Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that disabled people are hated?

292 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 23:59

Yes, I know that it was apparently very uplifting when I was planning a party for my disabled DS and his classmates from special school. When I was putting in all the hard work by myself to make it happen it was admirable and my DS and his friends were adorable.

But there have been so many threads here complaining about the way disabled children use up resources- in school, in clubs, in sports. So much hatred for the fact that disability is sometimes, inadequately, accommodated. So much blame and disdain for parents of disabled kids. So much anger at the unfairness and injustice(!) being suffered by the ‘normal’ kids, the functioning kids, the able kids when they are forced to encounter a disabled peer.

AIBU to think that this is people showing their true colours; that in fact the world is as full of hatred for disabled people as I’ve always feared?

OP posts:
Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 10:06

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 09:45

I also joined a Facebook group for women with ADHD and most posts were people asking how they could appeal their failed PIP claim. Most of these were from people with reasonable salaries, stable homes etc. I could understand why there claims were refused as they were coping already, and in my view benefits should be for people who are not coping.

How on earth can you tell what people do and don't need or how they are coping just by being in the same Facebook group? I get your point that not all ND people have the same difficulties, but then it's kind of hypocritical for you to look at other people's 'lives' (in inverted commas because Facebook isn't life) and decide that they couldn't have difficulties which are deserving of financial support because they are from stable homes and have good salaries. Having ADHD yourself doesn't give you an insight into other people's. Just your own.

And that's why people get pissed off. I was in a similar group and believe me, you do get a good insight into peoples lives. I also diagnosed adult ADHD for a few years so was explicitly told about their lives.

A small but not insignificant number of people do get a diagnosis and in the next breath ask 'can I claim PIP?'. And a few asked if they could now get fast track passes for theme parks, flights etc. One person asked if they could get a letter so they didn't have to queue for public toilets.

So weird on MN that some people are so completely sure that no-one ever takes the piss out of the system.

And often those people think they're 'deserving of financial' support because they have a diagnosis. Not that they need it or really warrant it but 'I'm entitled because of this'.

I'm not disabled by my ADHD but am by all formal definitions disabled by anxiety disorders and PTSD. But I work full time. Even without knowing about my additional conditions, people in the groups were saying 'you've got ADHD, put a claim in, you're entitled'.

I'm not going to claim PIP on the grounds of any of my diagnoses because the money won't make any difference to my conditions other than going into my bank and I'd have more money.

Which is the same for a lot of people with the 'entitled to' attitude.

Mumofsend · 24/09/2023 10:03

I didn't realise until I had a disabled child just how inaccessible the world is to them. They are treated as an inconvenience and often now, a marketing ploy not far off white saviourism. You get an accessible hour window at the supermarket but only at the most inconvenient time because it is when the store is already deserted. You get SEN soft play sessions 7pm-9pm on a school night. Etc. It's all tokenistic to make themselves look good and I hate it.

Sirzy · 24/09/2023 09:58

x2boys · 24/09/2023 09:55

Yep.the fact don't know how you do.it I could do it type people when taking about being the parent of disabled children are infuriating like its a choice !
I see it.on here all the time i.think.it comes from people being well meaning but totally ignorant tbh.

It’s the “god only gives special children to special people” type crap that really pisses me off. All that sort of message does is add more pressure to parents to be some sort of super hero who can do everything rather than feeling they can say “actually some times is is shit”

Mukey · 24/09/2023 09:57

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 07:04

@MyHornCanPierceTheSky I don't know if there is a petition to be honest. I'm complaining to the Merlin attraction direct at the moment.

To cut this short you need to apply for a ride access pass 7 days before you go (did) they send you an email to say you can upgrade up a access card (£15 - did) and link the two. You then have to queue (ironic) at the park to get the ride access pass printed. The ride access card and so called upgraded access card are useless there. You need to download their app. Except their signal is awful. So you'd queue again to get a mobile device from them to get the QR code to access the rides.

