Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Risk your life, live with taking a life but we will charge you with murder

135 replies

sleepyscientist · 24/09/2023 09:43

Anyone else things police officers should have indemnity from prosecution whilst on duty. This poor officer followed a suspect that was believed to be armed, stepped out of his vehicle and into the line of fire to protect us.

Now because it turns out he was unarmed he's not only up on a disciplinary but facing a murder charge. Rightly other officers are stepping back so now our armed capacity is falling......terror attack risk right there! Hopefully any jury finds him not guilty!

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12552965/Met-police-protest-Chris-Kaba-murder-charge.html

OP posts:
user1846385927482658 · 24/09/2023 12:58

I have nothing to hide and have no issue being stopped by police anyone who refuses to stop must have something to hide.

Were you living under a rock when Sarah Everard was murdered by a serving Met police officer who used his warrant card to stop her, kidnap, rape and murder her?

Were you still under your rock when women were told by the police to flag down buses or call 999 if the police tried to stop them?

WeWereInParis · 24/09/2023 12:47

Not only was he unarmed but the police were in an unmarked car which had no sirens or lights, would I stop for a random car chasing me and trying to force me off the road - no, would I try to get away if cornered in these circumstances - yes.

I completely disagree with the OP, but this isn't entirely accurate.

He was followed by an unmarked police car, and was then blocked by a marked police car (this is where the armed officers where). Not that that justifies shooting him.

off · 24/09/2023 12:41

Surely, regardless of what you have or haven’t done, if someone is yelling at you to get on the floor or I shoot and is pointing a gun at you, you get on the floor?!

I have absolutely no idea what I'd do in that situation. I've never had a gun pointed at me. Maybe I'd comply, or maybe the mortal terror would completely override the rational parts of my brain.

Ever watched one of those TV dramas where someone's told they're terminally ill and they suddenly stop hearing a word the doctor's saying? Sometimes it actually happens in the real world, that intense emotions like fear stop you taking anything in or processing any information.

How about fight, flight or freeze? We evolved around deadly threats that resulted in emergency responses we can't easily control without training, and none of these automatic responses are "immediately and calmly comply with the barely comprehensible screamed instructions coming from the deadly threat".

I'd be surprised if an ex-member of the Armed Forces didn't have an understanding of the wide range of human responses to fear and crisis, and the amount of training it takes to reliably override them. You might be able to think straight with a gun pointed at you, but I'm a random member of the public, and am not trained in assessing threats, remaining calm in life-threatening situations, or de-escalation (all the things that I'd hope a police firearms officer would be trained in).

When it comes to this kind of yelling and gun-pointing thing, I've seen occasional footage from the UK, but the US produces seemingly endless clips of aggressive police yelling incomprehensible, incoherent, sometimes contradictory commands while pointing guns at terrified members of the public, who end up dead.

There are a lot of factors contributing to this, but I think part of it is the result of a kind of weird, topsy-turvy allocation of responsibility.

Some US police are apparently conditioned by paranoid training programmes to overestimate threat, seem to be prone to volatility in a crisis, and have all kinds of allowances made for deadly violence if they just claim they felt threatened. They're held to a lower standard when on duty than the general public — they're almost never criminally prosecuted for their actions, for various reasons, and "qualified immunity" means it's virtually impossible to pursue civil action.

Random untrained members of the public, meanwhile, are expected to remain calm and rational when in fear for their lives, being threatened by armed officers who would likely face few repercussions for killing them. They're made responsible for de-escalating incredibly tense, deadly situations they've had no training in. And while police go about knowing that anything they do to a member of the public will be treated more leniently than usual, members of the public know anything they do to a police officer is categorised as a far more serious offence than the same action against an ordinary person.

Although there are more problems with US policing than the apparent assumption that it's okay to kill someone if they don't react quite right when you point a gun at them and scream, I don't think it really helps.

Also, what if the person's deaf, or autistic, or has dementia, or doesn't speak the language?

Blanketpolicy · 24/09/2023 11:59

Armed police officers are highly trained to risk assess in stressful situations before using deadly force and in the UK deadly force should be the last resort when it is clear lives are at risk. Even if Mr Kaba was guilty of other crimes, even if he was trying to evade capture the evidence must show he was not an immediate threat that required him to shot in the head.

Armed police officers absolutely should not have impunity from prosecution if they murder just because they are wearing a uniform. It wasn't a a slip up, it wasn't an accident, there is enough evidence for the police officer to be charged with murder.

The alternative is we end up with trigger happy cops like they have in the US.

Missingmyusername · 24/09/2023 11:42

@Iwasafool oh I see- thanks.
What on earth was the lad doing?!

tokennamechange · 24/09/2023 11:40

Missingmyusername · 24/09/2023 09:56

I know what you mean OP, I can understand why the officers are walking away in droves! No doubt that’ll have repercussions.

