Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:01

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 11:50

Lots of families are struggling on incomes that people without children wouldn’t struggle on, for example I don’t know anyone who struggles on a 40-50k a year income who doesn’t have children and that is the typical example this country seems to have decided to base its tax rules on.

This endless narrative that the only expense in the universe is kids is infuriating.
Single people trying to manage on one income, especially in areas of the country where housing costs are high will also struggle on 40k-50k. I should know, I'm one of them.

But God, sorry, forgot that as per the thread that inspired this one - us childless people are all "absolutely loaded".

Being single isn't an expense, nor does it necessitate living in a single adult household. Children cannot be got rid of. It's not comparable.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 11:50

Lots of families are struggling on incomes that people without children wouldn’t struggle on, for example I don’t know anyone who struggles on a 40-50k a year income who doesn’t have children and that is the typical example this country seems to have decided to base its tax rules on.

This endless narrative that the only expense in the universe is kids is infuriating.
Single people trying to manage on one income, especially in areas of the country where housing costs are high will also struggle on 40k-50k. I should know, I'm one of them.

But God, sorry, forgot that as per the thread that inspired this one - us childless people are all "absolutely loaded".

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/09/2023 11:29

On the specific question - it would be better dealt with if CB was sorted out - and the original name of family allowance was better, I agree

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/09/2023 11:28

CB should be universal again, or if not possible the threshold raised by alot

It should also be based on household income not “one person earns x”

I don’t think couples should be allowed to transfer their tax free allowance- it’s a choice to have one parent at home or working limited hours, and saves the couple a lot on childcare etc.

DragonFly98 · 25/09/2023 11:09

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/09/2023 10:43

Surely it depends on the age of the kids whether £37.50 a week would cover their food? It would certainly cover food for two under fives. It’s a significant proportion of a lot of families’ food budgets.

I have a 10 and 12 year old, if I send them for school lunches that’s £30 a week alone. It doesn’t cover their food budget including packed lunches much less housing, clothing, heating.

Family allowance was originally paid to the mother to ensure she had some money in her own name in the days when men were traditionally the breadwinner. It was never intended to cover all the costs of having a child, but posters on here seem to think it’s a significant amount of money - it really isn’t.

It doesn't cover school lunches plus family meals no. If you make pack lunches though you can easily feed two children of any age three meals a day for £37.50 I agree it wouldn't cover anything else though.

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/09/2023 10:43

Surely it depends on the age of the kids whether £37.50 a week would cover their food? It would certainly cover food for two under fives. It’s a significant proportion of a lot of families’ food budgets.

I have a 10 and 12 year old, if I send them for school lunches that’s £30 a week alone. It doesn’t cover their food budget including packed lunches much less housing, clothing, heating.

Family allowance was originally paid to the mother to ensure she had some money in her own name in the days when men were traditionally the breadwinner. It was never intended to cover all the costs of having a child, but posters on here seem to think it’s a significant amount of money - it really isn’t.

Baconisdelicious · 25/09/2023 10:37

BIossomtoes · 25/09/2023 07:47

Surely it depends on the age of the kids whether £37.50 a week would cover their food? It would certainly cover food for two under fives. It’s a significant proportion of a lot of families’ food budgets.

Sure, it might feed children. Will it also clothe them? Keep them warm? Pay for.toys and books?

The problem with CB is that posters will always claim 'that's what CB is for'. But it can't cover everything. It's just a contribution. Nothing more.

Clariee45 · 25/09/2023 10:03

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/09/2023 07:42

Just to make sure kid is fed etc.. there is child benefit.

Child benefit for two children is £150 every 4 weeks, so £37.50 a week - at current prices that isn’t feeding two kids much less anything else. Which is fine, I actively chose to be a parent and I work to provide for them but let’s not pretend child benefit is making a significant difference to the “squeezed middle”, whatever that means.

