Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that disabled people are hated?

292 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 23:59

Yes, I know that it was apparently very uplifting when I was planning a party for my disabled DS and his classmates from special school. When I was putting in all the hard work by myself to make it happen it was admirable and my DS and his friends were adorable.

But there have been so many threads here complaining about the way disabled children use up resources- in school, in clubs, in sports. So much hatred for the fact that disability is sometimes, inadequately, accommodated. So much blame and disdain for parents of disabled kids. So much anger at the unfairness and injustice(!) being suffered by the ‘normal’ kids, the functioning kids, the able kids when they are forced to encounter a disabled peer.

AIBU to think that this is people showing their true colours; that in fact the world is as full of hatred for disabled people as I’ve always feared?

OP posts:
Clymene · 24/09/2023 11:06

As I said, the world is full of liars and scammers. I don't think there are any more in the disabled community than in the non disabled. They're just easier to pick on.

British society is very keen on a race to the bottom.

Clymene · 24/09/2023 11:04

You need at least 8 points to get standard level in the care component

www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/pip-points-system

You wouldn't qualify @Secondwindplease

jolaylasofia · 24/09/2023 11:01

it depends what you mean. i believe disabled children should get enough funding to ensure their needs are met AND to ensure the other class members are not disadvantaged at all. There shouldn't be any disruption to classes in this day and age. Provisions must be in place to avoid this and make sure every single child disabled or not has the best opportunities in life. I don't think that is ableist and think it's what most parents feel.

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 11:00

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 10:57

Others come along and tell them very transparently that they are presenting too well and they need to embellish more, then give them the wording as to how.

Embellish more or advise people to fill in the application as it is on your worst day?

It definitely went beyond ‘describe your worst day’ sometimes. Just outright ‘here’s what to say’ and ‘don’t tell them X’.

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 10:57

Others come along and tell them very transparently that they are presenting too well and they need to embellish more, then give them the wording as to how.

Embellish more or advise people to fill in the application as it is on your worst day?

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 10:56

@Pollyputhekettleon when you have a disabled child I'm afraid you pretty much get used to the haters. It seems that society feels we must bear that load if we want any assistance at all just to give our children equality.

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 10:56

"I'm aware that's not the majority of cases, that's why I specifically said 'some proportion'. From the sneering reactions she got anyone would think PGT had absolutely nothing to do with autism."

It's a tiny proportion. No clinic should be saying their testing can screen for "autism" because it cannot.

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 10:52

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 10:48

I’m glad I was taught that the world wasn’t going to bend to my will and I would have to navigate the parts of it I found tough

Life is tough, with or without disability. But to manage in that tough world, it is essential that the world does indeed bend to ensure that people with disabilities are able to navigate on a half even playing field with the rest of us. Pretending all disabled people need to do is develop their resilience ignores the complexity of challenges many face to do even simple stuff - like get in a building - the rest of us take for granted.

I 100% agree with you that the world needs to bend for people with disability. I was writing from the perspective of someone with neurodiversity that isn’t disabling.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 10:52

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 10:48

I’m glad I was taught that the world wasn’t going to bend to my will and I would have to navigate the parts of it I found tough

Life is tough, with or without disability. But to manage in that tough world, it is essential that the world does indeed bend to ensure that people with disabilities are able to navigate on a half even playing field with the rest of us. Pretending all disabled people need to do is develop their resilience ignores the complexity of challenges many face to do even simple stuff - like get in a building - the rest of us take for granted.

It wasn't essential to the person you're responding to, and she's not the only one. Maybe people should stop making such blanket statements about people with disabilities.

She didn't 'pretend that all disabled people need to do is develop their resilience'. Not even close. You're the one making sweeping statements as if all disabled people are the same.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 10:49

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 10:43

"I don't know why people were sneering at a PP who was talking about PGT to screen prenatally for autism as if it couldn't be done. It clearly exists and can detect some proportion of cases either during IVF or prenatally."

These tests can only screen for genetic abnormalities. The vast majority of people with autism do not have detectable genetic differences.

They screen for genetic abnormalities that can cause autism. I'm aware that's not the majority of cases, that's why I specifically said 'some proportion'. From the sneering reactions she got anyone would think PGT had absolutely nothing to do with autism.

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 10:48

I’m glad I was taught that the world wasn’t going to bend to my will and I would have to navigate the parts of it I found tough

Life is tough, with or without disability. But to manage in that tough world, it is essential that the world does indeed bend to ensure that people with disabilities are able to navigate on a half even playing field with the rest of us. Pretending all disabled people need to do is develop their resilience ignores the complexity of challenges many face to do even simple stuff - like get in a building - the rest of us take for granted.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 10:46

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 10:18

There are some people that do take advantage of systems; tax, housing, education, health. Then there are people just trying to make sure that their child is able to start the race and stay in the race alongside other children. Most of us are those people.

And that's fine. But some people are trying to shut down discussion of the dark side by accusing those bringing it up of being motivated by hatred for them or their children. They're also pretending not to know that some of the actual hatred, or usually more accurately, resentment, annoyance, suspicion and lack of patience, partly stems from the real behaviour of a minority. Again, it's all simply written off as mindless 'hatred' because that's the currently fashionable root of all evil.

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 10:45

Clymene · 24/09/2023 10:28

There are always people who want to take more than their fair share. People do it when they bolster mileage claims or spend 20 minutes chatting to their mate by the coffee machine when they are being paid to work. They do it when they pay tax advisers large sums to structure their finances to avoid tax. They do it when they park in a disabled parking spot because they're in a hurry or over two parking spaces.

These are the PIP requirements.

Daily living part
You might get the daily living part of PIP if you need help with:
• preparing food
• eating and drinking
• managing your medicines or treatments
• washing and bathing
• using the toilet
• dressing and undressing
• reading
• managing your money
• socialising and being around other people
• talking, listening and understanding.
Mobility part
You might get the mobility part of PIP if you need help with:
• working out a route and following it
• physically moving around
• leaving your home.

If you're holding down a job at a senior level, you're unlikely to qualify.

So with my ADHD, I would say that I have trouble socialising (I’m always interrupting or drifting off, and I can’t just sit and talk for hours, and I’m noise sensitive) listening (again, drifting off) and following a route. None of that stops me thriving and none of it would improve with more money. At most I just need a little grace from my loved ones when I’ve zoned out while they are talking (inattention) or when I’m late (time blindness). I can make my own adaptations at work, like recording meetings and using the pomodoro technique, body doubling etc.

However, I am very sure based on the information I’ve been given by ADHD providers and through the support groups online that I could make a case for PIP - it might not be immediately accepted but in the end I think I would succeed.

Again, this is my experience. There will be others with ADHD who can’t hold down a job or manage the basics of their personal care, and these people should be supported. They have ADHD and it is disabling for them. I have ADHD and it is not disabling for me. I am just calling for a distinction between the two, mainly for the benefit of people with disabilities who have a hard enough job advocating for themselves as it is.

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 10:43

"I don't know why people were sneering at a PP who was talking about PGT to screen prenatally for autism as if it couldn't be done. It clearly exists and can detect some proportion of cases either during IVF or prenatally."

These tests can only screen for genetic abnormalities. The vast majority of people with autism do not have detectable genetic differences.

x2boys · 24/09/2023 10:43

PaperSheet · 24/09/2023 10:18

I agree with this. I was diagnosed with autism as an adult. I have a well paid job in the medical sector. Have done for many years. Own my own house. I can drive. I can queue. I can manage my bills and budget. I'm perfectly self sufficient. As are many people with autism. Especially those diagnosed as adults. Do I have struggles in life? Yes many. Mainly around anxiety and social things. For example, I hate talking on the phone. But if I have to call an plumber then I have to call a plumber. I hate it. I feel panicky and worried. But I know it NEEDS to be done otherwise my house will flood (or whatever). I hate going food shopping but i also don't like online deliveries for fresh food as I'm very fussy with what I'll eat. I get overwhelmed in lots of situations. Leading to me often having to leave places before I would like. Would me being able to claim PIP for any other benefit help this? No. It would just be extra money given to me to add to my already decent savings from my well paid job. (Not bragging. Just pointing out why I would never consider claiming anything for this condition alone). But I'd still need to go to the shops and I'd still need to call the plumber and leave places I found overwhelming.

Would you be entitled to.PIP.though?
I.think.there are two.different issues here not everybody with a disability is entitled to PIP it goes off what you can't do not the disability so if you can manage to live independently travel independently cook for yourself the chances are you wouldn't qualify anyway
My oldest son has recently been diagnosed with diabetes he's insulin dependent he wil!always be insulin dependent its a disability but I think its unlikely he would be entitled to PIP.as he's over 16 as he manages it independently and it doesn't affect his ability to self care or r travel independently.

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 10:39

PaperSheet · 24/09/2023 10:18

I agree with this. I was diagnosed with autism as an adult. I have a well paid job in the medical sector. Have done for many years. Own my own house. I can drive. I can queue. I can manage my bills and budget. I'm perfectly self sufficient. As are many people with autism. Especially those diagnosed as adults. Do I have struggles in life? Yes many. Mainly around anxiety and social things. For example, I hate talking on the phone. But if I have to call an plumber then I have to call a plumber. I hate it. I feel panicky and worried. But I know it NEEDS to be done otherwise my house will flood (or whatever). I hate going food shopping but i also don't like online deliveries for fresh food as I'm very fussy with what I'll eat. I get overwhelmed in lots of situations. Leading to me often having to leave places before I would like. Would me being able to claim PIP for any other benefit help this? No. It would just be extra money given to me to add to my already decent savings from my well paid job. (Not bragging. Just pointing out why I would never consider claiming anything for this condition alone). But I'd still need to go to the shops and I'd still need to call the plumber and leave places I found overwhelming.

Exactly. My anxiety disorders and PTSD which could be potentially linked to my ND make life extremely difficult.

I rarely go outside the local same 0.5 area where I walk daily. I've gone outside of that 4 times this year. I work from home full time and have a reasonable adjustment that I don't attend in-person group meetings but will attend 1:1 in person meetings if necessary. And they are rare.

And doing that does cause me significant stress and exacerbates my anxiety. But that's part of living with my condition, that some things are extremely hard and cause me difficulties but complete avoidance isn't a solution either.

I could easily put a claim in for PIP and could be considered 'entitled' but that money would make no difference whatsoever to my condition and would just be more money in my bank.

So why would I? Because I'm entitled? And the parameters of of the definition of 'disability' have shifted so much that in some cases, they're meaningless.

Virtually no-one I know knows that I'm disabled in formal terms. And I think most of society would judge me as not.

Which can be a valid argument as most people have an idea of what they think the definition of disability should apply to.

TGGreen · 24/09/2023 10:37

I'm adult and not a pushover. I'm also ill enough that I automatically qualify for blue badges. The amount of times I've been abused for using these spaces tells me all I need to know about some people's feelings. If you've never experienced it you have no idea.
I feel for disabled children growing up. There is little real empathy, just lip service. Services are crashing under the weight of financial cuts and fear the future will only be harder and harder.
As unpalatable as Georgia is. She isn't alone in her vile opinions.

SpanielsMatter · 24/09/2023 10:36

Don’t get me started.

Large retailer ‘ The Warehouse’ has inaccessible aisles, refuses to have disabled trolleys I wrote to them (especially, because they put out so many smug promos about their disabled policies) and they couldn’t even be bothered to respond. It wasn’t a horrible email at all, it did invite them to work with us to see the challenges wheelchair uses face in store.

DH got a grant towards a van that would transport his power chair because over his life he has been an active volunteer in the community, but the provider needs a report from a private company that requires DH to attend in his power chair ( we cannot transport). The local disabled van is often being repaired and it doesn’t have the proper seatbelt so in an accident DH will become a huge missile by being jettisoned out of his chair, the chair alone weighs 90kg DH is 110kg. DH got a grant because he cannot mobilise easily, needs his power chair but we cannot get the report done that the provider requires. The private company assists you in finding buying and altering the car via a company that seems to think of a number and triple it when costing installing a ramp into a vehicle. Oh and yes his condition is degenerative, is lifelong and a full doctor report was submitted with the application. You couldn’t make it up

DH had to change doctors because the surgery couldn’t accommodate his wheelchair, had a huge heavy front door and the steepest ramp imaginable. When mentioning these issues was looked at as unreasonable

The local pub has a ramp, yep lovely ramp but a huge lip/ step going into the side doors which is about 25cm high. Dh has a substantial power chair but it cannot manage that lip. So dh cannot occasionally enjoy his local pub for a quiet pint ….

Why is it, when you put the word disabled next to anything the price quadruples, often for a section of society who can ill afford inflated prices to start with.

Being disabled is shit and I’m so tired of complaining, pointing stuff out and then being seen as a grumpy middle aged woman who ‘complains about everything’ when it’s systems and companies that are wrong in the first place!

Clymene · 24/09/2023 10:28

There are always people who want to take more than their fair share. People do it when they bolster mileage claims or spend 20 minutes chatting to their mate by the coffee machine when they are being paid to work. They do it when they pay tax advisers large sums to structure their finances to avoid tax. They do it when they park in a disabled parking spot because they're in a hurry or over two parking spaces.

These are the PIP requirements.

Daily living part
You might get the daily living part of PIP if you need help with:
• preparing food
• eating and drinking
• managing your medicines or treatments
• washing and bathing
• using the toilet
• dressing and undressing
• reading
• managing your money
• socialising and being around other people
• talking, listening and understanding.
Mobility part
You might get the mobility part of PIP if you need help with:
• working out a route and following it
• physically moving around
• leaving your home.

