Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that disabled people are hated?

292 replies

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 23:59

Yes, I know that it was apparently very uplifting when I was planning a party for my disabled DS and his classmates from special school. When I was putting in all the hard work by myself to make it happen it was admirable and my DS and his friends were adorable.

But there have been so many threads here complaining about the way disabled children use up resources- in school, in clubs, in sports. So much hatred for the fact that disability is sometimes, inadequately, accommodated. So much blame and disdain for parents of disabled kids. So much anger at the unfairness and injustice(!) being suffered by the ‘normal’ kids, the functioning kids, the able kids when they are forced to encounter a disabled peer.

AIBU to think that this is people showing their true colours; that in fact the world is as full of hatred for disabled people as I’ve always feared?

OP posts:
TigerRag · 24/09/2023 07:57

TheLightProgramme · 24/09/2023 07:46

I will try to be really honest here.

I struggle with the blanlet term "disabled" and the wide spectrum this covers.

When i was a child, "disabled" referred primarily to physical disability and was predominantly used for people with quite severe conditions.

Now it is used for everything from a wheelchair bound, incontinent child with cerebral palsy, to a fully verbal mainstream educated person with a spouse & well paid job, who on first glance many of us won't have any clue of their disability.

It used to be about having ramps in buildings and braille on bus stops, now it can feel like the autism/ND agenda is at the forefront and its a very different set of needs that are not as well understood

It's not "wheelchair bound" it's "wheelchair user" / "uses a wheelchair".

Why shouldn't the term "disabled" cover everything? That mainstream educated married person could have something like a brain injury which does (talking from experience) cause disability. Their needs are just as valid.

Frickinghell · 24/09/2023 07:55

I dont agree with your POV. I dont feel this way and have never talked to anyone who feels this either.

i have a friend of a friend (early 20s, im 40s) who has three children now. Her first is autistic non verbal and hits out/bites etc. shes had a lot of help adapting her house, has a mobility car and the child has just started at a school specifically for the childs needs. I mean this friend has a lot on her plate. Shes only young but I applaud her. She is amazing and resilient. I feel she is getting the support she needs from family/friends all agencies involved. The children are well cared for. I dont feel any resentment at all for her help/support. To do that would be utter madness

clpsmum · 24/09/2023 07:52

Not rtft yet but totally agree with you OP

Ilovenicnacs · 24/09/2023 07:48

hattie43 · 24/09/2023 07:05

Cancelling debate is not the answer . Georgia has put her point across eloquently and although unpalatable it's her right to say it . We either have free speech in this country or we don't .
FWIW I think MN gives a skewed perspective on how many SEN
children there are . In my whole adult life I have met one diagnosed autistic man . Yet MN would have me thinking every third child was SEN , some of whom the parents seem to have diagnosed .

My empathy goes to the parents because I've read some absolutely horrific threads of the lives some are leading as a result of SEN children . I absolutely know I wouldn't cope .
The other problem is that the country is broke and when peoples own needs aren't met they turn on others who will disproportionately take but never put back . Same could be said for some non working adults though .

I don't know any adults with a diagnosis of autism (or at least have shared it with me) but as a teacher, between 20-40% of the children my primary classes over the last 8 years have SEN. MN maybe slightly exaggerates how many children have SEN but it is not entirely inaccurate, in my experience at least.

I didn't think we lived in an abilist society until I had a wheelchair user in my class and parents complained on sports day about the adapted races that enabled him to take part 😡

Cubic · 24/09/2023 07:48

@Pollyputhekettleon I've just looked for the thread but can't find it. Can you post a link please?

I have a severely disabled child, 2:1 support, respite, inde school etc the majority fought for via tribunal, Jr etc.

I believe it's a mixture of reasons. The biggest being money or lack of it. Cost of living, lack of funding for services, increase in service users, covid, reduction of Special schools, some parents ensuring their rights while other parents are too tired to, more people being classed as disabled and more people with nd.

Some people don't like others to have more or perceive accommodations as preferential treatment. School ta's are a really good example of this. Why should a child get a dedicated ta to access school and education that they are legally entitled to when a child that doesn't need a ta would do so much better if they had 1:1 support? I've heard this a few times. I've also heard "imagine how many children in a mainstream school could be helped if your child's funding was given to the school" from a mainstream teacher when I moved ds to specialist inde school.

Other crackers "do you really want your child on there with the normal kids?", "whats wrong with him?", "I wish my child had a blue badge so I could park there", "he sounds like a monkey" I could go on.

TheLightProgramme · 24/09/2023 07:46

I will try to be really honest here.

I struggle with the blanlet term "disabled" and the wide spectrum this covers.

When i was a child, "disabled" referred primarily to physical disability and was predominantly used for people with quite severe conditions.

Now it is used for everything from a wheelchair bound, incontinent child with cerebral palsy, to a fully verbal mainstream educated person with a spouse & well paid job, who on first glance many of us won't have any clue of their disability.

It used to be about having ramps in buildings and braille on bus stops, now it can feel like the autism/ND agenda is at the forefront and its a very different set of needs that are not as well understood

itsmeafterall · 24/09/2023 07:45

Hello everyone.

I'm an able bodied person and I'm finding the posts on here a real shock and quite distressing. I've never seen incidents described here - spitting on people in wheelchairs, abuse for using disabled parking spaces etc. I fully believe they happen though. It's really shocking and awful.

I just wanted to say that if ever I witness anything like that I'd wade right in to support you. I hope that other decent MNers would too. We shouldn't have to though.

It's important that we all call out shitty, discriminatory behaviour in all of its forms. It's essential that we educate our kids and normalise the differences between people.

Finally, I do think that a lot of shifty attitudes stem from the government and the policies that demonise people who need additional support for daily living. The whole narrative around 'there isn't enough money' (there is, they just choose to spend it elsewhere) and the deliberate starving of funds to state schools, social services , councils etc all cause a 'dog eat dog' mindset where we poor suckers at the bottom have to scrap it out for the unnecessarily meagre resources they deign to 'give' us. It creates division, it dehumanises people and it sends an abhorrent signal out that some of our society are less valuable or, worse, a burden.

My view is that all people, whatever their physical or mental condition all have a part to play in our society. Everyone deserves a decent, happy life. Loved, safe, warm, fed, comfortable and respected for who they are.

We need a government that leads with that message and puts it's money where it's mouth is. Lead with respect and people will eventually follow. I hope. In the meantime if I see any nasty bastards doing shitty stuff, I'll be there to tell them to feck off. Smile

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 07:30

No one actually believes that 'disabled people are hated'. For anyone wanting to know what this is really about you'll want to see the post on inclusion not working.

TigerRag · 24/09/2023 07:28

I've noticed it's got worse after covid.

I've got an ongoing complaint against a company because no one can be bothered to use their brains which causes me all kinds of problems. (I'm told to find staff on the train. I don't get an answer how a visually impaired person I do this) I'm told time and time again it won't happen again...it happens the following week. I'm told by a "friend" who deals with the same company but different branch she doesn't get my issue because she's never had problems. I'm lucky nothing serious has happened yet. But I'm concerned it will.

DiddyRa · 24/09/2023 07:25

I’ve also reported the above comment (sorry page froze and can’t see username. One who referred to disabled children as feral etc)

reallyworriedjobhunter · 24/09/2023 07:19

Cherryana · 24/09/2023 07:05

I think there is a whole range of disabilities but one of the problems in mainstream education is the environment.

It works on conformity. Everyone in. Do this at the same time. Do that by the end of that hour. Leave.

Small margins of that can be accommodated. Needs beyond that and the system breaks down quickly.

Add in most teachers do not have learning difficulties to an extent that hindered them from learning to a high level - and they really don’t have a comprehension of what it’s like to not be able to just get on.

Then add the political background of poor funding and you have set up a system that doesn’t have the man power to cope with difference.

It’s a perfect storm for picking a people
group and blaming all the issues on them.

I am sorry, hopefully along the way, you will find people who show you kindness.

100 per cent.

My disabled daughter tried a new activity yesterday and after one session I have withdrawn her immediately.

The teachers/leaders are professionals but had absolutely no idea about how to include her despite me talking to them in advance. It just doesn't make sense to them. They don't see it.

