Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should families get a tax allowance for dependant children

443 replies

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 16:04

Just a thought from another thread about there being no help for the squeezed middle who feel they are hardly better off than those on universal credit. Wouldn’t it just be fairer if those families not entitled to universal credit were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child.
Why are adults given a tax allowance that acknowledges the basic costs of needing to eat and have a roof over there head etc and yet parents are expected to provide all this (plus 80% childcare costs) for their children completely out of their taxed income

OP posts:
Guffpuff · 24/09/2023 20:29

Yeah, definitely less taxes for people with young children.

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 20:27

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:06

Perhaps to put another angle on this, the children we have grow up ( finger crossed) to be tax payers, who pay for our state pensions.
Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Or a stepped state pension allowance based on your actual out of pocket tax contributions. 😊

Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea )

You mean a system whereby infertile people, some disabled people and gay people are penalised. How wonderful you are not suggesting that ableist homophobic idea.

I tend to think the tens of thousands I spent trying to have a baby as my childless tax anyway.

graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

So my baby was stillborn. So what you are suggesting is that I am financially penalised for not "successfully raising tax paying offspring" because my baby died. I was in fact unsuccessful. How remiss of me. So any families whose child dies are reminded of that financially. Charming.

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:25

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 20:17

Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Any country which decided that I was deserving of less of a state pension (or indeed NO state pension) simply because my body won’t produce taxpayers would see me emigrate right out of it.

Yes yes I know you said “decide they don’t want” but unless you’re proposing that the Government subject women and men to fertility tests, you can’t tell the difference between “don’t want” and “can’t have”.

Not to mention the fact that your charming idea would mean that anyone giving birth to a severely disabled child wouldn’t get this “allowance” if said child proved unable to work. Yet they’d still have born all of the costs of raising them.

I swear some people in here want to live in The Handmaid’s Tale.

That would be another country that you wouldnt have ANY right to a state pension in as a new immigrant I assume?

If someone is wanting a baby, and has "issues" they visit the doctor and would be tested anyway.

You need to go and have a muffin or a nice mug of hot chocolate, calm down and not get so upset by light hearted, flippant posts on the internet :o)

CoolerWeather · 24/09/2023 20:22

But everyone gets that. The child free have to pay for everyone’s extras.

You do realise that you need the next generations children, even if you don't have children yourself. It's part of living in a society.

grayhairdontcare · 24/09/2023 20:21

So according to this post, no one is have children because they want them.
They are having them to pay future tax and to look after old people.
So because of this, they deserve a tax break.
Do the children you have known they were born out of civic duty and not because they are actually wanted??
This thread is bat shit!
Only have what you can afford in life.
That statement applies to children as well!

Insommmmnia · 24/09/2023 20:21

I thought one of the reasons birth rates have dropped is because the generation who would currently be having children are having to contend with soaring house prices, insane energy bills and increasing rents. This means its taking them longer to reach a point of stability where they can have a child and for some they are not reaching that point at all.

Whilst I do think something needs to be improved around childcare costs, I never agreed with child benefit being capped, and I would love to see the return to sure starts etc and the underfunding of the schools is horrendous I'm not sure personal allowance increases for individuals is the answer.

The personal allowance is 12.5k. If you double that when you have a child it's 25k, 2 children and you are up to 37.5k.

The median salary is around 31k so we are talking about over 50% of people not paying any tax for 18 years (or would it just be allocated to one parent in which case 25% of the population not paying any tax for 18 years)

Even at 25% of the population not paying tax for 18 years there would be a drop in funds available for things like education or people without school ages children would have to be taxed higher

So unless there is some wierd "pre-children" tax break then people struggling currently to afford to get to a position where they can have children would struggle more. Thereby potentially dropping the birth rate further. Or more children would be born into unstable situations so people could get tax breaks to afford to live

Surely sorting out the soaring house prices, insane energy bills and increasing rents, bringing back child benefit for all children (which is likely to reduce the abortion rate) and better subsidised and invested in childcare and education would be better?

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 20:18

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 20:09

However yes effectively a person with 2 children would be able to earn 37.5k tax free to take account of the fact they are supporting 2 dependants (or alternatively claim UC if eligible) as would be 12.5k + 12.5k + 12.5k, however both parents wouldn’t be able to do this as just one tax allowance per child

So it isn't 2.5k per kid it's 12.5k, and you would remove a big chunk of the current taxpayers. I can't even begin to think how stupid people would have to be to think this is a good idea

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:17

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 20:15

And the parents that raise the criminals and pisstakers? Some sort of tax/pension penalty?

Euthanised for failure to parent properly 😆

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 20:17

Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Any country which decided that I was deserving of less of a state pension (or indeed NO state pension) simply because my body won’t produce taxpayers would see me emigrate right out of it.

Yes yes I know you said “decide they don’t want” but unless you’re proposing that the Government subject women and men to fertility tests, you can’t tell the difference between “don’t want” and “can’t have”.

Not to mention the fact that your charming idea would mean that anyone giving birth to a severely disabled child wouldn’t get this “allowance” if said child proved unable to work. Yet they’d still have born all of the costs of raising them.

I swear some people in here want to live in The Handmaid’s Tale.

ruby1957 · 24/09/2023 20:16

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 20:04

Yes absolutely mean just being the same tax allowance as adults, not asking to be given any extra cash at all or any more allowance that people over 18 get. Just for children to be considered ‘people’ in the tax system like anyone else. Quite happy for anyone else to be allowed to claim a tax allowance for those dependant on them too whether they have children or not. Not asking for any incentives/rewards to have children, anyone else’s money etc

Yes you are asking for anyone else's money and to be rewarded for having children!

Who would make up the shortfall if this was applied across the board for all children/dependents

The tax-free personal allowance is set against income - which is worked for.

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 20:15

Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:06

Perhaps to put another angle on this, the children we have grow up ( finger crossed) to be tax payers, who pay for our state pensions.
Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Or a stepped state pension allowance based on your actual out of pocket tax contributions. 😊

And the parents that raise the criminals and pisstakers? Some sort of tax/pension penalty?

FriedasCarLoad · 24/09/2023 20:11

Yes, not least because we are in danger of a rapidly falling population in future and need to encourage people to have more babies.

But the ability for married couples to file joint tax returns (thus sharing their allowance) is more urgent, and is allowed in all but a very small handful of countries.

(Admittedly this would now benefit me, but I felt just as strongly about it when I thought I was single forever.)

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 20:09

However yes effectively a person with 2 children would be able to earn 37.5k tax free to take account of the fact they are supporting 2 dependants (or alternatively claim UC if eligible) as would be 12.5k + 12.5k + 12.5k, however both parents wouldn’t be able to do this as just one tax allowance per child

OP posts:
Thatladdo · 24/09/2023 20:06

Perhaps to put another angle on this, the children we have grow up ( finger crossed) to be tax payers, who pay for our state pensions.
Im not suggesting that people that decide they dont want to have children dont receive a state pension ( interesting idea ) but a graduated allowance on your successfully raised tax paying offspring could be your reward.

Or a stepped state pension allowance based on your actual out of pocket tax contributions. 😊

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 20:04

AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 19:47

That's where the op wasn't clear, in the op it says were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child. The personal tax allowance is the amount you can earn without paying tax, so it reads like she wants a person with 2 kids to be able to earn £37.5k that is tax free, not that they would only get tax relief on 20% of that value (or I guess 40% if a higher rate tax payer)

Yes absolutely mean just being the same tax allowance as adults, not asking to be given any extra cash at all or any more allowance that people over 18 get. Just for children to be considered ‘people’ in the tax system like anyone else. Quite happy for anyone else to be allowed to claim a tax allowance for those dependant on them too whether they have children or not. Not asking for any incentives/rewards to have children, anyone else’s money etc

OP posts:
AnonAnonandAriston · 24/09/2023 19:47

sleepyscientist · 24/09/2023 19:35

@AnonAnonandAriston it wouldn't be 12.5k tho for a basic rate tax payer getting an additional it more like 2.5k (4k if you make it national insurance except) or 5k (5.25k NI excerpt) for higher rate tax payers.

