Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How we present ourselves determines how we are treated?

110 replies

AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 15:19

It is a well known concept, but interesting to see how it works in real life.

I have a friend who typically wears rather plain but well made clothes, has long hair which she always twists back into a neat french twist. She is average height and good looking. She recently told me that after having her hair cut into a contemporary style she has noticed a swift change in how people respond to her when out and about (shopping, bank, restaurants etc).
According to her, she is treated with less respect generally, compared to her old look. I thought this was really fascinating!

I also noticed that when I am fully togged up in rain wear with my hood up and waterproof boots on (so that most of me is hidden), people are much less likely to slow down and allow me to cross a road, or hold a door open and so on. In ordinary clothes (say a summer dress for example) I have observed cars slow to let me cross far more often than when I am accompanied by DP.

I think we barely realise this in everyday life, how society will make quick, unconscious judgements about us from our surface appearance, often before we can even open our mouths. When I am mostly visible with hair loose, people are noticeably friendlier and more accommodating. And I am presuming it is different for all of us, considering looks, age, gender, etc, but it does stand.

My friend thinks that previously people considered her to be wealthier or of a higher status due to her hair and clothes. I was very young looking in my 20's and was definitely treated as if I was a teen, frustratingly.

Anyone have any other examples of this?

OP posts:
UndercoverCop · 25/09/2023 08:01

Accent makes a difference too, I'm from East London and live in Essex so everyone assumes I'm thick and/or promiscuous. Just through uni and work etc my accent has neutralised and is much closer to RP. I can still switch back easily and do unconsciously when I go 'home' , the difference in how people treat me is astonishing

Fistralstorm · 25/09/2023 07:56

It must be an issue worldwide. Otherwise Unconscious Bias training wouldn't exist

(and I've had to do it in Germany, UK and Norway as part of various jobs!)

FloralDerangement · 25/09/2023 07:54

The only difference I've noticed is if my hair is up or not. I find more men flirt with me when my hair is tied up than when it's down. Otherwise I get treated the same no matter what I wear.

Beezknees · 25/09/2023 07:49

I'm covered in tattoos and can't say that I feel I get worse treatment than anyone else, although maybe I'm just thick skinned!

lljkk · 25/09/2023 07:45

Only rarely. And it's on them.
I don't have many data I suppose, because never change my look.

I am a right scruff bag.
New in job, I was introduced to someone at work who I already knew was a greasy pole climber and possibly a total lech. He looked me up & down and visually dismissed me.

it was so obvious & so funny I laughed my head off, telling colleague the story. I didn't think much of him, anyway.

Few yrs later, I've got loads of accolades at work for various things. Greasy pole was suddenly friendly. Yeah yeah. Still amused. His reputation hasn't improved.

sashh · 25/09/2023 05:41

I first noticed this age 11. Every school in the town had a gray uniform, except the RC girls' school, ours was navy.

Men are really pervy when it comes to 'catholic girls'.

Later riding a motorbike around London, that confused people, they would see the black leather, then I would take my helmet off and suddenly I'm a short blond woman.

Red hair got me different attention.

What I do notice though is the genuinely posh places don't judge you.

The kind of shops with a buzzer on the door treat you beautifully no matter how you are dressed.

Even when you say, "I'll never be able to afford it but could I try on that Patek Phillipe watch". As PP watches go it was a cheapy, only £7K. It is the most expensive thing I have ever had on my wrist.

Worriedaboutpp · 25/09/2023 05:16

Yes, definitely. I dress a bit depending on how sociable I'm feeling. So if I'm feeling super sociable, I wash my hair, 2 mins makeup and wear nicer clothes on the school run. Everyone smiles and chats to me. If I can't be bothered that day, I deliberately don't and wear jeans, hoodie, trainers and find even if I look for a chat I get barely any response. I realise these days from the "you look amazing" comments that I don't do the holy trio of washing hair, putting make up on (literally concealer, mascara, blush) and wearing "nicer" clothes very often (by this, I mean clothes that fit and not too big).

