Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Contaminant in Diet Coke Bottle (For the 2nd Time)

38 replies

PineapplePrincess · 24/09/2023 12:25

Avid Diet Coke drinker here. I usually purchase 2ltr bottles for the house.

About a year ago I found a brown circular button type thing at the bottom of a 2ltr bottle. Was fortunate it wasn't poured into a glass and drank, as being brown in colour it wouldn’t have been obvious and would pose a potential choke risk particularly to young children.

I took photos and emailed them to Coke Cola, who asked for the packaging and ‘button’ to be sent to them for investigation. Which I did. I got a letter a few weeks later stating that they had concluded their investigation, had found no evidence of contamination through their process and (bizarrely) intimated that it would have had to enter the bottle at a later stage, I took from this they were almost blaming me!?! There was a ~£1.50 voucher included in the letter by was of an apology for the inconvenience.

The letter annoyed me, but I couldn’t be bothered arguing the point and marked it down to poor customer experience/service.

Until yesterday. When the same thing happened again.

Poured a drink into a glass, trace amount left at the bottom of the bottle when cutting the bottle in half to pop into the recycle bin - low and behold the same little brown circular button.

That’s a heck of a coincidence to happen twice to the same customer. Either that, or it happens a lot???

So I need help solving this mystery….

  • Has this happened to anyone else?
  • What do you think it is?
  • How could it got into the bottle (twice)?
  • Should I trust Coca Cola to investigate again?
  • Who should I report to?

I really, really don’t think this has gone in at my house. I’m pretty sure the bottle was sealed when it was opened for first use (I’m sure I would have notice if it had been open, as I’m the only person in the house that drinks it).

Tried calling Coca Cola today, their helpline is closed. If I’m honest I’m a bit reluctant to send everything away to them again, to get a similar response. Not sure who I would contact for a more independent assessment - Food Standard maybe…?

AIBU to want (proper) answers to this mystery?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Callyem · 25/09/2023 21:02

YesitsBess · 25/09/2023 19:09

@PineapplePrincess there is a sub Reddit called "what is this thing?" and I bet if you put all those pictures up someone will be able to tell you what that thing is.

I am invested in this mystery.

OP please do this, I am also invested 😁

malmi · 25/09/2023 21:01

YesitsBess · 25/09/2023 20:50

I think OP would have noticed if her scissors fell apart on both occasions...

They haven't fallen apart, the little plastic button has popped off. Happens on ours whenever you use them to cut anything more substantial than paper.

AliciaLime · 25/09/2023 20:53

allthehops · 24/09/2023 12:52

lol, I still think about that ironing board but I'm now convinced it was a troll 😂

Me too. I guess that’s women think of when men are thinking of the Roman Empire.

YesitsBess · 25/09/2023 20:50

I think OP would have noticed if her scissors fell apart on both occasions...

Jk987 · 25/09/2023 20:34

Diet Coke is choca bloc full of chemicals and caffeine. Best off with water all day and a bit of wine in the evening!

malmi · 25/09/2023 20:27

It's off the scissors.

Neverwatchedgameofthrones · 25/09/2023 20:13

Send it in to your local authority. I once had a large piece of plastic in a bag of pasta. It was doubly annoying as it was during covid so I couldn't swap it for another. Sainsbury refused to refund me the 47p. So I went to the local authority. The lady that works there thanked me for giving her something interesting to do during lockdowm and I later got a 20 page report about how sainsbury had sent 3 people to their factory in France to investigate it. It was determined to be part of the mixer. I bet it cost them a lot more than 47p to determine this!

This Saturday, I bought some pancakes from asda, still in date and everything. Opened them the day I bought them to find they were mouldy. I don't dare go back to the LA again incase they think it's me lol. But if you've got no previous, go for it. It'll cost them a lot more than £1.50 to resolve!

Jamandhamsandwich · 25/09/2023 20:00

Could it come from your scissors when you are cutting the bottles? Like this:

Contaminant in Diet Coke Bottle (For the 2nd Time)
QuestionableMouse · 25/09/2023 19:33

Afterschoolrun · 24/09/2023 15:11

Hate to be judgey but seriously stop drinking that stuff, it's OK very occasionally but otherwise is full of cancer causing ingredients and is just generally so bad for you. Maybe this is a sign to cut back at least!

Diet coke is not full of cancer causing chemicals. Artificial sweeteners aren't great for you but there's no solid evidence that they cause cancer.

PineapplePrincess · 25/09/2023 19:14

@Againstmachine · Today 18:07

If it is something off an machine it would be really weird to happen to same person twice with how much coke is produced

I know, the odds must be astronomical unless this is a regular thing? Particularly arising at two different factories!?!

But I can’t come up with any other logic. I don’t see how it could enter the bottle at distribution, that would only leave someone putting it in the bottle at the house.

I very much doubt the kids would (DS4 couldn’t, DS9 highly unlikely and not with the same item). And if my DH was trying to knock me off, I’m sure there would be more productive ways than this!?!

OP posts:
YesitsBess · 25/09/2023 19:09

@PineapplePrincess there is a sub Reddit called "what is this thing?" and I bet if you put all those pictures up someone will be able to tell you what that thing is.

