Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home education should mean one parent has no requirement to work under UC?

210 replies

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 08:11

I home educate but I’m in receipt of carers allowance so I don’t have to worry but many of the parents in the groups we attend have children with difficulties who couldn’t manage school and because they don’t get dla or are waiting for a dla claim (it takes months) they are under extreme pressure.

I know that some people plan to home educate and yes if its a choice for NT dc from age 4 then I can see why they’d be expected to fund that/work alongside but there’s a huge groups of parents struggling to home educate children with difficulties and it seems as if they aren’t recognised and supported ?

AIBU to think that if you’ve had to de register for a child who can’t manage school and you are engaging with your LA home education department (a lot of home educators refuse to engage so there should be something in place where UC have it verified ?) that you should be able to get UC with no requirement to work?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Emz6103 · 27/09/2023 03:21

MojoMoon · 25/09/2023 08:20

Ideally if your child has enough difficulties that they cannot be in school and the LEA doesn't have suitable special education provision, then parents should get carers allowance or other similar payment which would then facilitate home education. In an ideal world this would be very rare as special education would be suitably funded.

I don't think the religious wingnuts who don't want their children mingling with heathens should get payments from the state to facilitate this to home educate. Or those who take their kids out of school to avoid safeguarding concern investigations.

Religious wingnuts? How dare you!! There's all manner of reasons people might not want their child to attent school, most who keep their children home for religious reasons don't need universal credit! They don't waste their money on false nails, eyelashes fancy hair dos, fags booze, nights out, take aways, designer clothes n shoes, endless days out, foreign boozy holidays,flash cars, and can often afford to live on one salary because of this!! Why can't you just talk to op without being extremely rude about people with religious beliefs who rarely take anything from the state

Saracen · 26/09/2023 23:47

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 12:34

To add to this, you say what evidence, a big bit of evidence is the shit way many of us handled educating our children at home during COVID. You can argue that is not 'proper' homeschooling but that's the point how many people can offer a good homeschooling experience- not many!

The unsuccessful nature of lockdown home schooling for many families was not due to parental incompetence or lack of financial resources!

First, many schools were demanding parents follow an inappropriate, inflexible school-at-home model. That's difficult and unnecessary, and yes, it is beyond the ability of many nonprofessionals. (By the same token, if I'd been required to look after my babies exactly as a professional working in a day nursery would, I would have failed at that, but luckily there was no such requirement. Parenting is worlds apart from paid childcare in a group setting, just as home education is worlds apart from schooling.)

Second, Covid restrictions deprived families of the opportunities most of us rely on heavily: going out for a change of scene, discussing challenges with other parents, participating in the larger community, getting kids together with friends, doing sports and art and scouts in groups with other kids.

Third, many parents were under immense stress at this time because they were thrown into a situation where they were expected to work from home at the same time as educating their kids.

I totally disagree that "not many" parents can offer a good home ed experience, or that those who turn to home education in desperation after their kids have been harmed by school are more likely to deliver poor quality home education. This isn't what I've seen at all. It is no more true than the prediction that people whose pregnancies were unplanned are destined to be crap parents.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 23:39

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 22:07

Not sharing your life story isn’t lying.
It’s like a school, maybe there is a mum who an advisor at the job centre. She probably won’t mention it to everyone, kids can still be friends. Another parent might vote for the Tories, she doesn’t tell everyone. No one usually even cares what you do, until you tell them. 99% of the time‘I’m busy’ is just fine.
I bet if your son tells another child he saw a tutor that kid won’t remember it 30 seconds later, let alone report back.
stop imposing adult values and disagreements on kids. You aren’t in it to make friends. Your kids can be friends with kids whose parents share other values.
Some of my home Ed friends are hippy types, some unschool, some tutor, some will go back to school. So what? It’s just like school in that respect.
You’ll not find many people to socialise with if you keep having silly rows over nothing. And that means the kids won’t either. The only time I ever struggle with home Ed is when they bore on about philosophy, whether Steiner, Charlotte Mason, the national curriculum or unschooling…. Just that inflexible drone of ‘can’t do different’.

Wow, you are rather defensive. I’m not desperate to make friends with home Ed people particularly, I have both mum friends and pre baby friends. My home Ed kid has friends who aren’t home Ed- but sometimes we also go to home Ed stuff.

I’m only bothered about turning up and making polite small talk for an hour here or there while he joins in with an activity. I don’t have the luxury of enough time to try to be bezzy mates with every home Ed parent I meet.

This never seems to be an issue with the families with children with SEN who have been forced out of the school system- they all seem to be concentrating on caring for their children as best they can- not picking apart everyone else’s families and methods of home educating.

If responding to a question about what my career is by saying… what my career is (they always love that one!) or a question about my husband by referring to my wife, is an unnecessary telling of my life story then fair enough. I guess some people would lie and gloss over things to fit into a group but that isn’t me.

And I’ll certainly never tell my children to lie about their family in case some bigot gets upset- and none of us would want to be friends with ‘people who hold other values’ if those other values are homophobic.

Be a new age unschooling hippy, be a high court judge with a governess and 4 tutors- I’m somewhere in the middle myself- that doesn’t affect being able to be friendly and polite- just don’t pretend that your way is the correct way and everyone else is doing it wrong!

OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 22:46

@Goldenbear my original question - Can you provide an example of the type of companies EHE families give their personal data to that schooled families don’t? So, no I’m not asking for specific company names, you clearly didn’t want to post any, but the type of companies you mean. It is relevant to your point because you are incorrectly assuming schooled families don’t share their personal data with companies themselves separate to school. So I was asking what companies do EHE families use that others don’t.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 22:39

OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 22:26

I am not talking about e-safety, I am talking about personal data. I asked for examples of the types of companies EHE families may give their data to that others don’t, not specific companies, not about e-safety. I don’t need to pay for anything, you are the one stating something which I asked you to provide an example of.

I don't understand your question, you want examples but you don't want specific company names. It is not that personal data of children will be shared by homeschoolers but not by schools, I mean it may be the case that there are organisations, companies that home schoolers have shared their data with and a school wouldn't touch with a barge pole but who knows. It is not relevant to my point, which is about the ability and resources to carry out due diligence, to put in place technical and organisational measures to reduce the risk to the personal data. It is sometimes a risk assessment process, the action taken is on a case by case basis. The outcome of this is that the risk to the homeschoolers sharing their personal data is higher than in an organisational context.

Some such list and service is for organisations, not private individuals and they cost thousands.

OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 22:26

I am not talking about e-safety, I am talking about personal data. I asked for examples of the types of companies EHE families may give their data to that others don’t, not specific companies, not about e-safety. I don’t need to pay for anything, you are the one stating something which I asked you to provide an example of.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 22:22

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 21:10

@Studswagger Oh I've been biting too. Like talking to a self important brick wall ha

Hilarious, when you are trying to convince me that I am wrong about a point that I have never asserted i.e it is complete fiction on your part.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 22:14

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 21:03

@OvertakenByLego no she can’t, she will say she can’t possibly know that and anyway you don’t understand.

😂good grief is this you demonstrating you know about data protection as what you are alluding to yet again is e-safety, for what seems like the 100th time there is not some categorical list of companies or other organisations that process your personal data that is available out there on the internet, if you want anything akin to that for Ed tech you need to pay for it, a PP is right the government doesn't provide a pre approved list so outside of that it will to be paid for- mainly because it is reflecting the hard work and knowledge needed to approve that compliancy.

You can always ask Studswagger though as they appear to have all the knowledge of this area of work.

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 22:07

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:26

So, lie then? What would be the point in that?! Why would I go out of my way for my son to socialise with groups of children whose families are so entirely close minded and unpleasant, just because they happen to be home educated?

Is my son supposed to lie too? Should I warn him before groups “X, if they ask what you have been up to today, tell them we went to the park- don’t tell them the tutor came’. Or “don’t tell X about having two mummies, they won’t want to be friends with you anymore”?!

