Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that disabled people are hated?

292 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 23:59

Yes, I know that it was apparently very uplifting when I was planning a party for my disabled DS and his classmates from special school. When I was putting in all the hard work by myself to make it happen it was admirable and my DS and his friends were adorable.

But there have been so many threads here complaining about the way disabled children use up resources- in school, in clubs, in sports. So much hatred for the fact that disability is sometimes, inadequately, accommodated. So much blame and disdain for parents of disabled kids. So much anger at the unfairness and injustice(!) being suffered by the ‘normal’ kids, the functioning kids, the able kids when they are forced to encounter a disabled peer.

AIBU to think that this is people showing their true colours; that in fact the world is as full of hatred for disabled people as I’ve always feared?

OP posts:
squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:53

If anyone's interested, have a look at the

deinstitutionalization movement.

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:51

It's gone from one extreme to the other.

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:51

@Pollyputhekettleon
There are numerous factors involved including what has been described as an autism diagnosis epidemic.
What is definitely known though, is that children, not so long ago, were not being diagnosed.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 13:50

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 13:38

"A recent thread discussed this. You have teachers and SENCOs on these threads saying as many as 20-40% of children in their classes are deemed SEN. School statistics back this up.

Having SEN doesn't mean a child is ND. It means they need extra support with learning at that point.

The increase in the rate of SEN includes an increase in the rate of ND children who have SEN.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 13:46

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:23

There's this misconception that there are more disabled people around now. Not so long ago, people with disabilities were hidden away from a very young age in institutions. There was no help for families or any thought to integrate into society.
I was a support worker for a while and a few of the people I worked for were brought up in those institutions. So you can see, this happened in our lifetime.
I'm now a parent to a child with DS. Thankfully, I became a parent with my eyes wide open.
She is my absolute reason for living. It hasn't been easy fighting for the support that she needs. Thankfully, things are changing, albeit very slowly.

This has been studied pretty well when it comes to autism. It's simply not the case that the increase is caused solely by more diagnosis. I haven't looked into the others but it's highly unlikely they're different.

Not only that, there are teachers, plenty of them, who've been teaching long enough and who'll tell you that the rates have increased massively in just the last 10 years. And they're not talking about rates of diagnosis, they're talking about actual incidence as witnessed first hand in the classroom.

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:42

I worked for 15 years with people who had a variety of different disabilities. I slept in their houses, I got to know their families, I fought alongside them for very basic support that most of us will take for granted.
Diagnosis is a lot better now. Not so long ago, these children would have been considered unruly, and unteachable.

Prinnny · 24/09/2023 13:39

x2boys · 24/09/2023 13:05

Some children with SEN manage very well.in mainstream school there shouldn't be a blanket ban and not all.of them are violent
My own son has always been in a special school.because his needs could never have Bern met in mainstream ,there are of course some children with SEN who.are in mainstream because there isn't any appropriate. Specialist provision for them but that's no their fault
I think its quite hard to play the system ,I think some peop!e ,try I have seen people on the various DLA groups I'm on on Facebook put in claims foe very tenuous reasons but they are mostly unsuccessful .

I know, that’s why I specifically said violent SEN children..

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 13:38

"A recent thread discussed this. You have teachers and SENCOs on these threads saying as many as 20-40% of children in their classes are deemed SEN. School statistics back this up.

Having SEN doesn't mean a child is ND. It means they need extra support with learning at that point.

senparents · 24/09/2023 13:37

I feel very judged as a disabled person with Sen dc who can’t work. I’m seen as a drain on society and even had a doctor once ask me why I had children knowing I’d struggle and they’d likely have issues too ???

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:35

@Carebearstare12e That's because diagnosis is better now.

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 13:33

"There was a thread recently where a poster said disabled people should show a bit more gratitude"

That one crops up all the time often accompanied by a tale of a nice disabled person they know who is properly grateful and would never dream of doing anything that might put their own needs first.

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 13:32

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:23

There's this misconception that there are more disabled people around now. Not so long ago, people with disabilities were hidden away from a very young age in institutions. There was no help for families or any thought to integrate into society.
I was a support worker for a while and a few of the people I worked for were brought up in those institutions. So you can see, this happened in our lifetime.
I'm now a parent to a child with DS. Thankfully, I became a parent with my eyes wide open.
She is my absolute reason for living. It hasn't been easy fighting for the support that she needs. Thankfully, things are changing, albeit very slowly.

There are definitely more ND or ND diagnosed people around now than in the past.

A recent thread discussed this. You have teachers and SENCOs on these threads saying as many as 20-40% of children in their classes are deemed SEN. School statistics back this up.

It was never the case that 20-40% of the childhood population were in institutions. Never. Nowhere even near.

squareyedannie · 24/09/2023 13:23

There's this misconception that there are more disabled people around now. Not so long ago, people with disabilities were hidden away from a very young age in institutions. There was no help for families or any thought to integrate into society.
I was a support worker for a while and a few of the people I worked for were brought up in those institutions. So you can see, this happened in our lifetime.
I'm now a parent to a child with DS. Thankfully, I became a parent with my eyes wide open.
She is my absolute reason for living. It hasn't been easy fighting for the support that she needs. Thankfully, things are changing, albeit very slowly.

Carebearstare12e · 24/09/2023 13:23

gogomoto · 24/09/2023 11:42

Ableism is rife but there is also many forms of disability and one person's reasonable adjustment or action might be incredibly bad for another disabled person. My dd is hypersensitive to noise and the dc with adhd in her class caused her to drop out of school until she could go into separate provision, did their "they can't help it" trump her sensitivity (she's autistic). So I can understand why people are sometimes in two minds about inclusion. The reality is we need to be more understanding of each other, but be aware that things are always black and white (yes we have had to get off a bus because another person was vocally stimming, my dd could not cope with it)

Yep. The disability Olympics. Who wins?

At what point do there have to be ways to assess it in place, and criteria that should be met. Because otherwise the needs of one take precedence over the needs of the majority.

That's why quite often, the terms ND or disability become meaningless and there do have to be some kinds of ways to judge and provide for adjustments in place.

Givememyscreens · 24/09/2023 13:23

As for PIP, I'd qualify even though to others, I seem to cope with life fine. However, I struggle with housework, feeding myself and day to day self care, never mind bigger stuff like doing the garden or decorating a room. I'm working up to applying as I know that mentally, it's going to be tough.

Yes. Same. On the surface I appear to manage very well. Underneath its anything but. The level of anxiety I have about things that normal people would just roll their eyes at me about is debilitating. To mitigate, I have to plan and work up to doing basically anything. Going to the supermarket, taking the rubbish out, getting my hair done, going to work, anything social. Basically, leaving the house. I don’t have kids or a partner because I can’t cope with or maintain those relationships. I don’t really have friends…..just one or two that I work up to seeing for dinner every few months.

ALL of my energy goes on attempting to maintain / keep myself in employment because I have a mortgage and bills to pay.

anniegun · 24/09/2023 13:23

There was a thread recently where a poster said disabled people should show a bit more gratitude

Mabelface · 24/09/2023 13:12

This ignorance and ablism continues into the world of work. My company has amazing equality and diversity policies, but the amount of managers who don't do the training is astounding. I experienced this first hand and it made me very mentally ill. Some colleagues see reasonable adjustments as a perk, not a need and legal right.

I'm doing a lot of work now to make sure that no one else has to experience what I did, but I'm seeing the same thing over and over again.

As for PIP, I'd qualify even though to others, I seem to cope with life fine. However, I struggle with housework, feeding myself and day to day self care, never mind bigger stuff like doing the garden or decorating a room. I'm working up to applying as I know that mentally, it's going to be tough.

Givememyscreens · 24/09/2023 13:12

We had screens put up around our desks at work due to covid. Last week we were informed we could take them down now. I told one manager I would prefer to keep mine as they help buffer noise, visual distractions etc (I’m autistic and open plan offices are so so so difficult to work in). The manager was fine with this. A few days later I was working from home and the manager contacted me to tell me their manager has taken them all down, despite being told I would prefer to keep mine. This manager has basically dismissed/ignored what I asked for and knows I am diagnosed autistic. Now I’m going to have to be ‘that person’ and raise it to officially request them to go back up as a reasonable adjustment, and I’ll be seen as the awkward, trouble making complainer making everything difficult etc. There is no reason why the screens HAVE to be taken down but that’s what I’ll be told and then it will become a thing that I have to ‘fight’ for even though it’s such a simple, reasonable accommodation. It’s just exhausting.

I don’t get any financial support/benefits, nor would I try to, because I earn enough to pay for things that help me manage like a gardener, cleaner etc.
But to help prevent autistic burnout, anxiety, stress etc at work there are things that could be done to help make my working environment an easier place to be. Things that have zero impact on anyone else. Like letting me keep my screens up, not messing with my chair, having a place for people to go for teams calls instead of yelling on calls in the open plan office…..having small offices for those that don’t cope well in open plan spaces….they are the WORST idea ever for anyone but neurotypical people. I paid for my own noise cancelling headphones for wearing at work but I can’t always wear them. The working world is absolutely NOT set up with anyone but neurotypical, able people in mind. Small accommodations for people like me can make a massive difference in how well they cope with working but people just don’t really care.

x2boys · 24/09/2023 13:05

Prinnny · 24/09/2023 12:52

I think sometimes if you don’t promote inclusion without exception you can be branded as ‘hating disabled people’. The top and bottom of it is that not everything can be inclusive of all disabled people.

Mainstream school for example, yes adjustments can be made for children with physical disabilities but not for special needs children who are violent, they should not be in a mainstream school.

A little girl with autism was asked by the dance teacher to stop coming to my daughters dance school, she couldn’t learn the steps, couldn’t participate in the class, was just running around screaming, licking the mirror, distracting the other children etc. Does that mean the teacher hates disabled people? No it means the class was not appropriate for her.

Some disabled people can come across as entitled, like the poster who wanted her neighbour to get a different job and car so she wasn’t disturbed. Just as normal people can be entitled. Disability doesn’t mean you can’t not be a dick at times!

Everyone knows someone who claims benefits for carers or disability etc who is playing the system. It’s often in the media, obviously some people really can’t work and need to be supported by the state but there many who take the piss.

Some children with SEN manage very well.in mainstream school there shouldn't be a blanket ban and not all.of them are violent
My own son has always been in a special school.because his needs could never have Bern met in mainstream ,there are of course some children with SEN who.are in mainstream because there isn't any appropriate. Specialist provision for them but that's no their fault
I think its quite hard to play the system ,I think some peop!e ,try I have seen people on the various DLA groups I'm on on Facebook put in claims foe very tenuous reasons but they are mostly unsuccessful .

WhiteFire · 24/09/2023 13:03

TGGreen · 24/09/2023 10:37

I'm adult and not a pushover. I'm also ill enough that I automatically qualify for blue badges. The amount of times I've been abused for using these spaces tells me all I need to know about some people's feelings. If you've never experienced it you have no idea.
I feel for disabled children growing up. There is little real empathy, just lip service. Services are crashing under the weight of financial cuts and fear the future will only be harder and harder.
As unpalatable as Georgia is. She isn't alone in her vile opinions.

Is this other blue badge holders who think you are 'stealing' their space or a random gobshite walking past?

Prinnny · 24/09/2023 12:52

I think sometimes if you don’t promote inclusion without exception you can be branded as ‘hating disabled people’. The top and bottom of it is that not everything can be inclusive of all disabled people.

Mainstream school for example, yes adjustments can be made for children with physical disabilities but not for special needs children who are violent, they should not be in a mainstream school.

A little girl with autism was asked by the dance teacher to stop coming to my daughters dance school, she couldn’t learn the steps, couldn’t participate in the class, was just running around screaming, licking the mirror, distracting the other children etc. Does that mean the teacher hates disabled people? No it means the class was not appropriate for her.

Some disabled people can come across as entitled, like the poster who wanted her neighbour to get a different job and car so she wasn’t disturbed. Just as normal people can be entitled. Disability doesn’t mean you can’t not be a dick at times!

Everyone knows someone who claims benefits for carers or disability etc who is playing the system. It’s often in the media, obviously some people really can’t work and need to be supported by the state but there many who take the piss.

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2023 12:50

The worry from parents that the mainstream classroom might contain ‘SEN’ (not children, apparently) who will need unfair amounts of support with reading and writing, taking away from their own child (who perhaps can already write their own name etc. and thus obviously requires less support anyway)

That’s a legitimate concern but not the fault of the child at all. The resources are not there to help all the children unfortunately, but I can still extend sympathy for those parents who are frustrated their child has no extra help because they are ‘not the worse’. That was said to me by my child’s school SENCO and fired me into helping my child off my own back which has been extremely rewarding.

ASimpleLampoon · 24/09/2023 12:47

I'm willing to get that those 61% who are voting YABU are not disabled, don't have a disabled child and are simply outraged at having their bullshit called out.

Rubicon101 · 24/09/2023 12:44

I agree with you. My son is Autistic and during Christmas a photographer came in to take individual photos at nursery. The photographer said something a long the lines of "what is he doing?" And then turned to DS and said "what are you doing hey? What's all that for?" When DS started stimming, even though we explained beforehand he is Autistic and will sit there but wont be great with instructions. Could tell the photographer was getting fed up

YourMommaWasASnowblower · 24/09/2023 12:41

I think the modern world is very self-absorbed, entitled and nasty. Social media has encouraged these 3 traits in people. The end result being that people can’t see beyond themselves so can’t understand what a disabled person goes through, because people are very entitled they don’t like seeing anyone getting something that they can’t have (even though it would mean having a disability to get it) and people are nasty towards disabled people because it’s a trait that’s encouraged in our society.
People have lost their humanity.
I think it’s not just disabled people who get treated this way by people, people with chronic long term health conditions (like me) get treated the same way.