Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How we present ourselves determines how we are treated?

110 replies

AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 15:19

It is a well known concept, but interesting to see how it works in real life.

I have a friend who typically wears rather plain but well made clothes, has long hair which she always twists back into a neat french twist. She is average height and good looking. She recently told me that after having her hair cut into a contemporary style she has noticed a swift change in how people respond to her when out and about (shopping, bank, restaurants etc).
According to her, she is treated with less respect generally, compared to her old look. I thought this was really fascinating!

I also noticed that when I am fully togged up in rain wear with my hood up and waterproof boots on (so that most of me is hidden), people are much less likely to slow down and allow me to cross a road, or hold a door open and so on. In ordinary clothes (say a summer dress for example) I have observed cars slow to let me cross far more often than when I am accompanied by DP.

I think we barely realise this in everyday life, how society will make quick, unconscious judgements about us from our surface appearance, often before we can even open our mouths. When I am mostly visible with hair loose, people are noticeably friendlier and more accommodating. And I am presuming it is different for all of us, considering looks, age, gender, etc, but it does stand.

My friend thinks that previously people considered her to be wealthier or of a higher status due to her hair and clothes. I was very young looking in my 20's and was definitely treated as if I was a teen, frustratingly.

Anyone have any other examples of this?

OP posts:
vlo · 24/09/2023 20:52

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2023 17:44

This is all absolutely true but I think projecting a sense of confidence and entitlement to be there trumps all of this. Act like you belong and you will be treated as such, regardless of what you are wearing. I’m afraid to say being white, male and having the right accent also trump what you are wearing.

Clothing can help this in part because it helps people feel more confident but it’s largely a prop and if you don’t have the confidence to style it out you can end up looking like a child dressing up in mum’s clothes.

Kind of disagree with this! I feel more at ease in casual stuff but definitely get better treatment in local shops when wearing something more smart and formal and quietly shuffling through the checkout.

vlo · 24/09/2023 20:48

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/09/2023 20:42

I am mid 50s and used to bleach my hair. I guess at first glance, it could have looked like naturally grey hair. After a way decided I would like a change and went back to light blonde. People were so much more helpful to me.

wow that’s terrible!

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/09/2023 20:42

I am mid 50s and used to bleach my hair. I guess at first glance, it could have looked like naturally grey hair. After a way decided I would like a change and went back to light blonde. People were so much more helpful to me.

Fistralstorm · 24/09/2023 20:31

@AgneathaForest mushroomy dark blonde is on trend at the moment 😁

AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 20:16

I have experienced the opposite with hair colour.
I was a light blonde until my late 30's when it turned to a darker, ashy blonde with natural caramelly highlights. Known in the trade as dishwater.
I then had it lightened for a few years and noticed no difference in how other people reacted to me.

I now sport my natural shade once more, and quite like it now. It feels curiously unique since it's considered such a 'dull' colour most other people who have it dye it Grin

OP posts:
Fistralstorm · 24/09/2023 20:08

I have noticed this. I am a brunette and I had highlights for several years so had fairly blonde hair for a while. When I dyed my hair back to brunette people were much less friendly to me and I found work more difficult and more unfriendly

gogomoto · 24/09/2023 20:05

If I go into a department store with make up counter in fairly formal clothes and smart coat they fall over themselves ti try to get me to try their products, if I'm in jeans and a puffer jacket it isn't the case - I know how to get a free makeover Grin

EveryKneeShallBow · 24/09/2023 20:03

in my early 20s I worked in a legal office, but not client facing, so I wore clean jeans/white shirt every day. When it came to Christmas, for fun, I and the other women in my office decided to go to the Christmas party full on glam (this was the late 1980s).

Two of the partners flirted with me all evening, and didn’t recognise me, even though I had had conversations with both of them several times in the coffee room, or Reception.

When I told them (or someone else did, I can’t recall) who I was, their faces dropped. One of them said “Oh my God! I almost asked you to come down to the country with me this weekend.”

LakieLady · 24/09/2023 20:00

therealcookiemonster · 24/09/2023 16:19

@AgneathaForest the North South accent discrimination goes both ways though lol

My Yorkshire-born friend thinks I and everyone else with a perfectly standard RP accent sound "posh".

It always makes me laugh, because her family are far posher than mine, and I grew up on a dead rough council estate in Croydon, while she grew up in a big house in an affluent village near York and went to an independent school.

AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 19:53

That said, I was gently mocked and called precious when I used an umbrella in Wigan, once! Whilst I hail from Lancashire, not far from there, I was rather impressed by how resilient Wigan natives were in the face of freezing rain, wind and low temps.
I now notice which towns are quick to put their brollies up in a shower. Shrewsbury fit my personality like a glove.

OP posts:
AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 19:47

I wouldn't suggest changing my appearance to suit a community or neighbourhood, that might be difficult to keep up and lead to long term resentment.
Altering our look to pass through transient situations can work well though, depending how we feel about it. I honestly don't think I would want to live somewhere where people singled out, or commented on my clothing. I haven't experienced that though, and could only excuse it if the climate demanded a change!

OP posts:
Chipsahoy · 24/09/2023 19:07

MereDintofPandiculation · 24/09/2023 17:31

I imagine they're regarding you as a "townie", ie the lowest of the low.

Wow. Previously I have been called posh. Very mild plain accent and always dressed up. However I agree, I am an outsider. Maybe I need to wear country clothes? I do when cleaning out chickens.. but when I’m out and about, I’m wearing my usual clothes.

riotlady · 24/09/2023 18:47

I used to have a dress I called my “magic” dress in my early 20s because when I wore it men always fell over themselves to help me. I used to wear it getting the train home from uni so that I was nearly guaranteed to have someone carry my suitcase up the stairs. Interestingly it wasn’t at all “sexy”, it was quite innocent and youthful- white with a fairly pouffy skirt and a big bow at the back. Damsel in distress vibes I guess?

Barely anyone carried my suitcase when I wore jeans!

Onthelastdayofseptember · 24/09/2023 18:41

I'm not sure if I have noticed this. When younger, I'd get noticeably more attention/ discounts/ help from men if I looked more attractive ie make up on, hair done.
But don't think I've noticed any difference in how women treat me, or people like doctors/ teachers etc. I generally dress down, minimal make up, natural hair. Occasionally dress smartly for work but don't see a difference. Maybe I'm just unobserved!

Islandsadness · 24/09/2023 18:23

100%

Having been slim and obese the difference is staggering.

There is research that shows women's wages are linked to their weight Confused

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 24/09/2023 18:20

Let's add accent into the mix! I live in Denmark and have actually given up speaking Danish to drs. If you pause for half a fucking second to find the right word then you (and your children) just get dismissed. When I speak my mother tongue they suddenly pay attention to me because funnily enough I'm more articulate in English. Can only imagine how much worse it is for ethnic minorities and people whose mother tongue isn't understood by 95% of the population.

vlo · 24/09/2023 17:58

Mamette · 24/09/2023 15:28

Yes, I think it’s true. I have always noticed this, especially in shops. When I have my work clothes on I get a lot more smiley attention and help.

It’s the Pretty Woman effect I guess.

(Unfortunately I do not look like Julia Roberts).

I have noticed this at my local (small – not a big chain) supermarket. If I am neat and smart, dressed in work clothes, the staff are friendlier and more respectful than in the past when I’ve gone in in jeans/joggers, with natural wavy hair (not blow dried), etc.

Dontcallmescarface · 24/09/2023 17:52

Yep. I put make-up on and people will talk to me and make eye contact, when I don't bother with the slap well then I just become invisible.

Jericha · 24/09/2023 17:51

We moved to a house on a road with retired middle class professionals. We are mid 30s but both look young for our ages. Both work from home so dress sloppily most of the time. They all looked horrified and ignored us if they could. We bought from a retired middle class couple who tended their gardens diligently. When we got our back garden done they all came out of the woodwork. Now they all love us now they know we both work, have a family, encourage wildlife, take pride in our home etc etc. I reckon if we didn't work from home and they saw us drive home every night in the stuff we wear when we occasionally do venture into our respective offices they wouldn't have been so hard to crack.

solvendie · 24/09/2023 17:49

I’ve noticed this. If I wear a skirt I will get doors held open for me. When I have blonde hair, shop assistants are more helpful and friendly than when I have dark hair. Dressing up gets better service and interactions with the general public.

It’s getting less noticeable now that I’m getting towards 50 and I feel just ignored in general!

sonres · 24/09/2023 17:47

I’m afraid to say being white, male and having the right accent also trump what you are wearing

Probably true of my son. We live in a city with a strong local accent which my son has never acquired, he's generic northern. He's also tall, I think that helps

sonres · 24/09/2023 17:46

My son is 20, has a like for certain expensive things - watches, trainers, all of which he buys himself. His other clothes are often second hand, or come from Next or Costco. But he pieces his look together well, but never without a baseball cap. He recently went into Ralph Lauren to buy a sweater he'd been wanting. Staff fell over themselves and one gave him their staff discount. I think the fact he knows what he likes comes across

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2023 17:44

This is all absolutely true but I think projecting a sense of confidence and entitlement to be there trumps all of this. Act like you belong and you will be treated as such, regardless of what you are wearing. I’m afraid to say being white, male and having the right accent also trump what you are wearing.

Clothing can help this in part because it helps people feel more confident but it’s largely a prop and if you don’t have the confidence to style it out you can end up looking like a child dressing up in mum’s clothes.

Tremour · 24/09/2023 17:39

Is it because if you're in plain clothes etc you blend into the background a bit but if your wearing a bright colour or something that stands out even bright lipstick it might made a person top a second and notice.

Bit like in the matrix movie everyone in black then you the woman in red walking through, who do you notice more...obviously the person in red.

This doen't just mean colour but if everyone is wearing similar clothes e.g. everyone in leggings or trousers and then someone comes long in shorts... same effect it stands out

LemonQuiche · 24/09/2023 17:36

The world has gone very casual these days but when I first started my job about 15 years ago, I had to go in smart office dress everyday. Without a doubt, I got better and far more polite and attentive service in shops and restaurants when I was dressed formally than the way I dress for work now (smart casual).