Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
CBAanymoreTBH · 25/09/2023 15:23

@CCTVcity dividends absolutely do count as income...taxable and on your P60

CBAanymoreTBH · 25/09/2023 15:22

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 16:10

The government needs more taxes coming in not less.

The government needs to stop spending our taxes on giving lucrative contracts to their dodgy mates

AnonAnonandAriston · 25/09/2023 13:57

Singleness, or rather the choice to live alone, is no less of a choice than having children or not. You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive. Both are choices.

They are, but no one is suggesting that single people get tax breaks for their choices...

Insommmmnia · 25/09/2023 13:50

It's more efficient use of resources to let people 55+ die of cancer

No cost of cancer treatments plus they have paid in through work most of their adults life and simultaneously won't need a pension

Not necessarily a winning election campaign slogan though

It's also a more efficient use of resources to not support disabled people (I am disabled) and I tend to find a massive cross over between the sort of people who think childfree or single parents are a blight who should barely exist and certainly shouldn't have resources and the sort of people who complain about Bob down the road getting disability for his bad back when he was put in the garden yesterday.

The "I only want my tax payers money spending on people like me" sort of people. Most of whom are net takers not net givers in terms of their actual tax payments.

Insommmmnia · 25/09/2023 13:45

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 13:01

End of the day, nobody has to live alone. That's your choice. Society will collapse without chidren. If supporting families is an investment in our future, then so be it. Single adult households are a wildly inefficient use of resources (that goes for parents and childfree alike), which is why it's not and will never be encouraged. We need younger people, we don't need single people to have their own house. That's why it's not comparable.

Well of course nobody has to live alone. No one's parents have ever thrown them out. No ones ever left an abusive partner. No ones partner has ever died. No ones parents who they were providing live in care for have ever died.

Instead everyone lives in a utopia where they move seamlessly from home (not leaving behind a single parent) to a uni flatshare to a shared flat as a couple where no one will ever have to leave because they will never be punched or kicked or strangled or financially abused and they will then efficiently die on the same day leaving behind either two children living together or a child or more in a stable relationship.

How very neat and tidy.

Single adult households are a wildly inefficient use of resources (that goes for parents and childfree alike), which is why it's not and will never be encouraged

Adults and children should be free to live free from abuse which is why it is absolutely vital that it is financially possible to live in a single adult household whether that is with children or without

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 13:22

And, just to reiterate for the fifty-billionth time, nobody is suggesting that single people be subsidised. Literally nobody.

What I am saying is that childless people should not automatically be considered to be free of financial pressures such that they can bear the burden of supporting families. That logic appears to be underpinning the OP's suggestions and it needs to be challenged for that reason.

I'll live in whatever accommodation I can provide for by myself - no subsidies required from anyone else. I will not be living with strangers just to accommodate someone else's ideas about efficiency. I certainly won't be doing so just to make myself a better cash cow for financial redistribution to families.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 13:18

Single adult households are a wildly inefficient use of resources (that goes for parents and childfree alike), which is why it's not and will never be encouraged.

I'm absolutely wildly and passionately for encouraging single parents not to move their kids in with complete strangers. I don't care how wildly inefficient it is for them to live alone with their parent.

Uggtrending · 25/09/2023 13:14

Young**

Uggtrending · 25/09/2023 13:14

@Oliotya I'm a single mum...... who on earth do you expect me to shack up with?

My Son lives with me. Single adults are entitled to live alone though sharing is OK when you are you but everyone is entitled just like someone can have more than 1 child... but then you need to factor in the COSTS!

Alstroemeria123 · 25/09/2023 13:09

Single adult households are a wildly inefficient use of resources

Could argue that sending your kids to childcare is as well. Would be cheaper to support COL for a stay at nome parent while the other goes out to work full time.

While we’re at it, supporting single parents is also not the most efficient way. Let’s support two-parent families only, rather than expecting parents to run separate houses.

I trust you’d support both of those ideas?

