Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
AnonAnonandAriston · 26/09/2023 08:49

Child benefit should absolutely be calculated on household income (although I suspect that would be far too complicated to administer) and if we moved to a shared tax allowance that would be ok too (although if there were a significant difference between a couples earnings, you'd end up reducing the higher earners tax)

Desecratedcoconut · 26/09/2023 08:45

Insommmmnia · 26/09/2023 08:39

And the OP is specifically wanting people who earn more than that to get this extra money

But wants it to be instead of UC, so poorer people don't get more money

And if a childfree couple on minimum wage have to pay more tax to fund it that's also fine too as apparently they would have more disposable income than the family on a combined income of 98k

Two earners at a £49k is at the threshold of eligibility, but it could as equally by one earner at £49k. Such is the odd administration of the benefit.

Desecratedcoconut · 26/09/2023 08:42

Conkersinautumn · 26/09/2023 08:31

It seems unlikely that the majority of families are in receipt of child benefit. That's not the 'squeezed' middle, if you're eligible for benefits (unless you're old) you're not middle income.

Do you have child benefit mixed up with universal credit/tax credits?

Insommmmnia · 26/09/2023 08:39

BIossomtoes · 26/09/2023 08:37

A household with two people earning £49k each qualifies for child benefit. You’re right, that’s not middle income - it’s well above average.

And the OP is specifically wanting people who earn more than that to get this extra money

But wants it to be instead of UC, so poorer people don't get more money

And if a childfree couple on minimum wage have to pay more tax to fund it that's also fine too as apparently they would have more disposable income than the family on a combined income of 98k

HangingByYourFingernails · 26/09/2023 08:39

Conkersinautumn · 26/09/2023 08:31

It seems unlikely that the majority of families are in receipt of child benefit. That's not the 'squeezed' middle, if you're eligible for benefits (unless you're old) you're not middle income.

Child benefit isn't a benefit in the usuals sense though. It used to be universal and is now payable in full if neither of you earn over 50,000. People on a joint income of, say, 60,000 wouldn't be eligible for conventional benefits, they're not "poor", but the state recognises that they have additional living costs which the UK chooses to subsidise with a handout rather than a tax allowance.

BIossomtoes · 26/09/2023 08:37

Conkersinautumn · 26/09/2023 08:31

It seems unlikely that the majority of families are in receipt of child benefit. That's not the 'squeezed' middle, if you're eligible for benefits (unless you're old) you're not middle income.

A household with two people earning £49k each qualifies for child benefit. You’re right, that’s not middle income - it’s well above average.

Conkersinautumn · 26/09/2023 08:31

It seems unlikely that the majority of families are in receipt of child benefit. That's not the 'squeezed' middle, if you're eligible for benefits (unless you're old) you're not middle income.

useruseruser1234 · 26/09/2023 08:26

None of these things were introduced as a ‘favour to parents’ in your eyes kids seem not to be citizens but merely pets

Until a child is a useful productive member of society in their own right I consider them an extension of their parents. I also think you had them, you pay for them and stop expecting everyone else to prop up your choices

Lincslady53 · 26/09/2023 08:04

You get £1,248 a year in child benefit, for the first child, a bit less for others. That is the equivalent of earning c£6,500 tax free at 20% if you were in a family where the mother was a stay at home mother, with a father who was the main earner, the father would get the benefit of tax free allowances. With Child benefit the mother gets the benefit. I think this is why it was originally set up this way, back in the days when husbands were the breadwinners and mothers were the housekeepers, like my parents life.

Insommmmnia · 26/09/2023 08:03

Clariee45 · 25/09/2023 23:31

It’s about a basic justice of acknowledging children as people in the tax system, we don’t argue the ‘cost’ as a reason for denying fairness in most other situations?
To be honest however I don’t think it would significantly reduce the tax revenue of the country, a huge portion of parents currently claiming UC will be happily free of the system now that they are actually being allowed to keep more of the money they have earned to support their family’s Parents will no longer be so be under such a disincentive to go and earn extra money and think it also worth while to upskill this increasing the country’s productivity. They will also be spending this extra 2.5k in the economy so paying VAT etc. I personally think putting this fairness into the tax system is more important than many things our taxes are currently spent on. I also think there should be equal entitlement for such allowances for all families/couples supporting dependant members unable to work. I absolutely don’t believe in anyone else’s taxes being put up to pay for this.

So in your plan lower income families get no extra money, only families on higher incomes

So those families who are genuinely struggling to feed their children and heat their homes, they are in exactly the same position?

But this is what fair represents to you? Richer people paying less tax and poorer people getting less benefit? This is your justice?

Insommmmnia · 26/09/2023 08:00

CasperGutman · 26/09/2023 06:18

It's not the daftest idea I've ever heard. However, as the public purse can't afford a sizable drop in income this would have to be done instead of loads some of the stuff we get now - like child benefit, tax free childcare etc. And even then it would likely need a hike in tax rates to pay for it....

Despite the OP waffling on about how the childfree supposedly resent their taxes paying for education and parks, which no childfree person has said, the only person on the thread who has said they resent something child related being paid from their taxes is the OP.

The OP resents childcare for others being funded from her taxes so I'm pretty sure she has no issues with childcare not being subsidised/tax free etc any more.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 26/09/2023 07:36

@LimeCheesecake Unemployment is currently on the rise. We have the people, but they are not filling the jobs.

