Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
Oliotya · 25/09/2023 00:02

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:42

So you are in favour of policies forcing parents back into work then?

I'm confused? Because you said people aren't only measured by their financial contribution to society. But now you are measuring them by their financial contribution to society through their tax.

Either everyone is measured by their financial contribution to society equally or childfree people should not be told off for their lack of future financial contribution to society by not producing a future tax payer

I wonder what the relative merits are of a childfree person who is a higher rate tax payer the majority of their career, who funds their own private pension and their own care vs a sahp who produces a serial killer who spends their life in prison and has no kids.

Personally I think neither is the whole story of the individuals contribution, but on a financial basis neither has produced a young working person paying tax.

Multiple things can be true. An individuals value to society is not dependent upon tax, and we all rely upon tax payers.

ChesterDrawz · 24/09/2023 23:20

Pleaseme · 24/09/2023 22:58

I do think theOP is getting a hard time here. There are lots of variations in tax systems out there.

Obviously you have to work with the tax system you are in (or move) but OP is unfortunate that her set up is pretty much the worst one she could have (financially speaking) with our tax system.

The OECD reckons in the UK the difference in net transfers between the taxpayer and the government is over 30% higher for a single earner household earning 133% of average wage than in comparison to a dual income family with both partners earning equally.

compare it with France (taxed as a family) or Germany ( optional to be taxed as a couple) where there is very little difference in the tax burden for a single income/ dual
income family.

If it helps OP you could compare it with Greece which is a whopping 71.5% difference in net transfer so at least you’re better off than somebody!

Given that well over half of all households are net takers from the tax system, let alone for earners only on 1.3x average pay and having children, I'm not sure what this OECD figure is telling us?

Perhaps it's that the dual income household is a bit less of a burden than the single 133% earning household but still a burden all the same.

HangingByYourFingernails · 24/09/2023 23:17

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 23:13

There's a bit of a difference between making an allowance for the number of people you are supporting on your income and the chain of posts you are replying to around the suggestion that people without children would not be entitled to a state pension though

The state pension thing is bonkers and offensive I agree. But the specific post I was replying to was just about the tax bill.

BIossomtoes · 24/09/2023 23:14

heartofglass23 · 24/09/2023 23:04

Not just this. Single mums should get the same (double) tax allowance 2 parent families get.

And single dads presumably? The trouble with this is it has a knock on effect. It means higher rates kick in further up the scale, ie 40% at £62.5k.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 23:13

HangingByYourFingernails · 24/09/2023 23:07

Which country would you go to? The UK is very rare in making no allowance for the number of people you're supporting on your income within the tax system.

There's a bit of a difference between making an allowance for the number of people you are supporting on your income and the chain of posts you are replying to around the suggestion that people without children would not be entitled to a state pension though

HangingByYourFingernails · 24/09/2023 23:07

daliesque · 24/09/2023 22:50

Any country which decided that I was deserving of less of a state pension (or indeed NO state pension) simply because my body won’t produce taxpayers would see me emigrate right out of it

Now there's an interesting idea....I didn't want children anyway, but after a heavy dose of chemo when I was younger I couldn't have them anyway.

Yet, I'm now a comsultant oncologist and I absolutely would leave any country that made me pay more tax for being infertile. As would many other high tax paying, full time working people who have spent years supporting parents j the workplace....often tk the detriment of their own lives.

If we all go, who will do that Christmas morning shift?

Which country would you go to? The UK is very rare in making no allowance for the number of people you're supporting on your income within the tax system.

heartofglass23 · 24/09/2023 23:04

Not just this. Single mums should get the same (double) tax allowance 2 parent families get.

Pleaseme · 24/09/2023 22:58

I do think theOP is getting a hard time here. There are lots of variations in tax systems out there.

Obviously you have to work with the tax system you are in (or move) but OP is unfortunate that her set up is pretty much the worst one she could have (financially speaking) with our tax system.

The OECD reckons in the UK the difference in net transfers between the taxpayer and the government is over 30% higher for a single earner household earning 133% of average wage than in comparison to a dual income family with both partners earning equally.

compare it with France (taxed as a family) or Germany ( optional to be taxed as a couple) where there is very little difference in the tax burden for a single income/ dual
income family.

If it helps OP you could compare it with Greece which is a whopping 71.5% difference in net transfer so at least you’re better off than somebody!

daliesque · 24/09/2023 22:55

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 20:54

To add, I think the idea of people without children being penalised in anyway, in the present or the future is an abhorrent idea

And yet that is exactly what will happen with your innocent little proposals.

daliesque · 24/09/2023 22:50

Any country which decided that I was deserving of less of a state pension (or indeed NO state pension) simply because my body won’t produce taxpayers would see me emigrate right out of it

Now there's an interesting idea....I didn't want children anyway, but after a heavy dose of chemo when I was younger I couldn't have them anyway.

Yet, I'm now a comsultant oncologist and I absolutely would leave any country that made me pay more tax for being infertile. As would many other high tax paying, full time working people who have spent years supporting parents j the workplace....often tk the detriment of their own lives.

If we all go, who will do that Christmas morning shift?

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:49

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:49

Well yes but it did give a good opportunity for certain posters to be able to tell childfree people that they need people to have children as if the childfree are sneaking around slapping condoms on people in the middle of sex

🤣

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:49

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:45

True! But I think the vote was yabu even before that clanger.

Well yes but it did give a good opportunity for certain posters to be able to tell childfree people that they need people to have children as if the childfree are sneaking around slapping condoms on people in the middle of sex

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:45

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:43

TBF the plan would have had more merit if she hadn't explained that she wanted the tax back so it wouldn't go to fund other people's childcare. It kind of fell apart at that point.

