Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
User183642 · 24/09/2023 18:59

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 18:51

@User183642 if the justification for sin taxes is the aggregate cost to taxpayer then surely a tax credit for people having children is justified for the aggregate benefit to the taxpayer of people having more children?

The argument for sin taxes is that the public sector has taken on providing services that should be privately funded. The public sector should only do the bare minimum (essentially tax and law administration, policing the judiciary and prisons and national security) with everything else being provided by the private sector. Under such a system taxes would be much much lower but people would have to take personal responsibility.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 18:53

of

OP posts:
Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 18:53

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 18:03

Why do you keep saying 2.5k? You want full adult personal tax allowance, 2.5k is a fraction of that

Only asking for the equivalent adult tax allowance to be disregarded, which equates to parents keeping 2.5k extra of their earnings (between them) i.e. 20% or current individual tax allowance of £12500

OP posts:
Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 18:51

@User183642 if the justification for sin taxes is the aggregate cost to taxpayer then surely a tax credit for people having children is justified for the aggregate benefit to the taxpayer of people having more children?

User183642 · 24/09/2023 18:44

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 18:32

Training to be a nurse or an engineer are "lifestyle choices" which are subsidised by the taxpayer because the country would be knackered if only people who could afford a qualification to become a nurse or engineer outright could do so. With birth rates dipping well below replacement rates, with cost being a major reason, having children is a fair comparison.

Also if you reduce the amount of tax a person pays you aren't giving them anything you are just taking less from them.

And if it's not acceptable to "subsidise lifestyle choices" then why is it acceptable to tax lifestyle choices like smoking or having a car or buying a house?

Firstly training to be a nurse or engineer basically receives no subsidy now a days.
The taxation on cars and smoking can be justified due to the indirect costs picked up by the NHS and therefore taxpayer due to those choices being made. In a society with a privatised health service smokers would face higher insurance premiums or having to pay out of pocket for smoking related healthcare and car insurance would be more expensive due to the chance of the insurance company having to fund medical costs for those involved in accidents. The tax on housing is in lieu of VAT on such purchases and is essentially a standard tax on spending.

MereDintofPandiculation · 24/09/2023 18:41

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 17:43

We don’t have enough babies being born. We as a country could look at why the birth rate is falling, is it just a post covid blip or a long term trend? Does it need fixing?

there’s some commentators already saying it needs fixing, so this is one way to use the tax system to nudge people to have that 2nd or 3rd baby. Make it a bit less painful to add another child.

guess it would come down to which sections of society are not having babies, is it across the board or are the richer or poorer more likely to have no or only 1 child?

Having lots of babies born just after the war didn't work out very well, did it?

OneTwoThreeShake · 24/09/2023 18:38

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 18:32

Training to be a nurse or an engineer are "lifestyle choices" which are subsidised by the taxpayer because the country would be knackered if only people who could afford a qualification to become a nurse or engineer outright could do so. With birth rates dipping well below replacement rates, with cost being a major reason, having children is a fair comparison.

Also if you reduce the amount of tax a person pays you aren't giving them anything you are just taking less from them.

And if it's not acceptable to "subsidise lifestyle choices" then why is it acceptable to tax lifestyle choices like smoking or having a car or buying a house?

I'm here struggling to remember when any of the training I undertook to be an engineer was subsidised by anybody.

But yes, it was a choice I made. A good choice which benefits both me and wider society.

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 18:32

Training to be a nurse or an engineer are "lifestyle choices" which are subsidised by the taxpayer because the country would be knackered if only people who could afford a qualification to become a nurse or engineer outright could do so. With birth rates dipping well below replacement rates, with cost being a major reason, having children is a fair comparison.

Also if you reduce the amount of tax a person pays you aren't giving them anything you are just taking less from them.

And if it's not acceptable to "subsidise lifestyle choices" then why is it acceptable to tax lifestyle choices like smoking or having a car or buying a house?

GreyhpundGirl · 24/09/2023 18:24

The threshold is stupid. Both could earn £49999 amd get it but one partner earns £50001 and they start to claw it back through tax.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 18:23

Eleganz · 24/09/2023 18:20

The rich and large businesses? Closing a few tax loopholes for them would more than compensate.

Wouldn’t that be lovely, eh?

JenniferBooth · 24/09/2023 18:23

right now, birth rates in the UK are low. If this isn’t just a post covid /cost of living blip, but a long term trend, then this could be a serious problem for society in the future

Im childfree by choice anyway but do feel it should be pointed out that the very same Party that is in power now have always gone on and on about the fact that people shouldnt have children they cant afford (anyone else remember the infamous Peter Lilley speech) so they have no right to whine now that the reckoning has to paid. Never has the phrase "be careful what you wish for" been more apt!

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 18:21

SecretVictoria · 24/09/2023 18:19

Thank you for saying it’s true 😊.

These things always annoy me, I don’t have DC (not 100% by choice) and I know what it’s like to struggle as a single, low earner. You get zero help. I’m in a better position now, but that is thanks to my DH. I couldn't afford to travel to my (under £23k for full time) job if it wasn’t for him. I have another job in the pipeline (🤞) which is more money (before anyone tells me to ‘up my hours’ or ‘take in ironing’).

I still don’t think parents should get more money for having children that they chose to have.

And no one would pay me for my ironing skills 🤣.

Flowers
Eleganz · 24/09/2023 18:20

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 18:18

It’s 2.5k a year, no parent is going to have some unfair advantage by this over non parents by having children

Firstly being able to keep £12.5k (x each additional child) more of your own money is an advantage that parents would have over non-parents under your proposals.

Secondly, this sizeable loss in taxable income going to HMT is going to need to be recouped somehow. If parents are carved out of that responsibility (because there’s be no point in seeking to recoup from them what was given away in the first place), then who’s left? Ooh I know!

The rich and large businesses? Closing a few tax loopholes for them would more than compensate.

SecretVictoria · 24/09/2023 18:19

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 18:11

True - but it does benefit society for people to continue to have children - ideally at a rate that means we will have a decent ratio of workers to pensioners in the future.

right now, birth rates in the UK are low. If this isn’t just a post covid /cost of living blip, but a long term trend, then this could be a serious problem for society in the future.

taxes and benefits have always been used as a way to nudge people to act in a way that will benefit society.

Thank you for saying it’s true 😊.

These things always annoy me, I don’t have DC (not 100% by choice) and I know what it’s like to struggle as a single, low earner. You get zero help. I’m in a better position now, but that is thanks to my DH. I couldn't afford to travel to my (under £23k for full time) job if it wasn’t for him. I have another job in the pipeline (🤞) which is more money (before anyone tells me to ‘up my hours’ or ‘take in ironing’).

I still don’t think parents should get more money for having children that they chose to have.

And no one would pay me for my ironing skills 🤣.

Eleganz · 24/09/2023 18:18

The do this in Germany along with a range of other allowances.

They should definitely get rid of the higher income benefit charge or at least reform it to consider household income rather than individual income.

Birth rates are too low in this country and we are facing significant issues as we are trying to restrict immigration but need to maintain a decent sized workforce in the future to pay for the welfare state. If people are being put off having children in this country because of the cost we need to do something about it otherwise there will be trouble in the future. It doesn't really matter that parents aren't having kids to fill the demographic gap as that gap still exists and needs to be filled either by immigration or a higher birthrate.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 18:18

It’s 2.5k a year, no parent is going to have some unfair advantage by this over non parents by having children

Firstly being able to keep £12.5k (x each additional child) more of your own money is an advantage that parents would have over non-parents under your proposals.

Secondly, this sizeable loss in taxable income going to HMT is going to need to be recouped somehow. If parents are carved out of that responsibility (because there’s be no point in seeking to recoup from them what was given away in the first place), then who’s left? Ooh I know!

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 18:11

SecretVictoria · 24/09/2023 18:00

No one has kids for “the good of society”. No one.

True - but it does benefit society for people to continue to have children - ideally at a rate that means we will have a decent ratio of workers to pensioners in the future.

right now, birth rates in the UK are low. If this isn’t just a post covid /cost of living blip, but a long term trend, then this could be a serious problem for society in the future.

taxes and benefits have always been used as a way to nudge people to act in a way that will benefit society.

anniegun · 24/09/2023 18:11

bopbey · 24/09/2023 17:27

And 90% isn't 100% when I last checked.

Over 90% of families get paid CB. Less than 10% earn too much to qualify although as you say, there are NI benefits
You are right 90% is not 100% and I do think it should be a universal benefit. My point is (in answer to the original post) is that it is a better way of helping people with the extra cost of children than complicated and divisive tax breaks. Raising children is a net investment in the future of the country, it should be supported. Universal benefits are much simpler and get broader support. Everybody got something from CB (even if it was when you were a child). That's starting to be eroded and the Tories will always reduce a benefit if their supporters feel its something they will not get. Look at how the state pension is supported compared to other benefits.

User183642 · 24/09/2023 18:08

At £2500 per child it would cost £32billion a year in lost taxes the equivalent of the cost running the NHS for over 2 months which is clearly not a sustainable loss to the public budget and would largely have to be recouped elsewhere.

LimeCheesecake · 24/09/2023 18:05

Uggtrending · 24/09/2023 17:52

@Desecratedcoconut the problem with being a SAHM it's easy to expand your family because you are at home anyway and you are the free childcare. However how many people can afford it? Many alledge they can on MN..... but in reality I don't see how it's viable in this economy. Those days ended when I was growing up in the 90s.

i became a SAHM after dc2, childcare plus travel to work was more than I would earn a month and dh earned too much for us to get help. We were better off as a family with one parent at home, working would have been the luxury. Either way we had to arrange our finances to just live off DHs wage. if I worked, less than just DHs wage.

I rejoined the workforce when dc2 was at school. But the state missed out on 4+ years of me paying tax and when I went back to work, it was earning less than I’d left on.

this is still normal, that the lower earner is bringing in less than the childcare and travel costs.

family childcare plugs a lot of gaps in this. Other countries manage cheap childcare, cheap public transport and tax systems that reward working after having dcs.

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 18:03

Why do you keep saying 2.5k? You want full adult personal tax allowance, 2.5k is a fraction of that

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 18:00

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 17:53

I’m not even asking for anyone else’s money, just they we could just keep a little more of our own while raising children.

But that’s how everyone sees it, as wanting to keep a little more of their own.

Sounds like you and DH both have good jobs. What are you finding unaffordable? It it putting food on the table? Bills?

Just asking that our children as recognised as people with the same rights and needs as any other people, we fully accept earning the money to pay for them on their behalf but why is that money 100% taxed. It’s 2.5k a year, no parent is going to have some unfair advantage by this over non parents by having children

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 24/09/2023 18:00

bopbey · 24/09/2023 16:36

I'm sorry if you are struggling but I really think that people should only have children they can afford.

Why wasn't this the case 40 yrs ago?

And people are having what they can afford hence the birth rates

I can't afford my second but you make it work

mrsbyers · 24/09/2023 18:00

Fuck that , I subsidise other people’s kids enough through my taxes as it is

SecretVictoria · 24/09/2023 18:00

No one has kids for “the good of society”. No one.