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 13:01

Uggtrending · 25/09/2023 12:56

@Oliotya no I don't agree. Isn't this part of the debate? I know your argument is about single childless people. It's the same argument people have mentioned though for a single parent getting punished if they earn well.

I remember the days of living alone before having my Son it is expensive I can see why those single without kids are coming from. I wouldn't say its a choice in the same way it is to continue to have kids I don't think its even comparable.

End of the day, nobody has to live alone. That's your choice. Society will collapse without chidren. If supporting families is an investment in our future, then so be it. Single adult households are a wildly inefficient use of resources (that goes for parents and childfree alike), which is why it's not and will never be encouraged. We need younger people, we don't need single people to have their own house. That's why it's not comparable.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/09/2023 12:58

Sorry, that reads as snotty! Isn’t, really don’t know.

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/09/2023 12:57

Why? Does child benefit no longer exist?

Uggtrending · 25/09/2023 12:56

@Oliotya no I don't agree. Isn't this part of the debate? I know your argument is about single childless people. It's the same argument people have mentioned though for a single parent getting punished if they earn well.

I remember the days of living alone before having my Son it is expensive I can see why those single without kids are coming from. I wouldn't say its a choice in the same way it is to continue to have kids I don't think its even comparable.

JenniferBooth · 25/09/2023 12:54

Back in the late 1990s i was signing on (this was before minimum wage came in) and there were NO tax credits then UNLESS you had kids.
I saw jobs advertised that were £50 a WEEK (my rent was £48 then) and that was it. No top up UNLESS you had kids. But you try telling that to parents. At the time it was "why cant you take the job You dont have kids to worry about" Well i would have lost my flat.

And ive mentioned it on these boards and got gaslighted that it didnt happen.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/09/2023 12:52

@Alstroemeria123 Exactly!

Alstroemeria123 · 25/09/2023 12:51

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:40

Singleness, or rather the choice to live alone, is no less of a choice than having children or not. You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive. Both are choices.

Agree it’s a choice - but it’s not single people who are suggesting others should subsidise their choices.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 12:47

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:40

Singleness, or rather the choice to live alone, is no less of a choice than having children or not. You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive. Both are choices.

You're right.

But this entire thread is predicated on the basis that one choice leaves families struggling and tax allowances should be made accordingly, but that the other choice does not leave anyone struggling and therefore no tax allowances should be made accordingly.

Pointing out that the latter is untrue is really bloody important, especially if those putting forward the suggestion that those without kids should be exposed to more financial vulnerability are doing so because they believe that it's impossible for them to be struggling.

Insommmmnia · 25/09/2023 12:45

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:40

Singleness, or rather the choice to live alone, is no less of a choice than having children or not. You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive. Both are choices.

Being single can literally be due to the absence of choice

You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive.

Please quote where I said that

Not only have I not said that I have said on this thread and others frequently how I advocate in real life for:
Better maternity pay
Better and longer paternity pay
Better funded childcare
Better funded education
Free school dinners
Removal of the child benefit cap
An improved/overhauled CMS system

I sometimes wonder why I bother though. Because as soon as I simultaneously defend childfree women (and its almost always women) from the accusations of being selfish etc I am therefore antiparent automatically.

It is possible to both sympathise with the fact that life is more expensive as a single person and sympathise with the fact that the system seems to be rigged against single parents for example.

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:40

Insommmmnia · 25/09/2023 12:38

Being single isn't an expense except for:

Higher priced holidays on a per person average
Higher priced council tax on a per person average
Higher priced rent on a per person average
Potentially higher food costs due to wastage if you cannot get small enough portions of food
Higher priced heating on a per person average
Higher priced electricity on a per person average
Depending on whether you are on a meter higher priced water bills on a per person average
Higher priced property maintenance costs on a per person average
Higher priced TV licence and other TV packages on a per person average

It costs 10k a year on average more to be single than to be in a couple and that's without the potential benefit of a dual income

And yes you will probably argue that every single person should probably live in a flat share as if there is an abundance of those in every town and village across the country but being single is absolutely more expensive.

Children cannot be got rid of. It's not comparable.

I'm not sure whether you are suggesting here that single people be forced into a relationship or single people can be got rid of.

It is however the second time an incel-ish sort of comment has been made on this thread that implies that if only the pesky single childfree women on this thread were forced financially into a relationship and parenting it would be better which is an interesting trend.

Singleness, or rather the choice to live alone, is no less of a choice than having children or not. You can't tell people not to complain that children are expensive and in the same sentence complain that living alone is expensive. Both are choices.

Insommmmnia · 25/09/2023 12:38

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:01

Being single isn't an expense, nor does it necessitate living in a single adult household. Children cannot be got rid of. It's not comparable.

Being single isn't an expense except for:

Higher priced holidays on a per person average
Higher priced council tax on a per person average
Higher priced rent on a per person average
Potentially higher food costs due to wastage if you cannot get small enough portions of food
Higher priced heating on a per person average
Higher priced electricity on a per person average
Depending on whether you are on a meter higher priced water bills on a per person average
Higher priced property maintenance costs on a per person average
Higher priced TV licence and other TV packages on a per person average

It costs 10k a year on average more to be single than to be in a couple and that's without the potential benefit of a dual income

And yes you will probably argue that every single person should probably live in a flat share as if there is an abundance of those in every town and village across the country but being single is absolutely more expensive.

Children cannot be got rid of. It's not comparable.

I'm not sure whether you are suggesting here that single people be forced into a relationship or single people can be got rid of.

It is however the second time an incel-ish sort of comment has been made on this thread that implies that if only the pesky single childfree women on this thread were forced financially into a relationship and parenting it would be better which is an interesting trend.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 12:37

Oliotya · 25/09/2023 12:01

Being single isn't an expense, nor does it necessitate living in a single adult household. Children cannot be got rid of. It's not comparable.

I didn't say being single was an "expense". I said that it's possible to not have kids and still struggle on £40k. Because it is.

I have single friends who flat share on £40k and still struggle, because housing costs in many areas of the country are literally bananas. Moving in with strangers doesn't automatically solve the problem.

I have no idea why you think I think children can be gotten rid of, either.

My only point was tackling the really, really annoying narrative that the only thing that causes a household to have any financial difficulties is kids.

Gwenhwyfar · 25/09/2023 12:21

This is how it works in France and Belgium. Lower tax for anyone with dependants in addition to the usual help of child benefit, subsidised childcare, etc.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/09/2023 12:09

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/09/2023 11:50

Lots of families are struggling on incomes that people without children wouldn’t struggle on, for example I don’t know anyone who struggles on a 40-50k a year income who doesn’t have children and that is the typical example this country seems to have decided to base its tax rules on.

This endless narrative that the only expense in the universe is kids is infuriating.
Single people trying to manage on one income, especially in areas of the country where housing costs are high will also struggle on 40k-50k. I should know, I'm one of them.

But God, sorry, forgot that as per the thread that inspired this one - us childless people are all "absolutely loaded".

Agree.

People have children knowing full well it's expensive. No one is forced to do it. Any struggles are self-inflicted.

Single and childfree people have a right to allocate the fruits of their labour, their hard-earned wages, as they see fit; their values, life choices and financial priorities are just as valid.

If my lifestyle choices leave me more comfortable than someone who's made more expensive lifestyle choices, that's their lookout. We all had the same options.

Uggtrending · 25/09/2023 12:06

@gluenotsoup I appreciate your input you put it nicely. The issue is there's no solution that fits all, I guess everything was different back in the days. Mainly cost is what I'm getting at I'm a 90s child here I remember my mum getting an incentive on the old working tax system if she did 30 hours. I remember when day riders were released for £1, me and my DB went to a playscheme which cost 50p a day. Those days have gone!

Again I like that it's a detterant so people don't just continue to have DC they can't afford.

I can't relate to having a disabled child and I don't want to come across as insensitive because you replied politely to me but you are a 2 parent household and your DH must earn well. If things seem a stretch... it's likely because you've got 3 DC I only have 1 child and he cost me a fortune! I stand by my take but I absolutely appreciate your circumstances too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread