data, than a school child's. A lot of school children are also using the same online educational games and resources that home ed kids use. You've chosen such a strange angle to attack home ed from, it's almost like you can think of no other tangible argument against it. Just say "I don't like it! I dont understand it. It's too strange to me." I'd actually respect that more, than anything else you've said.

dimorphism · 26/09/2023 19:20

Being badly schooled during Covid is not a safeguarding risk. An education risk, yes. They are not the same things.

I'm asking this question: what evidence is there that families that homeschool are proportionally more likely to pose safeguarding risks to their children than families with children in school.

I'm assuming there is no such evidence and this is just an assertion that people who have a vested interest in schools make.

I'm not pro- or anti- homeschooling. I think for some children it works, whilst others are better in school. However some people in government positions do seem to be very anti-homeschooling.

There are plenty of online providers of homeschooling materials now. If parents aren't well educated themselves they can access these. Some you have to pay for of course, so those who don't have any money will likely get worse resources. However there are also free resources. The LA / government could have a role in approving online homeschooling resources to help homeschooling parents, but to my knowledge do not do this. I do think that if a child is homeschooled due to trauma in school / inability of the school to meet the child's needs, then the LA should have some responsibility to finance homeschooling resources for that family.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:09

Ultimately, I'm not really going to provide free consultancy on the above, why would I?

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:06

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:42

Right, so as I expected- normal online use for both home ed and schooled children. The universal data protection issues that occur in every family because children and parents don’t only use the internet and interact with the mysterious ‘companies’ inside school 🤦‍♀️.

We got there in the end.

Well no, sorry, again you've misunderstood as you are alluding to e-safety, that isn't what data protection is about. Schools have to by law carry out the due diligence that informs the protections they put in place to comply with data protection laws. You as a private individual don't have that obligation put upon you and won't be drawing up contracts, data sharing agreements, applying technical measures, have you obtained ISO certification for example? When you are looking at the privacy notice do you know what you are looking for to guarantee your privacy? No offence but I doubt it as you haven't understood the difference between e-safety and data protection! The risks are mitigated by organisations as they have specialist knowledge that they can apply in different areas of school life, like safeguarding, like data protection, like cyber security and professional expertise that is not going to be covered by one parent. Yes, parents can use their Ed tech for example outside of the safety net of school but are they likely to diverge from the ones checked out by the school and used to compliment the curriculum, probably not.

If it was as simple as you are making out there would be no need for my kind of job at all.

OlizraWiteomQua · 26/09/2023 18:50

Long let it remain that home education be a choice for parents to make, and not legislated against

there will have to be legislation against it soon. The labour plan to charge VAT on school fees has such an easy work-around if clusters of 15 sets of parents of 7 year olds happen to choose to home-educate and club together to employ tutors for the group of them, and for an agency to exist which helps to gather together like-minded families and hire them a venue for such get-togethers. The new labour government will either have to have VAT on tutoring too or have much more draconian policing of home-ed.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:42

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 18:33

😩I cannot tell you what personal data you share only you know that, if at all. The companies again are ones you choose to use for homeschooling but also the ones they use if they use sub- processors.

I never said, 'serious' but it could be! depends on what 'you' choose to use personal data for.

If you want to learn about data protection like I have already posted, the ICO website is good. You would have to teach yourself all about it or go on a course. I am not special and it is not an exclusive club but like anyone you will have to pursue your interest or job in it yourself.

Right, so as I expected- normal online use for both home ed and schooled children. The universal data protection issues that occur in every family because children and parents don’t only use the internet and interact with the mysterious ‘companies’ inside school 🤦‍♀️.

We got there in the end.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 18:33

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:10

We are going round in circles because you have asserted that there are serious data related issues concerning home education, but each time you are asked anything further you act as if it is special clever information that only special clever you can understand.

You mention ‘data’ and ‘companies’- all I’m asking is; what data and which companies are you referring to?!

I fully accept that this isn’t my wheelhouse, if it was why would I be asking you?

You seem to be so committed to the ‘home ed parents are a bit thick and can’t really understand the world, their poor children’ thing that you have lost all your communication skills!

😩I cannot tell you what personal data you share only you know that, if at all. The companies again are ones you choose to use for homeschooling but also the ones they use if they use sub- processors.

I never said, 'serious' but it could be! depends on what 'you' choose to use personal data for.

If you want to learn about data protection like I have already posted, the ICO website is good. You would have to teach yourself all about it or go on a course. I am not special and it is not an exclusive club but like anyone you will have to pursue your interest or job in it yourself.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:25

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 17:54

Facebook is a massive way of connecting in the community, I don’t know anyone who left it entirely. You’re denying then a massive amount of groups if you do. Just stop arguing and ignore those threads like most people

It isn’t actually that easy- yes you can just ignore the conversations about the LA, but what happens when you go to a group and someone says ‘can you you do x on Tuesday?’ and you say no, that’s when my child’s tutor comes… and before you can say when you can make it they have looked at you like you have just announced you brand your child and lock them in the cupboard.