The rides then "sell out" so if you go later in the day all the good rides are gone thus making the park useless for any disabled guests who can't get there early enough to get a QR code. I was kicked off a ride after using my upgraded pass which my son was very upset about. The whole thing is a joke and it is discrimination. It might seem minor but that is just part of the problem. It is huge to my son. It's such a shame because we came to Disneyland Paris and they got it so right, it can be done.

Is Disneyland paris good for access passes then? Only yesterday I had my friend on the phone ranting about Disney access pass as they were looking to go later this year. She last took her son about 7-8 years ago and they could access as many rides as they wanted at any time without queuing. She said they did all rides they wanted 2-3 times. Plus they could bring at least 2 other people with them in the queue. But she said she was looking into it now and it's changed. That you need to book a time slot for each ride and you can only book every 2 hours. So she doesn't think it's really worth going now as they'll only get on a few rides.

blahblahblah1654 · 24/09/2023 09:56

I'd say disabled people are more invisible than hated.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 09:55

Tessisme · 24/09/2023 09:54

Are you really claiming that no one has ever abused or defrauded the system for financial gain?

No.

I wasn't responding to you.

x2boys · 24/09/2023 09:55

Doormatnomore · 24/09/2023 09:49

I’ve found it’s definitely about being thr right kind of disabled. My son is disabled, in primary school every was happy to accommodate if they could speak to him like a toddler and hold his hand. Intellectually he’s totally fine so this is not appropriate but it’s once I pointed this out all the completely necessary accommodations stoped too because “he copes so well”. Um no, you just don’t get a nice warm fuzzy feeling helping the disabled child now.

as he’s got older, his accommodations are fine until they cut into everyone else’s time/space, then there’s various euphemisms about needing them for “real” uses. Thankfully the charity associated with his disability is huge, well funded and very recognised so can force issues. But I’m not exactly winning friends and influencing people.

it’s weirdly pervasive throughout though (ableism). Talking to family who adore my son and fully include him without question, I was talking about him being on the Oxbridge route and suddenly we were talking about “would that be fair” to the others applying.

anyway I lose track of which name change I use to to be huffy about this but I’m the one that says “why don’t you permanently disable yourself to get all the benefits? It’s surprisingly easy and then you can become and lazy scrounger! No one has taken me up on it yet.

final point to the “I couldn’t parent a disabled child” mob. What do you suggest we do? Pillow over the face? Or dump them in foster care knowing how damaging that is cause they aren’t worthy of love?

Yep.the fact don't know how you do.it I could do it type people when taking about being the parent of disabled children are infuriating like its a choice !
I see it.on here all the time i.think.it comes from people being well meaning but totally ignorant tbh.

Tessisme · 24/09/2023 09:54

Are you really claiming that no one has ever abused or defrauded the system for financial gain?

No.

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 09:54

@Carebearstare12e well that just shows how little you know about the hoops we have to jump through to supply evidence! Nothing we apply for is on a whim or just granted by a statement from a parent!

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 09:53

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 09:45

I also joined a Facebook group for women with ADHD and most posts were people asking how they could appeal their failed PIP claim. Most of these were from people with reasonable salaries, stable homes etc. I could understand why there claims were refused as they were coping already, and in my view benefits should be for people who are not coping.

How on earth can you tell what people do and don't need or how they are coping just by being in the same Facebook group? I get your point that not all ND people have the same difficulties, but then it's kind of hypocritical for you to look at other people's 'lives' (in inverted commas because Facebook isn't life) and decide that they couldn't have difficulties which are deserving of financial support because they are from stable homes and have good salaries. Having ADHD yourself doesn't give you an insight into other people's. Just your own.

I understand and wouldn’t judge someone ordinarily, but people do go into great depth in these private Facebook groups because they want advice on how to appeal. You can see that people are functioning, even thriving, and that is what has prevented their claims from being approved. Others come along and tell them very transparently that they are presenting too well and they need to embellish more, then give them the wording as to how. I left the groups in the end because it was making me a bit jaded and that’s not how I like to be.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 09:52

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 09:45

I also joined a Facebook group for women with ADHD and most posts were people asking how they could appeal their failed PIP claim. Most of these were from people with reasonable salaries, stable homes etc. I could understand why there claims were refused as they were coping already, and in my view benefits should be for people who are not coping.

How on earth can you tell what people do and don't need or how they are coping just by being in the same Facebook group? I get your point that not all ND people have the same difficulties, but then it's kind of hypocritical for you to look at other people's 'lives' (in inverted commas because Facebook isn't life) and decide that they couldn't have difficulties which are deserving of financial support because they are from stable homes and have good salaries. Having ADHD yourself doesn't give you an insight into other people's. Just your own.

Are you really claiming that no one has ever abused or defrauded the system for financial gain?

Sirzy · 24/09/2023 09:52

What really gets to me is other people in the disabled community trying to downplay other peoples suffering. It’s almost like it’s become some sort of competition or race to the bottom.

if disabled people and their families can’t be supportive of each other then what hope have we got changing attitudes in the wider community?

Doormatnomore · 24/09/2023 09:49

I’ve found it’s definitely about being thr right kind of disabled. My son is disabled, in primary school every was happy to accommodate if they could speak to him like a toddler and hold his hand. Intellectually he’s totally fine so this is not appropriate but it’s once I pointed this out all the completely necessary accommodations stoped too because “he copes so well”. Um no, you just don’t get a nice warm fuzzy feeling helping the disabled child now.

as he’s got older, his accommodations are fine until they cut into everyone else’s time/space, then there’s various euphemisms about needing them for “real” uses. Thankfully the charity associated with his disability is huge, well funded and very recognised so can force issues. But I’m not exactly winning friends and influencing people.

it’s weirdly pervasive throughout though (ableism). Talking to family who adore my son and fully include him without question, I was talking about him being on the Oxbridge route and suddenly we were talking about “would that be fair” to the others applying.

anyway I lose track of which name change I use to to be huffy about this but I’m the one that says “why don’t you permanently disable yourself to get all the benefits? It’s surprisingly easy and then you can become and lazy scrounger! No one has taken me up on it yet.

final point to the “I couldn’t parent a disabled child” mob. What do you suggest we do? Pillow over the face? Or dump them in foster care knowing how damaging that is cause they aren’t worthy of love?

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 09:48

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2023 09:35

I was reframing their assertion into a question seeing that I had never said that in the post that quoted of mine. It just suited them to infer I did..

Your response, in the context of all of it, will be interpreted as you saying that invisible disabilities don't exist. I know that's not what you meant, but it's really unhelpful. People who are looking for any excuse to avoid discussing difficult issues.

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 09:48

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 09:32

Especially when that disability is also a mental health condition. The ableist attitude also exists in places you don't expect it to.

We applied for a blue badge for my daughter last year. As part of her disability it was vital she parked as close to a shop door as physically possible ( I won't go into detail but I did explain not doing this often resulted in a 999 call). She was still a child at that stage ( yes disabled children can drive at 16)

Guess what she didn't get the badge because it wasn't a physical immobility!
Wow!

I'm doing it here. I'm having to explain and plead my case. Why?

Why? Because otherwise we have a situation where anyone can say they're disabled and need whatever accommodation made by society without there being any ability to question it or any way to assess who really needs it or not.

There have to be some parameters in place, some eligibility criteria and some way of assessing it.

Otherwise it's just going on what someone says, feels or believes. Can you not see the flaw in that?

x2boys · 24/09/2023 09:46

Mums net can be particularly hateful.about disabled children
There was a thread the other week with lots of posters getting angry about the the amount if " money " people receive in disability benefits and extra tax/ universal credit for having a disabled child
And the amount of times I read threads where posters suggest just putting disabled children into " care" ore residential schools to parents of disabled children I find really upsetting.

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 09:45

I also joined a Facebook group for women with ADHD and most posts were people asking how they could appeal their failed PIP claim. Most of these were from people with reasonable salaries, stable homes etc. I could understand why there claims were refused as they were coping already, and in my view benefits should be for people who are not coping.

How on earth can you tell what people do and don't need or how they are coping just by being in the same Facebook group? I get your point that not all ND people have the same difficulties, but then it's kind of hypocritical for you to look at other people's 'lives' (in inverted commas because Facebook isn't life) and decide that they couldn't have difficulties which are deserving of financial support because they are from stable homes and have good salaries. Having ADHD yourself doesn't give you an insight into other people's. Just your own.

Redandpinkstripes · 24/09/2023 09:42

This makes me so angry! All I will say is anyone can become disabled at any point I'm their life. I worked with a young lady, who at 14 was hit by a white van driver and developed Epilepsy, MLD and other disabilities. Her life changed in an instant. She lost all of her friends and went to a specialist school. The elderly can develop Dementia too.
As a mother of an adult with a disability, it doesn't get any easier. Only 3% of people with Autism are in employment. Most people with Autism want to be employed but the cruel/sad thing is that no adjustments are made so that they can work. The government needs to do more.

PixiePirate · 24/09/2023 09:42

Simonjt · 24/09/2023 09:02

“I’m glad I was taught that the world wasn’t going to bend to my will and I would have to navigate the parts of it I found tough.”

This couldn’t be more ignorant.

I disagree. In the context of the post (the poster was talking about her own lived experience, after all), I think it is at very least a worthy point of discussion tbh.

Clearly children with a disability shouldn’t simply be expected to crack on with no additional help or support to help level the field (which is the chronically under-resourced part that is currently being referenced in a parallel thread). However I also believe that ALL children should be encouraged to be as self sufficient and resilient as possible for their unique position. Anything less would surely mean limiting their expectations of their own capabilities and failing to help them reach their potential (whatever that may be). A lack of resilience is a really big issue in primary schools at the moment, and I don’t think that talking about it should exclude the needs of children with disabilities.

Allofthisisasimulation · 24/09/2023 09:36

Simonjt · 24/09/2023 09:02

“I’m glad I was taught that the world wasn’t going to bend to my will and I would have to navigate the parts of it I found tough.”

This couldn’t be more ignorant.

I'd say that writing off her experience, which she was kind enough to share, is also ignorant.

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2023 09:35

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 09:30

Yes it was, in response to your post. Your response started with: 'Are invisible disabilities valid?'. You asked the question, so what did you mean by that? Do you mean that autism, for example, doesn't exist?

I was reframing their assertion into a question seeing that I had never said that in the post that quoted of mine. It just suited them to infer I did..

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 09:32

Especially when that disability is also a mental health condition. The ableist attitude also exists in places you don't expect it to.

We applied for a blue badge for my daughter last year. As part of her disability it was vital she parked as close to a shop door as physically possible ( I won't go into detail but I did explain not doing this often resulted in a 999 call). She was still a child at that stage ( yes disabled children can drive at 16)

Guess what she didn't get the badge because it wasn't a physical immobility!
Wow!

I'm doing it here. I'm having to explain and plead my case. Why?

C8H10N4O2 · 24/09/2023 09:32

Clymene · 24/09/2023 06:20

What test @GeorgiaGirl52?

I assume they are referring to the genetic screening of embryos as part of IVF.

Far from being standard its specific to IVF treatment and then its an elective test. In the UK its used to screen for life limiting genetic conditions - don't think it has expanded beyond that type of use case officially. It can also be used to ensure the sex of the implanted embryo which would only be legal in the UK for sex related conditions but of course legal and actual don't always align.

PGT can only identify genes, it can't predict the extent of any associated condition, especially where multiple genes need to be expressed and interact with environment (rather than a direct and definite link such as Huntingdon's). The ethics of selecting just on the presence of genes which may or may not be expressed and may or may not actually be disadvantageous is treated differently in different jurisdictions (and quantity of $$$$).

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 09:30

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2023 09:23

i think that was the person after me talking about validity.

Yes it was, in response to your post. Your response started with: 'Are invisible disabilities valid?'. You asked the question, so what did you mean by that? Do you mean that autism, for example, doesn't exist?