Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 24/09/2023 21:50

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:10

People would be paying for their own children out of their own earnings, just have a bit less taken off them to take account of that

Who is going to plug that shortfall?

grayhairdontcare · 24/09/2023 21:48

So you are pissed you couldn't afford to be sahp.??
Should of worked the financial aspects out before hand and got your head around it

SueVineer · 24/09/2023 21:48

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:42

I have to pay more for my heating because I live in an area not served by mains gas

Can I get some tax breaks over those who live in a mains gas area?

I also have to pay more for transport because I live in an area with no public transport. I will take my tax break for that please 😃

I mean this could open up a whole range of complicated tax calculations!

Government uses the tax system to drive public policy objectives- eg pension savings. There’s no reason the tax system couldn’t take account of people with, say, a maximum of two dependent children under 18. That’s done in lots of other countries. In order to drive desirable behavior for society (ie that those not eligible for benefits can still afford to have children).

There are subsidies for public transport and indeed a price cap on domestic fuel including heating oil. The government facilitates our lives in many ways.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:47

shouldn’t have to pay tax on childcare

OP posts:
Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:46

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:36

The average cost of childcare is 6.5k but you didn't want that to be subsidised because you didn't think your tax should have to pay for it

So this feels hypocritical

I want it to be subsidised for those who need it subsidised e.g. those on UC, students etc. We paid 13.5k a year in childcare not long ago so I’m not unfamiliar with the costs of childcare, especially given that certain months we had to borrow money to cover the cost. However I just disagree that I was some how more virtuous having be a working mother than my friend who was a SAHM and so entitled to their money to pay for that, I do agree parents should have to pay tax on childcare costs so agree with TFC.
All I would like is some fairness in the tax system so that it acknowledges children as having the same right to a tax free allowance within the family as adults currently receive

OP posts:
ChesterDrawz · 24/09/2023 21:45

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:32

Unless children really can survive on fresh air then how on earth is a parent being able to keep 2.5k a year more of their own earned income per child better off than someone who doesn’t have the expense of a dependant child??? Please explain how you think parents are able to spend less than 2.5k a year in raising a child??

So, OP, how do we know you're any good at this vital job of raising children?

Before we, as a country, cough up more tax to subsidise you I'd like to see proof you'll do a good job of producing and raising educated, productive, law abiding, good future adult citizens (disability not withstanding before someone shouts "eugenics!").

After all, you don't get to just chose yourself for a job in any other avenue, do you, and you might be shit at this one you're appointing yourself to at everyone else's expense.

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 21:44

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:34

I mean the details I asked for where things like

How does someone prove they are infertile - which tests prove this
How does someone prove they are gay
Does someone have to jump through every hoop such as IVF to justify their infertility

No financial values required

Regardless,
Im sorry for your loss

Little bit late after calling me distasteful for mentioning it really isn't it

Spoiling for a fight.

No, asking questions. You have already told one women to calm down and now I am apparently being overly emotional for asking you questions about your proposal. Do you always call women emotional when they ask you questions you can't answer?

😊
I cant ever remember calling a women emotional when I couldnt answer a question.

How does someone proove they are infertile? Quite simple for a man its semen analysis, females have a number of options including blood tests, ultrsound scans to name a couple. I did touch on this answer earlier.

How does someone proove they are gay? As I understand it the test we use today in the uk is self identification, your not expected to proove, demonstrate or act it out infront of a panel of judges.

Does someone have to jump through every hoop such as IVF to justify their infertility? No, see answer one.

Hope this helps.

User183642 · 24/09/2023 21:42

I wouldn’t be opposed to a household based tax allowance with some additional tax free income for those with children as long as those who chose not to work had a negative allowance for the household and the allowance was the same whether the household had one or two adults (or more in the case of polygamous households).
Something along the lines of £22,000 for childless households, £29,000 for those with one child and £35,000 for those with multiple children however each adult not working through choice would have a negative allowance of £20,000 reducing the allowance to £2,000 for childless couples with a housewife or househusband, £9,000 for families with a stay at home parent and one child and £15,000 for those with multiple children and a stay at home parent (the reduction equating to £4000 in additional tax being paid to cover lost pension contributions and the loss to the economy).

