Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?

494 replies

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 11:34

My DD is 19 and has a disability, she is not able to work and won’t be able to for the foreseeable. She receives PIP.

As she’s no longer in education, I was not entitled to claim benefits for her from the end of august this year. My tax credits went down quite considerably, and lost CB too, and all of my housing benefit. All together I am about £190 per week worse off. Which isn’t great as I am a single parent and also have a health condition (I receive low rate mobility PIP), and I had to give my job up in July as I couldn’t manage it anymore, so that’s another £1000ish per month down.

I am self employed and doing bits and pieces where I can, to give you an idea I’ve managed about 12 hours of work this month.

I did an online calculator in august and it looked like I would be better off on UC, and also needed to start a UC claim for DD, so I claimed for us both on the same day. We had an appointment at the jobcentre for DD’s claim a couple of weeks ago, and the advisor suggested that I become her appointee and I could have her UC paid into my account, if we felt DD didn’t have the capacity to manage it herself. I asked DD what she thought and she said she’d rather it was paid into my account. I am getting fit notes for both of us from the doctor and and hopefully we will both be entitled to the LCWRA elements.

The idea of being an adult and having to pay bills terrifies DD, mentally she is more like a 12 year old in a lot of ways. I have spoken to her about it and said the options are that either we work out exactly what her share of rent and bills etc would be and she just gives me the money for those, and she can arrange her own food shopping etc, and pay for herself if she wants to come on holidays etc. Or I keep the amount that I’ve lost in benefits for her, she can have whatever is leftover (which I think will still mean she’s better off than she is now with just her PIP). And then she can carry on essentially being a child for as long as she wants (I don’t mean this negatively, she regularly gets very tearful that she’s not a child anymore). She liked the sound of that option better. She just doesn’t want to have to think about finances at all.

But AIBU to take this much money from her? I don’t know the exact figures of what I’ll have lost until we get our first UC statements in a few days, but will probably be at least £150 per week. I know this a lot more than a lot of people take from adult children, which is why I feel bad, but then maybe they have a partner or are just financially in a better situation than I am. Realistically she’s going to be living at home for many more years to come.

OP posts:
OvertakenByLego · 26/09/2023 05:21

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 23:13

Oh please!! What are we talking max £8 for a pizza? Why dont you get off your high horse telling me what I do and do not know. I may not know the benefits system but you have zero and I mean fucking zero idea what I know about complex dietary needs and the additional costs generally relating to this especially with OP daughter's diagnosed health problems and then some. Downright rude!

No I won’t. It is clear from your post you know little if you think ‘seldom does it cost more’. If you don’t want people replying to you pointing that out don’t post nonsense on a forum.

Using your example of £8, that is £8 for one meal for one person. Which is clearly more expensive per person compared to other meals. If DD eats one a day (or something of a similar cost per day for dinner) that is £56 a week before you consider any other meal, snack or drink. Clearly that is significantly more expensive than most families would spend on one meal a day for one person. If you add in lunches, breakfasts, snacks and drinks it could easily be over £100 per week for 1 person.

MECFSSurvivor · 25/09/2023 23:36

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 23:29

I don't think people are ignorant of the fact she has CFS. It's an awful debilitating condition when it peaks of that I'm sure. I don't recall posts saying she hasn't got this condition or is just tired and doesn't need help financially because of it.

The OP asked WIBU to take recent lost amount from DD benefits (or something similar along those lines) I hold my hands up and say I was totally ignorant that this was allowed as it didn't seem fair... I just thought it did seem too much to use from DD benefits even after the explanations but apparently you can and it's not frowned upon at all so she can carry on with her proposed plan without worry.

Fair enough.

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 23:29

MECFSSurvivor · 25/09/2023 22:59

A lot of ignorance on this thread about CFS, I see.

chronically fatigued FFS! It's not tiredness. It's not normal fatigue. It's another way of saying M.E. It's a real disability and can affect your mobility.

I don't think people are ignorant of the fact she has CFS. It's an awful debilitating condition when it peaks of that I'm sure. I don't recall posts saying she hasn't got this condition or is just tired and doesn't need help financially because of it.

The OP asked WIBU to take recent lost amount from DD benefits (or something similar along those lines) I hold my hands up and say I was totally ignorant that this was allowed as it didn't seem fair... I just thought it did seem too much to use from DD benefits even after the explanations but apparently you can and it's not frowned upon at all so she can carry on with her proposed plan without worry.