LimeCheesecake · 26/09/2023 07:33

@OnAFrolicOfMyOwn - but we do need jobs to be filled by working aged people to avoid our economy collapsing. Those younger people could be imported, but we do need them.

as many commentators and politicians have started saying the birth rate is too low, it does stand to reason they should start looking at policies that would remove some of the barriers to couples having children/more children. One of those is cost - having more disposable income could tip the balance for some families to have that 2nd child.

OneTwoThreeShake · 26/09/2023 07:27

I don't really understand why someone else, in this case the State, should be paying for people to raise the children they've chosen to have.

It isn't a secret that kids cost money. You know this before you decide to have them.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 26/09/2023 07:23

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 18:11

True - but it does benefit society for people to continue to have children - ideally at a rate that means we will have a decent ratio of workers to pensioners in the future.

right now, birth rates in the UK are low. If this isn’t just a post covid /cost of living blip, but a long term trend, then this could be a serious problem for society in the future.

taxes and benefits have always been used as a way to nudge people to act in a way that will benefit society.

Only if those children grow up to be contributors - and that's a big if, with fewer than 60% of UK adults paying any income tax at all, let alone being net contributors.

sashh · 26/09/2023 07:21

So you want those of us who do not have children to pay more tax than those with children?

You already get:

Child benefit - OK I know not everyone does.
Some Childcare
Your children's education
In some places your children get free travel
Free school meals for the first three years in school
In Scotland you get a 'baby box'

I'm happy that my taxes support families with these things, it benefits society so it will benefit me in the future, but it is a choice to have children and you have made that choice.

Ramdogs · 26/09/2023 07:00

@Uggtrending Child Benefit isn't capped at 2 children. Only Child Tax Credits/UC is.

ohsobroody · 26/09/2023 06:44

Jellycatspyjamas · 24/09/2023 16:08

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit.

They may feel they are hardly better off, but in reality they have significantly more life chances than someone dependent on benefits.

I appreciate that this is true but day by day and week by week when you are pennies over the cut off and scraping together enough to pay bills and childcare it feels really unfair. My friends who earn a smudge less are getting up to 85% off childcare and other support.

This isn't benefit bashing they work hard too!! Not bashing at all and I know there has to be a line drawn somewhere but I think it should have moved in the last 5 years to better reflect reality. We only just fall over it and we're comfortable pre Covid. We are now very very worried and frugal

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 26/09/2023 06:36

Land Value Tax could replace income tax and make a lot of these arguments go away by hitting those with huge inherited estates hardest, making the foreign housing owners pay tax on the land they own here, and leaving what you earn by your own efforts untouched.

Shumpalumpa · 26/09/2023 06:33

Clariee45 · 25/09/2023 23:57

We wouldn’t have more disposable income than you?? It costs a hell of a lot more than 2.5k a year to raise a child so honestly you don’t need to worry, you would still get to enjoy the financial benefits of being child free over parents earning exactly the same as you.

Jeez, the more you post the more unhinged your posts get.

You had kids, you pay for them.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 26/09/2023 06:32

Clariee45 · 25/09/2023 23:57

We wouldn’t have more disposable income than you?? It costs a hell of a lot more than 2.5k a year to raise a child so honestly you don’t need to worry, you would still get to enjoy the financial benefits of being child free over parents earning exactly the same as you.

Which is massively outweighed by the financial penalty of being disabled enough to decide that having kids was an unachievable option. A chunk of that penalty being because I live alone so that I don't have to mask in my own home, but also penalties related to adaptive equipment being stupidly expensive and being on lifelong medication.

Unlike you choosing to have children, I didn't get a choice about being disabled.

OMGitsnotgood · 26/09/2023 06:31

I get where you're coming from but ultimately it means that child free tax payers are subsiding other people's children. That doesn't seem fair either. Saying that as a parent who would have welcomed the extra income, but we already had child benefit. don't see how it is fair to those who don't have children to be given even more?

CasperGutman · 26/09/2023 06:18

It's not the daftest idea I've ever heard. However, as the public purse can't afford a sizable drop in income this would have to be done instead of loads some of the stuff we get now - like child benefit, tax free childcare etc. And even then it would likely need a hike in tax rates to pay for it....

AllyCart · 26/09/2023 05:59

With OP's fantastic new tax system, DH and I would be over £11,000 per year better off (2 x DC, 45% tax rate).

We really don't need the money and would probably spend it on another holiday or maybe new cars.

We would of course be grateful to those people without children. Especially those who desperately wanted them but were sadly unable to become parents, and even more so if they are now struggling with their day-to-day living expenses to fund our tax cut.

It sounds great, doesn't it...

KeepTheTempo · 26/09/2023 00:05

cowgirl42 · 24/09/2023 16:09

I think that would really be great for rewarding hard work. They need to start with allowing full shared allowances between parents in a household so one can choose not to work and be the parent at home first though if they wished.

But overall the best way would be for tax allowances to go up substantially. I think anyone working for the minimum wage shouldn’t pay tax at all. It is the minimum after all but actually it’s far less once tax and NI kick in. This fiscal drag is hurting a lot of people.

Incentivising dramatically financially unequal relationships is not in our best interest as a society or as taxpayers.

It reduces our tax take, encourages more dads to opt out of parenting and more mums to opt out of working.

This then makes a personal choice a taxpayer issue, given that 43% of marriages end in divorce, and the mum has no recent work history and far too frequently ends up in low income work and reliant on further taxpayer funding. Or the mum - along with the kids - is trapped in a grim marriage due to the massive financial impact of separation. Very 1950s and retro-chic, but not great for anyone at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread