Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell them to stick their job where the sun don't shine?!

68 replies

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 13:04

Have been offered a new role at my current company of Project Manager in the Comms team, working on some nice events and internal projects. Previously been an EA with 10yrs+ experience, working on projects at Director level, so have relevent applicable knowledge to bring.

Have been offered a 10% payrise, which I haven't argued, but I did say that my condition was to be sponsored to do my PRINCE2 training, paid for by the company, within work hours. I've done project work, but would value learning a more formal approach as I've often had to make stuff up as I've gone along.. HR were positive but the Finance guy has been on A/L for 2 weeks, so hasn't been able to approve the training, and now it feels like a fate accomplished that I'm taking the job whatever he replies, as they've given me a start date of beginning Oct.

Had a meeting with my to be line manager on Thursday and it was awful. Didn't ask me one question about my quals/experience/aspirations for the role. When I mentioned the training her response that the company was 'too fluid' to take such a 'narrow minded and inflexible approach'. I mentioned I'd bought some highly recommended PM books to upskill/familiarise myself with the language/processes, and she laughed at me. Apparently they have some PPTs I can look out that will outline their existing approaches, but that no-one in their team has any formal PM training so they've also just made it up as they've gone along.

Another part of the job is anticipating/booking team member's time, and she joked that I'd need to expect lots of last minute requests and changes. Fine, and these things do happen, but I've heard her working style described as "nice but chaotic", so she ridiculed my desire to learn an organised framework while in the next breath saying she's takes a last minute panic as just an accepted approach?!

She then apologised for coming across as 'so negative' in the meeting.

It's just left me so cold about what should have been a promotion/great opportunity, and that it's not going to be a supportive environment to work with someone so dismissive of change or personal development, and who didn't even ask one question to get to know me.

As background, prior to my current boss I had an AWFUL line manager who put me down, belittled me and meant I lost a lot of confidence. Crying in the loos at lunchtime type situation. Feel like I've just built myself back up again with my current boss, who is lovely, and feel confident in my current role, so just very reluctant to go and work for someone who could make my life miserable again... Feel like I've seen some huge red flags!

So do I just say thanks but no thanks? Or bite the bullet as long term it would be good for my CV, and I LOVE the idea of going into PM properly... But I just don't want to work for another bully...

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 23/09/2023 19:04

I work in a company that has both a very prescriptive PMO and also utilizes the fly by the seat of your pants project management. To be honest both are effective. Disclaimer; Outside of specific circumstances I tailor my PM activities to the project I’m leading.

What won’t be effective is to try to institute a rigid methodology into a go with the flow group. From some of your comments this is sounding like product management or similar. (Maybe I’m wrong there) which, again in my experience, tends be way more fluid than a software project.

The good news is walking into a less formal group, it’s unlikely that you’ll be suddenly asked for project plans a Gantt charts. You will likely be asked to use the existing framework but it’s likely you will have a lot of latitude beyond that.

LinkedIn Learning has a ton of PM courses which are really good. There are 1,000’s of free templates available online. But I’ve learned it’s best not to overthink things sometimes.

The last thing I’m going to mention is that you seem very antagonist towards the role and line manager already, That’s not a great place to be starting a new role. So I would take a step back and really ask yourself what the main issues are. If the role/team isn’t the right fit that’s ok. If you’re scared of the unknown that’s ok too. If you need to recalibrate expectations based on the new information be open to it.

At any rate good luck!

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 18:56

@OnlyFannys No, we don't have an PMO department, it's a marketing agency made up of smaller teams, so within each team we have an Operations Manager who looks after the specific teams workflows/deadlines/resource bookings etc for client work, and they have set processes/templates they use, so I could see what they do that could help me, but the team I'd be joining is internal and external comms for the whole company and seems to be more delivery focused.