Fuck that for a bag of toffees.

There are other children and opportunities to socialise.

Not sharing your life story isn’t lying.
It’s like a school, maybe there is a mum who an advisor at the job centre. She probably won’t mention it to everyone, kids can still be friends. Another parent might vote for the Tories, she doesn’t tell everyone. No one usually even cares what you do, until you tell them. 99% of the time‘I’m busy’ is just fine.
I bet if your son tells another child he saw a tutor that kid won’t remember it 30 seconds later, let alone report back.
stop imposing adult values and disagreements on kids. You aren’t in it to make friends. Your kids can be friends with kids whose parents share other values.
Some of my home Ed friends are hippy types, some unschool, some tutor, some will go back to school. So what? It’s just like school in that respect.
You’ll not find many people to socialise with if you keep having silly rows over nothing. And that means the kids won’t either. The only time I ever struggle with home Ed is when they bore on about philosophy, whether Steiner, Charlotte Mason, the national curriculum or unschooling…. Just that inflexible drone of ‘can’t do different’.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 21:52

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:59

Once more for those at the back- I ASKED YOU TO EXPLAIN IN AN ATTEMPT TO GET YOU TO SHOW YOUR TRUE BIAS. And you did (and did quite a lot of amusing showing off and throwing around of long words along the way). You proved I was correct in my first supposition about you.

Why do you think I have a chip on my shoulder? Because I didn’t immediately bow to your self proclaimed wisdom and authority on a topic I understand very well? Ok- if that makes you feel better.

Edited

No you didn't, are you honestly expecting me to believe you work in privacy/data protection and know what you are talking about, if that is the case you can explain the situation in depth to those that are asking me to do it, all the actions they need to take and what the due diligence involves. You might want to separately go about that though as the thread may not be big enough for that level of information to be posted.

I am not sure why you have carried out some covert investigation to get me to reveal my true intentions as I have openly said from the outset the idea in the OP is flawed. This is not some great conspiracy where people are out to get the homeschoolers - I don't give a toss if you homeschool, I do care that children have a right to an education, which would be a substandard one in some cases if homeschooling was a choice just because it is nice to do!

Jigglypuff87 · 26/09/2023 21:18

Some people have home visits and they are successful, that's fantastic. The issue for some of is that the vast majority of the EHE teams don't have any experience whatsoever with educating children with additional needs. We allowed a home visit and it completely backfired as the staff member who came had no idea regarding my child's very complex needs. I had to explain his communication aid which she then totally misrepresented as she had no clue what it was nevermind how it works! She insisted on comparing him to his peers, asking about gcses despite severe learning difficulties. We no longer allow visits and instead write a detailed report, that way there can't be any misinterpretation due to ignorance.

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 21:10

@Studswagger Oh I've been biting too. Like talking to a self important brick wall ha

ketchup07070 · 26/09/2023 21:08

While schools can and should be vastly improved, I think it's impossible to provide an environment suitable to every child. A small grant equivalent to pupil funding, as suggested many times on this thread, would be beneficial to assist access to more suitable learning environments. In my area a number of alternative schools offer part time education, including Montessori, Democratic and Self directed learning styles. I think it would be fairer and more realistic to allocate funding to assist home educated children to access these facilities, rather than insisting mainstream schools need to be inclusive and suitable for everyone. The insistence from some that home educators should receive no financial help, because one day schools can be made one size fits all, is completely unrealistic.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 21:06

@PandaExpress you are right. I don’t know why I bother really!

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 21:03

@OvertakenByLego no she can’t, she will say she can’t possibly know that and anyway you don’t understand.

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 21:02

@Studswagger I would just leave @Goldenbear to it now. She's still going on about a fictional higher data protection risk and an imaginary pot of money, that could go to schools instead of home ed 😅 No money is getting taken from schools and given to home ed @Goldenbear 'The money' you keep talking about putting into schools, is all in your head! If you want a better education system, vote for a different government and lobby for change!

OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 21:01

OlizraWiteomQua · 26/09/2023 18:50

Long let it remain that home education be a choice for parents to make, and not legislated against

there will have to be legislation against it soon. The labour plan to charge VAT on school fees has such an easy work-around if clusters of 15 sets of parents of 7 year olds happen to choose to home-educate and club together to employ tutors for the group of them, and for an agency to exist which helps to gather together like-minded families and hire them a venue for such get-togethers. The new labour government will either have to have VAT on tutoring too or have much more draconian policing of home-ed.

15 would be an unregistered school. A school is considered one which provides full time education for 5 or more CSA pupils, or at least 1 pupil with an EHCP or is a LAC.

OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 21:00

@Goldenbear Can you provide an example of the type of companies EHE families give their personal data to that schooled families don’t? Because I also don’t know what companies you mean. Families with DC in schools also use tutors, extra curricula clubs, subscriptions/memberships/resources etc., so I’m not quite sure what type of companies you mean. I say that as a parent with DC in school and one with EOTAS.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:59

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 20:50

You really don't understand though as evidenced by your need for an explanation. I don't work in the education sector anymore as the pay is crap and the hassle from parents that don't understand (and think they did) was even worse!

My opinion all along has been that homeschooling should not be funded further by those who just want to do it as opposed to having no choice as it is regulatory void and parents obviously don't have the breadth of resources or knowledge as a single entity to make it a feasible choice for the masses. The money needs to go on providing a reformed, inclusive, educational system.

I will leave you with your delusions though as I can see that you're not open to learning about anything new, maybe if you get that chip off your shoulder you may be open to the idea that other people have ideas you can learn from!

Once more for those at the back- I ASKED YOU TO EXPLAIN IN AN ATTEMPT TO GET YOU TO SHOW YOUR TRUE BIAS. And you did (and did quite a lot of amusing showing off and throwing around of long words along the way). You proved I was correct in my first supposition about you.

Why do you think I have a chip on my shoulder? Because I didn’t immediately bow to your self proclaimed wisdom and authority on a topic I understand very well? Ok- if that makes you feel better.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 20:50

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:19

You don’t get it- I have been asking you to explain it in simple terms not because I don’t understand and need you to explain, but because you have been obfuscating your incorrect opinion that data protection is not an issue for families who have children at school. I was interested to know how far up your own arse you would go in order to avoid being challenged. Turns out- quite a long way!

Eventually you said what you really think- home ed families aren’t capable of understanding data protection and privacy (because we are a bit thick presumably), the families of schooled children are (and are magically protected in all their data needs anyway by you and your Very Clever and Important Job).

We get it. You’re wrong. Let’s leave it at that ey?

You really don't understand though as evidenced by your need for an explanation. I don't work in the education sector anymore as the pay is crap and the hassle from parents that don't understand (and think they did) was even worse!

My opinion all along has been that homeschooling should not be funded further by those who just want to do it as opposed to having no choice as it is regulatory void and parents obviously don't have the breadth of resources or knowledge as a single entity to make it a feasible choice for the masses. The money needs to go on providing a reformed, inclusive, educational system.

I will leave you with your delusions though as I can see that you're not open to learning about anything new, maybe if you get that chip off your shoulder you may be open to the idea that other people have ideas you can learn from!

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:32

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 19:59

You just say ‘I’m busy Tuesday’.

I actually used to work for the LA directly as an home educator and still get on with people, even being a former teacher. There’s just no need. Turn up at workshops or groups if you want but don’t confuse it with a social group for you. Kids can play. Have some down time or focus on your child, go home. I’ve been doing it for many years. Imagine if I said ‘Hi I’m Claire and I work for the council’ to everyone I met.

The very fact you put it as ‘EVEN as a former teacher’ makes my point- there isn’t anything wrong with being a teacher. It shouldn’t be something you have to gloss over in order to be able to talk to people- why was it?

