Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?

494 replies

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 11:34

My DD is 19 and has a disability, she is not able to work and won’t be able to for the foreseeable. She receives PIP.

As she’s no longer in education, I was not entitled to claim benefits for her from the end of august this year. My tax credits went down quite considerably, and lost CB too, and all of my housing benefit. All together I am about £190 per week worse off. Which isn’t great as I am a single parent and also have a health condition (I receive low rate mobility PIP), and I had to give my job up in July as I couldn’t manage it anymore, so that’s another £1000ish per month down.

I am self employed and doing bits and pieces where I can, to give you an idea I’ve managed about 12 hours of work this month.

I did an online calculator in august and it looked like I would be better off on UC, and also needed to start a UC claim for DD, so I claimed for us both on the same day. We had an appointment at the jobcentre for DD’s claim a couple of weeks ago, and the advisor suggested that I become her appointee and I could have her UC paid into my account, if we felt DD didn’t have the capacity to manage it herself. I asked DD what she thought and she said she’d rather it was paid into my account. I am getting fit notes for both of us from the doctor and and hopefully we will both be entitled to the LCWRA elements.

The idea of being an adult and having to pay bills terrifies DD, mentally she is more like a 12 year old in a lot of ways. I have spoken to her about it and said the options are that either we work out exactly what her share of rent and bills etc would be and she just gives me the money for those, and she can arrange her own food shopping etc, and pay for herself if she wants to come on holidays etc. Or I keep the amount that I’ve lost in benefits for her, she can have whatever is leftover (which I think will still mean she’s better off than she is now with just her PIP). And then she can carry on essentially being a child for as long as she wants (I don’t mean this negatively, she regularly gets very tearful that she’s not a child anymore). She liked the sound of that option better. She just doesn’t want to have to think about finances at all.

But AIBU to take this much money from her? I don’t know the exact figures of what I’ll have lost until we get our first UC statements in a few days, but will probably be at least £150 per week. I know this a lot more than a lot of people take from adult children, which is why I feel bad, but then maybe they have a partner or are just financially in a better situation than I am. Realistically she’s going to be living at home for many more years to come.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:44

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 23:25

They are not disputing you have the conditions but PIP is not about the diagnosis, it is about how the illness affects you in relation to the PIP descriptors, so cooking a simple meal from scratch, washing, dressing, communication/ engaging with others etc and scoring enough points on these descriptors. and as mentioned on the previous post, to score points for any descriptor, you must be affected on the majority of days.

Spot on. I think this is where a lot of people get confused. No two people will be affected in the same way by a disability or health condition, so PIP doesn’t look at the disability itself, but the effect on daily life.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:40

MySugarBabyLove · 24/09/2023 17:24

I know people who have been awarded PIP with no assessment. Not many, but it does happen.

No it doesn’t. Just because the claimant isn’t seen in person or contacted by telephone doesn’t mean their claim isn’t assessed. It just means that the assessor had enough information to carry out the assessment based on the paperwork and medical evidence they provided and will possibly have been able to contact any health professionals involved with the claimants’ care to clarify as necessary. No-one is awarded PIP without an assessment. This can be in person, by phone, or paper based.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:33

Lastchancechica · 24/09/2023 17:21

^ here

This was low rate mobility on DLA. OPs dad is now on PIP and has obviously had a higher award as a result.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:27

honestyisnotthebestpolicy · 24/09/2023 17:17

@Rosscameasdoody

Not necessarily. If she gets higher rate mobility there are clearly severe problems getting around so if she doesn’t pass a test, she can nominate someone else as the driver to use the car for her benefit.

She isn't in need of being driven about. She has no job or place of study to go to.

It’s not just about that though. What about leisure activities, doctors/hospital appointments and day to day needs ?

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 23:25

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:19

Perhaps because some people working at DWP (or the outsourced DWP) are nasty pieces of work.

Perhaps because there's a bias towards physical disability?

Note it isn't disputing either mania or depression. I found the 'motivation' to work full time because I couldn't pay for anything otherwise.

They are not disputing you have the conditions but PIP is not about the diagnosis, it is about how the illness affects you in relation to the PIP descriptors, so cooking a simple meal from scratch, washing, dressing, communication/ engaging with others etc and scoring enough points on these descriptors. and as mentioned on the previous post, to score points for any descriptor, you must be affected on the majority of days.

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:19

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:11

It’s not about your ability to work though, it’s about motivation, which is different. Without knowing what was stated in your application it’s impossible to know for sure but the assessor clearly disagreed with your own assessment of your condition on multiple issues and didn’t consider the medical evidence supported what you were saying.

Perhaps because some people working at DWP (or the outsourced DWP) are nasty pieces of work.

Perhaps because there's a bias towards physical disability?

Note it isn't disputing either mania or depression. I found the 'motivation' to work full time because I couldn't pay for anything otherwise.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:18

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:08

I'm not wasting my time engaging further.

Lots of genuine disabled people score zero.