I’ve given up trying 🤷‍♀️ what with that and the massive number of ultra religious people who won’t include my son because I’m a dyke.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:13

Homeeducationproblems · 26/09/2023 17:37

All we were asked for was to show a few examples of work - we did this in person for a home visit (they just looked at it no photos etc) or with yearly reports we just emailed some examples in (usually similar eg comprehension work from one year to the next or art to show progress), I left the fb groups as after admitting this it was a pile on and I was called all sorts of things - the thing is I want the LA to check up that my dc are ok and getting a suitable education. I know it’s important . I also got had a go at for having a timetable as was told I shouldn’t be ‘recreating school’

I wonder if you live near me?! I could really do with connecting with some home educators who see things this way.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 18:10

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 17:29

We are just going around in circles as you have misunderstood my point again. It is not wholly about 'what' personal data, that depends on what you are using it for, do you know what and how companies are using your children's personal data when you share it with them.

We are going round in circles because you have asserted that there are serious data related issues concerning home education, but each time you are asked anything further you act as if it is special clever information that only special clever you can understand.

You mention ‘data’ and ‘companies’- all I’m asking is; what data and which companies are you referring to?!

I fully accept that this isn’t my wheelhouse, if it was why would I be asking you?

You seem to be so committed to the ‘home ed parents are a bit thick and can’t really understand the world, their poor children’ thing that you have lost all your communication skills!

Thesearmsofmine · 26/09/2023 18:02

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 17:53

How would I know what personal data you are sharing, that's like asking me what colour shoes do you like or what did you have dinner last Wednesday. It is known to you what if any personal data you are sharing, more importantly if you are doing that who is it with and how is used. How will it be used in the future.

So why are you insinuating that home educated children are any more at risk? Children in school also have parents who may be sharing their data online. Yes, schools out safeguards in place while in school but as you say yourself that isn’t the case outside of school so there is the same risk there.

RedToothBrush · 26/09/2023 17:55

What would happen is chancers and arseholes would remove their children from school 'to make money' and wouldn't even try to educate them. Cos people try to exploit the system wherever they can.

This would be a safeguarding risk and rob already vulnerable children of an education.

It's not about well meaning good citizens OP. It just wouldn't work.

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 17:54

Homeeducationproblems · 26/09/2023 17:37

All we were asked for was to show a few examples of work - we did this in person for a home visit (they just looked at it no photos etc) or with yearly reports we just emailed some examples in (usually similar eg comprehension work from one year to the next or art to show progress), I left the fb groups as after admitting this it was a pile on and I was called all sorts of things - the thing is I want the LA to check up that my dc are ok and getting a suitable education. I know it’s important . I also got had a go at for having a timetable as was told I shouldn’t be ‘recreating school’

Facebook is a massive way of connecting in the community, I don’t know anyone who left it entirely. You’re denying then a massive amount of groups if you do. Just stop arguing and ignore those threads like most people

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 17:53

Thesearmsofmine · 26/09/2023 17:42

Sorry I actually was aiming my comment at @Goldenbear I know what a home visit entails for home educators.

I am curious what personal data she believes that home educators are sharing online?

How would I know what personal data you are sharing, that's like asking me what colour shoes do you like or what did you have dinner last Wednesday. It is known to you what if any personal data you are sharing, more importantly if you are doing that who is it with and how is used. How will it be used in the future.

scoobydoo1971 · 26/09/2023 17:51

I home educate my youngest child who has ASD and dyspraxia. It takes time and some financial resources to be performed well. I also run my own business, I don't claim UC and I have a serious disability. It is a struggle balancing everything in the week, but we get there because she is happier at home and academically thriving. However, the Government are never going to allow UC claimants to avoid the work rules because their children are home educated. It would be akin to admitting that the State education system doesn't suit everyone, and isn't always desirable or best. I broadly agree with some of the comments made in this thread. Some home educators have a political agenda weaved in stories of State conspiracy, indoctrination and surveillance that make them opposed to cooperating with home education officers. It is, for some, rooted in adverse experience of the establishment (the Portsmouth council experience is one example). However, I do think there is some hypocrisy amongst them if they have ever received benefits, used the NHS for care or otherwise relied upon State funding. You cannot hate State 'dictators' and then gladly receive remuneration from this source as well. Many home educated families we have met are not using schools because they didn't attend themselves (parents) or because the school has failed to meet child needs in some way. The parents who were home educated run family business operations, or became professionals like nurses or dentists. They seem to have a genuine interest in their child's well being and best interests, and make lots of effort to make sure their child is exposed to a formal education. Long let it remain that home education be a choice for parents to make, and not legislated against as has happened in some other countries.

Thesearmsofmine · 26/09/2023 17:42

Homeeducationproblems · 26/09/2023 17:37

All we were asked for was to show a few examples of work - we did this in person for a home visit (they just looked at it no photos etc) or with yearly reports we just emailed some examples in (usually similar eg comprehension work from one year to the next or art to show progress), I left the fb groups as after admitting this it was a pile on and I was called all sorts of things - the thing is I want the LA to check up that my dc are ok and getting a suitable education. I know it’s important . I also got had a go at for having a timetable as was told I shouldn’t be ‘recreating school’

Sorry I actually was aiming my comment at @Goldenbear I know what a home visit entails for home educators.

I am curious what personal data she believes that home educators are sharing online?

Swipe left for the next trending thread