They aren’t social groups for me, but since my kid is disabled with special needs, I do actually have to go and be there for the duration.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:26

GeneralLevy · 26/09/2023 19:59

You just say ‘I’m busy Tuesday’.

I actually used to work for the LA directly as an home educator and still get on with people, even being a former teacher. There’s just no need. Turn up at workshops or groups if you want but don’t confuse it with a social group for you. Kids can play. Have some down time or focus on your child, go home. I’ve been doing it for many years. Imagine if I said ‘Hi I’m Claire and I work for the council’ to everyone I met.

So, lie then? What would be the point in that?! Why would I go out of my way for my son to socialise with groups of children whose families are so entirely close minded and unpleasant, just because they happen to be home educated?

Is my son supposed to lie too? Should I warn him before groups “X, if they ask what you have been up to today, tell them we went to the park- don’t tell them the tutor came’. Or “don’t tell X about having two mummies, they won’t want to be friends with you anymore”?!

Fuck that for a bag of toffees.

There are other children and opportunities to socialise.

Studswagger · 26/09/2023 20:19

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 19:45

The absence of it, as with other areas of focus, regulatory bodies require organisations to make, 'IS' an issue for homeschooling, it is a regulatory void and that is relating to the specific issue of HSing.

You absolutely are describing e-safety concerns, you evidently don't have a clue by the language you are using and the lack of knowledge you have and neither would I expect you to unless it was your field of work. I absolutely don't have a monopoly on it which I have repeated again and again, I've signposted you to the ICO website and you could read up on the legislation, books, whatever but the very fact that you asking me to summarise this information in two sentences suggests your complete absence of knowledge in this area. You've said nothing to convince me otherwise!

You don’t get it- I have been asking you to explain it in simple terms not because I don’t understand and need you to explain, but because you have been obfuscating your incorrect opinion that data protection is not an issue for families who have children at school. I was interested to know how far up your own arse you would go in order to avoid being challenged. Turns out- quite a long way!

Eventually you said what you really think- home ed families aren’t capable of understanding data protection and privacy (because we are a bit thick presumably), the families of schooled children are (and are magically protected in all their data needs anyway by you and your Very Clever and Important Job).

We get it. You’re wrong. Let’s leave it at that ey?

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 20:15

Thesearmsofmine · 26/09/2023 20:01

Some people don’t agree with home ed, absolutely fine, I get it, 15 years ago I probably would have felt the same way. I have no problem with that viewpoint if if it’s researched or from experience.

However it is so tiresome when people who dislike home Ed come up with the most bizarre agreements against it that make no sense or are simply untrue.
The notion that home ed children are having their data shared online and used in ways that schooled children are not is frankly a load of rubbish. I have yet to see a single example of this given when asked, so it’s either a highly protected secret(doubtful) or just not true.

Please explain why it is 'rubbish' for a start it is making a broader point about the regulatory void of homeschooling so it is not even about just DP. Saying something is rubbish is no argument at all and just suggests to me another poster that doesn't have any knowledge of this area. This is fine but what annoys me is don't pretend you do know when all your posts prove otherwise!

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 20:09

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 19:49

@Goldenbear Which money is this? The UC that some home ed parents are already getting, that they don't want stopping? So are you arguing that this money should be stopped, the home ed kids gets sent back to school and the parents go back to work? Do you really think that amount would be enough to improve the school system even slightly? Home ed isn't funded by the government. There is no money being kept out of schools and spent on home ed kids. If anything home ed is saving the government millions. Is that being put into schools? Of course not! So data protection and an insignificant amount of benefit money, is your reason for being anti home ed. Yeah, sure it is.

This is will full misinterpretation again - opting to homeschool because somebody wants to but there are no issues with the school is the idea i object to as it will certainly be abused. The idea that everyone who homeschools can provide an adequate education is ridiculous! The education system should be for all not just homeschooled children, it needs an overhaul for the system to be inclusive. A two tiered system that is unregulated it is not a good idea IMO. Nothing to do with DP, it was just an example of how it isn't effective.