Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that disabled people are hated?

292 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 23:59

Yes, I know that it was apparently very uplifting when I was planning a party for my disabled DS and his classmates from special school. When I was putting in all the hard work by myself to make it happen it was admirable and my DS and his friends were adorable.

But there have been so many threads here complaining about the way disabled children use up resources- in school, in clubs, in sports. So much hatred for the fact that disability is sometimes, inadequately, accommodated. So much blame and disdain for parents of disabled kids. So much anger at the unfairness and injustice(!) being suffered by the ‘normal’ kids, the functioning kids, the able kids when they are forced to encounter a disabled peer.

AIBU to think that this is people showing their true colours; that in fact the world is as full of hatred for disabled people as I’ve always feared?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 24/09/2023 12:36

Ime abled bodied people 'care' about disabled people until they are or feel they are negatively affected.

When my kids were at school other parents could be bloody awful. Definitely feeling my sons shouldn't be there and that they were taking up resources. I even had one bloke come directly to me to complain about it. 🤬

Now they're adults it's even harder for them.

I'm also disabled and yeah. There's a lot of ignorance and - bizarrely, jealousy.

Jealousy! I'll swap them. They get the pip if they also take the disabilities and me and my sons can have a chance at an actual life!

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 12:29

I agree OP. I do think that people are very good at making all the right noises about fairness and the rights of disabled people until they see their precious child's classmate being 'given' something to put them on a level playing field with their peers. Then suddenly all bets are off. The parent's radar detects that someone else's child is getting more of something, be it equipment/time/attention, and they start wondering how this will disadvantage their own child.

x2boys · 24/09/2023 12:29

MidnightMeltdown · 24/09/2023 12:17

I agree with this. It think that using the umbrella term 'disabled' to describe an enormous range of different conditions, is problematic.

When I was at schools there was a kid with fairly mild dyslexia who was considered disabled, which meant that they were provided with a load of extra funding to buy laptops etc. This kid came from an extremely wealthy family - huge house with massive en-suite bedrooms, swimming pool, expensive cars etc.

By contrast, I couldn't afford a laptop, even when I went to university, which made the first couple of years really tough.

You went to.University which proves you didn't need exta help.,and I doubt someone with mild dyslexia was given loads of extra help. Even in bygone years it was hard enough ro.access extra help.for children with quite significant disabilities let alone ,ones that are " mild".

Anewuser · 24/09/2023 12:28

You’ve only got to look at your poll. Two thirds think you’re being unreasonable but the majority of comments seem to be agreeing with you.

Having a severely disabled adult son, we’ve seen and heard it for years. From a church telling us he was a fire hazard and had to leave the place, to lining up in the disabled access queue at Legoland and hearing parents deliberately announcing loudly that we shouldn’t queue jump.

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 12:22

"The studies I linked to do not appear to be talking about a tiny proportion and you've provided no evidence at all. I'm not discussing the ethics of what IVF clinics may be claiming. I'm saying the reaction to that unfortunate poster was completely misleading and wildly disproportionate. This obviously triggers strong emotions for some reason although I have no idea why."

CMA testing detects genetic abnormalities in 5 -14% of people with autism who are tested. Apart from specific conditions such as Fragile X the test does not tell you if having that genetic abnormality means autism since many people will have a genetic abnormality that causes no ' ill effects'.

MidnightMeltdown · 24/09/2023 12:17

TheLightProgramme · 24/09/2023 07:46

I will try to be really honest here.

I struggle with the blanlet term "disabled" and the wide spectrum this covers.

When i was a child, "disabled" referred primarily to physical disability and was predominantly used for people with quite severe conditions.

Now it is used for everything from a wheelchair bound, incontinent child with cerebral palsy, to a fully verbal mainstream educated person with a spouse & well paid job, who on first glance many of us won't have any clue of their disability.

It used to be about having ramps in buildings and braille on bus stops, now it can feel like the autism/ND agenda is at the forefront and its a very different set of needs that are not as well understood

I agree with this. It think that using the umbrella term 'disabled' to describe an enormous range of different conditions, is problematic.

When I was at schools there was a kid with fairly mild dyslexia who was considered disabled, which meant that they were provided with a load of extra funding to buy laptops etc. This kid came from an extremely wealthy family - huge house with massive en-suite bedrooms, swimming pool, expensive cars etc.