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:42

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 21:38

Ah. So you think that because a parent on £30k has more that they need to spend their money on, then them being permitted to keep more of their tax means they’re not being paid more than their non-parent colleague on £30k.

This could really spice up the tax system. Can I, a single childless person, get a tax break on my £30k because my disposable income has to go further than that of my colleague Helen, who has a husband also earning £30k and therefore gets to live on twice what I earn?

Edited

I have to pay more for my heating because I live in an area not served by mains gas

Can I get some tax breaks over those who live in a mains gas area?

I also have to pay more for transport because I live in an area with no public transport. I will take my tax break for that please 😃

I mean this could open up a whole range of complicated tax calculations!

grayhairdontcare · 24/09/2023 21:42

@Clariee45 children survive because you chose to have them so you provide for them.
If I choose to go on 3 holidays a year, could I have a tax break? I can't afford it otherwise

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 21:38

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:32

Unless children really can survive on fresh air then how on earth is a parent being able to keep 2.5k a year more of their own earned income per child better off than someone who doesn’t have the expense of a dependant child??? Please explain how you think parents are able to spend less than 2.5k a year in raising a child??

Ah. So you think that because a parent on £30k has more that they need to spend their money on, then them being permitted to keep more of their tax means they’re not being paid more than their non-parent colleague on £30k.

This could really spice up the tax system. Can I, a single childless person, get a tax break on my £30k because my disposable income has to go further than that of my colleague Helen, who has a husband also earning £30k and therefore gets to live on twice what I earn?

SueVineer · 24/09/2023 21:37

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:21

increasing numbers of parents are not eligible for child benefit, just make child benefit taxable, problem solved :)

How does that solve any problems? It means everyone would have to do a tax return and it would cost more to give it to everyone then take some back in tax.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:36

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:32

Unless children really can survive on fresh air then how on earth is a parent being able to keep 2.5k a year more of their own earned income per child better off than someone who doesn’t have the expense of a dependant child??? Please explain how you think parents are able to spend less than 2.5k a year in raising a child??

The average cost of childcare is 6.5k but you didn't want that to be subsidised because you didn't think your tax should have to pay for it

So this feels hypocritical

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:34

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 21:27

I really dont have to justfify or explain anything, to anyone.

You arent asking for justification your asking for specific details which i would have to base on blind guesses on financial values ( Guesses ) which you would then further ask specific questions on. Spoiling for a fight.
Thats largely pointless.

Regardless,
Im sorry for your loss.

I mean the details I asked for where things like

How does someone prove they are infertile - which tests prove this
How does someone prove they are gay
Does someone have to jump through every hoop such as IVF to justify their infertility

No financial values required

Regardless,
Im sorry for your loss

Little bit late after calling me distasteful for mentioning it really isn't it

Spoiling for a fight.

No, asking questions. You have already told one women to calm down and now I am apparently being overly emotional for asking you questions about your proposal. Do you always call women emotional when they ask you questions you can't answer?

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:32

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 20:55

I’m absolutely not wanting non parents or parents whose children are no longer dependant on them to be worse off than people earning the same salary

I mean, that’s exactly what you’re suggesting. You want a parent of a dependant child on £50k to get to keep more of that £50k than a non-parent on £50k. Leaving the latter worse off than the parent earning the same salary.

At least be honest about it!

Unless children really can survive on fresh air then how on earth is a parent being able to keep 2.5k a year more of their own earned income per child better off than someone who doesn’t have the expense of a dependant child??? Please explain how you think parents are able to spend less than 2.5k a year in raising a child??