OP I think it's a good idea and could be a vote winner for many parents. The current government needs some vote winners like this

That's where the op wasn't clear, in the op it says were given an extra tax allowance equivalent to the adult personal allowance for each child. The personal tax allowance is the amount you can earn without paying tax, so it reads like she wants a person with 2 kids to be able to earn £37.5k that is tax free, not that they would only get tax relief on 20% of that value (or I guess 40% if a higher rate tax payer)

sleepyscientist · 24/09/2023 19:35

@AnonAnonandAriston it wouldn't be 12.5k tho for a basic rate tax payer getting an additional it more like 2.5k (4k if you make it national insurance except) or 5k (5.25k NI excerpt) for higher rate tax payers.

OP I think it's a good idea and could be a vote winner for many parents. The current government needs some vote winners like this

TheLightProgramme · 24/09/2023 19:24

No, but I'd like to see more fairness with families that have one low earner or stay at home parent.The HICBC should be fairer. There should be the ability to transfer more unused allowances to the other spouse too. Not just 10%.

But the whole point is to reflect that a family with one stay at home parent can increase their income by both working. The family with two working parents are already both working. Why do they deserve it less than the family where one parent isn't even working?

The point is to a) incentivise working but also b) incentivise women to keep their careers - a family will be better off if both parents go part time vs if just the mother quits work.

bopbey · 24/09/2023 19:23

right now, birth rates in the UK are low. If this isn’t just a post covid /cost of living blip, but a long term trend, then this could be a serious problem for society in the future.

it already is a serious problem

bopbey · 24/09/2023 19:22

@Cowlover89 I don't understand your point? People are having less dc now that's a fact.

@anniegun I agree with you & said CB should be universal.

lifesnotaspectatorsport · 24/09/2023 19:22

I agree with you OP, and I doubt £2.5K does more than cover the basics of raising a child in the U.K. like food, clothing, transport. You're hardly "profiting" by it.

I live in an EU country which gives these tax allowances for every child (and more if you have 3+). It is a much simpler way of acknowledging the extra cost of having children - and at the end of the day, those children pay your future pensions and the taxes that enable the economy to continue functioning. You don't have to claim anything, you just submit the tax return and it's taken off.

But you can't look at just one part of the tax system in isolation. I also pay much higher taxes in general - you hit the 30% tax rate at about 20k euros income. Stamp duty equivalent is massive and no allowance for your main residence. But I don't begrudge the taxes because the public sector functions very well. At the same time I feel like families are recognised for the part we play in creating the country's future, through the tax system.

The U.K. is a mess viewed from a European perspective.

BIossomtoes · 24/09/2023 19:18

Having lots of babies born just after the war didn't work out very well, did it?

It did when they were all working and paying tax. Not so much now they’re getting old - an entirely predictable with no crystal ball required scenario that successive governments failed to address for decades.

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 24/09/2023 19:06

@User183642 fwiw I actually agree with you but we don't live in anything close to the society you describe and probably never will in our lifetimes. In the context of what is politically plausible a tax credit for children is a pretty reasonable and logical measure that would benefit in the long run.

Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 19:05

fitzwilliamdarcy · 24/09/2023 18:18

It’s 2.5k a year, no parent is going to have some unfair advantage by this over non parents by having children

Firstly being able to keep £12.5k (x each additional child) more of your own money is an advantage that parents would have over non-parents under your proposals.

Secondly, this sizeable loss in taxable income going to HMT is going to need to be recouped somehow. If parents are carved out of that responsibility (because there’s be no point in seeking to recoup from them what was given away in the first place), then who’s left? Ooh I know!

A tax allowance of 12.5k isn’t keeping 12.5k extra of your income 🤦🏻‍♀️ it is 12.5k disregard from your income i.e if you earn 25k as an adult individual you get the luxury of only having to pay tax on 12.5k of that i.e you only pay 2.5k tax instead of 5k

OP posts:
Clariee45 · 24/09/2023 19:00

Shumpalumpa · 24/09/2023 18:21

Flowers

My proposal is asking for ‘more money’ off you or anyone else, simply to be allowed a tax ‘allowance’ I.e. portion of income to be disregarded in the calculation of tax taken off us. Plenty of people like yourselves I have come across who find they are not on a low enough combined income for any benefits, can you imagine how much more of a struggle that would be with children. It costs more than 2.5k a year to feed, clothe and house a child so I’m not even asking that parents be entitled to keep that extra of the their own earnings. Just to be able to keep the 2.5k you get to keep of your income as a human in this country, why should you be entitled to that and not the money earned for children to eat and be housed?

OP posts: