Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seeing lots of single child family

309 replies

Guffpuff · 23/09/2023 18:44

We went for a long walk today around a reservoir. It's quite a popular place. We saw a large number of single child families. We feel that it's becoming more and more common now. Could be due to Cost of living and inflation or mix of lots of reasons.
Is this something you're observing as well?

OP posts:
bakewellbride · 23/09/2023 22:12

How do you know they were single child families at the reservoir? It's impossible to be sure. Could've had an older child but not with them on that particular outing, lots of other explanations.

ThePlantKiller · 23/09/2023 22:09

mrsDracoMalfoy · 23/09/2023 19:02

Best not too assume. If you saw us walking round with our 7 year old, you'd assume they're an only child. However there is a big age gap and their mother older sibling is 17. Don't assume what you don't know.

Agree, my DS is 13, DD is 8. DS is out with friends all the time now so if I'm out and about it's usually just with DD.

Joeylove88 · 23/09/2023 22:02

I have recently turned 35 and have a 10 month old DD who is perfect. I honestly don't know how I feel about having a second child yet. We are a very solid family unit of 3 and have lots of fun and I don't feel an urge to have another, at least yet! I ideally wanted to wait until DD was 3 to make it easier to have a newborn baby when she was close to being ready for school but I might feel too old to do pregnancy and birth again I don't know. If I end up only having one then it wouldn't necessarily be for financial reasons it would be most likely because I haven't felt the need to have anymore. If it feels right then I would do it again but I wouldn't go through it all again just to give my DD a sibling.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 23/09/2023 22:01

I know a woman who is an only and she married an only (both are now in their 60s so was not as common back then). They had 4 children. Their kids have no Aunts, no Uncles, no Cousins. I always thought that seemed kind of sad.

ETA: This message was in reply to @Comedycook 's post. For some reason it didnt include their quote.

AmazingSnakeHead · 23/09/2023 21:49

I think that the increasing age of parents plays into this. If you have your first at 24, as was the norm 50 years ago, you have a good 15+ years of fertility ahead you in which to have a second. If you have your first late 30s/early 40s, then of course it's have them close together or stick to one.

For my part, I really wanted two. But a number of things happened. My relationship with DP took a real nosedive. After DC was born he turned controlling, prone to rage and on top of that he doesn't pull his weight with DC. I decided that I couldn't put myself and existing DC through the experience of parenting with him again. But it's not only that. I feel that it's already a lot to juggle my life with work, family, etc. I don't enjoy the drudgery of parenting, and a second would bring with it even more drudgery for not much more reward. I would also have to move house to afford somewhere with two rooms, which I don't want to do.

blahblahblah1654 · 23/09/2023 21:30

I'd love to have 2 but I think we'll have to stop at 1 as it would be dangerous for me to try again health wise after 2 losses and complications. A few of my friends are content with the 1. 2 is very costly.

Goldencup · 23/09/2023 21:25

GreyhpundGirl · 23/09/2023 19:13

I have an only. For a number of reasons. We were ambivalent about having any (if it happens, it happens. If it doesn't it doesn't) We're older parents. We don't qualify for government support, nor do we live near family- she only has one grandparent who is 3-4 hours away. We had an amazing life travelling the world etc before her and want to be able to share that with her, which is very different to my childhood (basically no family holidays dropped off at grandparent in Somerset or Lake District) . Plus although my pregnancy and birth were problem free, I can't imagine choosing to go through that again.

This must be a generational thing. The financial arguments I totally get, that is a large part of why we stopped at 2. But not wanting to go through pregnancy again I cannot relate to at all. DD (DS2) is 17 next month I still sometimes feel sad I will never be pregnant or breast feed again.

PuzzledWatermelon · 23/09/2023 21:14

We have one child which we were incredibly lucky to have fallen pregnant with naturally (took 2.5 years) We thought we would have a second but it just never happened naturally over the years my child was a toddler/young school age. I was then diagnosed with a chronic incurable illness two years ago, so my husband and I made the decision for him to have the snip because for me to fall pregnant now would endanger both mine and baby’s lives.

As it happens in my child’s year group at school, she is one of two only children - all of the other children in her year group have siblings.

I do find it easier to organise my child’s activities (both in and out of school) and all the finances associated with those activities (breakfast club, swimming lessons, karate, etc), compared to other parents who have two or more children. I find my life less stressful with one (less stress is needed for my medical condition anyway) so maybe in some ways it was the universe’s way of telling me not to have a second child, if that makes sense?

Please don’t assume all parents with one child actually wanted to stop at one - in some cases it will be reasons that were out of their control.

IDontLikeMondays88 · 23/09/2023 21:08

Apparently around 50% of families have only one child. So it kind of quite normal I think. It’s a myth that it’s not the norm iyswim

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 23/09/2023 21:07

Yes - I've 6 "best friends" from different stages of my life, who are not friends with each other. All 38-45. 1 has 2 children and 1 is expecting her first. The other 4 have said they are unlikely to have any.

Uggtrending · 23/09/2023 21:07

@User342465662 I think parenthood changes your life so much I would of had the 2nd with a 3/4 age gap in hindsight. Even if you have 1 child your relationship changes anymore than 2 DC then I do agree with most of what you're saying. A sibling bind is nice not just growing up but it's later on in life too whilst there's no guarantees usually 2 siblings do get along fine.

PumpkinPie2016 · 23/09/2023 21:06

I haven't noticed it within my local area. I live in a very middle class village but most families have at least 2.

We have one by choice but certainly seem to be the exception where we live.

The wider town is very deprived in places but there are lots of larger families with 3+ children.

On holiday in Austria this summer, I saw far more one child families. Felt less 'odd one out' there.

For us, it was partly that DS delivery was difficult and the baby year very tough. I didn't want to do it again.

There is also the financial consideration, although we are comfortably off. Childcare/food/clothes/hobbies/holidays. Then as he gets older, uni costs/driving lessons/support with a house. I don't think we could afford to support more than one child.

SaySomethingMan · 23/09/2023 21:06

Like @mrsDracoMalfoy says, other sibling (s) could be away doing their own thing with friends, staying at home, etc etc

I find it interesting that many people from non-white cultural backgrounds are still having 4/5 children regularly. It’ll be interesting to see the effect on the british demographic in the decades to come.

Out of interest, are people from area with say very strong or protestant backgrounds also having 1 child, out of choice? I do wonder

SisterJo · 23/09/2023 21:03

I don’t think you can know if they’re one child families. We’re often out and about with only 2 kids, but we actually have 4.

It’s also not my experience. I worked out the average child per family of my son’s class (inspired by the fact someone is expecting twins) and it’s over 3 kids per family! Only one, 1-child family in the class. I suspect what is more common are the people choosing to have none at all. Many of my old school friends (who are now nearly past it) have not had kids.

Sapphire387 · 23/09/2023 21:03

I have four - but an unusual journey. DH and I both previously widowed, so I have two children from my previous relationship, DH has a daughter- my DSD- and we have a baby daughter together. She might appear to be an only as she grows up, as the age gap to the others is around 10 years. I am about to turn 38 and not intending to have any more! But enjoying our large family despite the chaos.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 23/09/2023 21:01

I think you are seeing what you want to see. Some of them might have other children elsewhere. I usually only have one with me as the other one is at school. Most families I know have two, some have three. Not many only children.

Holly60 · 23/09/2023 21:01

I have adult children but my kids and their friends overwhelmingly have 2 children. I'm thinking of their friendship group of say 10 couples each and I think I can maybe think of 1 family between them who have more than two kids. I can think of a few who have none.

Two kids seems the standard in their circles. No onlies and very few 3 or above. A few with none. Interesting...

ginandtonicwithlimes · 23/09/2023 21:00

seven201 · 23/09/2023 19:40

There are only two one child family in my dd's class of 30 kids. Currently we are the third, but I'm due a second soonish with a 7 1/2 year age gap due to secondary infertility and recurrent losses, we wanted a 2 year gap. Most people I know have two, some three. So I've not seen this where I live. I guess women leaving it later to have dc and that affecting fertility for a second could be a factor.

Don't mind me saying but not everyone who has fertility issues leaves it late. Plenty of younger women have IVF. I was 29 when I started IVF and 30 when I had my first. 35 when I had my second. 25 when we started TTC. This isn't unusual.

Mulhollandmagoo · 23/09/2023 20:59

We are a single child family, for lots of reasons. I had quite crippling PND after she was born, and that definitely changed my mind, before I had her I would have said I would have 2/3 kids. Also, we have a decent sized but not massive 3 bed semi, and one room is a box room - perfect size for 3, tight squeeze for 4. Same goes for cars/holidays/days out.

We earn fairly decently, but we're not rolling in it, but we can live a comfortable life, and kids are expensive to raise, so sticking at one will mean we can probably retire earlier 🤣

MaybeOneAndDone · 23/09/2023 20:57

User342465662 · 23/09/2023 19:43

Single child is fantastic! You get to experience motherhood but also have your own life, identity and earning power back as soon as possible. It's much easier to arrange childcare with grandparents and you have to deal with the lowest number of potential sick days.

Also borderline unpopular opinion...many marriages crack and break under the strain of two or more kids. It's a cumulative effect of too many years of sleep deprivation, babies, toddlers, mess and stress. The mother isn't in best shape after consecutive pregnancies and she might not be feeling the best about her body etc. People muddle through for years and eventually realise there's nothing left.

Having one baby is already enough of an upheaval in a relationship. However being one and done means you can work through issues and spend time alone before it really goes pear shaped. DH and I have been going on kid-free holidays 3 times a year since DD was 3. Usually only 3-4 nights but it's amazing and brings the spark back into marriage.

This is tremendously helpful as it resonates with why I think I should stick with one.

I also agree that a second kid can be the straw that breaks the camel's back in many marriages. If you've got lots of local family support, or one spouse is really happy to quit or scale back their career, then I think a marriage can survive a second child, but if both parents are trying to maintain their careers, and have no village to rely on, then the second child means they are just spread too thin and can't cope.

I think my DS would prefer to be in a home with two happy parents who are still together as opposed to getting a sibling but having his parents divorce a year or so later.

Uggtrending · 23/09/2023 20:56

@mrsDracoMalfoy true lol! I have a brother 2.8 then two younger sisters both 10 and 10+ agr gap. We are all full siblings too. The only children were probably born before this most recent COL anyway.

SpaceRaiders · 23/09/2023 20:51

@RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway I suspect as it’s a private school my observations are skewed somewhat because finance’s definitely come into play. I wouldn’t feel guilty however, I’m one of 5 and I’m very close to 3 not so much the other one. And I hear the same from other large families.

What I notice though is those with only’s are far more structured with their time. They specifically plan opportunities for their children is socialise. Where as I tend to be more relaxed as they entertain fight each other mostly. 😂

TheLightProgramme · 23/09/2023 20:50

would have to drag the other child to his rugby/swimming/whatever clubs. So each child would end up doing half as many, just because I can’t be in two places at once.

Somehow though it just isn't like this for us. My two have swimming & tennis at the same time. Eldest loves the half hour he and i have together while youngest is in ballet. We chat, digest the week, play card games. No one is dragged anywhere. When we have to go two places, DH takes one & i take the other.

Both are honestly happy with it because they love having each other

Tohaveandtohold · 23/09/2023 20:48

In my circle, people mainly have 2 children but with a large age gap so you can easily think they are a one child family.
For example there’s 6 years between DD1 and DD2 and this was mainly because of childcare fee and we wanted to save when DD1 started getting her free hours then and that’s like the same as most of our friends.
DD2 just started school but if you see me, you’ll think we’re a one child family because she’s going to a different school from her sibling and their activities and clubs are so different so someone goes out with just one of them most times.

TheLightProgramme · 23/09/2023 20:46

I have to say though, i had various issues that meant a third wasnt possible and it does make me sad at times that i'll probably only end up with 3 or 4 grandkids.

My two get along really well, I can't imagine either as an only child!