OP posts:
Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:30

Tremour · 24/09/2023 21:25

In that world if thats the case than single childless or childfree people should then be able to opt out of paying taxes towards funding school and anything child related like child benefit. Cos i'd use that tax to fund my own pension thanks very much. Because what reward do I get for paying taxes to fund children related things? A reduced pension thats what - at that point most people would say fuck off!

I would be really interested to know if @Thatladdo is in fact a man, going by the user name.

Because when someone suggests monetising a woman's uterus I would be really interested to know whether they actually have one themselves.

It's very easy suggesting things to force women into having children when you aren't the one taking the financial, medical, and emotional risks that come with pregnancy, childbirth and parenting.

It's also sort of incel-ish to suggest women should be forced to be impregnated by a man or else forfeit their right to a pension or be financially detrimented by it.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:28

ChesterDrawz · 24/09/2023 21:10

Oh they understand it perfectly.

They just want someone else to pay for it all, not them. 🤷🏻‍♀️

It’s about fairness in the tax system, sure we could ‘try’ to pull in extra taxes by just increasing everyone’s tax tomorrow but it wouldn’t be very fair. Lack of fairness reduces tax revenue ultimately as people tend to not think it very fair when they are not much better off compared to being on UC (as many families find) so don’t bother doing anything to increase their income. Parents facing 80% marginal tax rates between 50-60k turn down that promotion or overtime despite being one of the few people able to do that job so hospitals have to spend thousands head hunting abroad or paying agency staff. How much gets spent in UC administration for families who wouldn’t need it/be eligible if they just had to pay a little less tax. It’s a ridiculous system

OP posts:
SueVineer · 24/09/2023 21:27

There did use to be an extra tax allowance for single parents which matched the marriage tax allowance (pre abolition and reinstatement). Id like to see that reinstated and for the child benefit tax charge to be higher for single parents.

Tremour · 24/09/2023 21:27

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 18:53

Only asking for the equivalent adult tax allowance to be disregarded, which equates to parents keeping 2.5k extra of their earnings (between them) i.e. 20% or current individual tax allowance of £12500

Single person no kids only gets 25% off their council tax, dont you think they should get 50%? After all in a 2 adult home earning money its 50% per person.

Would you back this? Go out an show solidarity for those people so they get 50%? After all its only fair right, or is it that only people with kids should only be treated fairly

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 21:27

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:15

You are putting laughing emojis in reply to your posts to me calling me distasteful for mentioning my stillborn baby just to be clear.

Perhaps if you can't justify your ill thought out discriminatory and distasteful suggestions at 9pm you shouldn't post them?

I think it's more likely that you actually can't justify them.

I really dont have to justfify or explain anything, to anyone.

You arent asking for justification your asking for specific details which i would have to base on blind guesses on financial values ( Guesses ) which you would then further ask specific questions on. Spoiling for a fight.
Thats largely pointless.

Regardless,
Im sorry for your loss.

Tremour · 24/09/2023 21:25

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:06

Perhaps to put another angle on this, the children we have grow up ( finger crossed) to be tax payers, who pay for our state pensions.
Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Or a stepped state pension allowance based on your actual out of pocket tax contributions. 😊

In that world if thats the case than single childless or childfree people should then be able to opt out of paying taxes towards funding school and anything child related like child benefit. Cos i'd use that tax to fund my own pension thanks very much. Because what reward do I get for paying taxes to fund children related things? A reduced pension thats what - at that point most people would say fuck off!

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 21:25

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:17

I mean a family is given a 12.5k tax allowance i.e. for each child 12.5k of earnings is disregarded from the calculation for tax so e.g. at the moment an individual has a 12.5 k tax allowance so if they earn 25k they only pay 2.5k in tax. If a single parent with 2 children earned 50k they would only pay 2.5k in tax rather than 7.5k
NI would still usually be payable on any earnings over the threshold of 12.5k a year, just like it is for regardless of other things currently disregarded for tax purposes such as pensions etc.

Yes agree with better funding for schools and housing.