By contrast, I couldn't afford a laptop, even when I went to university, which made the first couple of years really tough.

Talapia · 24/09/2023 12:14

I don't think hated, but definitely not considered within society.

Lots of lip service, but no real action.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 24/09/2023 12:11

Dramatic · 24/09/2023 00:20

I think what you're talking about is when the "normal" kids (as you put it) are being attacked by their disabled classmates, in which case I don't think anyone is directing their frustration towards the parent of that child but more to the system which means that those children aren't adequately supported.

@Dramatic it is fair to be frustrated if your child is being hurt and the schools/teachers/authorities aren’t managing to step in appropriately.

But actually what I’m talking about is the exclusion and othering that disabled people face at every step. The sports club where parents complain that the kid with disabilities is slower to gain skills and takes up an unfair amount of the coach’s time. The early intervention Occupational Therapy that is withheld because ‘your child is also delayed at walking and talking, and their fine motor skills match their current overall ability’. The worry from parents that the mainstream classroom might contain ‘SEN’ (not children, apparently) who will need unfair amounts of support with reading and writing, taking away from their own child (who perhaps can already write their own name etc. and thus obviously requires less support anyway). The recruitment managers who dismiss job applications because they lack the imagination to see how a few reasonable adjustments could work. The posters on here who say ‘Well I don’t have adult friends with learning disabilities so why should my kids have to be friendly at school?’ The notion that Downs Syndrome or CP might be tolerable in a peer but ASD or PEG feeding would be an intolerable burden, without regard to the individual in question.

People in public mostly manage to say the ‘right’ thing, or nothing, but on here they voice all the disgusting things they really think and it’s horrid.

OP posts:
AgnesX · 24/09/2023 12:06

I think hate is a bit strong. Resentment by certain groups for getting or being given things that they don't have most definitely.

In general there are a lot of people who are shits to everyone else though.

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2023 12:01

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 09:48

Why? Because otherwise we have a situation where anyone can say they're disabled and need whatever accommodation made by society without there being any ability to question it or any way to assess who really needs it or not.

There have to be some parameters in place, some eligibility criteria and some way of assessing it.

Otherwise it's just going on what someone says, feels or believes. Can you not see the flaw in that?

That’s literally what’s happening right now in the gender debate. You can appropriate any sex you feel.

Mukey · 24/09/2023 11:52

x2boys · 24/09/2023 10:43

Would you be entitled to.PIP.though?
I.think.there are two.different issues here not everybody with a disability is entitled to PIP it goes off what you can't do not the disability so if you can manage to live independently travel independently cook for yourself the chances are you wouldn't qualify anyway
My oldest son has recently been diagnosed with diabetes he's insulin dependent he wil!always be insulin dependent its a disability but I think its unlikely he would be entitled to PIP.as he's over 16 as he manages it independently and it doesn't affect his ability to self care or r travel independently.

Maybe someone wouldn't qualify for pip. But I'm sure if they could word things well in an application they could give it a good try.
I have a friend who was diagnosed ADHD as an adult. I do not doubt she has it. I can recognise many markers of it in her. But she's now started saying she's going to apply for ride access passes at theme parks. And told me I can use it with her if she gets it. We've been going to theme parks together for about 20 years. She does not need an access pass. She manages queuing perfectly well. Yes she moans when it's a long queue. But don't we all??
This is the difference between a condition being actually disabling and then just using it to get extra things. Maybe her ADHD does disable her in ways. But by using an access pass she doesn't need (if she gets it) she'll be making people with other conditions who ARE affected by queuing wait longer. I'm sure an access pass would make her life easier. It would also make mine easier. It would make everyone's life easier. That's what I consider the difference anyway.

PurpleChrayne · 24/09/2023 11:51

It's definitely on the rise.

I think because society has become so dog-eat-dog, people are now less patient and willing to accept that the less-able require more help and resources.

TigerRag · 24/09/2023 11:48

Mumofsend · 24/09/2023 10:03

I didn't realise until I had a disabled child just how inaccessible the world is to them. They are treated as an inconvenience and often now, a marketing ploy not far off white saviourism. You get an accessible hour window at the supermarket but only at the most inconvenient time because it is when the store is already deserted. You get SEN soft play sessions 7pm-9pm on a school night. Etc. It's all tokenistic to make themselves look good and I hate it.

I remember a lot of disabled people complaining about the hour in the supermarket because it was before their bus pass worked or their disability meant they couldn't get to the supermarket at 8/9am.

NotAnotherPylon · 24/09/2023 11:46

I did not claim @Carebearstare12e that nobody 'takes the piss out of the system'. I suggested that you can't possibly know what someone else's difficulties are based on your own circumstances, or on their activity on Facebook. I'm sure it's wonderful that you don't need financial support, but you don't have any special insight into other people's needs and difficulties. Even if you think you do.

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 11:44

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 11:24

think it still illustrates that there is a lot of confusion and a lot of conflation of neurodiversity with disability though, which only sometimes overlap

To be able to claim DLA for a child you need to evidence that your child requires more looking after than the average child. Therefore it will usually be possible to claim when you have a ND child. Some ND people will also qualify for PIP. My child has Type 1 diabetes - we can claim DLA but know he is unlikely to get PIP unless he begins to require more support than he does now or indeed, unless something else happens to him or another condition were to rear its head. There is no harm in trying to claim or getting support to do so. You might manage perfectly well but that's not the same for everyone. Many conditions require support, medications or therapies not available on the NHS. People should be made to feel ashamed for trying to claim extra funding to support them.

I fully understand and agree that many people would be much more affected than I am by the same condition. But I am disconcerted that on diagnosis I was encouraged to apply for so many things I didn’t need, because as you say I was clearly managing perfectly well. In my particular circumstances I think it would have been shameful to apply, because I have always been taught not to take what you don’t need, especially if it comes from resources allocated to those who do. And then I saw a lot of other women with similar life stories to mine (professional jobs, late diagnosis) who were trying to claim things they didn’t need and getting offended when they were refused. It’s almost like getting the diagnosis was validating (understandable) and then being refused PIP diminished that somehow.

It’s hard to unpick and I’m probably not doing it justice. With more adult ADHD being diagnosed there will be more people like me though, who are grateful for the insight into their brain and character but don’t warrant access to disability services or spaces, and I think the place for that should be more clearly demarcated for everyone’s benefit.

Iam4eels · 24/09/2023 11:44

Mumofsend · 24/09/2023 10:03

I didn't realise until I had a disabled child just how inaccessible the world is to them. They are treated as an inconvenience and often now, a marketing ploy not far off white saviourism. You get an accessible hour window at the supermarket but only at the most inconvenient time because it is when the store is already deserted. You get SEN soft play sessions 7pm-9pm on a school night. Etc. It's all tokenistic to make themselves look good and I hate it.

God yes, the tokenism which is also used as an excuse to shunt disabled people off to one side because if you dare to complain about a 'standard/normal' version of something being inaccessible you get reminded "we have a SEN session available on this inconvenient day at this inconvenient time, you should go to that instead".

SEN sessions are all well and good for those who prefer them but they're not suitable for everyone and are often 'less good' - for example, cinema SEN sessions tend to be older films or less popular films rather than the latest releases, pantomime relaxed performances are often in the middle of the school day so no good to school-aged children, SEN activity sessions often don't include the really fun stuff (e.g., local trampoline park doesn't include the airbags in their SEN sessions, a soft play place doesn't include the go karts, etc).

Public spaces should be made as accessible as possible to as many people as possible 100% of the time, not just for an hour between 9am and 10am on the first Sunday of every month.

gogomoto · 24/09/2023 11:42

Ableism is rife but there is also many forms of disability and one person's reasonable adjustment or action might be incredibly bad for another disabled person. My dd is hypersensitive to noise and the dc with adhd in her class caused her to drop out of school until she could go into separate provision, did their "they can't help it" trump her sensitivity (she's autistic). So I can understand why people are sometimes in two minds about inclusion. The reality is we need to be more understanding of each other, but be aware that things are always black and white (yes we have had to get off a bus because another person was vocally stimming, my dd could not cope with it)

x2boys · 24/09/2023 11:40

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 11:08

Well that’s actually good to know! Probably explains why there were so many pissed off women on that Facebook group too. I think it still illustrates that there is a lot of confusion and a lot of conflation of neurodiversity with disability though, which only sometimes overlap. That was my original point.