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 23:13

OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 22:17

I do know about sensory dietary requirements to some degree and in my experience seldom does it cost more than an average meal, mostly very repetitive.

You clearly don’t! For some, their restricted diet costs significantly more. Pizzas come in a range of prices from cheap to expensive and you do not know where on that scale OP’s DD’s safe version lies. Nor what else is on her safe list.

Oh please!! What are we talking max £8 for a pizza? Why dont you get off your high horse telling me what I do and do not know. I may not know the benefits system but you have zero and I mean fucking zero idea what I know about complex dietary needs and the additional costs generally relating to this especially with OP daughter's diagnosed health problems and then some. Downright rude!

MECFSSurvivor · 25/09/2023 22:59

A lot of ignorance on this thread about CFS, I see.

chronically fatigued FFS! It's not tiredness. It's not normal fatigue. It's another way of saying M.E. It's a real disability and can affect your mobility.

BlueLines81 · 25/09/2023 22:43

@Meadowflower2023 I don’t believe at any point I said those activities took me a whole week? I also have another high needs child to look after and everything in my own life that needs to be done. I was giving examples of things I’ve done for DD over the last 7 days that most 19 year olds would be capable to doing for themselves, or wouldn’t need doing at all.

OP posts:
OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 22:17

I do know about sensory dietary requirements to some degree and in my experience seldom does it cost more than an average meal, mostly very repetitive.

You clearly don’t! For some, their restricted diet costs significantly more. Pizzas come in a range of prices from cheap to expensive and you do not know where on that scale OP’s DD’s safe version lies. Nor what else is on her safe list.

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 22:11

BlueLines81 · 25/09/2023 19:00

@Meadowflower2023 ok I’ll bite. So just taking the last week as an example (and this is just in relation to DD1, not my other child who has additional needs too and has taken up even more of my time over the last week).

  1. took DD to the jobcentre for her UC appointment, 17 miles away, as this is something she wouldn’t be able to manage alone. Had to pay for fuel and also pay for my neighbour to puppy-sit in order to be gone for a few hours.
  2. have been to the supermarket twice to do food shops, buying the specific things that DD likes to eat (which aren’t cheap) due to having a restricted diet because of sensory issues.
  3. organised a trip to a theme park for her birthday, which we couldn’t do in the summer holidays as she wouldn’t cope with the crowds. She still expects a ‘birthday party’ as I’ve discussed before she has no desire to be treated as an adult.
  4. ordered a repeat prescription and gone to collect it for her.
  5. been to post parcels for her twice.
  6. phoned to arrange her next appointment relating to her surgery.
  7. her pet cats - which she desperately wanted for a long time and have been massively beneficial for her, have cost me £60 in monthly pet food subscription, £85 in flea treatment and £40 in pest control because of the rat they bought in but decided not to kill, in the last week.
  8. £70 on a driving lesson and £20 to take her car to get it cleaned before her driving lesson.

That’s on top of having to do everything around the house single handedly, and do as much work as I had the energy for. So not all of those things cost money, but many of them are things you wouldn’t have to do for an average 19 year old.

I've read your list a few times and struggled to see how it could have taken a whole week to complete if I'm honest. Very standard but then if you're unwell yourself I can understand it may take longer to do a few errands.

100% knew this reply would follow after my last post, so predictable and really not worth the bite.

She was eating pizza yesterday, they hardly cost the earth. You also mention food deliveries in previous posts. Maybe this could/should save you time. You contradict yourself in so many posts. I do know about sensory dietary requirements to some degree and in my experience seldom does it cost more than an average meal, mostly very repetitive.

You know you really shouldn't ask for peoples opinions if you're not prepared to listen to the odd person disagreeing with you.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 21:11

Cola2023 · 25/09/2023 19:37

Benefits advisor at the job centre or CAB etc?

Worked in benefits for several years then went into welfare rights. Medically retired and since then have done what I can voluntarily with the organisation specific to my disability, including being on their advisory committee during consultations in preparation for the introduction of PIP in 2013 and helping out with PIP applications/appeals on behalf of members.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 20:58

CHRIS003 · 25/09/2023 20:08

You say that you have applied for UC due to your own situation. Down £1000
On reduced working hours
I may be wrong but I don't think the amount you wil get withl uc will cover all these extras
You will get a set amount for being a single mum with 1 child and 1 adult who is dependant - you may get an amount for housing costs if you need it ( rent ).
You will get a set amount and deductions will taken off for any thing that you earn- savings etc
Both of you will get your pip payments as extra.
If you claim carers allowance it is does mean you get extra each week but it is deducted from uc and you can't earn more than £100 a week ( approx)
You can have £6000 in savings that isn't included
You should get a reasonable amount
But please be prepared that the point of uc is cover the basics
Utilities- food shop etc.
It will not cover lots of trips petrol costs etc , pets , special dietary needs.
Trips out etc.
I assume from this level of expenditure that you had a really well paid job?
Or credit cards or may be lots of savings.
Unfortunately universal credit is only designed to cover the essentials .

If the OP claims carers allowance it will be deducted from UC but she will get the carers element of UC added on. She would be allowed £136 in weekly earnings before CA eligibility is affected. It should be noted that claiming CA gives better NI contributions than on UC so important not to render herself ineligible. Also important to note that if she is a carer there will be no compulsion to work.

CHRIS003 · 25/09/2023 20:08

You say that you have applied for UC due to your own situation. Down £1000
On reduced working hours
I may be wrong but I don't think the amount you wil get withl uc will cover all these extras
You will get a set amount for being a single mum with 1 child and 1 adult who is dependant - you may get an amount for housing costs if you need it ( rent ).
You will get a set amount and deductions will taken off for any thing that you earn- savings etc
Both of you will get your pip payments as extra.
If you claim carers allowance it is does mean you get extra each week but it is deducted from uc and you can't earn more than £100 a week ( approx)
You can have £6000 in savings that isn't included
You should get a reasonable amount
But please be prepared that the point of uc is cover the basics
Utilities- food shop etc.
It will not cover lots of trips petrol costs etc , pets , special dietary needs.
Trips out etc.
I assume from this level of expenditure that you had a really well paid job?
Or credit cards or may be lots of savings.
Unfortunately universal credit is only designed to cover the essentials .

OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 19:39

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 19:14

Yes, if they’re also an appointee that makes a difference, but there’s so much misuse of motability vehicles that trackers are the norm, as is the requirement for the car to remain overnight at the claimants’ address. In my capacity as benefits adviser I’ve come across motability cars being used as private hire taxis by nominated drivers and worse - and it’s always the claimant that pays the price.

I agree, some are misused. I just wanted to point out sometimes it is agreed the car can be kept at an address of a driver that doesn’t live with the disabled person.

Slaterz · 25/09/2023 19:38

You can get prescriptions delivered from the chemist - that would be at least one less thing you'd have to worry about. I get mine delivered all the time. (I know I said I was leaving, but I hope you find this comment helpful)

If they're her pet cats then surely her money should be paying for them, not yours?

Also I'm nearly sure you can buy postage online and get the items collected by the postman, which again would be one less thing for you to do.

Cola2023 · 25/09/2023 19:37

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 19:14

Yes, if they’re also an appointee that makes a difference, but there’s so much misuse of motability vehicles that trackers are the norm, as is the requirement for the car to remain overnight at the claimants’ address. In my capacity as benefits adviser I’ve come across motability cars being used as private hire taxis by nominated drivers and worse - and it’s always the claimant that pays the price.

Benefits advisor at the job centre or CAB etc?

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 19:28

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 16:30

@Rosscameasdoody

I do hear what you’re saying and it’s probably blindingly obvious, I have zero clue on how benefits work. Following on from your comment… I haven’t read from OP in any of her near 60 posts about additional care costs that you mention (cue this information appearing shortly no doubt) They can’t be that much due to the fact the DD is able to drive a car alone (if she passes in November), passed a theory test first time and can go into town with friends occasionally, however, if she had said ‘I work full time, DD can’t help with housework, I have to pay for a cleaner, someone to come and look after DD, bathe her, take her into town’ etc, then yes, I agree I wouldn’t have thought twice about the ‘But AIBU to take this much money from her? I don’t know the exact figures of what I’ll have lost until we get our first UC statements in a few days, but will probably be at least £150 per week. I know this a lot more than a lot of people take from adult children, which is why I feel bad, but then maybe they have a partner or are just financially in a better situation than I am’ comment, but I haven’t. That would make a lot more sense as to the question of AIBU surely rather than the OP’s first statement?