Further funding for childcare doesn’t really sit comfortably with me, despite my entire salary and more going out in childcare at one point, so I am not anti working mother at all, I am very much for choice. Yes absolutely makes sense to continue with 85% of childcare costs to UC recipients as would be paying equivalent in extra UC if not working. I myself was a single parents before UC/tax credit childcare support and was ludicrous that was effectively forced to not work. However more funded childcare doesn’t sit well with me for lots of reasons. In many cases you will be funding people to work who would have preferred to be at home with their babies, doing jobs that the local teenagers would have had the opportunity to do otherwise and taking up nursery places resulting in mothers who really want or need to work not being able to get childcare. All seems a bit pointless, I would much rather just let their family keep more money so they can make a free choice. The other issue I have with more funded childcare is that when I was a SAHM then significant amounts of tax were being taken off us to fund the childcare of people much better off than us, so effectively felt like being punished for caring for your own children

doing jobs that the local teenagers would have had the opportunity to do otherwise

Lots of teenagers could train as nursery workers if there was a better funded childcare system. Teenagers are far more likely to get entry level roles as nursery workers than replace a woman in her 30s who has had a child.

significant amounts of tax were being taken off us to fund the childcare of people much better off than us, so effectively felt like being punished for caring for your own children

So to be very clear, you don't like your taxes funding childcare because you didn't use it yourself so you felt like you were being punished for caring for your own children, but you expect childfree people to pay higher taxes (they would have to to fund your plan) despite not having children than require children's services and not to feel punished for this?

I firmly believe that everyone, whether they have children or not, needs to pay in taxes to support the next generation of children. I'm just slightly baffled by the notion that the only people that should not pay in taxes to support children are in fact the parents of those children, in case the money goes to subsidised childcare and that punishes them when they haven't used it 🙄

SueVineer · 24/09/2023 21:24

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 21:17

I mean a family is given a 12.5k tax allowance i.e. for each child 12.5k of earnings is disregarded from the calculation for tax so e.g. at the moment an individual has a 12.5 k tax allowance so if they earn 25k they only pay 2.5k in tax. If a single parent with 2 children earned 50k they would only pay 2.5k in tax rather than 7.5k
NI would still usually be payable on any earnings over the threshold of 12.5k a year, just like it is for regardless of other things currently disregarded for tax purposes such as pensions etc.

Yes agree with better funding for schools and housing.

Further funding for childcare doesn’t really sit comfortably with me, despite my entire salary and more going out in childcare at one point, so I am not anti working mother at all, I am very much for choice. Yes absolutely makes sense to continue with 85% of childcare costs to UC recipients as would be paying equivalent in extra UC if not working. I myself was a single parents before UC/tax credit childcare support and was ludicrous that was effectively forced to not work. However more funded childcare doesn’t sit well with me for lots of reasons. In many cases you will be funding people to work who would have preferred to be at home with their babies, doing jobs that the local teenagers would have had the opportunity to do otherwise and taking up nursery places resulting in mothers who really want or need to work not being able to get childcare. All seems a bit pointless, I would much rather just let their family keep more money so they can make a free choice. The other issue I have with more funded childcare is that when I was a SAHM then significant amounts of tax were being taken off us to fund the childcare of people much better off than us, so effectively felt like being punished for caring for your own children

Funding childcare doesn’t force anyone to work. It just gives them the choice.

why do you think your dhs tax was funding childcare for people who earned more than him? That really doesn’t make sense.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 21:23

The other issue I have with more funded childcare is that when I was a SAHM then significant amounts of tax were being taken off us to fund the childcare of people much better off than us, so effectively felt like being punished for caring for your own children

Yes, it’s aggravating when someone suggests that you should pay more tax to fund other people’s choices around children, isn’t it.

But as you’ve said, a person getting to keep more of their own tax just for making one type of reproductive choice doesn’t mean another person who makes a different choice is losing out or being penalised!

grayhairdontcare · 24/09/2023 21:22

@Clariee45 so basically you are pissed that you didn't get free money for being a SAHP?
I refer you back to the only have what you can afford comment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread