Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 17:41

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 17:38

Because they would not live very long in old age without other peoples children propping up the economy , caring for them in hospital or nursing care

So how many parents on this thread will be encouraging their children to
a. work in the NHS.
b. to become a care worker in a nursing home
c. to become a mobile carer caring for the elderly/disabled in their own homes.

I"ll wait.

Oh Jennifer, didn't you know that no-one has children for their own selfish reasons, people only have them to benefit society

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:41

@Uggtrending as I said not all of the 90% who claim will be eligible. I just think the rule for joint vs family income is silly, the income tax bands are too low & the fact its equivalent was universal. Primary pupils in London already get free school meals regardless of income.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 17:40

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 17:38

Because they would not live very long in old age without other peoples children propping up the economy , caring for them in hospital or nursing care

So how many parents on this thread will be encouraging their children to
a. work in the NHS.
b. to become a care worker in a nursing home
c. to become a mobile carer caring for the elderly/disabled in their own homes.

I"ll wait.

💯

MidnightOnceMore · 24/09/2023 17:40

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 16:59

Are you saying the squeezed middle / those not on UC can’t afford to pay for food?

And no one has kids to help the future economy.

The parents skipping meals extends beyond those on UC, yes.

A huge number of households are unable to manage their expenses. The cost of living crisis is affecting working age people very badly, obviously those with children have higher outgoings. The additional income (e.g. child benefit) doesn't cover the additional costs.

These are just the economic realities of where the UK is currently.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 17:38

Because they would not live very long in old age without other peoples children propping up the economy , caring for them in hospital or nursing care

So how many parents on this thread will be encouraging their children to
a. work in the NHS.
b. to become a care worker in a nursing home
c. to become a mobile carer caring for the elderly/disabled in their own homes.

I"ll wait.

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 17:38

no just a tax allowance to take account of the fact children need to eat, have shelter, be clothes etc, bring allowed to keep 2.5k a year more per child of the money they have earned would hardly pay for a month in private school, not to mention to ++>£2.5k a parent will be spending on the absolute basics anyway. This is money the parents have earned themselves, not money being taken from you

Adult personal allowance is 12.5k not 2.5k, and you specifically said equivalent to the adult tax allowance in your OP. And it takes away from everyone because lots of parents would no longer pay any tax at all if they had several children.

Uggtrending · 24/09/2023 17:37

@bopbey OK that's fine. I gave my opinion just like you. When you said CB is 90% that's still high I don't see why it must be 100%. Its a form of benefit and not everyone is entitled.

It's like the free school meals rule you could go on and on with various things. I mean where would it end?

Ffsmakeitstop · 24/09/2023 17:36

Lowrysbrush · 24/09/2023 16:55

I couldn't have children - we spent all our savings on 4 cycles of IVF and ended up having to sell the house to do so.

I'm therefore probably the worst person to ask and I know this is a minority situation, but why the hell should I be penalised financially for not having something I so desperately wanted?

I'm so sorry for your situation Flowers but you are definitely right in your thinking. The people who think this is a good idea haven't thought about where the money is going to come from.
There are so many things that need to be considered, when do we stop paying for other people's children? After full time education? What about children with disabilities? There'll be suggestions we take it from pensioners next because we're all living too long.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 17:35

gogomoto · 24/09/2023 17:34

Happens in the USA, but of course it benefits better off families as low income families don't reach that threshold

Which is what the OP wants.

gogomoto · 24/09/2023 17:34

Happens in the USA, but of course it benefits better off families as low income families don't reach that threshold

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:33

Everyone is entitled their opinion aren't they?

I'm was just interested in why you had that opinion hence the question.

grayhairdontcare · 24/09/2023 17:33

@anniegun because a Nanny is in paid employment and a sahp is not

OlizraWiteomQua · 24/09/2023 17:32

I totally disagree with the idea of the tax system supporting a family having a SAHP. This is a huge luxury - not that I begrude those families that can afford it, but having a SAHP is equivalent to being able to do without the £30kpa-ish (or more) that a capable adult could earn, and instead have a full time person to provide a full household management service. Totally fine for families to choose that but not subsidised by the tax payer.

Yes yes to a higher tax allowance for single parents though.

but don't think it's appropriate to boost the personal tax-free allowance amount - child-benefit already does pretty much exactly this with an amount that's basically equivalent to boosting the allowance by about £4500 per child, it's just structured so that those who aren't earning get it too because punishing kids for their parents not being in work isn't something a civilised society does.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 17:32

ThinWomansBrain · 24/09/2023 16:30

Children do get free education?
Or are you suggesting you deserve an additional tax allowance so that you can send your children to a private school?

no just a tax allowance to take account of the fact children need to eat, have shelter, be clothes etc, bring allowed to keep 2.5k a year more per child of the money they have earned would hardly pay for a month in private school, not to mention to ++>£2.5k a parent will be spending on the absolute basics anyway. This is money the parents have earned themselves, not money being taken from you

OP posts:
bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:32

@Uggtrending I'm not talking about my circle though I'm talking statistically. I'm one of 3 but I'm not a child anymore so what happened in the 80s isn't reflective of today.

"There are estimated to be around around 3.56 million one-child families in the United Kingdom as of 2022, with a further 3.4 million two-child families, and 1.25 million families that have three or more children."

The vast majority of families now don't have 3 plus dc

anniegun · 24/09/2023 17:30

User183642 · 24/09/2023 17:06

I think the best method to solve the issue in which many women claim work doesn’t pay would be to tax the choice to be a stay at home parent (with exemptions for the disabled and those with disabled children) so that it would always make financial sense for both parents to work (with the proceeds of such a tax being ring fenced for subsidising childcare for those in work). At the end of the day being a stay at home parent is a economically damaging choice for the country as a whole and significantly increases the chance of a person needing to be supported by the state later in life so should be a choice that comes with a cost.
That being said the current child benefit rules are unfair on higher earning single parents who could be earning less than 2 working parents who qualify so some changes should be made (potentially with a raise in the threshold to around £70,000 but with a minimum assumed income of £20,000 per parent in the exception of disabilities or genuine short term unemployment).

We have a slightly weird system where looking after your own children is not counted towards GDP whereas a nanny doing the same job is added to GDP.

Uggtrending · 24/09/2023 17:28

@bopbey I'm 1 of 4 siblings so it depends on your circle. From what I've heard people say it's been a deterrent the benefit cap though and I think its a good thing. I'm a single parent myself, not high flying or anywhere near. I just feel that it's very easy to become reliant on benefits not CB as such but things like UC

Everyone is entitled their opinion aren't they?

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 17:27

User183642 · 24/09/2023 17:06

I think the best method to solve the issue in which many women claim work doesn’t pay would be to tax the choice to be a stay at home parent (with exemptions for the disabled and those with disabled children) so that it would always make financial sense for both parents to work (with the proceeds of such a tax being ring fenced for subsidising childcare for those in work). At the end of the day being a stay at home parent is a economically damaging choice for the country as a whole and significantly increases the chance of a person needing to be supported by the state later in life so should be a choice that comes with a cost.
That being said the current child benefit rules are unfair on higher earning single parents who could be earning less than 2 working parents who qualify so some changes should be made (potentially with a raise in the threshold to around £70,000 but with a minimum assumed income of £20,000 per parent in the exception of disabilities or genuine short term unemployment).

If you want to start taxing people for staying at home, you can't stop at mothers. Part timers, early retirees? Taking choices away from women is they very last thing we should be doing.

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:27

And 90% isn't 100% when I last checked.

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:27

@anniegun but more claim than who are entitled to it because of the NI stamps

anniegun · 24/09/2023 17:24

bopbey · 24/09/2023 16:43

People with children get child benefit

No, some people do.

Over 90% of families with children claim CB

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:23

@Uggtrending yes, you often hear a lot of debate that that should be means tested hence why I used it as a comparison.

Child benefit adds up to a decent chunk of you have 3/4 kids that's why the GOV capped it at 2 DC.

The vast majority of people don't have 3 or 4 dc though, why shouldn't it be universal for say 2 dc?

buckingmad · 24/09/2023 17:23

JustAMinutePleass · 24/09/2023 16:48

A couple with only one person in employment has zero childcare costs. They don’t need anything extra.

What about the women living under financial abuse? For some that £20 a week is all they have. And it’s taken away because their husband earns over the threshold.

Children still cost, plus childcare is not just about working it’s about the social development of the child and getting them ready for school. Why should a child miss out on that just because a parent is at home?

Maybe the parent that isn’t working isn’t working due to illness or was made redundant. It’s not as black and white as you’d like it to be.

but fine. My argument still stands for a couple that earn £60,000 and the other earns say £30,000 full time. They’re still worse off than the two on £49,999 each PLUS don’t get the child benefit.

ruby1957 · 24/09/2023 17:22

OP - 'Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.'

So you suggest that there should be an ADULT tax allowance (£12750) for each child. Really a family of 5 - 2 adults and 3 children would have a tax-free income of £60k+

That is hardly fair.

Just to give you an idea of how tax allowances worked when I was a full time working single parent in the 70s/80s.

There was an 'additional personal allowance' which meant that a single parent household got the same tax-free allowance as a couple. This was NOT double the tax allowance - just the equivalent of having a partner.

Then women demanded their own separate taxation instead of being an additional tax allowance on their husband's tax bill.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 17:21

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 24/09/2023 17:18

100% this. We all make choices in life. How about the child free who don't look after their health and cost the NHS more in their care? I'm sick of parents, usually always mothers, being demonised for having kids. Shall we just let the human species die out then? Our kids will be your future tax payers and those propping up society.

What about the child free makes you think they don’t look after their health and cost the NHS more?

Do you have any statistics to back up your assertions?

Or are you just annoyed the child free don’t want to pay more for your kids?