Its how the disability impacts a person not the disability itself so.if someone is managing well then they are unlikely to be success ful.in claiming for PIP.

x2boys · 24/09/2023 11:34

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 11:24

think it still illustrates that there is a lot of confusion and a lot of conflation of neurodiversity with disability though, which only sometimes overlap

To be able to claim DLA for a child you need to evidence that your child requires more looking after than the average child. Therefore it will usually be possible to claim when you have a ND child. Some ND people will also qualify for PIP. My child has Type 1 diabetes - we can claim DLA but know he is unlikely to get PIP unless he begins to require more support than he does now or indeed, unless something else happens to him or another condition were to rear its head. There is no harm in trying to claim or getting support to do so. You might manage perfectly well but that's not the same for everyone. Many conditions require support, medications or therapies not available on the NHS. People should be made to feel ashamed for trying to claim extra funding to support them.

Im.on various DLA groups in Facebook because my youngest child has severe autism and learning disabilities he gets High rate care and high rate Mobility under SMI rules
There are definitely same people who just see it as extra money and will.try and claim for the vaguest of reasons with no evidence or diagnosis or have even spoken to.a Dr or health visitor about their concerns I see it a lot they are usually unsuccessful though
Diabetes is a funny one my oldest son wss diagnosed in February but he's 16 so I don't think he would as you say qualify for PIP.
But I understand and why a child qualifies for. DLA as its pretty full on.

Iam4eels · 24/09/2023 11:31

IME, inclusiveness and accessibility ends at the point where non-disabled people feel they're being inconvenienced, disadvantaged or that disabled people are getting a "perk" that they themselves want.

Over the years I've been told that it's unfair DC has a one to one support in school as other, more academic children, would benefit more from that level of extra teaching (i.e, it's wasted on someone like DC). I've overheard people saying a child like DC shouldn't even be in "our school". DC had a reasonable adjustment in place that had zero impact on anyone else (arriving five minutes late, leaving five minutes early) but a small group of gobby parents whose DC were regularly late as a matter of course complained so much and so loudly about it being unfair that school removed the adjustment. We ended up having to change schools.

If you want to see how society views disability, read the comments section on any news article relating to a disabilities.

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 11:24

*shouldn't

Baconisdelicious · 24/09/2023 11:24

think it still illustrates that there is a lot of confusion and a lot of conflation of neurodiversity with disability though, which only sometimes overlap

To be able to claim DLA for a child you need to evidence that your child requires more looking after than the average child. Therefore it will usually be possible to claim when you have a ND child. Some ND people will also qualify for PIP. My child has Type 1 diabetes - we can claim DLA but know he is unlikely to get PIP unless he begins to require more support than he does now or indeed, unless something else happens to him or another condition were to rear its head. There is no harm in trying to claim or getting support to do so. You might manage perfectly well but that's not the same for everyone. Many conditions require support, medications or therapies not available on the NHS. People should be made to feel ashamed for trying to claim extra funding to support them.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 24/09/2023 11:20

Merlin now want to exclude him from something he loves because of his disability to make it fair to everyone. Where is the fairness to him, because I only see discrimination.

I'm so sick of any attempts to redress unfairness caused by disability as 'unfair' to the people who don't get the extra concessions - because they 100% do not need them in the first place.

It's a cliche, but it's still completely true: many able-bodied people want to have free access to the things that a disabled person needs, which they think look like quite a convenient perk to them; but they're not interested in having the disability that transforms that cool convenience into an absolute basic essential.

Secondwindplease · 24/09/2023 11:08

Clymene · 24/09/2023 11:04

You need at least 8 points to get standard level in the care component

www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/personal-independence-payment-pip/pip-points-system

You wouldn't qualify @Secondwindplease

Well that’s actually good to know! Probably explains why there were so many pissed off women on that Facebook group too. I think it still illustrates that there is a lot of confusion and a lot of conflation of neurodiversity with disability though, which only sometimes overlap. That was my original point.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 11:07

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 10:56

"I'm aware that's not the majority of cases, that's why I specifically said 'some proportion'. From the sneering reactions she got anyone would think PGT had absolutely nothing to do with autism."

It's a tiny proportion. No clinic should be saying their testing can screen for "autism" because it cannot.

The studies I linked to do not appear to be talking about a tiny proportion and you've provided no evidence at all. I'm not discussing the ethics of what IVF clinics may be claiming. I'm saying the reaction to that unfortunate poster was completely misleading and wildly disproportionate. This obviously triggers strong emotions for some reason although I have no idea why.