Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Power of attorney and weight issues

31 replies

Hellostrawberries · 24/09/2023 18:29

I just got involved in a big heated debate. I'm pretty certain I'm right but no one agreed with me which drove me mad as a person's bodily autonomy was at stake. Sorry it's a long one.

My parents live in a retirement block. All residents have their own flat and there are carers for people who need it. There's a restaurant on site. One woman who lives there, will call her Sally, is 75 and great fun. She's sociable and chatty and has a great sense of humour. She has dementia and tends to hold onto information for around 10 minutes. So if you make a reference to an earlier conversation she'll have forgotten it. She has a daughter who lives abroad and visits a couple of times a year. The daughter has power of attorney.

Now Sally, like lots of us, likes her food. She's overweight but not excessively so and has no weight related health problems. From looking at her I'd say she was a size 16 or 18. Apparently her daughter came to visit last week and was shocked at how much weight her mother had put on. So she spoke to all the staff and literally demanded that she be put on an enforced diet, so she mustn't be served any desserts, biscuits or cake.

To clarify, this is not a care home. Sally has her own money and a bank account. A carer takes her shopping and Sally eats her meals either from the food in her flat, which a carer helps her to prepare. Or she orders and pays for a meal in the on site restaurant. Biscuits are offered free of charge twice a week at a coffee morning. Sally's daughter has said that her mother must be told she's not allowed to take one! She's also spoken to the restaurant staff and said that her mum can't order desserts.

It's irritated the hell out of me seeing someone treated like this. Because she has dementia and her daughter has LPA, everyone's acting like there's no choice but to comply with the demands. But being a bit fat isn't a situation where power of attorney kicks in. This is literally one adult, having a preference for another adult losing weight. And so instructing everyone around them to withhold food. And that isn't a thing.

OP posts:
AngryAndAnxious · 24/09/2023 18:35

I can’t believe nobody told the daughter that Sally has the right to choose to eat whatever the hell she likes.

helpfulperson · 24/09/2023 18:35

Not 100% sure about elsewhere but in Scotland capacity is decision specific so someone might not have capacity to decide where to live but still have capacity to decide if they want another biscuit. I suspected that staff may well have made polite noises when told this and will continue to allow this lady to eat what she wants.

User183642 · 24/09/2023 18:33

If she can still retain information for 10 minutes or so I wouldn’t have thought she would have reached the stage where power of attorney could be invoked for such minor issues. Whilst it wouldn’t be unreasonable to ask the staff to remind her that she had already eaten if she requested multiple meals or snacks in a short time period a complete ban on desserts and snacks is both taking too things and also likely to be unhelpful in the long run.

Doggymummar · 24/09/2023 18:33

It's a tough one, do you know Sally's medical history? She might have diabetes or other illnesses that would benefit from reduced sugar. I have heard that dementia reacts to sugar in the diet too. Or her daughter might just want her to live a long time and be safeguarding her weight.

Frozenone · 24/09/2023 18:33

LockdownLisa · 24/09/2023 18:32

I'm no legal expert but I find it hard to believe that somebody with LPA can request this and it has to be enforced! If I was the home manager, I'd refuse the request unless it was court ordered.

This

LockdownLisa · 24/09/2023 18:32

I'm no legal expert but I find it hard to believe that somebody with LPA can request this and it has to be enforced! If I was the home manager, I'd refuse the request unless it was court ordered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread