Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seeing lots of single child family

309 replies

Guffpuff · 23/09/2023 18:44

We went for a long walk today around a reservoir. It's quite a popular place. We saw a large number of single child families. We feel that it's becoming more and more common now. Could be due to Cost of living and inflation or mix of lots of reasons.
Is this something you're observing as well?

OP posts:
Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 22:46

I think this thread is for middle class people. No wonder you think you can’t afford more than one child if you are paying their uni fees, weddings and house deposits! I will be expecting my kids to get a part time job at 16 and learn to save up and contribute to their own future. Same way me and my siblings did, we have our own homes paid for ourselves. Important life lesson imo. How much do you think clubs cost? I’m not talking horse riding I’m talking hockey, athletics , swimming it doesn’t cost a fortune to have two kids if you are not buying everything for them post 18 . We are not rich but our kids don’t miss out on anything they have holidays , clubs, days out, we just have realistic expectations of what they need, which does not include private school! 🙄

Mushroo · 24/09/2023 22:36

Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/09/2023 21:28

My kids all worked and paid for driving lessons, cars, uni costs and house deposits.
No reason why yours or anyone else's should do the same.

They could, but scrimping for a house deposit (we live in London) is depressing and I’d prefer they didn’t have to - I’ll probably offer to match what they save. I don’t feel I ‘gained’ anything from living in terrible rentals.

I generally feel things are getting harder to each generation, so if I can give my child a step up, why wouldn’t I. Things are just becoming less and less affordable - so whilst I paid for my own driving lessons, I can see it’s harder to do the same now. The driving lessons is also just an example, I may or may not end up paying for them. My life would just generally be financial less stressful with one.

It’s so individual though and I’m still on the fence if it’s the right decision, and if a sibling would be better!

PurpleWisteria1 · 24/09/2023 22:14

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 20:56

I agree. I hear a lot of parents with one child say they want to give their child their undivided attention...honestly I'd rather have my sister than more one to one attention from my parents whilst growing up. We had a blast!

Absolutely. Both my father and my MIL were only children with undivided attention. It shows.

LlynTegid · 24/09/2023 21:53

I'm not seeing it myself. If it is the case, I wonder if later starting of a family than say in the last century has a part to play, as both female and male fertility declines with age.

Piglet89 · 24/09/2023 21:49

I reckon there are many more single child families now because women are much less willing to do the bloody hard graft of caring for (particularly young) children, the lion’s share of which they inevitably seem to be lumped with.

they have one and are like “I am NOT fucking doing that again”.

PaprikaPlease · 24/09/2023 21:41

@Daisybuttercup12345 probably missing the point a bit here but I’ve been following along and can’t believe how many parents are prepared to pay for their children’s driving lessons! Would never have crossed my mind!

WaitingfortheTardis · 24/09/2023 21:32

@Daisybuttercup12345 No there isn't, but it is okay to make that choice.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 24/09/2023 21:28

Mushroo · 23/09/2023 18:51

Im about to have my first and always assumed I’d have two, but then I factor in:
2x nursery fees, holiday costs, after school clubs, hobbies, food, uniforms, phones for teenagers, uni costs, driving lessons and house deposits and it financially makes no sense.

So I’m currently on the fence mainly due to cost of everything!

My kids all worked and paid for driving lessons, cars, uni costs and house deposits.
No reason why yours or anyone else's should do the same.

Badseedmum · 24/09/2023 21:20

TheLightProgramme · 23/09/2023 20:46

I have to say though, i had various issues that meant a third wasnt possible and it does make me sad at times that i'll probably only end up with 3 or 4 grandkids.

My two get along really well, I can't imagine either as an only child!

I always find statements like this totally bizarre. The more children you have doesn't automatically mean more grandchildren. I find it mind boggling people would want more children just to increase your odds of having grandchildren. You may well find neither of your children have kids or they have 3 each.

My mum has 3 children and one grandchild and it will probably stay that way. She has a friend who has one child and three grandchildren!