I'm considered attractive i'd say, though these days, not in a debelitating way. I n my teens and 20s, I often deliberately dressed down to stop older men hitting on me in every day life. I found it way too much. No longer such an issue and I do like that!

I'm sure many can relate here, how quick people are to smile, chat let you cross the road, open doors for you etc when you're pregnant... whether you look horrendous or not. I always find that fascinating. I guess some immediately feel a caring instinct?

I always go to see medical professionals looking "well-cared" for if its a long-term condition. I think it's taken more seriously. Also, if I was vomiting every few minutes for a few days, I wouldn't bother breaking myself showering etc before seeing a doctor, because it kinda illustrates the issue. So yep, appearance is important. Even if it's just a confidence thing and a smile.

WandaWonder · 25/09/2023 04:40

I can't say I have felt anyone treats me personally differently on how I dress/am or whatever but I feel I probably treat people who have chips on their shoulders or who come across as 'normal', or are smarmy or rude or have this aura of self importance differently

So I probably react to how they are to me, they may receive a different reaction to someone else

M4J4 · 25/09/2023 04:35

ChocolateCinderToffee · 25/09/2023 03:56

I realised in my 20s that there was no point in going shopping on Oxford Street without full slap on. You simply wouldn’t get served. Interestingly, now that I’m middle aged, women the same age as me do notice me in shops. To everyone else I don’t exist.

Yes, Selfridges were terrible. I went without make up so I could try some on, in a sundress, and the make-up lady didn’t want to know.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 25/09/2023 03:56

I realised in my 20s that there was no point in going shopping on Oxford Street without full slap on. You simply wouldn’t get served. Interestingly, now that I’m middle aged, women the same age as me do notice me in shops. To everyone else I don’t exist.

M4J4 · 25/09/2023 03:26

Yes, definitely. People do treat me differently when I’m well dressed (e.g. a suit) with blow dried hair and make-up.

Also, heels. I’m on the petite side but when I wear heels people, especially men, are less likely to expect me to move for them.

I think a little of this could be attributed to me being more confident when I’m well dressed, in heels etc, but only a small part.

And if I’m wearing any sort of ethnic clothes, I’m often treated like I can’t speak English.

Rudderneck · 25/09/2023 03:10

I think it's true, in any case, when you see a person you will interact with, your brain is making a thousand calculations about what the best way to deal with this person is. And your immediate information is only going to be based on the most obvious, and most general, information, and then that will be used to generate probabilities.

The more you interact with a person, the more you can tailor your response.

This isn't necessarily a bad thing, it helps us deal with people in the way that is most appropriate, or look out for danger. Of course it can also expose negative prejudices. But the idea that anyone doesn't make evaluations of this kind is just deeply naive.

Rudderneck · 25/09/2023 03:00

FOJN · 24/09/2023 15:43

I dyed my hair blond many years ago and the difference in the way men treated me shocked me. I never expected hair colour to make such a difference to the amount of attention I got.

So, when I was in my mid-40s I stopped colouring my hair, and let it just be silver/white.

At a certain point I realized that there was a contingent of male people who read this as "blond". Partly because I have a relatively young looking face, or at least I did then, and I had fair colouring naturally too so it seemed plausible I could be blond (as I was when I was a little girl.)

But it did seem to affect that group's sense of my attractiveness that they perceived me as a natural blond, it was really kind of odd and funny.

Kerantli · 25/09/2023 02:29

I have short (as in a couple inches on top, almost completely shaved off back) either bleach blonde or bright pink hair, a lot of visible piercings (nose, lip ears), use a pink walking stick with dragonflies on it and mostly wear black dresses or skirts that are knee-length or lower. I also have cronic "resting bitch face" as usually concentrating on not falling over.
I'm both visible but invisible. I get let on trains first if there's a crowd to make sure I get a seat, but there's no chance of that on a bus. In shops I'm ignored most of the time.

I just find it funny these days, and if anyone recognises me from that description - hi, I promise I don't bite 😂

givemeasunnyday · 25/09/2023 01:52

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/09/2023 21:12

I agree, and find it quite bizarre that anyone would be treated differently simply because of their hairstyle.

Most evaluations are done within seconds. Once an interaction goes on longer, people may change or be nicer, but it is the snap judgements that are affected most.

Did you not read the rest of my post? I have never felt evaluated in a less than positive way - ever. Do you really believe that someone is judged on a hairstyle? As a receptionist of many years standing I never once evaluated anyone on what they were wearing or their hairstyle.

AgneathaForest · 24/09/2023 22:37

Regarding racism, added to my OP I made a point of stating that this was about the appearance we choose, not what we were born with. Wearing hair in a french twist or changing it's colour being examples. Raincoats versus tailored wool.
Hope that helps.

OP posts:
MotherOfRatios · 24/09/2023 21:59

Right?!

the white privilege is showing

Howtosolveit · 24/09/2023 21:46

Oh yes, for sure. I look very different with makeup in work clothes vs. no makeup and casual, and people give me so much more respect in the former. Luckily no one I love falls into this category!

SpaceRaiders · 24/09/2023 21:42

@MotherOfRatios I was just about to chime in with the same, glad it’s only hair colour or a pretty dress that makes people treat you better. At least both can be changed!

In all honesty I never dress down for this reason unless I’m walking the dog. I remember having a conversation with Dd 9 explaining that when you’re a minority, dressing like a scruff will lead to you being judged unfavourably, ie. we never wear hoods inside and first impressions count so you must present well.

I’ve walked in naice shops neatly dressed and still I’ve been followed around as though I were a shoplifter. It’s frustrating. Generally once people hear my posh accent i’m treated a little better, unconsciously we tend to talk fairly loudly amongst ourselves, I find it greatly reduces that unconscious perception and puts people at ease.

MotherOfRatios · 24/09/2023 21:17

I mean have you never heard of something like racism?

As a black woman this has been my reality since birth...

muddyford · 24/09/2023 21:13

I think you are spot-on, saying all.these unconscious judgements. In terms of evolution all the little judgements would have saved your life, enabled you to eat and live long enough to breed. Anyone saying they never judge is seriously deluded, in my opinion. We evolved to judge.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/09/2023 21:12

I agree, and find it quite bizarre that anyone would be treated differently simply because of their hairstyle.

Most evaluations are done within seconds. Once an interaction goes on longer, people may change or be nicer, but it is the snap judgements that are affected most.

givemeasunnyday · 24/09/2023 21:11

I forgot to add - this has been the same for my whole life, not just because I am older now.

givemeasunnyday · 24/09/2023 21:05

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 24/09/2023 15:29

I'm not denying this happens, but I've never really noticed it in relation to myself tbh. Maybe I'm just not very sensitive to these things! I'm a very ordinary-looking 51 year-old woman, not especially well-groomed. I generally find people pretty friendly and accommodating, and I don't really think that changes according to how well-dressed I am or how good my hair looks (it's shortish, very fine and looks a mess in a slight breeze!).

I agree, and find it quite bizarre that anyone would be treated differently simply because of their hairstyle.

I am 64, mostly retired (just do a bit of casual work) and usually wander around in tracksuit pants and a sweatshirt, never wear make-up at all (not at work either). No-one has ever treated me any different to when I was in work attire. People are always friendly and mostly helpful. I have a friend who is always beautifully dressed and she is treated just the same as I am.

However, I am not in the UK - maybe people here don't judge on appearance quite as much?

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/09/2023 20:54

Yes, it was really surprising. What made me really notice it is that I was sorting out the house at the time, and before and after changing colour had been to the tip. Bleached hair - none of the employees came to help as I struggled with heavy stuff. Light blonde hair - they were falling over themselves to help. There were other things too, but that was the most blatant.