I do think this government has done a great job of embedding the politics of jealousy into folks psyche, and making work less desirable for people on the threshold of UC. I don’t think tax breaks for parents as a stand alone policy is the right way to go but there has to be a better system out there.

I don’t think people realise the degree to which government policy disincentivises productivity, at the UC level and then again at the level the the CBHIC kicks in. When I was a single parent it would have absolutely made the best financial sense to just get a 16 hour a week minimum wage job locally within school hours thus minimising my commuting and childcare costs. Going to uni, getting professional qualifications etc was something I did as passionate about the career I’ve gone into but otherwise would have made no financial sense at the time. For parents at that 40-50k level, it makes no sense for them to do overtime or progress their careers unless it doesn’t bother them losing 80% of their extra earning or will be on 70k+ … this at a time many parents are struggling and would desperately like to earn more to make a difference to their family. It just seems very unjust their children are not viewed as people by the tax system and instead a multitude of much more expensive convoluted and socially coercive schemes to support families are put forward instead

OP posts:
heartofglass23 · 25/09/2023 10:01

gluenotsoup · 25/09/2023 08:46

@Uggtrending and @Lowrysbrush ,
I’m not a single parent, so I don’t fully appreciate how hard it must be, but do have empathy. My point of view is coming from my own situation- 2 parents, 3 children, one with profound disabilities which mean I can’t work anymore apart from a few hours a week term time. Dh earns just above the cb amount, meaning we don’t get any, and it can sometimes be a struggle. It’s not a situation we chose, any more than some people choose not to be a single parent, or just can’t have any. We have been through redundancy and so on with no help, and while I appreciate we have more household income than some the disparity between other families with 2 parents who earn just below the threshold but have a household income approaching £100k and yet still can claim child benefits, and ours with much less and a disabled child and their extended expenses and impact on my earnings doesn’t seem fair either. So- I do think child benefit should be the same for all families, just as it used to be, with extra help via other qualifying systems for those with a low household income, probably as there is now.

Don't you get DLA and carers allowance?

one262 · 25/09/2023 09:59

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 21:44

😊
I cant ever remember calling a women emotional when I couldnt answer a question.

How does someone proove they are infertile? Quite simple for a man its semen analysis, females have a number of options including blood tests, ultrsound scans to name a couple. I did touch on this answer earlier.

How does someone proove they are gay? As I understand it the test we use today in the uk is self identification, your not expected to proove, demonstrate or act it out infront of a panel of judges.

Does someone have to jump through every hoop such as IVF to justify their infertility? No, see answer one.

Hope this helps.

Some people are physically able to have children but mentally and emotionally unable to looke after them. Where do they fit it in this brave new world of yours? Maybe they should have a child anyway so that infertile or gay couples can adopt it, allowing them to get a pension?

Clariee45 · 25/09/2023 09:47

Pleaseme · 24/09/2023 22:58

I do think theOP is getting a hard time here. There are lots of variations in tax systems out there.

Obviously you have to work with the tax system you are in (or move) but OP is unfortunate that her set up is pretty much the worst one she could have (financially speaking) with our tax system.

The OECD reckons in the UK the difference in net transfers between the taxpayer and the government is over 30% higher for a single earner household earning 133% of average wage than in comparison to a dual income family with both partners earning equally.

compare it with France (taxed as a family) or Germany ( optional to be taxed as a couple) where there is very little difference in the tax burden for a single income/ dual
income family.

If it helps OP you could compare it with Greece which is a whopping 71.5% difference in net transfer so at least you’re better off than somebody!