If you're holding down a job at a senior level, you're unlikely to qualify.

Doormatnomore · 24/09/2023 10:21

Well I’m not as kind as you, for dementia care and pest control you have the choice and they are saying they’re glad someone is doing it and they’re glad it’s not them.
the difference with single parents and parents of disabled children (heavy overlap) there’s judgment in my experience. Ask a single parent if their married friends have had some interesting reactions. The parent “praise” sorta means implies there was a choice too. How many times have I been asked if it was because I drank pregnant or what I’d done. I do run people up the wrong way though. Sorry if all these people are praising me for something that’s beyond my control and I’m making a hash off.

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 10:20

@Mukey we went at the end of July this year. I had heard about the time slot thing however did not experience it. When we got to Disney we went to the guest services / assistance desk. Showed proof (DLA letter) and they took a photo and produced a card. You still have a small queue usually with the fast pass (or whatever they call it) and you can take up to 4 guests. There were four of us but we had two passes (both children have autism). Our passes were gold edged (I believe there is a green one maybe for physical disabilities) but otherwise we flashed those and went in the disabled entrance. No booking like what you friend mentioned, I thought it was that system too but it wasn't in July. Disney were brilliant. No arguments or hassle and no one batted an eyelid.

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 10:18

There are some people that do take advantage of systems; tax, housing, education, health. Then there are people just trying to make sure that their child is able to start the race and stay in the race alongside other children. Most of us are those people.

PaperSheet · 24/09/2023 10:18

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 10:06

And that's why people get pissed off. I was in a similar group and believe me, you do get a good insight into peoples lives. I also diagnosed adult ADHD for a few years so was explicitly told about their lives.

A small but not insignificant number of people do get a diagnosis and in the next breath ask 'can I claim PIP?'. And a few asked if they could now get fast track passes for theme parks, flights etc. One person asked if they could get a letter so they didn't have to queue for public toilets.

So weird on MN that some people are so completely sure that no-one ever takes the piss out of the system.

And often those people think they're 'deserving of financial' support because they have a diagnosis. Not that they need it or really warrant it but 'I'm entitled because of this'.

I'm not disabled by my ADHD but am by all formal definitions disabled by anxiety disorders and PTSD. But I work full time. Even without knowing about my additional conditions, people in the groups were saying 'you've got ADHD, put a claim in, you're entitled'.

I'm not going to claim PIP on the grounds of any of my diagnoses because the money won't make any difference to my conditions other than going into my bank and I'd have more money.

Which is the same for a lot of people with the 'entitled to' attitude.

I agree with this. I was diagnosed with autism as an adult. I have a well paid job in the medical sector. Have done for many years. Own my own house. I can drive. I can queue. I can manage my bills and budget. I'm perfectly self sufficient. As are many people with autism. Especially those diagnosed as adults. Do I have struggles in life? Yes many. Mainly around anxiety and social things. For example, I hate talking on the phone. But if I have to call an plumber then I have to call a plumber. I hate it. I feel panicky and worried. But I know it NEEDS to be done otherwise my house will flood (or whatever). I hate going food shopping but i also don't like online deliveries for fresh food as I'm very fussy with what I'll eat. I get overwhelmed in lots of situations. Leading to me often having to leave places before I would like. Would me being able to claim PIP for any other benefit help this? No. It would just be extra money given to me to add to my already decent savings from my well paid job. (Not bragging. Just pointing out why I would never consider claiming anything for this condition alone). But I'd still need to go to the shops and I'd still need to call the plumber and leave places I found overwhelming.

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 10:14

pompomdaisy · 24/09/2023 09:54

@Carebearstare12e well that just shows how little you know about the hoops we have to jump through to supply evidence! Nothing we apply for is on a whim or just granted by a statement from a parent!

Claiming can be very difficult. But it's not the case for everyone.

Otherwise there wouldn't be so much fraud.

And believe me, I know the system as have helped many people get PIP. And turns out in more than a few cases, I was manipulated and conned. And some were put through the wringer and others just weren't. It is a case by case basis and very much relies on how persistent someone is, how much they are helped to make a claim, and whether they've always been a claimant one way or the other.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 10:12

The 'I don't know how you do it'/'I could never do that' is a thing people say about dozens of things in life. Single parents hear it all the time, family carers get it, people who work in nursing homes with dementia patients, rodent control people, people with large families, people with 3 children under 4, child psychologists who have to hear details of horrific abuse, dentists are always hearing it. It's just a social noise people make that means roughly 'that sounds like something I'd find grim'. Sometimes it implies admiration as well, sometimes it doesn't.