I just don't have the energy to educate them - I have so much other shit to deal with.

For them there is one way to be and if you don't fit, nothing is done to change the situation.

It's exhausting and so depressing.

PriOn1 · 24/09/2023 07:16

“There was a tricky one with this woman complaining about a selfish neighbour who was stopping her sleeping.”

Was this the woman who needed to sleep a lot and thought her neighbour should change her job or park further away and walk to her car in the dark (presumably disturbing someone else as well) because her neighbour starts work at 4am every morning and has an older car that she starts for a few minutes to warm it up?

I don’t think it was the neighbour being selfish.

I’m with @MrsTerryPratchett in thinking that at least part of this comes from a lack of funding. Everyone ends up being angry with everyone else and everyone is suffering.

I’m really sad though about the ableism that does, genuinely exist though. Shocked at the suggestion we should have aborted our children with autistic spectrum disorders. Given that problems during birthing are generally implicated, rather than it being simply genetic, any spare money might be better spent on improving maternity services.

And I’m sorry for all those who’ve experienced horrible things. Comments on the bus? Just why? Unnecessary commenters can fuck right off with that.

nether · 24/09/2023 07:12

Most people are fine.

But there are enough who aren't fine to make things horrible sometimes.

I have an immediate family member who is critically vulnerable to covid. The number of people who actively agree with perpetual isolation for them is horrifying.

(And no, before someone annoying pops up to say "but that must be true for every infection - no it sodding well isn't, because of treatment options)

hattie43 · 24/09/2023 07:05

Cancelling debate is not the answer . Georgia has put her point across eloquently and although unpalatable it's her right to say it . We either have free speech in this country or we don't .
FWIW I think MN gives a skewed perspective on how many SEN
children there are . In my whole adult life I have met one diagnosed autistic man . Yet MN would have me thinking every third child was SEN , some of whom the parents seem to have diagnosed .

My empathy goes to the parents because I've read some absolutely horrific threads of the lives some are leading as a result of SEN children . I absolutely know I wouldn't cope .
The other problem is that the country is broke and when peoples own needs aren't met they turn on others who will disproportionately take but never put back . Same could be said for some non working adults though .

Cherryana · 24/09/2023 07:05

I think there is a whole range of disabilities but one of the problems in mainstream education is the environment.

It works on conformity. Everyone in. Do this at the same time. Do that by the end of that hour. Leave.

Small margins of that can be accommodated. Needs beyond that and the system breaks down quickly.

Add in most teachers do not have learning difficulties to an extent that hindered them from learning to a high level - and they really don’t have a comprehension of what it’s like to not be able to just get on.

Then add the political background of poor funding and you have set up a system that doesn’t have the man power to cope with difference.

It’s a perfect storm for picking a people
group and blaming all the issues on them.

I am sorry, hopefully along the way, you will find people who show you kindness.

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 07:04

@MyHornCanPierceTheSky I don't know if there is a petition to be honest. I'm complaining to the Merlin attraction direct at the moment.

To cut this short you need to apply for a ride access pass 7 days before you go (did) they send you an email to say you can upgrade up a access card (£15 - did) and link the two. You then have to queue (ironic) at the park to get the ride access pass printed. The ride access card and so called upgraded access card are useless there. You need to download their app. Except their signal is awful. So you'd queue again to get a mobile device from them to get the QR code to access the rides.

The rides then "sell out" so if you go later in the day all the good rides are gone thus making the park useless for any disabled guests who can't get there early enough to get a QR code. I was kicked off a ride after using my upgraded pass which my son was very upset about. The whole thing is a joke and it is discrimination. It might seem minor but that is just part of the problem. It is huge to my son. It's such a shame because we came to Disneyland Paris and they got it so right, it can be done.

Dogsitterwoes · 24/09/2023 06:56

@GeorgiaGirl52 so you learned on Mumsnet that it's appropriate to describe disabled children as feral? And you think people get financial incentives to have disabled children? I have to assume you don't know what the word incentive means.

I think you may have a point about schooling provision in the US. I know a UK family who have decided to stay there long term as the support their autistic child gets at school is far better, they believe, than that available in the UK. Although the child is in a mainstream, not special, school.

