Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inclusion policies are not working

629 replies

somewherbetweenHoneyandTrunchbull · 22/09/2023 23:44

I am an experienced teacher. And every year budgets are being cut and more and more children are being chucked into mainstream. Non-verbal, extremely sensitive to noisy kids being put into an overcrowded open plan mainstream school. Some have a little speech but couldn't hold a conversation. Many not toilet trained. Many cannot control their emotions and anger. Some where English isn't a first language. Many with social work involvement and living through ongoing trauma at home.
Meanwhile support staff numbers are being cut, year on year.
I had been managing just about. Spinning many plates. Constantly juggling. But then they enrol another two kids with complex needs into my class on 28 individuals. I just can't do it any more. This week I've been bitten, scratched, hit so hard I thought they had cracked a rib. Violent incident forms all filled in but reality means not much will change as I can't get more that 2 20 minute slots of teaching assistant time each week.
I love my job. I love the kids. I love those lightbulb moments. But at the moment I can't do my job of teaching children. I can barely keep them and myself safe in my class. I try. I'm exhausted. I'm worn out working day and night so that I'm super organised so everything can go smoothly but it never does. If it was just one child having a meltdown I probably coolyld cope. I just do t know which firework will go off when. I don't know what is setting them off and once they go, others follow.
I cry most days at how hopeless it feels. I have some really bright and eager children too. They are also being let down by this system. I'm not sure who the current education policies help. It doesn't seem to help anyone except desensitising children to daily bouts of violence and the language.
I'm very broken tonight. I'm so sleepy but won't help x

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:57

mids2019 · 24/09/2023 15:45

@Pollyputhekettleon

do teachers have to explain to pupils that some are exempt from disciplinary policies (to an extent). I would think violence against a teacher by a child with no underlying issues would result in at least suspension?

are governing bodies in any way aware of what teachers are going through and their legal duty of care?

do teachers that lobby of suggest a child is removed from their care criticised for being 'anti-inclusive' and simply good to try harder with the chi ld?

I don't think they're required to explain that to the other children, no. They certainly don't seem to. The cases on here were simply told something along the lines of 'they have ASD, they can't help being violent.' I don't think they were explicitly told that the child was exempt from normal disciplinary policies. Anyway, in practice violent children without SEN are frequently also exempt from normal disciplinary policies, because they could be neglected or abused at home so schools don't want to exclude them.

Yes teachers seem to often be told that it's their fault and they must do better. But there also seems to be an understanding that their job is frequently impossible. Teacher's governing bodies would know about this, but the education profession in general seems to take the view that the right of a violent child to education trumps the right of teachers/other children to not be assaulted. So that's the answer to any questions about duty of care.

You'd get a better answer if parents and teachers started suing schools for failing in their legal duty of care to them/their children whenever they were injured or their mental health suffered as a result of the unsafe environment. Then governments would have to defend laws that place the rights of violent children to education above the rights to safety of others. Money would magically appear if that ever became a trend, but I don't see it happening.

OhmygodDont · 24/09/2023 15:55

I don’t think children are told exactly why said child isn’t punished. More of a X can’t help it as they don’t understand.

We all remember that one child at school in our classes who seemed to be star of the week or whatever for what would be considered the expected behaviour in everyone else. The child always picked to be the one to run the register because they need to, all little things they get to do for maybe sitting still while you’re told off for fidgeting. Never did it help that child build a good peer relationship though everyone just avoided them.

The children who had extra things because of needing a wheelchair or walker seemed to be pretty popular at least in my school anyway. The child off for cancer treatment got millions of cards and art and was treated like a hero whenever they could be in school the whole class pretty much doted on them. The child who couldn’t ever hit the ball in rounders was still picked we just threw the ball easier for them and ran a little slower so they could still get to a base rather than being out every go.

lavenderlou · 24/09/2023 15:54

A lot of SEN support that students can access is provided after parents have fought and fought. Unfortunately it's not always the case that parents will be willing or able to do that

mids2019 · 24/09/2023 15:45

@Pollyputhekettleon

do teachers have to explain to pupils that some are exempt from disciplinary policies (to an extent). I would think violence against a teacher by a child with no underlying issues would result in at least suspension?

are governing bodies in any way aware of what teachers are going through and their legal duty of care?

do teachers that lobby of suggest a child is removed from their care criticised for being 'anti-inclusive' and simply good to try harder with the chi ld?

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:42

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:37

Have you read the links I posted?

Those were aimed at me?! Haha, no, I'm not ploughing through a bunch of links if you can't be bothered to either answer the questions I've asked, summarize the point you're taking from the links, and ideally take a short quote from them. That's really not much to ask. I'm not engaging with you any more.

BlackeyedSusan · 24/09/2023 15:39

It appears and feels like you are failing the kids because you can't do it all. But it's not you at all. It's those who think one person is able to do three people's work.

Back in the last century, the NASUWT used to strike over these issues of individual teachers not getting support and getting attacked.

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:37

Have you read the links I posted?

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:36

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:30

It’s increasing because the issue in education have now been going on for more than a generation. So yesterday’s children with special educational needs are the parents of the current children.

I don't think you're getting the issue of rates and proportions. Anyway, you're not answering any of the questions I asked so this is not very interesting.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:35

mids2019 · 24/09/2023 15:16

Can I ask teachers to what extent the standard school disciplinary policy can be brought into effect? Some of the behaviour here would be punished by a suspension of exclusion? Are there variations in these policies for children with SEN? If a certain subset of pupils are excluded from the full disciplinary policy will this not lead to a more general behaviour issue I the school as it appears that appalling behaviour has no consequence?

I suspect even quite young children in problem classes can understand that some children fall into the category of those allowed to be violent and others don't? A few parents here whose children have been assaulted were told that the violent child had SEN, so I presume their child was told too.

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:30

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:28

But why would that kind of behaviour be increasing? And the same questions apply as I stated above about the poverty hypothesis.

It’s increasing because the issue in education have now been going on for more than a generation. So yesterday’s children with special educational needs are the parents of the current children.

SocialistSally · 24/09/2023 15:28

mids2019 · 24/09/2023 15:16

Can I ask teachers to what extent the standard school disciplinary policy can be brought into effect? Some of the behaviour here would be punished by a suspension of exclusion? Are there variations in these policies for children with SEN? If a certain subset of pupils are excluded from the full disciplinary policy will this not lead to a more general behaviour issue I the school as it appears that appalling behaviour has no consequence?

One aspect of my daughter’s EHCP is that consideration needs to be taken when applying the disciplinary policy. Because she is disabled and covered under the Equality Act, and not doing this could be discrimination.

Excluding a child because of behaviour caused by their disability would be discrimination. It also doesn’t help the child in terms of their education.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:28

Boomboom22 · 24/09/2023 15:23

Poverty like cultural deprivation too not just material, it's not just having no books in the house it's having no concept that it is normal to read 2-3 picture books at bedtime every night from pretty much birth to 10 years old encouraging your child to tell you the story. It is not playing basic games such as animal noises and colours with your toddler so they go to school not knowing what colours and animals are. It is not talking to your child as they can't speak yet so you don't get the point. Generational as your parents were the same. School is making odd comments to you and you Don understand why. Misinterpretation of what the school says and the level that is normal and expected.

But why would that kind of behaviour be increasing? And the same questions apply as I stated above about the poverty hypothesis.

derxa · 24/09/2023 15:27

Boomboom22 · 24/09/2023 15:23

Poverty like cultural deprivation too not just material, it's not just having no books in the house it's having no concept that it is normal to read 2-3 picture books at bedtime every night from pretty much birth to 10 years old encouraging your child to tell you the story. It is not playing basic games such as animal noises and colours with your toddler so they go to school not knowing what colours and animals are. It is not talking to your child as they can't speak yet so you don't get the point. Generational as your parents were the same. School is making odd comments to you and you Don understand why. Misinterpretation of what the school says and the level that is normal and expected.

https://aggslanguage.wordpress.com/2010/06/04/bernstein-elaborated-restricted-code-1971/
Also restricted code and elaborated code

Bernstein – Elaborated & Restricted Code (1971)

The underlying theory The construct of elaborated and restricted language codes was introduced by Basil Bernstein in 1971, as a way of accounting for the relatively poor performance of working-clas…

https://aggslanguage.wordpress.com/2010/06/04/bernstein-elaborated-restricted-code-1971

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:24

spanieleyes · 24/09/2023 15:16

Yes, of course. If you don't talk to a child, they don't learn to talk back. We have one child who was literally left in a cot for the first 2 years of their life, until removed from parents. They have the language and vocabulary of a 2 year old now, speak in single, sometimes 2 word " sentences" That's due to nurture- or lack of it.

I don't think you can conclude that's 100% nurture. Very few things are. Given the parent's behaviour, the prenatal environment was probably terrible - malnutrition, smoking, infections, lack of attendance at prenatal care, prematurity alcohol, drug use. That's environmental but not 'nurture' in the sense that most people mean it.

Anyway, this begs the question why the rate of inadequate parenting/neglect is increasing. Or are people who are inadequate parents having more children on average than people who are adequate parents.

Boomboom22 · 24/09/2023 15:23

Poverty like cultural deprivation too not just material, it's not just having no books in the house it's having no concept that it is normal to read 2-3 picture books at bedtime every night from pretty much birth to 10 years old encouraging your child to tell you the story. It is not playing basic games such as animal noises and colours with your toddler so they go to school not knowing what colours and animals are. It is not talking to your child as they can't speak yet so you don't get the point. Generational as your parents were the same. School is making odd comments to you and you Don understand why. Misinterpretation of what the school says and the level that is normal and expected.

derxa · 24/09/2023 15:23

spanieleyes · 24/09/2023 15:03

Well, we are not the experts, we are the ones that have to deal with the outcomes as best we can. I have no idea why the need for speech and language has increased. I could hazard a guess- lack of parental interaction, being handed a tablet in the pram and left to get on with it, sat in front of a tv for hours at a time, reduced social interactions, fewer social groups for children, and so on. But I'm sure there are other, medical reasons too, you would need to try to find a speech and language specialist to advise- good luck with that!

Former SALT here. I agree with a lot of what you said. I started working with children in 1983 and the rise in poor receptive and expressive language difficulties rose exponentially. Also the rise in autism. I used to work with children with articulation difficulties till they had improved but then Blair's government brought in six week packages of treatment. Of course there could be all sorts of unknown factors for this rise in autism such as environmental and nutritional factors.
I ended up working in schools dispensing advice to TAs. My main purpose though was assessment and helping the SENCo to get a Statement of SEN.
I then trained as a teacher because I wanted to actually work with children. I ended up in a very small school and we often had children in the classroom with autism, ADHD and dyslexia because the parents wanted small classes. I was lucky in that I had some fantastic TAs who delivered programmes diligently and managed behavioural problems well.
Sorry if this post is muddled and disjointed.

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:19

Yes. If you are a parent with learning difficulties or limited language the input you can give your child is reduced.
Poor vocabulary is a huge problem, and very very hard to address. The difference in vocabulary in Year R can be 2 or 3 years.
If you struggle with reading you are less likely to read to your child at bedtime, they are then in a class with a child whose parents read to them daily. That’s 1000 books difference.
Child B picks up reading much easier, Child A struggles, they then start to avoid reading because it’s too difficult, they start to have behaviour problems. Child B reads at home, is read to and starts reading harder books so their vocabulary increases.
Child A is stuck on boring books and doesn’t want to come to school because it’s boring and hard. By the end of Year R there is a 4 year difference in their vocabulary.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:17

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:07

It’s not about reading and writing, it’s about language which is the medium used to access the curriculum. If you have poor language skills you can’t learn, you can’t understand, there is nothing in school that is not affected by poor language skills. Only about 20% of children with SLCN achieve GCSEs. 80% of unemployed people have poor language skills, in some young offender institutions it’s close to 100%
People with poor language skills are more likely to smoke, drink and take drugs. They are more likely to be in low paying jobs, their life expectancy is reduced by 10 years.
These children don’t start with a learning disability, but it becomes one when their needs are not met. The vast majority of pupils in PRUs have SLCN. It is a huge, huge problem in school.

But you were saying that some of the historical increase is just an artefact of increased literacy. Never mind, you're still not explaining how poverty is causing the increase.

mids2019 · 24/09/2023 15:16

Can I ask teachers to what extent the standard school disciplinary policy can be brought into effect? Some of the behaviour here would be punished by a suspension of exclusion? Are there variations in these policies for children with SEN? If a certain subset of pupils are excluded from the full disciplinary policy will this not lead to a more general behaviour issue I the school as it appears that appalling behaviour has no consequence?

spanieleyes · 24/09/2023 15:16

Yes, of course. If you don't talk to a child, they don't learn to talk back. We have one child who was literally left in a cot for the first 2 years of their life, until removed from parents. They have the language and vocabulary of a 2 year old now, speak in single, sometimes 2 word " sentences" That's due to nurture- or lack of it.

spanieleyes · 24/09/2023 15:16

Yes, of course. If you don't talk to a child, they don't learn to talk back. We have one child who was literally left in a cot for the first 2 years of their life, until removed from parents. They have the language and vocabulary of a 2 year old now, speak in single, sometimes 2 word " sentences" That's due to nurture- or lack of it.

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/09/2023 15:14

spanieleyes · 24/09/2023 15:03

Well, we are not the experts, we are the ones that have to deal with the outcomes as best we can. I have no idea why the need for speech and language has increased. I could hazard a guess- lack of parental interaction, being handed a tablet in the pram and left to get on with it, sat in front of a tv for hours at a time, reduced social interactions, fewer social groups for children, and so on. But I'm sure there are other, medical reasons too, you would need to try to find a speech and language specialist to advise- good luck with that!

I can't imagine working in a field and not wanting to know the causes of an increase in my workload! Especially when the field is underfunded and the dominant conversation is about how more money is required. There seems to be no discussion of how much money will be required if the current rates of increase persist, or how that's even sustainable as society's overall capacity decreases continually.

greengreengrass25 · 24/09/2023 15:11

So some of it is down to nurture?

Elisheva · 24/09/2023 15:07

It’s not about reading and writing, it’s about language which is the medium used to access the curriculum. If you have poor language skills you can’t learn, you can’t understand, there is nothing in school that is not affected by poor language skills. Only about 20% of children with SLCN achieve GCSEs. 80% of unemployed people have poor language skills, in some young offender institutions it’s close to 100%
People with poor language skills are more likely to smoke, drink and take drugs. They are more likely to be in low paying jobs, their life expectancy is reduced by 10 years.
These children don’t start with a learning disability, but it becomes one when their needs are not met. The vast majority of pupils in PRUs have SLCN. It is a huge, huge problem in school.