I wouldn’t disagree with hat at all and I definitely wouldn’t say you weren’t genuine - just that you didn’t make your case convincingly. PIP is a very difficult benefit to claim and those with mental health problems have a harder time than most. I would apply again but get some help from a benefit adviser when you fill in the application form because it can be tricky and as you’ve found to your cost, you’ll be scrutinised. CAB can point you in the right direction and l’d be happy to help you reapply - just PM me.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:11

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:05

On page one it says:

"Low mood and motivation would be consistent with seasonal affective disorder, depression and bipolar but you are motivated to work from home for 35 hours a week"

It’s not about your ability to work though, it’s about motivation, which is different. Without knowing what was stated in your application it’s impossible to know for sure but the assessor clearly disagreed with your own assessment of your condition on multiple issues and didn’t consider the medical evidence supported what you were saying.

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 23:10

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:08

I'm not wasting my time engaging further.

Lots of genuine disabled people score zero.

Yes unfortunately they do but I have seen some people go from zero points to an award after an MR or appeal so please don't give up hope.

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 23:08

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:05

On page one it says:

"Low mood and motivation would be consistent with seasonal affective disorder, depression and bipolar but you are motivated to work from home for 35 hours a week"

If you need extra support at work or your employers allow you to work at home because of your health then it may be beneficial if you are going to apply again to include something like an occupational health report. you may have already done this.

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:08

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:06

Absolutely not. Your claim was refused because what you reported in your application wasn’t consistent with the assessors’ findings, and there are multiple reasons for refusal, all fully explained. Nowhere can I see refusal on the grounds that you work.

I'm not wasting my time engaging further.

Lots of genuine disabled people score zero.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:06

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:56

Now you've read the wording on my actual letter, are you satisfied this is real?

Absolutely not. Your claim was refused because what you reported in your application wasn’t consistent with the assessors’ findings, and there are multiple reasons for refusal, all fully explained. Nowhere can I see refusal on the grounds that you work.

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:06

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:02

The reasons for refusing PIP are many and complex, and clearly dispute what you have reported in your application because they are not consistent with the findings of the assessment. Obviously there’s no way to know if this is accurate or not but it’s certainly not a refusal on grounds that you work, as you stated in your first post.

I guess all the psychiatrists and therapists I've seen over the years must be lying then.

I take it the cancer patient previously mentioned is also lying and having chemo to pass the time.

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 23:05

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:59

Sorry Cola - I can't see it mentioning work at all in the report - am i missing it somewhere?

On page one it says:

"Low mood and motivation would be consistent with seasonal affective disorder, depression and bipolar but you are motivated to work from home for 35 hours a week"

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 23:03

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:59

Sorry Cola - I can't see it mentioning work at all in the report - am i missing it somewhere?

Sorry just seen a brief mention on the first page but that is just one line of the report and one small part of the report. The main issue seems to be that they don't think you have difficulties on the majority of days ? To qualify for the points you need to meet the descriptors for more than 50% of the time.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 23:02

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:54

Page 2. Keep in mind this was during full lockdown so I wasn't seeing a CPN etc.

The reasons for refusing PIP are many and complex, and clearly dispute what you have reported in your application because they are not consistent with the findings of the assessment. Obviously there’s no way to know if this is accurate or not but it’s certainly not a refusal on grounds that you work, as you stated in your first post.

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:59

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:54

Page 2. Keep in mind this was during full lockdown so I wasn't seeing a CPN etc.

Sorry Cola - I can't see it mentioning work at all in the report - am i missing it somewhere?

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:56

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 21:51

Yep, so do millions of others - ‘because you work’ has never been a reason to refuse PIP. I think some people think we were all born yesterday !

Now you've read the wording on my actual letter, are you satisfied this is real?

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:55

Evidence of scoring zero points.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?
Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:54

Page 2. Keep in mind this was during full lockdown so I wasn't seeing a CPN etc.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?
Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 22:51

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:42

I would advise having rock solid medical evidence to support her next review.

The review form doesn’t ask for further medical evidence unless something has changed. So if things are essentially the same DWP will most likely leave the award unchanged. They may follow up by phone or check with the health professionals involved but I don’t understand why you think they would refuse a renewal of an award made on the basis of permanent disability.

Cola2023 · 24/09/2023 22:50

Right, so I've stopped work this evening to look for my old (depressing) PIP assessment. I applied on 1 December 2019 and was assessed in summer 2020 by phone. I submitted a lot of medical evidence.

I've removed my name since I haven't disclosed a disability at work, funnily enough. Being called a liar here is in really bad faith. You do disabled people a massive injustice by claiming the PIP process is great for all with a genuine disability:

Here is the first page.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?
Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:45

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 22:44

Thanks for the advice @Babyroobs. Don’t worry, we have plenty of evidence because funnily enough I’m not making any of this shit up and I speak to the doctors regularly about her.

That's great then.

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 22:44

Thanks for the advice @Babyroobs. Don’t worry, we have plenty of evidence because funnily enough I’m not making any of this shit up and I speak to the doctors regularly about her.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 22:42

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 22:39

@Meadowflower2023 and @Babyroobs, I take it you are both still implying that DD is not deserving of benefits? On what basis did you come to that conclusion? Bearing in mind you’ve never met her…

I would advise having rock solid medical evidence to support her next review.