I'm not disabled myself but have witnessed openly horrendous behaviour towards disabled people, and know that must be the tip of the iceberg.

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 06:51

@hattie43 yes you are right. I saw that post and I saw red. Obviously, misjudged as my son doesn't read Mumsnet (he can't read full stop). But to have someone say "feral" about disabled children (or adults) is horrific and I was offended and upset.

I love my son to pieces and the secondary message of I could have just aborted him hurt further.

Lastly, the notion that I'm lucky I get DLA funding for him just baffles me. I lost a good friend who couldn't see that I will always be financially worse off then their two income family. I am a single mum of a disabled child. DLA doesn't make up a whole extra income and it isn't mine. It is my son's to provide therapies and support /supplies for him.

SiliconHeaven · 24/09/2023 06:37

There you go @AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman proof right on the thread. Parents should have aborted their disabled children to stop them using up all the resources.
reported @GeorgiaGirl52 ‘s horrible post

hattie43 · 24/09/2023 06:36

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 02:29

@GeorgiaGirl52 I've reported your post. Your language to describe autistic children is horrific. Take it from a mother of a non verbal autistic child. I use his DLA to pay for speech therapy because the NHS will not help him. I'm desperate for him to talk and I'm doing everything I can. His brain doesn't function like a NT person and he does have meltdowns. It's a balancing act every day.

So how very dare you come onto this thread and berate parents and children who have these very real challenges day in day out. You haven't lived it. It may be your opinion but honestly walk in someone else's shoes for years on end and then come back and use that language again. Disgraceful.

Cancelling out a view you don't like is not the answer on a thread discussing why people are intolerable of disabled people . Unpalatable to you or not it stifles debate and there will be others who share Georgias views .

ClusterFukt · 24/09/2023 06:33

I don’t hate disabled people. I am not physically disabled but I am neurodivergent. What I hate is that there is no funding to properly support the autistic children I work with mainstream school.
They are constantly triggered by their environment, their peers and the adults who can’t let them do the unsafe things they’re driven to do. I am being hit, kicked, strangled, bitten and bruised on a daily basis because we can’t meet their needs, their peers are also being hurt and they are hurting themselves. Do I hate them? No. It’s not their fault. The system is fucked. No one is able to get their needs met, ND or NT no one is a winner in this situation. I want to be able to keep all of our pupils safe regardless of their abilities, I want to be able to keep myself and my colleagues safe. I want to create environments where everyone has the opportunity to learn and develop. The current system is fucked. That’s what I hate with a passion. Not any child or adult with a disability.

Floogal · 24/09/2023 06:24

Actually a lot of it on Mumsnet. Especially towards men who may be neurodiverse. And how they're icky, creepy, immature etc
There was a tricky one with this woman complaining about a selfish neighbour who was stopping her sleeping.
Also, there seems to be a general consensus that disabled people have easier lives. Noticed that at school

Clymene · 24/09/2023 06:20

What test @GeorgiaGirl52?

Spikeyball · 24/09/2023 06:13

It's not helped by professionals making assumptions that because a child has particular disabilities, they must be doing or not doing certain things and if a parent says otherwise, the parent is lying.
Due to unavoidable family circumstances we have had heavy involvement from health and social care recently and the amount of discriminatory attitude from them has been unbelievable.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 24/09/2023 05:25

Peanutbuttercrunchy · 24/09/2023 02:21

I think you're right. The world is becoming less tolerant and more intent on trying to get disabled people to conform to a "normal" and therefore "fair" society. I saw it at a merlin attraction this month. They are making it harder for disabled people to access their rides and quite clearly don't give a fuck.

I'm confident that it is all in aid of reducing queue times for the able bodied guests. But what doesn't seem to be recognised is queuing can be extremely difficult for many people with disabilities. Life is extremely difficult for many people with disabilities.

My own son struggles for a variety of reasons. He struggles every single day and he will for the rest of his life.

Merlin now want to exclude him from something he loves because of his disability to make it fair to everyone. Where is the fairness to him, because I only see discrimination.

What on earth are they doing and is there a petition against it?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread