Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
Desecratedcoconut · 24/09/2023 17:59

Right, so if we just make being a sahm chargeable, then it becomes a benefit to society?

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 17:58

So, if all the at-home parents swapped around their kids and made it chargeable, then that would be a benefit to society but if all the kids remain in their own home it's a loss to society?

Well yes, because the first one would have all of those people now earning money and therefore contributing to broader society via tax and NI, rather than just benefiting their own family by being economically inactive

Tremour · 24/09/2023 17:58

Well have children requires compromise and sacrifice. surely you thought about that impact it would have on your finances. If you wanted to keep more of your money then don't have so many children that it takes up all your money to raise them. Or get a job that pays more. Pretty simple.

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:56

@Uggtrending Of course there are cut offs as they should be but I think it's ok to have one benefit for families that is universal.

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 17:55

Is it me or did they monetize and decide to tax babysitting?

Desecratedcoconut · 24/09/2023 17:54

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/09/2023 17:53

No, because that isn't the same as a qualified professional providing a service.

🤣 okay.

HangingByYourFingernails · 24/09/2023 17:54

Desecratedcoconut · 24/09/2023 17:48

So, if all the at-home parents swapped around their kids and made it chargeable, then that would be a benefit to society but if all the kids remain in their own home it's a loss to society?

Yep. Keynesian economics at its best.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/09/2023 17:53

Desecratedcoconut · 24/09/2023 17:48

So, if all the at-home parents swapped around their kids and made it chargeable, then that would be a benefit to society but if all the kids remain in their own home it's a loss to society?

No, because that isn't the same as a qualified professional providing a service.

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 17:53

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 17:48

I’m a working tax paying parent and chose to work even when I paid my entire salary (and more) on childcare costs as I love my job but I would sure as hell hate to live in your dystopian world. There have been other times when I have been a SAHM as that was best for my children, my job and my mental health. Unless of course you would wanted me to be doing your IV medications on 2 hours sleep! Before you insist DH should have stepped in, should he have just AWOL’d from his highly specialised job that benefited us all. Should I have just told teenagers to pull themselves together when they needed me? We weren’t entitled to any benefits during this time, we just had to take the hit and are still paying off the debts from both being a SAHM and paying childcare. I’m not even asking for anyone else’s money, just they we could just keep a little more of our own while raising children.

I’m not even asking for anyone else’s money, just they we could just keep a little more of our own while raising children.

But that’s how everyone sees it, as wanting to keep a little more of their own.

Sounds like you and DH both have good jobs. What are you finding unaffordable? It it putting food on the table? Bills?

Uggtrending · 24/09/2023 17:52

@Desecratedcoconut the problem with being a SAHM it's easy to expand your family because you are at home anyway and you are the free childcare. However how many people can afford it? Many alledge they can on MN..... but in reality I don't see how it's viable in this economy. Those days ended when I was growing up in the 90s.

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 17:51

"Child Benifit"

Depending on your definition of "Squeezed" middle.

OR if thats not evening thing up with the more empoverished beneath you, maybe substitute some benifits for food parcels so theres a more comfortable differential 🙄

User183642 · 24/09/2023 17:51

Oliotya · 24/09/2023 17:27

If you want to start taxing people for staying at home, you can't stop at mothers. Part timers, early retirees? Taking choices away from women is they very last thing we should be doing.

Clearly it would have to be a generic tax on the working age population who are not earning a specified level from employment or self-employment or claiming out of work benefits or in full time education for a period of 3 months of longer. The specified level would be low enough that substantial part time work would be enough to qualify and exemptions would be made for those who have already paid enough NI to qualify for a full state pension (with the required numbers of years increased to 40).
It’s not about taking choices away but rather acknowledging that having an adult stay at home has financial benefits for the family and that such financial benefits should be taxed in the same way that conventional income would be.

Butterkist8 · 24/09/2023 17:49

Methinks Economics should be a compulsory subject.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 17:48

User183642 · 24/09/2023 17:06

I think the best method to solve the issue in which many women claim work doesn’t pay would be to tax the choice to be a stay at home parent (with exemptions for the disabled and those with disabled children) so that it would always make financial sense for both parents to work (with the proceeds of such a tax being ring fenced for subsidising childcare for those in work). At the end of the day being a stay at home parent is a economically damaging choice for the country as a whole and significantly increases the chance of a person needing to be supported by the state later in life so should be a choice that comes with a cost.
That being said the current child benefit rules are unfair on higher earning single parents who could be earning less than 2 working parents who qualify so some changes should be made (potentially with a raise in the threshold to around £70,000 but with a minimum assumed income of £20,000 per parent in the exception of disabilities or genuine short term unemployment).

I’m a working tax paying parent and chose to work even when I paid my entire salary (and more) on childcare costs as I love my job but I would sure as hell hate to live in your dystopian world. There have been other times when I have been a SAHM as that was best for my children, my job and my mental health. Unless of course you would wanted me to be doing your IV medications on 2 hours sleep! Before you insist DH should have stepped in, should he have just AWOL’d from his highly specialised job that benefited us all. Should I have just told teenagers to pull themselves together when they needed me? We weren’t entitled to any benefits during this time, we just had to take the hit and are still paying off the debts from both being a SAHM and paying childcare. I’m not even asking for anyone else’s money, just they we could just keep a little more of our own while raising children.

OP posts:
Desecratedcoconut · 24/09/2023 17:48

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/09/2023 17:46

Nannies provide a service for other people
Looking after your own children just benefits the individual family.

Edited

So, if all the at-home parents swapped around their kids and made it chargeable, then that would be a benefit to society but if all the kids remain in their own home it's a loss to society?

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 17:47

*People don't want to take accountability many women know they are struggling with 1 DC and go on to have the 2nd and the 3rdg

ah yes, children are the sole responsibility of their mothers….

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/09/2023 17:46

anniegun · 24/09/2023 17:30

We have a slightly weird system where looking after your own children is not counted towards GDP whereas a nanny doing the same job is added to GDP.

Nannies provide a service for other people
Looking after your own children just benefits the individual family.

Needmorelego · 24/09/2023 17:46

@Clariee45 to be honest what you should really campaign for is more social housing at a sensible rent level so families can have somewhere safe, secure, permanent and affordable to live in.
Private renting needs to much more strict with long term tenancies and affordable rents.
Schools need to stop insisting on over priced and unaffordable uniforms and equipment.
All children should be entitled to go their local school which should be a Local Authority school - no "faith" schools, pick and choosy Academies etc - because at the moment the so called "parental choice"* means children frequently have to travel miles to get to school often at parents cost (bus pass, paying for a car).
*often not the parents choice at all.
These changes would make a massive financial difference to many families.

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 17:46

@JenniferBooth - lots of people encourage children into medicine and nursing.

bur a bigger issue is if you are planning on a state pension being part of your own retirement plan, you need young people working.

oldandunderpaid · 24/09/2023 17:46

Nope.

Why should child free people pay full whack and people with kids get extra money?

Take responsibility for your own life choices!

I have kids but I remember being single and child free and really struggling while a junior colleague with three kids got everything topped up and was 'earning' way more than me when I managed her because of that. Sick of single or people without kids getting the shitty end of the stick.

Tremour · 24/09/2023 17:46

oh goodie yet another thread adovating for parents to have better tax rules and keep more money Never ever see anyone advocating for single childless/ childfree people to get better tax breaks or help - just fucking squeeze us for all our money why don't you. 🙄

Isn't it enough we pay enough taxes to fund things like schools etc. oh no you want more....

Uggtrending · 24/09/2023 17:44

@bopbey ahh really well you've taught me something. That's not the case up North you pay for school dinners so that's a HUGE saving of approx £120 per month based on 2 kids. I had no idea at all about that! So thanks. The point is though everything can't be the same and there is a cut off point/limit to things.

OneTwoThreeShake · 24/09/2023 17:44

No issue at all with child benefit being a universal entitlement. The government managed to set up a system for supermarket vouchers during the various lockdowns and school holidays, so the admin can't be that complex.

But I'm childless, not through choice. I would absolutely not ever be in favour of being financially penalised because my body doesn't work properly. I'd go self employed and utilise every tax avoidance scheme possible if that were the case.

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 17:43

OP - is this only for people not in receipt of UC or everyone with a child?

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 17:43

We don’t have enough babies being born. We as a country could look at why the birth rate is falling, is it just a post covid blip or a long term trend? Does it need fixing?

there’s some commentators already saying it needs fixing, so this is one way to use the tax system to nudge people to have that 2nd or 3rd baby. Make it a bit less painful to add another child.

guess it would come down to which sections of society are not having babies, is it across the board or are the richer or poorer more likely to have no or only 1 child?