Guffpuff · 24/09/2023 21:11

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 20:53

I just want to say having one and two cost wise doesn’t really feel any different. If you have two close together (less than three ur gap then I imagine it’s harder if you need to pay two x nursery fees ) but three year gap or more and there is free child care for one so I don’t feel it made any difference. I have a 6 yr gap I would have preferred a smaller gap but that’s how it worked out. Also the argument about clubs doesn’t work either , my dd is very sporty you just split time one parent takes one and the other takes the other child so they don’t miss out. I’ve never felt poorer for having two kids. I think the truth is people only want one child because it’s EASIER. We certainly had that debate by time dd1 was 5 should we have another now as life is quite easy, we’d got through the sleepless nights , the tiredness , grandparents would willingly babysit one child who slept through the night , we would quite often go out for dinner / cinema. When you have two it’s much harder to get any time alone , grandparents don’t want to have the one that doesn’t sleep well and is hectic. You are busier and more stressed with two but I would not trade it. I think to be honest we are all missing out by not having bigger families. The more I think of it ,it’s quite sad the thought of someone not having cousins. Cousins are your first best friends. My niece and my dd are extremely close as are my son and his male cousin. I don’t think you realise the importance of extended family in later life.

Cost being the same argument is wrong factually. Sending two to nursery costs double. For 1 child our cost is £1400. For two, it would be 2800. My friends send kids to private school, for one it's £1500 pm, for two it's £3000 pm. This is just the childcare and education aspect of it. Similarly for clubs, it would be double.
Also, I have around 20 cousins in total from both parents side who all are at least 10 years or more older to me and yes, there's nothing I can relate to them. So, no cousins don't matter in everyone's life. It's not universal fact.

OP posts:
WaitingfortheTardis · 24/09/2023 21:02

@Whippetlovely I find your comments quite sad, I'm an only child and never felt I missed out. Dd is also an only child and seems perfectly happy to be so.

Also, you may not find it more expensive, but it depends what you choose to do. If you have a second child certain costs will likely double - clubs, school trips, parties and birthday gifts, Christmas gifts (though I suppose these can be shared), driving lessons, uni accommodation, house deposit, wedding...

Dd has always been easy so far, it certainly isn't the 'stressful' aspect that has formed the basis of our decision to stick with one child. We are simply close and happy as a three.

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 20:56

PurpleWisteria1 · 24/09/2023 20:51

Gosh, I don’t see it that way at all.
Having a sibling to me is one of tue greatest opportunities there is. Teaches the child so much. Of course siblings might have nothing to do with each other when they grow up - or they might be everything to one another- that’s the chance. But what an amazing chance it is!

I agree. I hear a lot of parents with one child say they want to give their child their undivided attention...honestly I'd rather have my sister than more one to one attention from my parents whilst growing up. We had a blast!

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 20:53

I just want to say having one and two cost wise doesn’t really feel any different. If you have two close together (less than three ur gap then I imagine it’s harder if you need to pay two x nursery fees ) but three year gap or more and there is free child care for one so I don’t feel it made any difference. I have a 6 yr gap I would have preferred a smaller gap but that’s how it worked out. Also the argument about clubs doesn’t work either , my dd is very sporty you just split time one parent takes one and the other takes the other child so they don’t miss out. I’ve never felt poorer for having two kids. I think the truth is people only want one child because it’s EASIER. We certainly had that debate by time dd1 was 5 should we have another now as life is quite easy, we’d got through the sleepless nights , the tiredness , grandparents would willingly babysit one child who slept through the night , we would quite often go out for dinner / cinema. When you have two it’s much harder to get any time alone , grandparents don’t want to have the one that doesn’t sleep well and is hectic. You are busier and more stressed with two but I would not trade it. I think to be honest we are all missing out by not having bigger families. The more I think of it ,it’s quite sad the thought of someone not having cousins. Cousins are your first best friends. My niece and my dd are extremely close as are my son and his male cousin. I don’t think you realise the importance of extended family in later life.

PurpleWisteria1 · 24/09/2023 20:51

FlyingSoap · 23/09/2023 19:18

I guess also, having a second is consciously making a decision to halve the opportunities you can provide to your first. Time, money, energy, opportunities. That might be a good lesson to learn. Or it might alter their opportunities if you are average or below average earners and wanted to continue working full time.

Gosh, I don’t see it that way at all.
Having a sibling to me is one of tue greatest opportunities there is. Teaches the child so much. Of course siblings might have nothing to do with each other when they grow up - or they might be everything to one another- that’s the chance. But what an amazing chance it is!

Vettrianofan · 24/09/2023 20:38

CaramelicedLatte · 24/09/2023 18:53

You’re seeing a lot of families out with one child. That’s not the same. If you’d observed my family out for a walk today you’d think we were a one and done family. Actually our daughter is the youngest of four, but her siblings didn’t fancy coming today and are old enough to stay home.

I had my youngest out today on one trip, and DH had the older three out on a separate trip. This is often how we operate but we do also do big family trips/outings too. Just depends what is happening each week.

It probably looked like my youngest was an only.

Vettrianofan · 24/09/2023 20:35

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 20:31

Exactly. There's many reasons to stop at one, but the cost of driving lessons is a pretty bizarre reason imo.

Well, that's right. Children have to realise that you can't forever fund each significant milestone as they come into adulthood 🤷🏻 where do we draw the line?

I have four, so should I give each £50k for a house deposit from my magic money tree? I think not! It will do them good to go out into the world and earn money and save up and appreciate the value of a new house, car etc.

As for parties, mine each got one with friends from primary and the rest have been small family affairs/day trips. There is no need to be lavish each birthday.

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 20:31

Vettrianofan · 24/09/2023 20:30

I was one of 2 and had to pay for my own driving lessons. I didn't have my parents to pay for them. That was my responsibility.

Just another way of looking at the situation.

Exactly. There's many reasons to stop at one, but the cost of driving lessons is a pretty bizarre reason imo.

Vettrianofan · 24/09/2023 20:30

ChChChCherryBomb · 24/09/2023 17:55

Put it this way, if we’d had multiple DC (without a huge age gap) the driving lessons etc would have been put on the back burner!

I was one of 2 and had to pay for my own driving lessons. I didn't have my parents to pay for them. That was my responsibility.

Just another way of looking at the situation.

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 20:23

Both my parents were dead by the time I was 25...I am so thankful I am not an only child.

Imuptoolate · 24/09/2023 20:10

No of course not. I just meant that if you already know that you want to have more than one, but are put off by the cost of things, I don’t think that should necessarily stop you.

Guffpuff · 24/09/2023 20:07

Imuptoolate · 24/09/2023 19:53

I’m a teacher and haven’t noticed this trend, but have noticed bigger age gaps as parents wait until the first is in school before having the next one.

As a parent myself, I think aside from the crazy cost of putting 2 children through childcare, everything else that people think will be too expensive is actually optional. Lavish birthday parties, gifts and holidays abroad for example. Fair enough if you want to be able to afford those things, but I’d rather my children have each other to play and grow with, than big experiences and material things.

As for the cost of driving lessons etc when they are older, the children themselves can contribute towards these. I have several siblings and so earned my own money as a teenager through Saturday and evening jobs. I paid for all of my driving lessons myself and saved for my first car. Didn’t do me any harm, in fact I have always appreciated the value of hard work and saving.

Not judging single child families at all, but I think it is possible to have more than one if you are willing to forgo certain things. Just depends what your priorities are I guess, everyone is different and that’s fine!

I am one of four siblings. All of us barely speak to each other and there's no guarantee that siblings will grow up to get along. So, it shouldn't be the only concern while deciding the number of children people want to have.

OP posts:
Imuptoolate · 24/09/2023 19:53

I’m a teacher and haven’t noticed this trend, but have noticed bigger age gaps as parents wait until the first is in school before having the next one.

As a parent myself, I think aside from the crazy cost of putting 2 children through childcare, everything else that people think will be too expensive is actually optional. Lavish birthday parties, gifts and holidays abroad for example. Fair enough if you want to be able to afford those things, but I’d rather my children have each other to play and grow with, than big experiences and material things.

As for the cost of driving lessons etc when they are older, the children themselves can contribute towards these. I have several siblings and so earned my own money as a teenager through Saturday and evening jobs. I paid for all of my driving lessons myself and saved for my first car. Didn’t do me any harm, in fact I have always appreciated the value of hard work and saving.

Not judging single child families at all, but I think it is possible to have more than one if you are willing to forgo certain things. Just depends what your priorities are I guess, everyone is different and that’s fine!

BlueKaftan · 24/09/2023 18:55

I don’t know. There seems to be a lot of people on MN debating having a third because they’re not “done.”

CaramelicedLatte · 24/09/2023 18:53

You’re seeing a lot of families out with one child. That’s not the same. If you’d observed my family out for a walk today you’d think we were a one and done family. Actually our daughter is the youngest of four, but her siblings didn’t fancy coming today and are old enough to stay home.

OlafLovesOlives · 24/09/2023 18:48

We just have one DD but I always thought I'd have two. We could have afforded a second, pregnancy , newborn, toddler stages were all good, always 50/50 support from DH - sometimes much more from him! I never had a reason not to have another. However (and this is going to sound so cringe & cheesy) I fell so in love with DD & our family life, as time went on I thought no she's enough, I just want her and she's completed our family. It's been over a decade since she was born and our feelings haven't changed.