He didn’t stand in the line of fire though- the victim/suspect was not armed. I don’t think he should be charged with murder from the outset, there should be an investigation and then possibly a murder charge or disciplinary. What happens in the U.S?

I don’t know how many officers carry guns, what training they have, how often they deploy etc The policeman /story sounds like he was possibly scared? Shot without thinking? I don’t think we know what the operation was, what the intel was… but it does appear he made his own decision to discharge a fire arm without assessing any risk or threat whatsoever, at least that’s how I’ve read it. You can’t have nervous officers waving weapons about, firing at will.

armed police are a specialised unit with very intense training that you have to specifically apply for (and is usually very competitive, so I'm not convinced that this case will result in a reduction of people willing to be firearms officers). A lot of firearms officers are ex-armed forces. It's not as if he was a random officer who usually investigated low level theft, and had only been given a gun that morning, once you're accepted onto firearms and completed your training, that's your unit, every single shift you are deployed with a gun to the most serious incidents.

It's very unlikely he would have panicked or shot without thinking because that sort of scenario is exactly what all their training is based around. Of course he could still have been scared because you can't train human emotion out of people, but they are specifically trained to assess emotive and volatile situations and are trained in levels of escalation, how to justify decisions etc.

The reason why our death after police contact is so tiny (and despite the headlines it is compared to most countries) is because of policing by consent. Get rid of that and give them legal impunity and we'd end up worse than the US.
Believe me, they already get away with way more than the average person would.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/09/2023 11:23

bevelino · Today 10:11

The unarmed victim was shot in the head and that is completely unacceptable.”

This. A trained marksman is perfectly able to shoot out tyres.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 24/09/2023 11:20

sleepyscientist · 24/09/2023 10:18

The "victim" was driving a car linked to gun crime at police, he wasn't driving down the street like a normal person. He had authority to arm as the police believed the car was a threat to the public and them. Just because he wasn't armed this time doesn't mean the car wasn't known for carrying weapons.

He could have stopped when the marked car pulled in front of him, got out and dealt with the issue of the car like a normal person being stopped by police. Instead he drove at them in a high risk car and the police officer involved felt threatened enough he made a split second decision to end the situation to protect himself and other including the public.

I have nothing to hide and have no issue being stopped by police anyone who refuses to stop must have something to hide.

Premeditated rape and murder is completely different to making a decision to continue a car chase, discharge a taser or indeed discharge a fire arm.

Firstly, Chris Kaba is not a ‘victim’, he is a victim. He was murdered by armed police. Non-armed police regularly deal with car chases every day and use a number of strategies to deal with this, none of which involve shooting an unarmed man in the head.

Police should be held to higher standards. They are supposed to be highly trained professionals and should be treated as such. If they can’t accept that then they shouldn’t be in the job.

They have needlessly taken the life of an unarmed man. Rather than apologise or take some level of responsibility they are complaining that they should be immune from prosecution and refusing to work in their highly trained role because one of them is being held accountable. This tells me everything I need to know about these nasty bullying specimens trying to hold us to ransom.

Yes we need armed police but there is no room for this type of person in our police forces. We need to root out those who think they are above the law as a matter of priority.

Againstmachine · 24/09/2023 11:17

Nope there is currently massive corruption in the MET and you want to give them a free pass.

You only have to look at arrests at the coronation to see what happens when you give them a free pass on grounds of safety.

off · 24/09/2023 11:04

You can't just assume that on-duty police officer = automatically not at fault and shouldn't be charged, the same way you can't just assume that loving father or husband of victim/apparently obvious self-defence/on-duty doctor or nurse/diagnosed serious mental illness/respected religious leader = automatically not at fault, shouldn't be charged.

If somebody kills someone else, and the CPS thinks a prosecution can be justified, then things like the suspect's personal relationship to the victim, the circumstances in which they took their actions (like self-defence), their mental state and any psychiatric problems, and, yes, whether their actions were carried out in the course of their work and how somebody in that role would be expected to behave in those circumstances, are things which will undoubtedly come up in court and be taken into account.

But the idea of granting police officers total impunity — even just the idea that a single supposedly ordinary member of the public might think that that's a good idea — is chilling. I really hope you're just a troll, because if ordinary people out there are really willing to roll over like this and say "yes, yes, oh god yes, mister burgeoning totalitarian state, please screw me harder! harder!" then things aren't looking good.

Arightoldcarryabag · 24/09/2023 10:59

Lots of boot lickers in this thread.
Murder is murder, Police should have the highest standards of anyone in the land.

Jellycatspyjamas · 24/09/2023 10:58

I have nothing to hide and have no issue being stopped by police anyone who refuses to stop must have something to hide.

That’s a pretty naive take on things given what we know about institutional racism and the level of criminality perpetrated by serving officers in the police.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 24/09/2023 10:49

Police officers are civilians in uniform (much as some of them may hate to admit it). If the armed forces, whose job is to kill, are not indemnified against charges of murder why should the police be? You need to think this through a bit further OP.