Im not disputing that DD is reliant financially on OP, surely that’s the case for a fairly high percentage of 19 year olds with or without ASD and so on. I’ve no figures to go on but would imagine a lot of 19 years olds still live at home and to some degree are the opposite to OP and are financially reliant on the parent. It seems the other way around in this situation and somehow doesn’t sit right with me…but then I’m not the one giving out the money or checking it’s appropriately spent so who am I to argue? I assume that it’s all based on trust as no delegated persons accounts are ever audited?

OP asks AIBU for taking this much from her? My answer would remain a firm yes. Sorry OP! I do wish you all the best in recovering and with the business venture for you both when you’re ready for it though!

The OP’s DD qualifies for the higher rates of PIP, which is paid in respect of additional costs of living with a disability - these costs are not necessarily limited to extra care costs but the cost attached to every day life with a severe disability, which is considerable You are misunderstanding what PIP is based on and given the limited facility here to explain, I can only suggest you visit me of the many disability websites which explain in detail the extra cost involved and how PIP is designed to help. And the fact that other people of the same age as OP’s dd are financially dependant is irrelevant - this is a specific requirement of the use of a motability vehicle, so not applicable in any other circumstance.

Rosscameasdoody · 25/09/2023 19:14

OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 16:02

and the car must be returned to the claimants address at the end of each day.

@Rosscameasdoody Not always. Sometimes it is agreed that the car can remain overnight at the driver’s address, especially where, as in the OP’s case, they are appointee.

Yes, if they’re also an appointee that makes a difference, but there’s so much misuse of motability vehicles that trackers are the norm, as is the requirement for the car to remain overnight at the claimants’ address. In my capacity as benefits adviser I’ve come across motability cars being used as private hire taxis by nominated drivers and worse - and it’s always the claimant that pays the price.

BlueLines81 · 25/09/2023 19:00

@Meadowflower2023 ok I’ll bite. So just taking the last week as an example (and this is just in relation to DD1, not my other child who has additional needs too and has taken up even more of my time over the last week).

  1. took DD to the jobcentre for her UC appointment, 17 miles away, as this is something she wouldn’t be able to manage alone. Had to pay for fuel and also pay for my neighbour to puppy-sit in order to be gone for a few hours.
  2. have been to the supermarket twice to do food shops, buying the specific things that DD likes to eat (which aren’t cheap) due to having a restricted diet because of sensory issues.
  3. organised a trip to a theme park for her birthday, which we couldn’t do in the summer holidays as she wouldn’t cope with the crowds. She still expects a ‘birthday party’ as I’ve discussed before she has no desire to be treated as an adult.
  4. ordered a repeat prescription and gone to collect it for her.
  5. been to post parcels for her twice.
  6. phoned to arrange her next appointment relating to her surgery.
  7. her pet cats - which she desperately wanted for a long time and have been massively beneficial for her, have cost me £60 in monthly pet food subscription, £85 in flea treatment and £40 in pest control because of the rat they bought in but decided not to kill, in the last week.
  8. £70 on a driving lesson and £20 to take her car to get it cleaned before her driving lesson.

That’s on top of having to do everything around the house single handedly, and do as much work as I had the energy for. So not all of those things cost money, but many of them are things you wouldn’t have to do for an average 19 year old.

OP posts:
BlueBlubbaWhale · 25/09/2023 18:40

She's asleep 18 per day apparently. Given what the op's posts state she is actually able to do, I'm not sure what other than the standard parental roles the DD requires in the 6 hours awake. Isn't it the norm to run about after your kids, cook, heat the home for them etc?

Not after 18 no. Many young people are working or at university and looking after themselves to a large extent.

OvertakenByLego · 25/09/2023 18:26

You are being ignorant. The fact you can’t see OP’s DD needs support in excess of a typical young adult OP’s needs shows a lack of understanding. For a start, OP’s DD wouldn’t have an EHCP if there weren’t additional needs. It isn’t for you to decide OP’s DD could manage her claims herself. The DWP have appointed OP as appointee therefore they believe her to be unable to manage her own claims.

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 18:19

@BlueBlubbaWhale

She's asleep 18 per day apparently. Given what the op's posts state she is actually able to do, I'm not sure what other than the standard parental roles the DD requires in the 6 hours awake. Isn't it the norm to run about after your kids, cook, heat the home for them etc?
The OP did a training course earlier in the year for a promotion which she did get, so I'm not sure that part of your comment applies here though I'm sure it does generally.

I'm not that ignorant that I haven't read the OP's posts, from them I have gained what I feel is the satisfactory decision that she could, with a bit of gentle help, manage her own funds. I'm not here to bash anyone for getting benefits as I've said previously. I honestly can't fathom why my opinion isn't met with some understanding with the AIBU request. I seem to be constantly told of the generalised way things work with benefit claimants. Not all carers do the same as not all disabilities need the same care - obviously!

Again... it just seems strange to me as I am working to the OPs posts and shan't be backed into a corner and made to think that the way she plans to distribute DD's benefits is right.

I'll leave you to it now, obviously shouldn't have read this thread. It would appear that if you disagree and think OP is being unreasonable, you're wrong!

BlueBlubbaWhale · 25/09/2023 17:36

@Meadowflower2023 often the only reason there are no additional care costs is because a parent is providing it all. But doing so their earning potential is then limited. This actually saves the taxpayer billions each year. If every carer outsourced the care of their child/parent/partner so they could work, Social Care would be in an even worse state than it already is as they would have to fund it. But they don't fund it and no one gives a shit about the carers even having basic respite most of the time let alone being enabled to study or work (as they should be).

Also pip isn't necessarily to cover care costs. This should really be done by social services. Pip is for the additional expenses being disabled brings, needing extra heating to stay warm, needing specific items/food due to sensory needs, needing taxis if public transport is inaccessible, a cleaner, aids and equipment that won't be funded by any other services but are needed, clubs and hobbies if these are difficult to access and extra support is needed or it helps the person access the community etc

benoticanarsed · 25/09/2023 17:18

@OvertakenByLego Yes I got a out £28 a week

Cowlover89 · 25/09/2023 16:55

Yanbu

Meadowflower2023 · 25/09/2023 16:30

@Rosscameasdoody

I do hear what you’re saying and it’s probably blindingly obvious, I have zero clue on how benefits work. Following on from your comment… I haven’t read from OP in any of her near 60 posts about additional care costs that you mention (cue this information appearing shortly no doubt) They can’t be that much due to the fact the DD is able to drive a car alone (if she passes in November), passed a theory test first time and can go into town with friends occasionally, however, if she had said ‘I work full time, DD can’t help with housework, I have to pay for a cleaner, someone to come and look after DD, bathe her, take her into town’ etc, then yes, I agree I wouldn’t have thought twice about the ‘But AIBU to take this much money from her? I don’t know the exact figures of what I’ll have lost until we get our first UC statements in a few days, but will probably be at least £150 per week. I know this a lot more than a lot of people take from adult children, which is why I feel bad, but then maybe they have a partner or are just financially in a better situation than I am’ comment, but I haven’t. That would make a lot more sense as to the question of AIBU surely rather than the OP’s first statement?

Im not disputing that DD is reliant financially on OP, surely that’s the case for a fairly high percentage of 19 year olds with or without ASD and so on. I’ve no figures to go on but would imagine a lot of 19 years olds still live at home and to some degree are the opposite to OP and are financially reliant on the parent. It seems the other way around in this situation and somehow doesn’t sit right with me…but then I’m not the one giving out the money or checking it’s appropriately spent so who am I to argue? I assume that it’s all based on trust as no delegated persons accounts are ever audited?

OP asks AIBU for taking this much from her? My answer would remain a firm yes. Sorry OP! I do wish you all the best in recovering and with the business venture for you both when you’re ready for it though!

BlueBlubbaWhale · 25/09/2023 16:15

The mobility component of pip is weird. There are two sections “moving around “ making and planning a journey”. If you get the right amount of points on the moving around part you are entitled to a blue badge. My son gets 0 points on “moving around” but 12 points on “making and planning a journey” so he’s entitled to enhanced rate of PIP for mobility but not a blue badge. He does have one but we had to jump through hoops.

It's really weird that isn't it, we had the same, have to say our local council issued one with no question though.