Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they could make more effort

140 replies

babymamaaa · 23/09/2023 09:44

I don't even know why I am posting because I know I'm going to get ripped to shreds.

We moved near DH family a year ago. We live 5 minutes from them. My family live in the states.

DH has two younger siblings ( unmarried and no children yet , they still live at home (25 and 30). They come and see their nieces maybe one a month at the most. They're a very close family and do lots together and claim to absolutely adore their nieces, yet they come just about once a month. And no they're not constantly out and about, they're actually home quite a lot. It wouldn't take much to pop round for tea when they know I have to wrangle them both to bed on my own, pretty much every night.

I've made it very clear that they can come any time and don't need to call first, are always welcome and that I really appreciate their company. I don't ask them to look after my kids, but rather I just like to have everyone together and my kids love it as well. It makes them so happy.

My H also works away a lot and can work entire weekends and sometimes entire weeks away. I would really appreciate the company and have said so in a nice way.

I think it's a bit weak to be honest. I've stopped reaching out, because it's pretty much always a no.

I'm just kind of done with them and I'm going to stop being so nice to them, because clearly, they can't be bothered- so why should I ? I'll be cordial for the sake of my kids but that's about it. They clearly don't want to be in our lives much.

I already know I'm going to get some brutal responses.

1 they don't like you
2 once a month is more than enough
3 you don't sound very nice
4 you are spiteful
5 it's their life you have no right to expect anything from them

Etc etc

I do get it but at the same time, if someone doesn't make the effort with you- why should you make the effort back with them ? I don't think it's spiteful to stop bothering with them and also be ' busy ' to see them and prioritise other relationships. Their family is all about keeping family close bla bla, but they're not really practicing what they preach.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 23/09/2023 12:33

Younger people without children are rarely particularly interested in other people’s.

Lots of British people don’t feel comfortable turning up without a specific invite. Why not ask them for a regular date, tea with the kids on Fridays or some such?

Mamai90 · 23/09/2023 12:32

Everyone is different. When my sister had children and I was still child free I loved spending time with them, I loved them like my own (still do) and saw them several times a week as they lived just a mile away, took them on trips away and for over night stays all the time. I loved being their auntie.

My SIL (no children) sees our DD every 3 or 4 weeks, she'll offer to take her out every now and again, we've always been quite close but she's got her own life to lead with her own priorities. Before I had DD I thought she'd see more of her but I don't mind that she doesn't, maybe it's because I have good family support around me.

Allthegoodusernamesareused · 23/09/2023 12:31

How often do you take your kids to visit them?

SoRainbowRhythms · 23/09/2023 12:30

babymamaaa · 23/09/2023 12:14

Sad it's not like that. You've gone too far and are just being unkind.

They really aren't. This is off the back of what you've put out there.

FarEast · 23/09/2023 12:26

But clearly @babymamaaa 's siblings-in-law don't share her view about family support.

Which is TOTALLY their right. The OP needs to own her own feelings, not blame others.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/09/2023 12:26

This is still all the DH’s fault.

He insists they live near his family.
He works away all week and weekends.
OP can’t cope alone.

Yet, OP feels that this is somehow the problem of the DH’s brother and sister to solve?!

wizzywig · 23/09/2023 12:24

Build your own support network

RoachFish · 23/09/2023 12:21

@FarEast I read the OP completely differently. I read it from the point of view of a woman who lives in a foreign country away from her own supportive family. Her husband insists they need to live near his family but the disinterest from his family is getting her down and she misses being part of a bigger family unit. Like the one she is used to.

I have been that woman too and knows exactly how lonely that can be. Making new friends helps but it’s not the same as feeling a part of a family circle.

babymamaaa · 23/09/2023 12:14

FarEast · 23/09/2023 12:00

Here's your in-laws' version @babymamaaa :

We have this very controlling SiL who thinks that because we are a close family, we are responsible for helping her out with her children when our brother is working away.

We go over about once a month - it's great to see our (very young) nieces but we have really busy jobs & lives. She's now saying to mutual friends that she & our brother moved to be near family and that she's done with us because we won't come over to help her as frequently as she thinks we should. She seems to want us as back up childcare, and is actually quite passive-aggressive abut us being single & childless.

She's started to blank us at family events. She seems to think that our whole family should revolve around her children.

Are we being unreasonable not to want our lives run by what our SiL thinks we should be doing for her? Are we unreasonable to think that she and our brother should look after their own DC?

Sad it's not like that. You've gone too far and are just being unkind.

OP posts:
Ducksinthebath · 23/09/2023 12:10

FarEast · 23/09/2023 12:00

Here's your in-laws' version @babymamaaa :

We have this very controlling SiL who thinks that because we are a close family, we are responsible for helping her out with her children when our brother is working away.

We go over about once a month - it's great to see our (very young) nieces but we have really busy jobs & lives. She's now saying to mutual friends that she & our brother moved to be near family and that she's done with us because we won't come over to help her as frequently as she thinks we should. She seems to want us as back up childcare, and is actually quite passive-aggressive abut us being single & childless.

She's started to blank us at family events. She seems to think that our whole family should revolve around her children.

Are we being unreasonable not to want our lives run by what our SiL thinks we should be doing for her? Are we unreasonable to think that she and our brother should look after their own DC?

Spot on I suspect!

SM4713 · 23/09/2023 12:02

FarEast · 23/09/2023 12:00

Here's your in-laws' version @babymamaaa :

We have this very controlling SiL who thinks that because we are a close family, we are responsible for helping her out with her children when our brother is working away.

We go over about once a month - it's great to see our (very young) nieces but we have really busy jobs & lives. She's now saying to mutual friends that she & our brother moved to be near family and that she's done with us because we won't come over to help her as frequently as she thinks we should. She seems to want us as back up childcare, and is actually quite passive-aggressive abut us being single & childless.

She's started to blank us at family events. She seems to think that our whole family should revolve around her children.

Are we being unreasonable not to want our lives run by what our SiL thinks we should be doing for her? Are we unreasonable to think that she and our brother should look after their own DC?

Absolutely THIS ^

FarEast · 23/09/2023 12:00

Here's your in-laws' version @babymamaaa :

We have this very controlling SiL who thinks that because we are a close family, we are responsible for helping her out with her children when our brother is working away.

We go over about once a month - it's great to see our (very young) nieces but we have really busy jobs & lives. She's now saying to mutual friends that she & our brother moved to be near family and that she's done with us because we won't come over to help her as frequently as she thinks we should. She seems to want us as back up childcare, and is actually quite passive-aggressive abut us being single & childless.

She's started to blank us at family events. She seems to think that our whole family should revolve around her children.

Are we being unreasonable not to want our lives run by what our SiL thinks we should be doing for her? Are we unreasonable to think that she and our brother should look after their own DC?

FarEast · 23/09/2023 11:53

YABU. Once a month is loads! You have to understand that no-one is going to be as interested in your DC as you are.

yogasaurus · 23/09/2023 11:45

Once a month is fine. They’re younger and childless, enjoying their young and childless lives, I did the same before I had DC.

It wouldn't take much to pop round for tea when they know I have to wrangle them both to bed on my own, pretty much every night.

This sentence suggests you’re looking for help rather than just to see them. Realistically what young childless person wants to come along to join in wrangling young kids to bed. If you want help, come out and ask for it.

ValkyrieAssassin · 23/09/2023 11:43

pictoosh · 23/09/2023 09:55

They don't have kids. They're not especially interested, they don't get what pressure you're under, they don't owe you help and it won't occur to them to spend their free time hanging out with their nieces because they are little kids.

Some families are all in about one another I know, which I think is nice...but many are not. Sorry you're feeling isolated.

I think this u is s it really. They are young and caught up in their own lives. You are caught up in yours. You and they would be unlikely to communicate if not thrown together by family ties so it’s friendly but distant. Is there a cultural thing though? I am not from the uk and think families are generally less in each others pockets than I am used to. For me though I prefer that!

NoSquirrels · 23/09/2023 11:40

babymamaaa · 23/09/2023 10:40

I didn't want to, to be honest but DH said he needs to be near his family and could never move. I accepted it at the time like a right idiot. I wanted to live near my family. But because I was ' already here ' I was the one who needed to stay.

As is usually the way of these things, you don’t have an ILs problem you have a DH problem.

LegendsBeyond · 23/09/2023 11:39

At that age, lots of people have little interest in children, even those they’re related to. They’re just not that interesting. Once a month is enough.

SM4713 · 23/09/2023 11:37

It wouldn't take much to pop round for tea when they know I have to wrangle them both to bed on my own, pretty much every night.

Why should they help YOU wrangle YOUR children to bed or keep YOU company because YOU are bored and YOUR DH is working away??? I wouldn't visit for that very reason! I love my cousins children and my early 20's I used to have the odd meal there- not as often as once a month! The screaming, food, bath and bed tantrums were too much for me, so I stopped going. I wanted to catch up with my cousin and have a chat- not a childrens entertainer!

You say its cultural, but are these siblings 1st, 2nd, 3rd generation of being brought up in the UK? Just because you helped your SIL doesn't mean these siblings feel the need to, nor have the same 'cultural' pull that you seem to think they SHOULD have!

daliesque · 23/09/2023 11:37

Do you actually like them? Enjoy their company? Interested in their lives? Or do you just see them as a means to stop you feeling lonely and help with the kids?

If it's the latter then I don't blame them for wanting to only visit once a month.

Owjrbvr · 23/09/2023 11:21

I do get where you’re coming from with them saying that they make out they’re very close and it doesn’t feel that way; i wonder if they just have a different perception of what a close family is like.
I had to accept a while ago that my in laws perception of supporting us was different to what I hoped it’d be and I stepped back from making as much effort and matched their effort more, not in a horrible way but just in a Im not going to bend over backwards way anymore and it gave me a bit of peace and I focused more on other people in my life

RisingSunn · 23/09/2023 10:43

OP once a month is reasonable. They are mid 20s - early 30s with no children. They have their own lives. (Whether you think their days are filled up or not).

It’s good you have local friends with children - perhaps our more energy into those relationships especially if they have children too.

In my view “closeness” is not solely based on how often you see someone.

Boyonthenres · 23/09/2023 10:43

Are they male or female? Not sure I'd have been overly interested in young children at that age either tbh. Probably doesn't cross their mind to visit . It's sad though

daliesque · 23/09/2023 10:40

It wouldn't take much to pop round for tea when they know I have to wrangle them both to bed on my own, pretty much every night.

And somewhere else on MN there's probably a thread from a woman complaining about her childfree, young in,was who keep turning up for tea when she's wrangling kids to bed.

Honestly, in laws can't win.

babymamaaa · 23/09/2023 10:40

RoachFish · 23/09/2023 10:32

You really don’t need to keep asking them. See what happens when you don’t.

Is the long term plan to live in the UK? It seems a bit unfair to me that you do if your husband is frequently away and you don’t have the family support you expected. Would it make sense to move closer to your family in the US? I think this all stems from a general unhappiness from you and just by chance the sil’s are taking the hit. Do you see your pil’s more?

I didn't want to, to be honest but DH said he needs to be near his family and could never move. I accepted it at the time like a right idiot. I wanted to live near my family. But because I was ' already here ' I was the one who needed to stay.

OP posts:
TinglingTangling · 23/09/2023 10:35

How often do you go around to see them?

To be honest, I have no desire to go and hang out with my brothers wife just because she’s bored at home and wants some company.

Once a month is fine.