OrangeSlices998 · 24/09/2023 10:46

That he was unarmed and the car was unmarked? No thats been reported on in the press.

Soubriquet · 24/09/2023 10:46

He shot an unarmed man in the head. He should absolutely be charged

NalafromtheLionKing · 24/09/2023 10:45

sleepyscientist · 24/09/2023 10:18

The "victim" was driving a car linked to gun crime at police, he wasn't driving down the street like a normal person. He had authority to arm as the police believed the car was a threat to the public and them. Just because he wasn't armed this time doesn't mean the car wasn't known for carrying weapons.

He could have stopped when the marked car pulled in front of him, got out and dealt with the issue of the car like a normal person being stopped by police. Instead he drove at them in a high risk car and the police officer involved felt threatened enough he made a split second decision to end the situation to protect himself and other including the public.

I have nothing to hide and have no issue being stopped by police anyone who refuses to stop must have something to hide.

Premeditated rape and murder is completely different to making a decision to continue a car chase, discharge a taser or indeed discharge a fire arm.

Plus (according to The Independent) the “victim” was a career criminal with convictions for everything from gun crime to domestic violence, so likely well known to the police. He was driving the stolen car at them when he was shot.

Having said that, of course there needs to be a full investigation to establish whether the officer who fired the shot was reasonable in his actions. He could have shot the car tyres instead but that obviously wouldn’t have helped if Chris Kaba had been armed (as he had been in previous incidents) and you probably can’t be too specific about where you shoot someone if shooting through a windscreen. If not reasonable, there need to be consequences for the officer.

No way in Hell should the police have carte blanche to shoot people or railroad over people’s human rights just because of their job. If anything, power hungry bullies are more likely to be drawn to this type of career.

ComeOnThenFanny · 24/09/2023 10:45

You must be joking. After the things they do under the guise of upholding the law? Absolutely not.

I have a lot of respect for the officers that I have had dealings with over the years - but a good deal of them are power crazed and corrupt.

Thedogscollar · 24/09/2023 10:43

OrangeSlices998 · 24/09/2023 09:46

An unarmed man was followed by an unmarked police car, was not a suspect, and was shot without being approached or the risk assessed? Yes the police officer should be charged.

Precisely this.

Dweetfidilove · 24/09/2023 10:42

Yes OP, let’s give them indemnity.

Allow them to hide behind the uniform while they rape, assault, murder and otherwise.

Actually, let’s scrap police training too, because with indemnity they won’t need training and protocols for arresting and detaining suspect.

And let’s not forget innocent until proven guilty. That should be done away with too, because officers will be shooting or beating all suspects, so 🤷🏽‍♀️.

alldakatz · 24/09/2023 10:40

I don't think anyone should be guaranteed immunity from prosecution, least of all the people who are supposed to be enforcing the law.

RedHelenB · 24/09/2023 10:39

OrangeSlices998 · 24/09/2023 09:46

An unarmed man was followed by an unmarked police car, was not a suspect, and was shot without being approached or the risk assessed? Yes the police officer should be charged.

This. Or we ll end up like America.

DontLeanOnTheKeyboard · 24/09/2023 10:35

When I was in the Armed Forces, when the IRA was still a threat, we had to be on a rota of being an armed guard, carrying an SA80 fully loaded with 20 live rounds. We were taught to shoot to kill, the same as the police are. We were also taught that as soon as we had taken the baddy down we would be arrested for murder.

It’s a horrific position to put people in, and the justification for taking the shot is entrenched in law, rules of engagement are clear. They would have warned him, hands above your head or get on the floor. Surely, regardless of what you have or haven’t done, if someone is yelling at you to get on the floor or I shoot and is pointing a gun at you, you get on the floor?!

We weren’t there and the police won’t be able to give the full details, unmarked police car possibly signifies surveillance and therefore part of a bigger job which they don’t want to blow.

I hope more hand their tickets in.

There are some bad cops. There are more bad people. Most cops just want to go to work, do their job, be allowed the resources to put baddies away and sometimes have rest days where they’re not called into work to cover something that is under-resourced. The same officer would be vilified if he hadn’t taken the shot and the bloke had gone on to kill a member of the public (doesn’t matter if it’s another cop, boo, how sad, it’s their job).

Merrymumoftwo · 24/09/2023 10:34

Police should be held to the same accountability as the public they serve. There should also be the same criteria applied when charging rather than pressure applied from external sources to influence decisions

JudgeRudy · 24/09/2023 10:29

No!

SD1978 · 24/09/2023 10:25

Sorry, but with the information released, yes they should be charged. I accept not knowing all the facts, but a man, not currently 'guilty' of anything, was shot without it appears any chance to surrender. The police have to be held to account