Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In expecting him to pick me up from the airport?

388 replies

dramallamamx · 23/09/2023 16:01

I'm currently travelling alone in Mexico and I realised I had made a mistake with my coach times to get home from the airport as I forgot about the time difference. A new ticket is £40 and a 6 hour coach journey returning home at 8pm by which time I will have been travelling for around 24 hours and I am back at work the next day. I rang my partner and asked if he could give me a lift from the airport , it is about a 2 and a half hour drive. He says he has a meeting at 10am and I land at 11:15, I said ok I don't mind waiting at the airport for you to arrive, he says he will be too tired as he drove 5 hours to Devon yesterday for a music show and he doesn't know how long the meeting will last so he can't do it and it's my fault that I fucked up the times. I said he was being selfish as I would go out of my way to help him in this situation. Who is being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
jolies1 · 26/09/2023 07:54

Coyoacan · 23/09/2023 18:38

This is what I am seeing. A lot of people nowadays grew up in households where no-one ever took public transport and are consequently even frightened of it.

OP has just travelled round Mexico solo. I’m sure she has taken some public transport there.

GypsyTartForSchoolLunch · 26/09/2023 01:27

dramallamamx · 23/09/2023 16:39

I would rather be in the comfort of a car for 2 and a half hours than sitting on a coach for 6 hours but hey ho I've paid for the ticket now but I've told him I'm not happy about it .

I bet you would.

But he'd sooner be at home than in a car for five hours.

I think you're hugely unreasonable and entitled!

UsingChangeofName · 25/09/2023 23:17

What is so terrible about public transport? Coaches are generally pretty comfortable, you just sit back and read, or listen to music, or sleep.

This ^

It's not something you need to be rescued from!

Quite.
My dd is coming home this weekend, for something she's got booked. She's doing so on the coach. It wouldn't occur to her to ask me to fetch her, because she knows I work, and I have my own stuff going on, and it just all round makes no sense for me to do twice the distance so she can sit in a car, rather than on the coach Confused

And no, I don't agree that unnecessary 5 hour round trips are something that should be expected in a loving relationship. Quite the opposite actually, if someone was making those kinds of demands of me I'd run a mile.

I agree.

lemonraincoat · 25/09/2023 21:52

I've just this week come back from a holiday with a girlfriend. Back to LGW at 7.30pm. DH could have picked me up (an hour each way) but I took public transport instead.

  1. I hate the motorway driving
  2. DH been working all week while I've been having fun
  3. We should all be trying to use public transport rather than one or two people in a motor vehicle
  4. It was much cheaper, very easy. Took me an hour (1 tube change, one short bus ride).
  5. Common sense
MargotBamborough · 25/09/2023 21:48

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 18:14

@Sakura7 how is it bonkers? it's just what people in a loving relationship do...i'd never dream of making my partner use public transport when i'm fully able to get him myself and he would be the same. I find it weird that people are not willing to put themselves out for each other.

She planned to use public transport from the outset though. The only thing that has changed is that she needed to buy another ticket and she will get home later than she thought she would.

Coyoacan · 25/09/2023 21:43

i'd never dream of making my partner use public transport when i'm fully able to get him myself and he would be the same. I find it weird that people are not willing to put themselves out for each other

Different strokes. One way to be considerate is to give your loved one a lift on demand and another way to be considerate is not to demand a lift when there is really no need.

Public transport is not some fate worse than death some people seem to believe it to be

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 21:03

marcopront · 25/09/2023 20:43

After 5 hours of driving and a full day at work, you must have needed a good night's sleep or you would have been dangerous on that drive. So a significant part of the 10 hours you were with her must have been spent sleeping.
Why didn't you have her stay with you at the work location?

The benefit of youth made it possible. 6-7 hours of sleep was more than enough in my early 20s. Having her stay with me at the work location was most certainly not an option - she was post-surgery, bed-bound and needed assistance to get about. The 3-4 hours I did manage to spend each evening were 3-4 hours peace from her mother IYKWIM. That's a whole different thread.

Winter2020 · 25/09/2023 20:54

dramallamamx · 23/09/2023 16:39

I would rather be in the comfort of a car for 2 and a half hours than sitting on a coach for 6 hours but hey ho I've paid for the ticket now but I've told him I'm not happy about it .

...and he would rather be at home than driving for 5 plus hours.

Of course we do things to help partners but the cost/benefit in this case isn't reasonable. You are asking him to drive for 5 hours to save you six on a coach.

If his meeting is a couple of hours and the traffic is not too bad you might get home at 5 or 6 instead of 8. He will have spent all afternoon driving when there was no need to - just to save you two extra hours snoozing on a coach.

marcopront · 25/09/2023 20:43

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 18:25

During a period when my GF was laid up after surgery (for weeks), I had to work away for 3 weeks. The work site was 2.5 hours away each way. Work would have organised overnight accommodation and was prepared to pay my travelling expenses to get there and back once a week. The problem was that my then GF would have only had her DM for company in the evening which was not desirable putting it mildly (but that's another thread). Instead of staying away Mon-Fri each week, I travelled there and back every day setting off at 5am and not getting back until around 7pm in the evening. Work wouldn't pay me for the additional travelling expenses (even though I was saving them hotel and meal expenses) but it didn't matter, I still did it for 3 weeks... because I care for her. We've been married for over 28 years now.
Op - he doesn't sound like a keeper.

After 5 hours of driving and a full day at work, you must have needed a good night's sleep or you would have been dangerous on that drive. So a significant part of the 10 hours you were with her must have been spent sleeping.
Why didn't you have her stay with you at the work location?

Sakura7 · 25/09/2023 20:02

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 18:14

@Sakura7 how is it bonkers? it's just what people in a loving relationship do...i'd never dream of making my partner use public transport when i'm fully able to get him myself and he would be the same. I find it weird that people are not willing to put themselves out for each other.

What is so terrible about public transport? Coaches are generally pretty comfortable, you just sit back and read, or listen to music, or sleep.

It's not something you need to be rescued from!

And no, I don't agree that unnecessary 5 hour round trips are something that should be expected in a loving relationship. Quite the opposite actually, if someone was making those kinds of demands of me I'd run a mile.

UsingChangeofName · 25/09/2023 19:26

This is the first favour or help I've ever asked for from him and I just think it's telling how he's responded.

He's responded very sensibly.
It is the 'favour' that you have asked him is unrealistic.

It's also telling the "counting" you are doing of things you have done for him. Maybe those things are more reasonable thing for a person to be able to do.
Maybe there weren't perfectly feasible alternatives to those things.

As a pp said - it is a good life skill to get your head to a place where you graciously accept that what you are asking of someone is too big an ask, and to be able to continue a good relationship with that person afterwards.

I mean, you can end a fairly new relationship whenever you want, for whatever reason you want, but the young man isn't being at all unreasonable in this scenario to say he can't / won't do this.

Talapia · 25/09/2023 19:19

dramallamamx · 23/09/2023 16:39

I would rather be in the comfort of a car for 2 and a half hours than sitting on a coach for 6 hours but hey ho I've paid for the ticket now but I've told him I'm not happy about it .

What, that your not happy about your mistake ?
You can't blame him for not wanting to drive for 5 hours because of your error.

Seriously, I wouldn't expect my husband of 35 years to pick me up.

Just get the coach.

Moveoverdarlin · 25/09/2023 19:16

My DH would drop everything for me, however in the circumstances you’ve described I can see that it’s a massive inconvenience for him. Your Mum is a constant, you’ve not been with this guy six months, so it’s a big ask.

UsingChangeofName · 25/09/2023 19:12

I agree with most.
You are being v unreasonable to expect him to drive for 5 hours (potentially more as he is likely to get caught in built up traffic on the way home) on a working day, when there is no real need to, as you can get a coach.

Being self employed doesn't mean "I can just not do any work whenever I fancy it, without it having any impact". You seem a bit confused about that.

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 18:55

Also... I was never asked to do this by her. I volunteered.
Even though Op had cocked up her travel times, if she had been my GF I would have gone to the airport and collected her rather than say "nope your fault... sod off"

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 18:49

Vivi0 · 25/09/2023 18:41

This is not in any way a similar or comparable situation.

Never suggested that the situation was similar in any shape or form. The travelling time each way is the same so that is comparable for sure. My situation though is also completely different in that it involved much longer working days and repeated journeys over a period of time. The point is that less than 6 months into my relationship, I was prepared to do this for my girlfriend. Op's boyfriend clearly wasn't. Don't people make any effort any more?

Whataretheodds · 25/09/2023 18:43

dramallamamx · 23/09/2023 16:15

I offered him petrol costs or to use my car that is parked at home. Partner or boyfriend, probably didn't use the correct terminology but does it really matter ?

Why not just book a new coach ticket?

Have you even checked to see if you can get on an earlier one than booked?

Vivi0 · 25/09/2023 18:41

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 18:25

During a period when my GF was laid up after surgery (for weeks), I had to work away for 3 weeks. The work site was 2.5 hours away each way. Work would have organised overnight accommodation and was prepared to pay my travelling expenses to get there and back once a week. The problem was that my then GF would have only had her DM for company in the evening which was not desirable putting it mildly (but that's another thread). Instead of staying away Mon-Fri each week, I travelled there and back every day setting off at 5am and not getting back until around 7pm in the evening. Work wouldn't pay me for the additional travelling expenses (even though I was saving them hotel and meal expenses) but it didn't matter, I still did it for 3 weeks... because I care for her. We've been married for over 28 years now.
Op - he doesn't sound like a keeper.

This is not in any way a similar or comparable situation.

Vivi0 · 25/09/2023 18:40

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 18:17

absolutely! people saying they respect their partners time too much to ask them to pick them up too... how strange- half of that time would be shared together and presumably you miss each other after a trip

I’m one of those who said that I respect my husband’s time too much to put him in this situation, and I can’t see anything strange about it.

People have so many demands on them already. My first thought would be who is going to collect our children from school. Secondly, he also has to, you know, work.

If my husband were to take time off from work, I could think of better ways to spend time together than sitting in a car with him for a couple of hours.

Anyway, I can’t imagine anyone taking time off work for something like this. What a complete waste of annual leave.

Do people honestly have a spare 5 hours on any given day to do something like this?

HisNibs · 25/09/2023 18:25

During a period when my GF was laid up after surgery (for weeks), I had to work away for 3 weeks. The work site was 2.5 hours away each way. Work would have organised overnight accommodation and was prepared to pay my travelling expenses to get there and back once a week. The problem was that my then GF would have only had her DM for company in the evening which was not desirable putting it mildly (but that's another thread). Instead of staying away Mon-Fri each week, I travelled there and back every day setting off at 5am and not getting back until around 7pm in the evening. Work wouldn't pay me for the additional travelling expenses (even though I was saving them hotel and meal expenses) but it didn't matter, I still did it for 3 weeks... because I care for her. We've been married for over 28 years now.
Op - he doesn't sound like a keeper.

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 18:17

Bookworm20 · 25/09/2023 15:05

I am definitely in the minority here, but I'm actually with you OP. You've been away, its a newish relationship, but a good way into it. I think it shows something about him that he isn't willing to put himself out for a couple of hours to come get you - especially as you've been away!

I do know that in my reltionship I went away for a weekend about 6 months in to our relationship, and had a few train issues getting back, and my dp insisted on coming to get me (it was over a 3 hour drive - each way) and he arrived with flowers, snacks and my favorite drink.
Because he missed me.

I do find it odd how so many people are saying you are so unreasonable for expecting a loved one to help you out - your fault - you sort it.
Glad i'm not in one of those relationships. We help each other out here, and yes sometimes that means perhaps rolling your eyes and doing something you'd rather not be doing. But doing it anyway because the person you care about needs your help.

absolutely! people saying they respect their partners time too much to ask them to pick them up too... how strange- half of that time would be shared together and presumably you miss each other after a trip

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 18:14

@Sakura7 how is it bonkers? it's just what people in a loving relationship do...i'd never dream of making my partner use public transport when i'm fully able to get him myself and he would be the same. I find it weird that people are not willing to put themselves out for each other.

Sakura7 · 25/09/2023 17:23

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 17:09

sorry but i wouldn't even need to ask my other half he would be there to pick me up even before i'd considered booking a coach even if it was a 5 hour drive

Bonkers.

jolaylasofia · 25/09/2023 17:09

sorry but i wouldn't even need to ask my other half he would be there to pick me up even before i'd considered booking a coach even if it was a 5 hour drive

Noimnotstillonmumsne · 25/09/2023 16:07

YANBU OP - considering the amount of similar favours you’ve done for him. I don’t think he sounds like a keeper!