I am invested in this mystery.

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 25/09/2023 18:23

Very weird. Hopefully they will give a more satisfactory answer (and freebies!) this time.

It made me recall when I was growing up we were dirt poor, dry bread sandwiches poor, my dad bought some cobs from the local bakery once, and when cutting it open there was a large rusty nail in the middle. He called them and popped back with the offending cob and nail still inside.
A week later the bakery owner pulled up at our house and unloaded one of the big brown bread trays from his car brimming with bakery items and delivered it to us, I had never seen such treats. Cobs by the bag full, cakes, cream cakes, fruit loaf, doughnuts, freshly baked bread....... I think I drooled, I had only ever imagined trying all those things.
Mum and dad froze the bread/cobs and me and my brother had a fab weekend gorging on sugar laden treats.

Againstmachine · 25/09/2023 18:07

If it is something off an machine it would be really weird to happen to same person twice with how much coke is produced.

PineapplePrincess · 25/09/2023 18:06

Called Coca Cola today and reported the issue again.

They still had a record of my previous contact, which they said was associated with their manufacturing plant in Toulouse, France.

The serial number off this bottle is apparently associated with Edmonton, UK. So the mystery grows....

They wanted me to send everything to them, but I'm dubious about doing so given the last investigation was unsuccessful.

I also found the pictures from the previous incident.....

Contaminant in Diet Coke Bottle (For the 2nd Time)
Contaminant in Diet Coke Bottle (For the 2nd Time)
OP posts:
PineapplePrincess · 24/09/2023 15:17

Maybe you're drinking too much diet coke?

I fully accept I drink far too much Diet Coke. I am trying to cut down, and this experience, will definitely help in this regard.

I can’t accept however I drink that much to experience this same issue twice. This either happens a lot, or I should be buying myself a lottery ticket!?!

OP posts:
Fizbosshoes · 24/09/2023 15:16

We found a biro lid in a sealed bottle of wine once! (Sorry that doesn't help)

PineapplePrincess · 24/09/2023 15:12

YesitsBess · Today 15:03

That's not what I'm thinking. Those are usually white and not that thick. I am thinking it's some kind of washer used for tightening the new style of caps on the production line.

Said confidently with my ten whole minutes of knowledge on this subject 😆

That’s what my thinking was, it’s like a small cap for a screw maybe? The top is smooth and rounded, the bottom has a recess/hole. I had expected Coca Cola to quickly identify where it has come from in the manufacturing - the fact they hadn’t, or claimed not to, concerns me.

Doesn't appear to come from anywhere inside the bottle (I’ve check other bottles). And the fact it’s brown in colour is odd - it’s definitely suppose to be this colour, it’s not tarnished or coloured. You would expect foreign objects in manufacturing to be brightly coloured to stand out, so they can be easily identified - like plasters or plastic gloves.

OP posts:
Afterschoolrun · 24/09/2023 15:11

Hate to be judgey but seriously stop drinking that stuff, it's OK very occasionally but otherwise is full of cancer causing ingredients and is just generally so bad for you. Maybe this is a sign to cut back at least!

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 24/09/2023 15:10

It looks like the hole / dimple in it is hexagonal? It looks to me like a cover that goes over a bolt head or nut.

I used to work in a food factory, investigating complaints. I'd imagine that the very first thing they will do is check to see if they have any other complaints the same - saves time if someone else already discovered what the widget is! - and they'll see you had an identical complaint they'll put it down to you being the source of the item.

I would contact environmental health rather than the factory, be honest that it's the second time you've had this so they don't think you're concealing anything, and that you weren't happy with the explanation last time.

I'd also mention your suspicion that it may be from the bottle manufacture rather than the drink production.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/09/2023 15:08

Maybe you're drinking too much diet coke?

Given that they don't respond to complaints appropriately, tweet your complaints.
They sound like the type of company that would react to that.

I'm still smug about a £20 refund from Amazon (and told to keep the goods concerned) when I tweeted a couple of weeks ago after getting nowhere with their AI chat and automated phone service.😀

YesitsBess · 24/09/2023 15:03

That's not what I'm thinking. Those are usually white and not that thick. I am thinking it's some kind of washer used for tightening the new style of caps on the production line.

Said confidently with my ten whole minutes of knowledge on this subject 😆

Againstmachine · 24/09/2023 15:01

YesitsBess · 24/09/2023 15:00

I've been watching videos of fizzy pop bottling just to see if I can work out what this is. Bored? Moi?!

Does it fit in/on the cap by any chance?

That's what I'm thinking it's the plastic inside the cap.

CherryMaDeara · 24/09/2023 15:01

I’ve complained in the past (my M&S sandwich had fungus growing most of the filling). They don’t write to apologise or offer a refund.

I would send to food standards explaining CC didn’t take your first complaint seriously.

YesitsBess · 24/09/2023 15:00

I've been watching videos of fizzy pop bottling just to see if I can work out what this is. Bored? Moi?!

Does it fit in/on the cap by any chance?

Thewizardbinbag · 24/09/2023 14:55

There’s no point in you sending it in. You’re the same customer so they will definitely put it down to happening in your house and not with them.
You’d have to get someone else to email in for you, saying they bought it.