True! But I think the vote was yabu even before that clanger.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:43

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:42

I think 70% of people telling OP she is being unreasonable on a mostly parenting website should bring home how unreasonable she is being.

TBF the plan would have had more merit if she hadn't explained that she wanted the tax back so it wouldn't go to fund other people's childcare. It kind of fell apart at that point.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/09/2023 22:42

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:32

Nice try. But tax breaks are finite. If you give to parents you take from another group.

Parents are not on a par with disabled people in terms of need. Benefits are to help the vulnerable in our society, not to give parents with well paying jobs more disposable income.

Edited

But tax breaks are finite. If you give to parents you take from another group. This is overly simplistic. I don't personally favour a tax break but rather additional subsidies (particularly of childcare - which I no longer need myself) but you are speaking as though the overall amount of money is permanently fixed, whereas the way money is distributed can affect behaviour and result in growth or contraction.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:42

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:34

It is true though. I don't understand why people so resistant to this fact. Without young working people paying tax there's no pensions, no NHS, no social care. It shouldn't be controversial to acknowledge it.

So you are in favour of policies forcing parents back into work then?

I'm confused? Because you said people aren't only measured by their financial contribution to society. But now you are measuring them by their financial contribution to society through their tax.

Either everyone is measured by their financial contribution to society equally or childfree people should not be told off for their lack of future financial contribution to society by not producing a future tax payer

I wonder what the relative merits are of a childfree person who is a higher rate tax payer the majority of their career, who funds their own private pension and their own care vs a sahp who produces a serial killer who spends their life in prison and has no kids.

Personally I think neither is the whole story of the individuals contribution, but on a financial basis neither has produced a young working person paying tax.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:42

I think 70% of people telling OP she is being unreasonable on a mostly parenting website should bring home how unreasonable she is being.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:37

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:29

I don't really think that childfree people are relevant tbh. It's not about them. Nobody is being penalised because they don't receive something. Just like able bodied people aren't being penalised by not receiving PIP.
Children are good for society, as more than just future taxpayers. An individual being childfree whether by choice or circumstance doesn't change that.

I don't really think that childfree people are relevant tbh

I absolutely do believe you think childfree people are irrelevant

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:35

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:34

It is true though. I don't understand why people so resistant to this fact. Without young working people paying tax there's no pensions, no NHS, no social care. It shouldn't be controversial to acknowledge it.

Can you quote where anyone has said society doesn’t needs kids?

Your point has been debated upthread.

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:34

daliesque · 24/09/2023 22:31

Because they would not live very long in old age without other peoples children propping up the economy , caring for them in hospital or nursing care.
Wondered how long it would take for this old cnestnut to be spouted out.

It is true though. I don't understand why people so resistant to this fact. Without young working people paying tax there's no pensions, no NHS, no social care. It shouldn't be controversial to acknowledge it.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 22:32

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:29

I don't really think that childfree people are relevant tbh. It's not about them. Nobody is being penalised because they don't receive something. Just like able bodied people aren't being penalised by not receiving PIP.
Children are good for society, as more than just future taxpayers. An individual being childfree whether by choice or circumstance doesn't change that.

Nice try. But tax breaks are finite. If you give to parents you take from another group.

Parents are not on a par with disabled people in terms of need. Benefits are to help the vulnerable in our society, not to give parents with well paying jobs more disposable income.

daliesque · 24/09/2023 22:31

Because they would not live very long in old age without other peoples children propping up the economy , caring for them in hospital or nursing care.
Wondered how long it would take for this old cnestnut to be spouted out.

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 22:29

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:20

We absolutely can't measure contribution to society by finacial contribution alone. But I was responding along the lines of all the posters telling childfree people they are not contributing enough financially to society because they are not contributing future tax payers

Either financial contribution is the be all and end all, or it isn't. But it can't be the stick used to beat the child free but irrelevant when it comes to parents.

Personally I feel that there are many contributions to society and an artist who doesnt earn enough to pay tax is as great an addition as a trader in the city on a higher rate of tax (in fact I might even rate the artists contribution higher but that's just me)

I don't really think that childfree people are relevant tbh. It's not about them. Nobody is being penalised because they don't receive something. Just like able bodied people aren't being penalised by not receiving PIP.
Children are good for society, as more than just future taxpayers. An individual being childfree whether by choice or circumstance doesn't change that.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 22:23

PaperDoves · 24/09/2023 22:12

Sort of -- it used to be this way and will go back to it in a couple years. But it wasn't as much as the whole personal allowance per child.

The US also allows married couples to file jointly and fully share their personal allowances, so that a joint income of, say, 100k is taxed exactly the same whether one person or two people earn it. I don't know why the UK doesn't do this, it makes so much more sense IMO.

(Sorry if someone else has already said all this, I haven't read the full thread.)

So does that mean (for example)

One person on 100k and a sahp would be taxed like two people on 50k aka under the higher rate tax band

But one person on 100k would be taxed at the higher rate tax band

Because that's the same as what people are complaining about with child benefit where 2 people on say 40k get it but a single person on 60k doesn't

It penalising single parents and incentivises women to stay in domestically abusive situations because they are better off financially

There must be a middle ground where being a single parent doesn't shoot you into the foot every which way

Cowlover89 · 24/09/2023 22:20

bopbey · 24/09/2023 19:22

@Cowlover89 I don't understand your point? People are having less dc now that's a fact.

@anniegun I agree with you & said CB should be universal.

It was an happy accident and wouldn't have it any other way. I've always wanted more than one and money issues wouldn't stop it happening otherwise I would regret it

Swipe left for the next trending thread