Thank you, we have previously been in that really negative single earner tax trap situation so this is partly where my viewpoint comes from but for us personally at the moment that isn’t an issue as we’re both working and using our personal allowances. I am just thinking of a system that is fair for everyone. Lots of families are struggling on incomes that people without children wouldn’t struggle on, for example I don’t know anyone who struggles on a 40-50k a year income who doesn’t have children and that is the typical example this country seems to have decided to base its tax rules on. Thus resulting in many families needing top up benefits not because they don’t earn enough to support their family but because no allowance is made for their children in the tax system or otherwise people who work really hard to earn more but find they are hardly any better off than if they just received top up benefits. It just doesn’t seem a very sensible system. I am a working mother and have a professional career but I don’t buy into the ideology that every family should be forced into that mould either. I don’t want to spend the tax I pay coercing a mother to reluctantly leave her baby to go and work in Poundland because rather than just letting the family keep more of the money her partner earns, high levels of tax for everyone with free childcare is seem as the solution to everything. It’s rubbish this even makes economic sense as in most cases the tax payer is paying far more out in childcare funding than what that parent is paying in tax anyway and it’s hardly a job that’s going to close the gender pay gap. Therefore just let her family keep more of their own earned money. If she’s desperate to work/get a break from kids anyway then they’ll then have more money available to the family to make a free choice as to whether they want to spend it on childcare or not. I strongly support there always be a place for universal credit/top ups as well to those who don’t earn enough to benefit from this policy

OP posts:
gluenotsoup · 25/09/2023 08:46

@Uggtrending and @Lowrysbrush ,
I’m not a single parent, so I don’t fully appreciate how hard it must be, but do have empathy. My point of view is coming from my own situation- 2 parents, 3 children, one with profound disabilities which mean I can’t work anymore apart from a few hours a week term time. Dh earns just above the cb amount, meaning we don’t get any, and it can sometimes be a struggle. It’s not a situation we chose, any more than some people choose not to be a single parent, or just can’t have any. We have been through redundancy and so on with no help, and while I appreciate we have more household income than some the disparity between other families with 2 parents who earn just below the threshold but have a household income approaching £100k and yet still can claim child benefits, and ours with much less and a disabled child and their extended expenses and impact on my earnings doesn’t seem fair either. So- I do think child benefit should be the same for all families, just as it used to be, with extra help via other qualifying systems for those with a low household income, probably as there is now.

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 08:04

SofiaSoFar · 25/09/2023 07:42

Yep. I'll go with that, too, @Oliotya

It would benefit us all but somehow I don't think this will suit you, will it...

My DH is a migrant, so actually I have eggs in both baskets. I'm in favour of supporting families and sensible immigration levels.
End of the day people want to have kids, it makes them happy which in turn is good for society. From a purely economic standpoint, importing all our young people might make sense, but it's not going to be a pleasant place to live. Children matter.
Oh and obviously migrants have children too!

KimberleyClark · 25/09/2023 07:51

How about the child free who don't look after their health and cost the NHS more in their care?

why do you think the childfree don’t look after their health?

BIossomtoes · 25/09/2023 07:47

Surely it depends on the age of the kids whether £37.50 a week would cover their food? It would certainly cover food for two under fives. It’s a significant proportion of a lot of families’ food budgets.

SofiaSoFar · 25/09/2023 07:42

AllyCart · 24/09/2023 22:01

Immigration is far more cost-effective.

I'll pick that. Thanks.

Yep. I'll go with that, too, @Oliotya

It would benefit us all but somehow I don't think this will suit you, will it...

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/09/2023 07:42

Just to make sure kid is fed etc.. there is child benefit.

Child benefit for two children is £150 every 4 weeks, so £37.50 a week - at current prices that isn’t feeding two kids much less anything else. Which is fine, I actively chose to be a parent and I work to provide for them but let’s not pretend child benefit is making a significant difference to the “squeezed middle”, whatever that means.

I do think this government has done a great job of embedding the politics of jealousy into folks psyche, and making work less desirable for people on the threshold of UC. I don’t think tax breaks for parents as a stand alone policy is the right way to go but there has to be a better system out there.

