Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seeing lots of single child family

309 replies

Guffpuff · 23/09/2023 18:44

We went for a long walk today around a reservoir. It's quite a popular place. We saw a large number of single child families. We feel that it's becoming more and more common now. Could be due to Cost of living and inflation or mix of lots of reasons.
Is this something you're observing as well?

OP posts:
mogtheexcellent · 25/09/2023 09:25

Mostly the reason was because i was an older mum but the reality is the cost. I estimated the cost of childcare for my DD over the weekend. Shes year 5 and i have a spreadsheet from when she started nursery at 8 months old. Ive estimated year 6 costs.

Its just over 84k.

My dh and i work full time with a joint income of 45k. I worked at a loss until DD was nearly 3.

Theres no way we could have afforded a second.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2023 09:23

If you read some of the stuff by "experts" on attachment parenting or gentle parenting you quickly find yourself thinking how the hell you are supposed to do it with a big family. Some of the most extreme advice wouldn't even be possible with two children.

Wolfricbriandumbledore · 25/09/2023 09:21

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 09:15

No ...I'm imagining the housewives of the past with multiple kids who kicked them out to play in the street whilst they got on with their housework. And yes plenty of working parents are intensely parenting their dc. Tutors, extra curricular clubs, organised play dates, blah blah blah. Of course no one wants multiple kids when they're parenting in that way.

I would see the tutoring, extracurricular clubs as the reverse of ‘intense’ — it’s just outsourcing, not a million miles from sending your kids out to play all day, apart from financially, obv. And all that focus on private schools, sports, musical instruments, tutoring, is mostly social insecurity aspirationalism , or a fear their children will get ‘left behind’.

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 09:15

Wolfricbriandumbledore · 25/09/2023 09:09

Most women choose to work as well, and many choose to have a single child who fits in more easily around that. The people going on about ‘intensity’ appear to be imagining some kind of SAHP situation where the child is the sole focus of the household. Not so here.

No ...I'm imagining the housewives of the past with multiple kids who kicked them out to play in the street whilst they got on with their housework. And yes plenty of working parents are intensely parenting their dc. Tutors, extra curricular clubs, organised play dates, blah blah blah. Of course no one wants multiple kids when they're parenting in that way.

Wolfricbriandumbledore · 25/09/2023 09:09

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 08:42

Parenting is very different now for sure. Most women have to work as well. But parents are now so much more invested and involved with every aspect of their children's life. I'm not sure it's healthy for either party. Lots of parents of only children on here saying they have more one on one time, can give their child more attention and more financial assistance. It's all very intense.

Most women choose to work as well, and many choose to have a single child who fits in more easily around that. The people going on about ‘intensity’ appear to be imagining some kind of SAHP situation where the child is the sole focus of the household. Not so here.

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 08:42

NeedMyDress · 25/09/2023 08:29

Has anyone yet mentioned the fact that the generation who are now parents (roughly mid thirties to mid forties) grew up being half cared for by their own grandparents, whereas now the baby boomers seem to have decided they don't want to do childcare, or parents of young children have had to move away from family support in order to find work - mothers now compared to mothers in the eighties have so much less practical support from family.

Living away from any support network, the costs of childcare/ housing being about triple in real terms compared to their parents generation - of course families are getting smaller. Women can only cope with so much.

Parenting is very different now for sure. Most women have to work as well. But parents are now so much more invested and involved with every aspect of their children's life. I'm not sure it's healthy for either party. Lots of parents of only children on here saying they have more one on one time, can give their child more attention and more financial assistance. It's all very intense.

NeedMyDress · 25/09/2023 08:29

Has anyone yet mentioned the fact that the generation who are now parents (roughly mid thirties to mid forties) grew up being half cared for by their own grandparents, whereas now the baby boomers seem to have decided they don't want to do childcare, or parents of young children have had to move away from family support in order to find work - mothers now compared to mothers in the eighties have so much less practical support from family.

Living away from any support network, the costs of childcare/ housing being about triple in real terms compared to their parents generation - of course families are getting smaller. Women can only cope with so much.

Badseedmum · 25/09/2023 08:24

I've just read more of this thread and had to laugh out loud at the notion that cousins are your first best friends. I don't know anyone who is best friends with their cousins! Or anyone who was first best friends with their cousins.

One of my cousins is an only child. She didn't invite any of her cousins to her small wedding as she's far closer to her friends than us and considers them more family. I wasn't in the least bit upset about it

Family can come in all sorts of shapes and sizes and sometimes the family we choose can be closer than the ones that are blood. My mum had an elderly neighbour who had 2 daughters. One lived abroad and one wasn't in contact with her. It was mostly my mum that organised her care and visited her when she was in a care home. Proof that family comes in all forms. My DC is an only child and may in future get step siblings or half siblings and I have no idea how many cousins they will have but I know I will give them the skills to build close and nurturing relationships that will support them whatever.

Thepeopleversuswork · 25/09/2023 08:21

I have an only, never occurred to me to have more.

My marriage broke down when my DD was not quite four and I was 40+ by then so it wasn’t an option even if I had wanted more children but I never regretted it at all.

So many benefits for me:

  • more money to go around
  • more time to invest
  • didn’t derail my career
  • me and DD are very close, much more so than if I had had more kids

The only regret I have ever had is just the curiosity about what a second child might have been like.

But having an only is definitely the best option for me.

ChChChCherryBomb · 25/09/2023 07:49

kikisparks · 25/09/2023 07:27

Well yes, it is easier, and we’re allowed to want to be parents and to have a life that is not consumed by stress (not saying you are but some people with two children are and some of us would be if we were not single child families). It does not make us lazy parents. We are allowed to say as women we don’t want to put our bodies through IVF, miscarriages, losses, pregnancy, birth again. We are allowed to say that one lot of PND was enough. We are allowed to say we don’t want to do any additional laundry, cooking, tidying, cleaning, ferrying about etc. We are allowed to say we want more time for ourselves and our marriages. We are allowed to say we don’t want to take the risk of a second child with additional needs. We don’t have to give a reason why we don’t want more children, but if we do and the reason translates into “ easier” it doesn’t mean it’s a bad reason.

Well said.

We’re also allowed also not to try for a second after the age of 41, which would have been my case.

It’s not always the case that we’ve decided on the easier option.

blahblahblah1654 · 25/09/2023 07:37

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 20:53

I just want to say having one and two cost wise doesn’t really feel any different. If you have two close together (less than three ur gap then I imagine it’s harder if you need to pay two x nursery fees ) but three year gap or more and there is free child care for one so I don’t feel it made any difference. I have a 6 yr gap I would have preferred a smaller gap but that’s how it worked out. Also the argument about clubs doesn’t work either , my dd is very sporty you just split time one parent takes one and the other takes the other child so they don’t miss out. I’ve never felt poorer for having two kids. I think the truth is people only want one child because it’s EASIER. We certainly had that debate by time dd1 was 5 should we have another now as life is quite easy, we’d got through the sleepless nights , the tiredness , grandparents would willingly babysit one child who slept through the night , we would quite often go out for dinner / cinema. When you have two it’s much harder to get any time alone , grandparents don’t want to have the one that doesn’t sleep well and is hectic. You are busier and more stressed with two but I would not trade it. I think to be honest we are all missing out by not having bigger families. The more I think of it ,it’s quite sad the thought of someone not having cousins. Cousins are your first best friends. My niece and my dd are extremely close as are my son and his male cousin. I don’t think you realise the importance of extended family in later life.

It's quite insensitive to the people who can't have a second. I've had 2 miscarriages and was extremely unwell during my second late miscarriage. I don't think I should risk my life in case my child feels lonely. Not all siblings are close anyway.

kikisparks · 25/09/2023 07:27

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 20:53

I just want to say having one and two cost wise doesn’t really feel any different. If you have two close together (less than three ur gap then I imagine it’s harder if you need to pay two x nursery fees ) but three year gap or more and there is free child care for one so I don’t feel it made any difference. I have a 6 yr gap I would have preferred a smaller gap but that’s how it worked out. Also the argument about clubs doesn’t work either , my dd is very sporty you just split time one parent takes one and the other takes the other child so they don’t miss out. I’ve never felt poorer for having two kids. I think the truth is people only want one child because it’s EASIER. We certainly had that debate by time dd1 was 5 should we have another now as life is quite easy, we’d got through the sleepless nights , the tiredness , grandparents would willingly babysit one child who slept through the night , we would quite often go out for dinner / cinema. When you have two it’s much harder to get any time alone , grandparents don’t want to have the one that doesn’t sleep well and is hectic. You are busier and more stressed with two but I would not trade it. I think to be honest we are all missing out by not having bigger families. The more I think of it ,it’s quite sad the thought of someone not having cousins. Cousins are your first best friends. My niece and my dd are extremely close as are my son and his male cousin. I don’t think you realise the importance of extended family in later life.

Well yes, it is easier, and we’re allowed to want to be parents and to have a life that is not consumed by stress (not saying you are but some people with two children are and some of us would be if we were not single child families). It does not make us lazy parents. We are allowed to say as women we don’t want to put our bodies through IVF, miscarriages, losses, pregnancy, birth again. We are allowed to say that one lot of PND was enough. We are allowed to say we don’t want to do any additional laundry, cooking, tidying, cleaning, ferrying about etc. We are allowed to say we want more time for ourselves and our marriages. We are allowed to say we don’t want to take the risk of a second child with additional needs. We don’t have to give a reason why we don’t want more children, but if we do and the reason translates into “ easier” it doesn’t mean it’s a bad reason.

blahblahblah1654 · 25/09/2023 07:27

My FIL is 1 of 6 and the family fallouts and politics is ridiculous. Most of them don't speak. It's not a given you'll be less lonely with siblings. I have a brother 2 years younger than me and we aren't close.

Badseedmum · 25/09/2023 07:21

I find it morbid to just have another child just incase my DC might be lonely when I die, or so they have someone to help them care for me. I don't speak to either of my brothers so it's a not a given that siblings are going to be be some inbuilt support system.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 25/09/2023 07:20

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 06:38

I totally accept that only children can have very happy upbringings. But my concern is what happens when things go wrong. Like I said, by the time I was 25, all my grandparents and both parents were dead. Luckily I had my sister, I also had various aunts/uncles around to help support me. If I'd been an only child and my parents had been only children I'd have been really alone.

DD has had a network of friends that we’ve nurtured pretty much since birth. She is far closer with them than I ever was with my sister. Blood isn’t always thicker than water.

ChChChCherryBomb · 25/09/2023 07:16

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2023 07:10

A difficult sibling can just be an extra source of drama when dealing with elderly parents in my experience.

We have this EXACT situation with DH and his ‘D’B right now!

Mind you PIL are 90% to blame for this. DB was always treated like the ‘golden’ child. This situation deserve its own thread though.

Vettrianofan · 25/09/2023 07:14

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2023 07:10

A difficult sibling can just be an extra source of drama when dealing with elderly parents in my experience.

Definitely. There are two ways of looking at this. I say that as someone with several DC myself, and one of 2.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2023 07:10

A difficult sibling can just be an extra source of drama when dealing with elderly parents in my experience.

PeggyPiglet · 25/09/2023 07:09

Having one child doesn't necessarily mean they automatically get everything paid for and get their parents' undivided attention.

My DD will be learning to save up and pay for things herself as soon as she's old enough.

There's also nothing wrong with choosing to have an only child even though you do have the finances for several more.

Screw the 'lonely only' argument. Plenty of only children are perfectly happy.

Oh and the argument 'have more children so they're not lonely if someone dies' is a bit of a ridiculous one.

jeaux90 · 25/09/2023 06:39

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 22:46

I think this thread is for middle class people. No wonder you think you can’t afford more than one child if you are paying their uni fees, weddings and house deposits! I will be expecting my kids to get a part time job at 16 and learn to save up and contribute to their own future. Same way me and my siblings did, we have our own homes paid for ourselves. Important life lesson imo. How much do you think clubs cost? I’m not talking horse riding I’m talking hockey, athletics , swimming it doesn’t cost a fortune to have two kids if you are not buying everything for them post 18 . We are not rich but our kids don’t miss out on anything they have holidays , clubs, days out, we just have realistic expectations of what they need, which does not include private school! 🙄

Well I'm a lone parent and stuck with 1. I think it would have been batshit of me to have more as a single income/single adult household.

And yes I have my DD in private school, you know why?

State provision is shit for SEN kids
State provision does not enable women to work full time

That's why. I took a responsible position. And yes shoot me, I'm middle class.

Comedycook · 25/09/2023 06:38

I totally accept that only children can have very happy upbringings. But my concern is what happens when things go wrong. Like I said, by the time I was 25, all my grandparents and both parents were dead. Luckily I had my sister, I also had various aunts/uncles around to help support me. If I'd been an only child and my parents had been only children I'd have been really alone.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/09/2023 06:28

There's a real vibe of anxiety with this issue. It does seem to get harder and harder for young people to achieve things like stable housing through your own hard work. I don't think anyone really wants to see their offspring go on to have less than they had and if that means a deposit for a house and driving lessons then that's what will be factored in.

WaitingfortheTardis · 25/09/2023 05:17

@Whippetlovely Nonsense. Why is it so hard to understand that one is the perfect number for some people?

Panda89 · 24/09/2023 22:57

My mum is an only child, I’m an only child and my DD is an only child.
We are all very happy with that, I was never close with my cousins and prefer my own company.
DD will have a lovely life with us, she has friends at school and we can afford nice things for her as not overstretched.

Comedycook · 24/09/2023 22:53

Whippetlovely · 24/09/2023 22:46

I think this thread is for middle class people. No wonder you think you can’t afford more than one child if you are paying their uni fees, weddings and house deposits! I will be expecting my kids to get a part time job at 16 and learn to save up and contribute to their own future. Same way me and my siblings did, we have our own homes paid for ourselves. Important life lesson imo. How much do you think clubs cost? I’m not talking horse riding I’m talking hockey, athletics , swimming it doesn’t cost a fortune to have two kids if you are not buying everything for them post 18 . We are not rich but our kids don’t miss out on anything they have holidays , clubs, days out, we just have realistic expectations of what they need, which does not include private school! 🙄

It is very middle class yes!