Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to take this much from DD’s benefits?

494 replies

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 11:34

My DD is 19 and has a disability, she is not able to work and won’t be able to for the foreseeable. She receives PIP.

As she’s no longer in education, I was not entitled to claim benefits for her from the end of august this year. My tax credits went down quite considerably, and lost CB too, and all of my housing benefit. All together I am about £190 per week worse off. Which isn’t great as I am a single parent and also have a health condition (I receive low rate mobility PIP), and I had to give my job up in July as I couldn’t manage it anymore, so that’s another £1000ish per month down.

I am self employed and doing bits and pieces where I can, to give you an idea I’ve managed about 12 hours of work this month.

I did an online calculator in august and it looked like I would be better off on UC, and also needed to start a UC claim for DD, so I claimed for us both on the same day. We had an appointment at the jobcentre for DD’s claim a couple of weeks ago, and the advisor suggested that I become her appointee and I could have her UC paid into my account, if we felt DD didn’t have the capacity to manage it herself. I asked DD what she thought and she said she’d rather it was paid into my account. I am getting fit notes for both of us from the doctor and and hopefully we will both be entitled to the LCWRA elements.

The idea of being an adult and having to pay bills terrifies DD, mentally she is more like a 12 year old in a lot of ways. I have spoken to her about it and said the options are that either we work out exactly what her share of rent and bills etc would be and she just gives me the money for those, and she can arrange her own food shopping etc, and pay for herself if she wants to come on holidays etc. Or I keep the amount that I’ve lost in benefits for her, she can have whatever is leftover (which I think will still mean she’s better off than she is now with just her PIP). And then she can carry on essentially being a child for as long as she wants (I don’t mean this negatively, she regularly gets very tearful that she’s not a child anymore). She liked the sound of that option better. She just doesn’t want to have to think about finances at all.

But AIBU to take this much money from her? I don’t know the exact figures of what I’ll have lost until we get our first UC statements in a few days, but will probably be at least £150 per week. I know this a lot more than a lot of people take from adult children, which is why I feel bad, but then maybe they have a partner or are just financially in a better situation than I am. Realistically she’s going to be living at home for many more years to come.

OP posts:
BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 17:29

There was no assessment for her PIP no, but I did have a raft of medical evidence including her EHCP, so they obviously felt able to make a decision with the evidence they had.

OP posts:
Trez1510 · 24/09/2023 17:29

gamerchick · 24/09/2023 17:24

That's what I thought. Thankyou. So how is there a mobility car if daughter gets low rate mobility?

Is there a different scheme I don't know about?

As an aside, my teenager moved from DLA to PIP this year and didn't get a phone or face to face assessment.

Thank you. I thought I'd misunderstood about the mobility car/free driving lessons etc. I was bending my mind to work out how that be achieved on low rate mobility.

Hopefully OP will be able to clarify and assist others who also have low rate mobility to be able to secure a motability vehicle?

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:28

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 17:12

The whole assessment needs an overall. It really does as this thread shows.

I don’t think anyone would disagree but it’s unlikely to happen, and if it does it won’t be to the advantage of the claimant. PIP was never designed to provide adequate support - it replaced DLA for working age people and was designed to save money. The eligibility criteria screens out high levels of impairment by over simplifying disability and reducing it to a point scoring system. You only have to look at the cooking assessment to realise that - how can it realistically assess someone’s ability to safely and adequately cook a meal when it assumes they have everything they need already in front of them and doesn’t include bending, lifting or moving around the kitchen ? And that’s only the tip of the iceberg !!

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 17:27

@MySugarBabyLove of course I don’t WANT her to fail, I’d love if she could pass and have that independence, it’s just turned out to be unlikely to happen from what I’ve seen of her driving. But you never know, maybe she will. She doesn’t have many places to go at the moment no, but hopefully that will change as she gets older and driving is a useful life skill to have. I’ve already said it many times on this thread, but I am always encouraging her independence. She is currently cooking some food for herself (ok it’s a pizza), yesterday she went into the city with her friend. They missed their train because her timekeeping is hopeless, and she phoned me from the station to ask if I could drive her into the city as the next train wasn’t for hours. I said no, but I did drive them to another station half an hour away where they could get on a train on a different line. So I’m all up for encouraging independence, but I do have to be there to pick her up (literally) if things don’t go to plan.

OP posts:
catskittens · 24/09/2023 17:25

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:15

They don’t award PIP without an assessment. During the pandemic PIP assessments were done by phone appointments with assessors and from information on the paperwork. DWP also contacted health care professionals involved with claimants a lot more, to double check information.

i have had 2 paper decisions and one telephone accessment in 12yrs for pip so some will go straight to paper decision

i have no idea what the % paper decisions are but they do happen i have just had my second

Lastchancechica · 24/09/2023 17:24

And ops dd was one of them too.

gamerchick · 24/09/2023 17:24

TigerRag · 24/09/2023 17:14

No you have to be on enhanced / higher mobility

That's what I thought. Thankyou. So how is there a mobility car if daughter gets low rate mobility?

Is there a different scheme I don't know about?

As an aside, my teenager moved from DLA to PIP this year and didn't get a phone or face to face assessment.

MySugarBabyLove · 24/09/2023 17:24

I know people who have been awarded PIP with no assessment. Not many, but it does happen.

Lastchancechica · 24/09/2023 17:21

BlueLines81 · 24/09/2023 15:57

@CHRIS003 she would struggle to walk that far without having rests along the way. She was awarded PIP in covid times when they weren’t doing face to face assessments, we didn’t even have a phone assessment. I filled in the form honestly and supplied the medical evidence and that’s what they awarded her 🤷‍♀️. She only got low rate mobility on DLA.

^ here

MySugarBabyLove · 24/09/2023 17:18

She isn't going to pass her test if she doesn't understand roundabouts. Panic over! she only needs to get it on the day she takes her test, and then she will have a licence.

The issue here is the fact that the OP is essentially indulging her by letting her have a go at driving in the hope that she will fail.

So why is the OP not letting her have a go at managing her money? Something which she can succeed at.

I do wonder if the OP is in fact afraid that her DD is capable of being more independent than the OP thinks she is.

I see it on the VI groups on FB all the time. Adults posting that they’d love to learn to cook but their parents won’t let them, that their parents are away for the weekend and they don’t know how they will survive. And they’ve grown up being led to believe that they can’t do certain things, when they absolutely can if they’re just given the skills to try.

honestyisnotthebestpolicy · 24/09/2023 17:17

@Rosscameasdoody

Not necessarily. If she gets higher rate mobility there are clearly severe problems getting around so if she doesn’t pass a test, she can nominate someone else as the driver to use the car for her benefit.

She isn't in need of being driven about. She has no job or place of study to go to.

nochangeever · 24/09/2023 17:17

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:15

They don’t award PIP without an assessment. During the pandemic PIP assessments were done by phone appointments with assessors and from information on the paperwork. DWP also contacted health care professionals involved with claimants a lot more, to double check information.

My mum’s PIP was extended to 2027 during covid, with no phone interview at all. I know you said awarded though.

Lastchancechica · 24/09/2023 17:16

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:15

They don’t award PIP without an assessment. During the pandemic PIP assessments were done by phone appointments with assessors and from information on the paperwork. DWP also contacted health care professionals involved with claimants a lot more, to double check information.

You can read it yourself - the post about it further up.

nochangeever · 24/09/2023 17:16

Slightly off topic, but are you sure her driving instructor is any good, OP?

I had a terrible driving instructor the first time but a brilliant one the second time. I also had some friends/relatives whose driving instructors were purposely protracting the learning process, taking them on TWO hour long drives AWAY from the preferred test centre, just so they could keep pocketing the money endlessly.

My driving instructor had me so familiar with the routes my local test centre usually took, which I found was a great and simple strategy.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:15

Lastchancechica · 24/09/2023 17:02

I think op said she skipped the interview and assessment as it was during the pandemic.

They don’t award PIP without an assessment. During the pandemic PIP assessments were done by phone appointments with assessors and from information on the paperwork. DWP also contacted health care professionals involved with claimants a lot more, to double check information.

catskittens · 24/09/2023 17:15

Soontobe60 · 24/09/2023 17:02

I have to say, if shes competent enough to drive, she should have her own money. She clearly has capacity. You controlling it for her is infantilising.

What would be better would be for you to ensure she gets the right sort of bank account set up, set up DDs or standing orders and support her to manage her money herself. Of course some of her income should be used to pay for her living costs wherever she is living. Is it just the 2 of you living at home and do you rent? If so, then the joint living costs should be split 50/50.

agree with this
she should have her own money and if i remember right there is a younger child so she should pay approx 1/3

there was another thread yesterday with a similar theme about losing benefit when the son reached 18yrs ir seems like this and the other thread boil down to the op's losing money once the child reaches being an adult, and the benefits change and then the posters panic seems like the they get to used to the benefits children bring in im afraid

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 17:14

gamerchick · 24/09/2023 17:11

Can you get a mobility car when only awarded low rate mobility? I didn't know that. That would be useful.

No you can't ! Enhanced mobility only.

TigerRag · 24/09/2023 17:14

gamerchick · 24/09/2023 17:11

Can you get a mobility car when only awarded low rate mobility? I didn't know that. That would be useful.

No you have to be on enhanced / higher mobility

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 17:12

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:10

The problem is that PIP doesn’t look at the disability itself, but at how it affects the daily life of the claimant. It’s a very harsh assessment for all people with disabilities - hidden or otherwise.

The whole assessment needs an overall. It really does as this thread shows.

gamerchick · 24/09/2023 17:11

Can you get a mobility car when only awarded low rate mobility? I didn't know that. That would be useful.

Darkmode2 · 24/09/2023 17:11

HeffyAgain · 24/09/2023 16:58

I stand by what I said, I don't want my loved ones dying because someone who has been learning to drive for two years cannot understand how a roundabout works or could potentially fall asleep at the wheel. OP says she is sleeping for 18 hours a day.....what If she gets stuck in traffic? Could she safely drive herself home hours after she intended to be there?
Driving takes intense concentration and quick reflexes. Not something people with chronic fatigue tend to possess.

She isn't going to pass her test if she doesn't understand roundabouts. Panic over!

MySugarBabyLove · 24/09/2023 17:11

OP, you say that driving isn’t going to be an issue because she’s not going to pass. But what if she does? What then?

This isn’t about taking someone down to the local field and letting them drive a car around it to let them have a feel of how it is (been there, done that,) it’s about giving someone who you say has the mental capacity of a twelve year old the potential of having a car, being out on the roads, and tbh if the DVLA are permitting people with such difficulties permission to learn to drive that needs to be looked into. Not because disabled people shouldn’t have permission to drive where possible, but because once you set out on the road in a car, what you want becomes secondary to what is safe for the people around you.

Right now she’s driving in a car with an instructor so it’s all controlled. But if she does pass her test, (and you only have to look at some of the drivers on the roads to know that it is possible,) then she will be out in a car, alone, with the potential to become exhausted in the middle of the motorway.

If the DVLA aren’t going to look at this responsibly, then you really should be.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:10

Booksandwine80 · 24/09/2023 17:06

It is just sick that a hidden/hard to prove disability can get benefits yet someone with radiotherapy burns, mobility issues and chronic fatigue is just told “oh well, that’s just how it is”

The problem is that PIP doesn’t look at the disability itself, but at how it affects the daily life of the claimant. It’s a very harsh assessment for all people with disabilities - hidden or otherwise.

Babyroobs · 24/09/2023 17:08

Booksandwine80 · 24/09/2023 17:06

It is just sick that a hidden/hard to prove disability can get benefits yet someone with radiotherapy burns, mobility issues and chronic fatigue is just told “oh well, that’s just how it is”

Agreed. the long term side effects of cancer treatment can be horrendous and debilitating.

Rosscameasdoody · 24/09/2023 17:07

honestyisnotthebestpolicy · 24/09/2023 16:33

It's a hell of a waste of money, is all it is. £284 a month for a car that she can't even drive and is unlikely going to be able to drive. I'm sorry OP but this has been a poor decision on your part as her appointee.

Not necessarily. If she gets higher rate mobility there are clearly severe problems getting around so if she doesn’t pass a test, she can nominate someone else as the driver to use the car for her benefit. Lots of motability clients don’t drive themselves but still benefit from the provision of a car.