Pleaseme · 25/09/2023 07:31

ChesterDrawz · 24/09/2023 23:20

Given that well over half of all households are net takers from the tax system, let alone for earners only on 1.3x average pay and having children, I'm not sure what this OECD figure is telling us?

Perhaps it's that the dual income household is a bit less of a burden than the single 133% earning household but still a burden all the same.

Well at 200% of average earnings you're still paying 30%+ more than the average dual earning couple at the same income. It's a measurement of tax neutrality towards single/ dual earning family units.

I think if given a choice most people would lean towards a tax system that favours them Which explains a lot of tory tax policy. OP would prefer a system that favours her.

There are winners and losers in every tax system. I do fairly well as a working single parent. I earn ok but am still entitled to UC/ child benefit/ Scottich child payment. My ex is a higher rate tax payer so pays lots of tax that helps fund his childrens schooling/ healthcare. For some reason when he talks about his tax bill , English company but paying Scottish tax rates, I hear Elton John playing the circle of life.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/09/2023 03:00

Well said, @VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia

If anything parents should get a lower pension due to the burdens they have placed on the rest of us.

Especially if their offspring turn out to be duds. Unemployable, addicts, abusers, deadbeat parents, teen parents, etc. anyone producing any of the above should have their pension docked to repay fellow taxpayers.

telestrations · 25/09/2023 01:50

In Canada tax is calculated per household with allowances for dependent adults and children, further allowances for things like disabilities and then a load of deductible expenses for education, relocating for work, mortgage relief, medial expenses and so on. Some are taken off at source but most form a rebate at the end of the tax year.

However the initial allowances per person are much lower then in the UK, as is welfare (in and out of work) and even things like subsidies for prescriptions and dental.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/09/2023 01:48

orangegato · 24/09/2023 16:05

Because they chose to have kids? You’re asking why people should provide for their own kids, yikes.

Exactly.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/09/2023 01:46

YABU because you are talking about tweaking our current broken income tax system when we should scrap that and adopt a system of land value tax. Land is something that you don't earn through labour but instead possess it, and in doing so deprive others of its use. Land value tax is the fairest form of tax.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/09/2023 01:37

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:06

Perhaps to put another angle on this, the children we have grow up ( finger crossed) to be tax payers, who pay for our state pensions.
Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Or a stepped state pension allowance based on your actual out of pocket tax contributions. 😊

So, let me get this straight:

  1. I get to work all the earlies, lates, weekends, Christmas day callouts, etc whilst the parents use a claimed lack of childcare to opt-out of these working hours.
  2. I get to fund schools, paediatric wards, social services, CAMHS, park play equipment, childcare, child benefit etc that I will never have children to make use of.
  3. I get less State pension at the end of all that?

Bluntly, fuck no. Unlike all the parents who are tied to their kids' schools, I can emigrate with my STEM skillset. And I would if this country decided that I was worth less pension because I'd not had kids. I don't mind my taxes paying for your kids but I draw the line at being treated as a second-class citizen when I retire.

YeOldeGreyhound · 25/09/2023 01:36

YABU
Having kids is a choice, so you are responsible for funding that choice. Just to make sure kid is fed etc.. there is child benefit.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/09/2023 01:29

Gigi606 · 24/09/2023 21:51

Child-free people of mumsnet seem to be forgetting we all need children to pay future taxes to fund future major illnesses, infrastructure, retirement and old age. Flip the question to absurdity, why should parents pay to raise taxpayers to fund people who are child free? Equally idiotic. If everyone was child free by choice society would literally break down within 20 years time.

  1. Isn't it lucky that child-free people aren't telling other people not to have kids and have no power to stop you from doing so?
  2. There's enough people on earth as it is, the global birth rate needs to fall.
  3. It's not the fault of the child-free that current workers pay the pensions of current retirees. I think you can blame Attlee for that Ponzi scheme.
  4. Why does no one ever suggest land value tax as a vast improvement over income tax that would make the landed aristocracy pay more taxes?