OP posts:
Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 18:49

@oksothisisusnow Yes! This exactly!! This is exactly what I'm worried it will be like, and what I'm trying to do as much as possible from what I have available to me to avoid!
Think it would be good for my CV as a stepping stone, as I do like the idea of going into PM as it seems like the bits I enjoy most about being an EA, just having worked for a horrible line manager before I'm just extra wary of signing up to work closely with someone who didn't seem to have any respect for me whatsoever 😔

OP posts:
notquiteruralbliss · 23/09/2023 18:09

As others have said, Prince2 isn't suited to an organisation like yours. I'd take the job, get the hands on experience and do some introductory PM courses on the side. Maybe look at APM courses and online tutorials on lightweight PM tools. One of the best PMs I worked with was an ex EA. She delivered some huge projects and ended up at MD level.

OnlyFannys · 23/09/2023 17:56

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 17:33

@Trevorton Thank you for sharing - so they don't have a "methodology" they follow, or I think an awareness of what the ones you'd given are. It's all just muddling through from the sound of it.
I'd be the first person in the team with a PM title, everyone else is Brand Manager or Head of Brand/Comms.

Ah op as.soon as I read your op I knew you were going to say you don't have a methodology haha. It sounds like from a project management perspective your company lacks maturity and capabilities in the PM team and for them project management is very much delivery focused and lacks governance? This is quite typical for organisations that are new to project management. I'm assuming they don't have a PMO dept? Generally they would be the best people to speak to to understand what documents you would need to make sure the project is set up correctly, for example a business case and a project initiation document are pretty key elements in the planning stages. If the organisation isn't mature in its approach to project management I can see the reluctance to pay for formalised training as they don't see the value (I don't necessarily agree with this, they would probably benefit enormously from more control over project oversite but are unlikely to invest if that's not the done thing there). You could go on LinkedIn as there are lots of free courses that would help get you set up with the basics. If you are keen to move into PM you could use this job as a stepping stone while doing some self training in the backgroud

oksothisisusnow · 23/09/2023 17:50

I wouldn't be bothered at all about the Prince qualification, however the rest of the conversations you've had are absolute red flags.

In my experience as a PM, the last minute unorganised is a recipe for anxiety and a huge amount feeling like you're never on even ground.

I've worked on a few contracts like that, and it does lead to playing firefighter, trying to cover everyone's arses so no one looks unprofessional, generally finding out that the end client has expectations that haven't been conveyed or taken in properly, and I always lost personal time trying to make up for missed details.

I'd maybe accept it as an opportunity with it in mind that this isn't the long term place to work, but somewhere to prove myself, with the intent on finding another role in the not too distant future.

Trevorton · 23/09/2023 17:47

But also OP I can totally get your frustration. You literally don't know where to start. I think one thing is key here is that different projects and industries work so differently so without knowing in more depth what your projects are delivering as an end goal it is hard to advise. I know I work in legal tech, most of my jobs have been about delivering software as I explained above from inception to completion over a long time frame, this was my comfort zone. This included multiple people and skill sets and I see myself as the conductor of an orchestra. I did however do a stint for 3 months for another legal tech firm where the implementation was short (8-12 weeks) with one consultant. No real plan, just get it done. I couldn't cope, there was no step by step logic or process, no plan, no timeline. I just felt like a glorified PA putting meetings in the diary. You couldn't plan anyhow as you couldn't resource book, it could just be you grabbed an hour of someone's time when free or when the client was free. Very odd structure to me!

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 17:46

I think my main issue, rather than whether the course is appropriate or not, or adapting to internal styles of working, as I acknowledge I don't know the answers or the best course of action.
My issue is the attitude of just shooting me down without knowing me at all, dismissing something out of hand without hearing me out, laughing in my face when I said I was taking my own steps to upskill...
I just want to do the best job possible, and be an asset to the team as quickly as possible, so was more asking for what they could do to support that, completely open minded to what that might look like.
It's more the type and style of Manager she gave a very negative first impression of being.
When I said she "apologised" for being negative, it wasn't a concession of not being supportive, but a "well, didn't I just piss on your chips, HAHA!"

OP posts:
Trevorton · 23/09/2023 17:41

allaroundthelamplight · 23/09/2023 17:24

I did Prince2 about 20 years ago, paid for by the company and IMO it's a faffy ballache that I barely used in my then role as a project manager.

Funnily enough I did look into doing it whilst I was already in a PM role. My company offered to pay for it, but on the advice of others that had done it we all went "nah". The guys who had done it said it was pretty hard going and they never really used the foundations in their roles. I think OP, you need to start the job and do some research on tools/methodology etc that will help YOU as a person in this role make it a success, regardless of what they are doing and have done up until now. By the sounds of it any improvements in process you can make would be welcomed.

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 17:38

@LadyBitsnBobs
Sounds a bit chicken and egg really - agree I don't know about PM methodology, which is what I'm looking to get, but if I don't do training in it, how am I supposed to get it?! When there's no one in my company who has done it/uses it who can train me internally?
Agree perhaps PRINCE2 as a specific course isn't the most relevent these days, I just google PM courses and that seemed to be the most recognised/utlised qualification, so insert name of suitable course that would give me that insight into what the methodologies are and how to apply them.

OP posts:
Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 17:33

@Trevorton Thank you for sharing - so they don't have a "methodology" they follow, or I think an awareness of what the ones you'd given are. It's all just muddling through from the sound of it.
I'd be the first person in the team with a PM title, everyone else is Brand Manager or Head of Brand/Comms.

OP posts:
allaroundthelamplight · 23/09/2023 17:24

I did Prince2 about 20 years ago, paid for by the company and IMO it's a faffy ballache that I barely used in my then role as a project manager.

Charlattanus23 · 23/09/2023 17:19

I hope you get this sorted, sorry they are messing you around.

As an aside, your manager sounds like she'd be just perfect for the current crop of managers the NHS is recruiting...!

LadyBitsnBobs · 23/09/2023 17:15

It does seem like you’ve decided you want to do Prince2 without knowing much about it. Or about project management methodology in general. What kind of roles might you want to do after this one, say in a few years time? What qualifications and experience would you need for that?

on the other hand I would not want to work for such a disorganised boss. Sounds like that would be a horrible clash. I’d stay in current role and hold out for soemthing better to come along.

MissBiljanaElectronika · 23/09/2023 17:13

I'm looking into PM courses and they seem to be insanely expensive!

MissBiljanaElectronika · 23/09/2023 17:12

Tricky, I am in almost the same position!

I have been asked to become project manager (software) even though I am really a web tester/CRO person

The reason I was asked is that I know the company, and the devs well, and the devs like working with me, and I already do informal project management and chair meetings in a sort of way

It's all VERY improvised and firefighting and there are no processes 😁 (yes this is a successful company though...), I've started documenting processes which is a huge job but it's just so chaotic 🤪

Am thinking through if I can handle it, and have asked if I can do an Agile training course 😁 so quite similar to you.

Am meant to make the job switch in October (ie next week) and will get an offer letter this week.

I have given a provisional "yes" and am thinking that I am planning to give this a go and will re-evaluate in 1 year, and that after 1 year I will have some formal PM experience and will hopefully be more employable should I want to move

So I am going to do this mostly for career development reasons

Good luck, maybe we can have an unqualified PM support group here 😊😁

Trevorton · 23/09/2023 17:04

The main difference is that Waterfall is a linear system of working that requires the team to complete each project phase before moving on to the next one while Agile encourages the team to work simultaneously on different phases of the project. Agile methodology was developed as a response to Waterfall’s more rigid structure.

I copied and pasted the two definitions to explain the difference between the two ways of PM methodology. The documentation you refer to is just the collatoral. I would have the same, a PPT to kick the project off and various bits of documentation required for governance, strategy etc.

Notagains · 23/09/2023 16:39

Unless they use prince in the organisation the training isn't going to be very useful it is very technical and prescriptive there are other more flexible approaches that might be better.
Also I think she was probably warning you that there may be last minute changes and requests in the role.
Having said that if you don't feel comfortable taking the role don't.

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 16:35

@NeverDropYourMooncup Yeah.. I hadn't considered this before this thread but I do wonder... Someone to book in the meetings/capture actions/do the grunt work...
Suppose my (perhaps naive) approach was if I was to be a PM I'd want to be the best one I could be, with my idea about the qualification giving me a more rigourous aapproach to 'do it right'..

OP posts:
Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 16:28

@midlifecrash Thanks for your reply, yes do see that you don't need a qualification to figure it out.
Think I was just hoping for something that would give me a skeleton approach to follow as a starting point to ask the right questions at the beginning of a project, to set achievable goals for the desired outcome, then identify who needs to be involved when, and how to identify issues that might derail things and plan around trying to avoid them.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/09/2023 16:27

I'm very suspicious that they think they're getting a good typist/secretary, rather than a PM.

midlifecrash · 23/09/2023 15:29

It is all about forward planning and what you really need is the timeline, which projects have to be done by when, and how many hours and people they take. So you can say in January we can’t have that deadline in May, Sue is off for a month with planned surgery. We have to put it back or recruit someone to cover. (You also say, last year a similar project took FOUR weeks not two… this is where it can be tricky with a chaotic manager).

You don’t really need a qualification for this.

Trevorton · 23/09/2023 15:15

I will reply to you properly in a bit but you can use all sorts of tools to plan. I use smartsheet and it will give you a gant chart view. Suggesting this would probably stand you in good stead, it’s much more advanced than MS project (easy to use, it’s very similar to excel).

Wiggleinherwalk · 23/09/2023 15:08

Hi @Trevorton ,
Thanks so so much for your detailed and thoughtful reply, really appreciated.
So I don't think they follow either Agile or Waterfall as an approach, if that's a recognised way of working - think they have PPT decks/excel docs/a Teams channel that have been developed organically... And then recycle it for the next year. But yes, projects would be 12m max with reoccurring events (AGMs/launches) and a big research piece published annually.
I suppose my worry is just that I'd suddenly be responsible for things/budgets/deliverables/reporting, without having the tools I need to be able to do that. Perhaps naively I assumed a qualification would give me a skeleton for at least what questions need to be asked when, and how to make a Gant chart!

OP posts:
Trevorton · 23/09/2023 14:30

I am a PM and work in a niche industry doing software implementations. These projects are typically 18mths-2years long and take a company from inception to Go live. I have no formal qualifications and do not have Prince 2. A lot of jobs ask for it but when they see my experience then say it doesn't matter. A lot of the role is relatively easy for me as I have domain knowledge, I have been in this niche industry (legal) for nearly 30 years implementing software and doing a whole variety of different roles from training (in the beginning) to consultant to PM Roles.

That said, whilst I personally do not have qualifications there is an pretty much standard approach of how the implementation process works over the timeline of the project and each vendor I have worked for generally has this documented approach and it is followed as part of governance.

What I don't know from your OP is whether the projects are Agile or Waterfall. I do mainly Waterfall and as I said above there is generally an agreed process in place to follow. From the little you have said it sounds like your projects are agile, and in their nature are much more fast paced, short bursts of work rather than a laid out 2 year plan that I would follow.

Personally, as another PP said I think in this situation the qualification is outdated and far less important than your current experience in the company. Of course what you could bring to the role is documenting procedural stages and using resource tools to better plan the resources needed in advance. This would help stop the peaks and troughs and last minute panics but I am unsure if you would have the transparency of what is needed for the project at the outset to do this. For instance when I am working with a vendor (rather than client side) I would get a clear statement of work detailing the amount of effort required (in hours) for each stage of the project. I could have say, 240 hours of PM time over a 2 year project. This gives me 10 hours a month. I know from experience the first month needs 30 hours but other months will need 0, so in my plan I can see what I need to do when and work out how to resource the project. Because of what we are delivering is so transparent then we can predict pretty much the resource required. Of course, not all projects would be run the same way and I should imagine if they are internal they would be completely different.

So what I am trying to say here is you need to look at the work involved, and see where you can add value in planning rather than concentrating on a rather vanilla one size fits all approach that the foundation of Prince 2 might give you.