Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Inclusion policies are not working

629 replies

somewherbetweenHoneyandTrunchbull · 22/09/2023 23:44

I am an experienced teacher. And every year budgets are being cut and more and more children are being chucked into mainstream. Non-verbal, extremely sensitive to noisy kids being put into an overcrowded open plan mainstream school. Some have a little speech but couldn't hold a conversation. Many not toilet trained. Many cannot control their emotions and anger. Some where English isn't a first language. Many with social work involvement and living through ongoing trauma at home.
Meanwhile support staff numbers are being cut, year on year.
I had been managing just about. Spinning many plates. Constantly juggling. But then they enrol another two kids with complex needs into my class on 28 individuals. I just can't do it any more. This week I've been bitten, scratched, hit so hard I thought they had cracked a rib. Violent incident forms all filled in but reality means not much will change as I can't get more that 2 20 minute slots of teaching assistant time each week.
I love my job. I love the kids. I love those lightbulb moments. But at the moment I can't do my job of teaching children. I can barely keep them and myself safe in my class. I try. I'm exhausted. I'm worn out working day and night so that I'm super organised so everything can go smoothly but it never does. If it was just one child having a meltdown I probably coolyld cope. I just do t know which firework will go off when. I don't know what is setting them off and once they go, others follow.
I cry most days at how hopeless it feels. I have some really bright and eager children too. They are also being let down by this system. I'm not sure who the current education policies help. It doesn't seem to help anyone except desensitising children to daily bouts of violence and the language.
I'm very broken tonight. I'm so sleepy but won't help x

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
OhmygodDont · 23/09/2023 17:10

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:08

It's interesting, and disturbing, how much emphasis you place on your son's intelligence. You've mentioned it numerous times now. And specifically you focus on how much cleverer he is than most of the children that you place at risk of violence from him on a daily basis.

Indeed his high Iq won’t matter much when his violent to the wrong person as a teen or adult and either gets himself arrested or beaten to a pulp. But hey ho his smart.

LakieLady · 23/09/2023 17:09

SocialistSally · 23/09/2023 15:23

My autistic daughter is one of the children. She’s been out of school since April. We’ve applied for an EHCP, but Brent old that all the suitable specialist provision is full. She’s had no alternative provision, which she’s legally entitled to (despite and endless battle on my part).

She has extreme anxiety and is traumatised by school. She’s also very bright and was shivering above her age range. There is no suitable provision for her. Mainstream schools could be made more inclusive with funding. But the government don’t care about children like my daughter.

Shes 11 and anxious about her future. She desperately wants to be able to go to school.

I’m also an ex-teacher. I don’t blame her teachers, the system is utterly broken.

Friend's son was waiting for an EHCP when he went from primary to secondary. He absolutely couldn't hack secondary, was having meltdowns, self harming, tried to jump out of the car on the way to school and all sorts, so she stopped sending him.

The school off-rolled him, friend was then told that he couldn't have an EHCP because he wasn't registered at a school.

greengreengrass25 · 23/09/2023 17:08

Prinnny · 23/09/2023 16:16

Also I take my hat of to school staff dealing with this day in day out, no one should go to work and be faced with violence but it seems some of you are told its part of the job and get in with it. In my role (front line nhs) we come into contact at times with abusive patients, we have a zero tolerance policy, the patient would be removed by security/police and ‘red carded’ from the hospital so barred from the premises, it seems you need something similar. And yes I know they’re children and yes they have special needs but is their right to an ‘education’ more important than the safety of other children and staff? Staff that are just trying to earn a living and the innocent children caught in the crossfire? Not in my opinion.

Yes that's what is so appalling about it

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:08

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 17:05

I think you’re massively projecting because of your relative’s poor experience here @toomuchforonewoman and you should step away from the internet for a bit. If there was any sensible alternative to MS for my DS, I would snatch it with both hands. However, I won’t apologise for educating my child through the only available setting. He trounces most of the other kids academically btw.

It's interesting, and disturbing, how much emphasis you place on your son's intelligence. You've mentioned it numerous times now. And specifically you focus on how much cleverer he is than most of the children that you place at risk of violence from him on a daily basis.

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 17:08

Specifically the ones who are knowingly placing their child's right to education above other child's right to not be attacked

Yes, I do that. I’ve admitted that and I don’t apologise for it.

I’ve been waiting 4 years for a specialist place with DS in mainstream. How much longer do you think I’d wait if DS was at home not being the school’s problem?

You are blaming parents for a problem that is not of their making.

Allofthisisasimulation · 23/09/2023 17:07

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 17:05

I think you’re massively projecting because of your relative’s poor experience here @toomuchforonewoman and you should step away from the internet for a bit. If there was any sensible alternative to MS for my DS, I would snatch it with both hands. However, I won’t apologise for educating my child through the only available setting. He trounces most of the other kids academically btw.

How patronising, her experience as as valid as yours.

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:06

feralunderclass · 23/09/2023 16:45

Exactly @itsgettingweird . Many children with SEN are not violent and many violent children don't have SEN.

I don't think anyone is saying otherwise. But the parents with violent children who don't have SEN are wildly unlikely to be on this thread!

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 17:05

I think you’re massively projecting because of your relative’s poor experience here @toomuchforonewoman and you should step away from the internet for a bit. If there was any sensible alternative to MS for my DS, I would snatch it with both hands. However, I won’t apologise for educating my child through the only available setting. He trounces most of the other kids academically btw.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/09/2023 17:05

Amara123 · 23/09/2023 16:53

The only solution is to vote out the Tories.
They've raided the state coffers to enrich their friends, and the general population is paying for it.
There's no good state provision under a Tory government and there never will be. They don't believe in it.

So please explain why the centre left governments of France and Germany are also unable to provide sufficient education and help for SEN children, as evinced by PP.

Anecdotal evidence only, but I am told that things are fairly similar in Spain and Greece as well. I don’t think the ‘Tories’ are controlling these countries.

There is obviously a serious problem amongst children in many ‘developed’ countries, and one which should be highlighted and discussed , but political diatribes are not the answer, IMHO.

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:04

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:53

Yet he can stop 29 other kids from getting one and a few black eyes into the bargain... ok then

And the LA could fix this in a heartbeat by offering him a place at an appropriate setting, but here we are, demonizing disabled children over an abject failure of policy.

No one's demonizing the children. They/We could be said to be demonizing some of the parents, if you wanted to be dramatic about it. Specifically the ones who are knowingly placing their child's right to education above other child's right to not be attacked.

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:03

Amara123 · 23/09/2023 16:53

The only solution is to vote out the Tories.
They've raided the state coffers to enrich their friends, and the general population is paying for it.
There's no good state provision under a Tory government and there never will be. They don't believe in it.

Earlier in the thread I linked to articles from Ireland, France and Germany demonstrating that they have the same problems. And not a Tory in sight...

OhmygodDont · 23/09/2023 17:02

Problem as well is say you’ve a sen child who is violent you then can’t really complain when other parents don’t want their child to play with yours or invite yours to their parties etc because why would they want their child near someone who is causing them actual harm which you see time and time again on posts people complaining.

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 17:02

Spikeyball · 23/09/2023 16:41

"If she were persistently a violent threat to another child for any reason I'd put the other child first and keep her away from them."

Very few parents would keep there own child out of school for years perhaps permanently unless they thought it was better for their child. Maybe you are one of them.

I don't see why the calculation would change over time. It would always be morally wrong to place my child's right to an education over another child's right not to be assaulted. I understand why people are doing it, but the more I think about it the more I realize actually I wouldn't do it and I know I'm not alone. The lack of special school places is not the fault of other innocent children. Even if it were it wouldn't justify allowing them to be attacked.

toomuchforonewoman · 23/09/2023 16:59

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:53

Yet he can stop 29 other kids from getting one and a few black eyes into the bargain... ok then

And the LA could fix this in a heartbeat by offering him a place at an appropriate setting, but here we are, demonizing disabled children over an abject failure of policy.

We all know it is the governments fault but it doesn't mean that your child's violence against others can ruin 29 other children's education and health. Knowingly sending your child in to cause that much damage and destruction, to affect all those lives and then say to the parents of those kids that we are demonizing yours? It's the other way around. My child has the right not to come home with injuries and broken bones just by going to school.

Mrburnshound · 23/09/2023 16:57

My DS attends a school which is very fortunate to be well funded as it has a specialist base. DS attends MS Plus the base and it is working amazingly for him. And even though there are probably more kids with SEN than other schools there is little to no violence, quite a few kids have 1/1s and the base has loads of great resources. It gives all children a fair chance at a good education.

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:53

Yet he can stop 29 other kids from getting one and a few black eyes into the bargain... ok then

And the LA could fix this in a heartbeat by offering him a place at an appropriate setting, but here we are, demonizing disabled children over an abject failure of policy.

Amara123 · 23/09/2023 16:53

The only solution is to vote out the Tories.
They've raided the state coffers to enrich their friends, and the general population is paying for it.
There's no good state provision under a Tory government and there never will be. They don't believe in it.

LakieLady · 23/09/2023 16:49

All the ‘in-year’ children we get are always significantly behind into the bargain. They are usually undiagnosed with something, so I assume the parents are moving them because they are frustrated with a lack of progress. We also have a lot of military children with significant needs - honestly don’t know why the stats swing in that direction in those cases.

I wonder if they're undiagnosed because they haven't sought referrals, or if it's because they have to wait so long for assessment and diagnosis? Friend's son finally had his autism assessment this week. He was referred to CAMHS in May 2017 - over 6 years ago.

I really hope his wait isn't typical.

toomuchforonewoman · 23/09/2023 16:47

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:44

Very few parents would keep there own child out of school for years perhaps permanently unless they thought it was better for their child. Maybe you are one of them

I am unashamedly not. Particularly because DS is so bright - I will do everything in my power to get him into a specialist school, but I won’t keep him from having an education.

Yet he can stop 29 other kids from getting one and a few black eyes into the bargain... ok then.

feralunderclass · 23/09/2023 16:45

Exactly @itsgettingweird . Many children with SEN are not violent and many violent children don't have SEN.

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:44

Very few parents would keep there own child out of school for years perhaps permanently unless they thought it was better for their child. Maybe you are one of them

I am unashamedly not. Particularly because DS is so bright - I will do everything in my power to get him into a specialist school, but I won’t keep him from having an education.

Spikeyball · 23/09/2023 16:41

"If she were persistently a violent threat to another child for any reason I'd put the other child first and keep her away from them."

Very few parents would keep there own child out of school for years perhaps permanently unless they thought it was better for their child. Maybe you are one of them.

Ylvamoon · 23/09/2023 16:41

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 23/09/2023 16:15

@Ylvamoon if you are implying your DC have it worse than mine you are welcome to swop for a while and find out what it’s like. The pain of seeing everything they can’t do and everything they are excluded from is magnified by awareness of the hatred and mistrust from other parents. For the record, the only person my DC is violent towards is me. So I suppose that makes us lucky.

To my shame, I remember my naïveté and embarrassment looking for a nursery place all those years ago. I actually said ‘We have funding for a two year old placement because DC is developmentally delayed. I don’t know if that’s a disability you can accommodate?’ I was so nervous expecting rejection and so pathetically grateful to the nursery that said ‘of course we can accommodate that.’ I know better now- almost everyone will reject us, and my job is not to care and not to give them an easy out.

You don’t have to ‘suffer in silence’ though. If your DC is hurt, advocate for them. Find a better school that has better ways of handling issues. Just don’t blame disabled kids as a group, or inclusion as a concept.

I am not implying anything.

I was responding to your post about how "normal" my children are.

And was trying to point out that because they are "normal" we have to put up (in silence) with the shit show that is called inclusion.

I do/ did advocate for them... but that is a whole other thread. Unless they get physically hurt, the school can do very little. And even when DS got hurt, the wheels were turning very slowly....

And just for your record: to me a disabled child does not equal a violent child.

Pollyputhekettleon · 23/09/2023 16:39

Prinnny · 23/09/2023 16:16

Also I take my hat of to school staff dealing with this day in day out, no one should go to work and be faced with violence but it seems some of you are told its part of the job and get in with it. In my role (front line nhs) we come into contact at times with abusive patients, we have a zero tolerance policy, the patient would be removed by security/police and ‘red carded’ from the hospital so barred from the premises, it seems you need something similar. And yes I know they’re children and yes they have special needs but is their right to an ‘education’ more important than the safety of other children and staff? Staff that are just trying to earn a living and the innocent children caught in the crossfire? Not in my opinion.

It's an odd kind of culture. I've been remarking on it throughout this thread. I think the answer is that teachers are generally compassionate people and are therefore easily manipulated into tolerating abuse. I suspect part of why the NHS has a different policy is because there are far more men on the frontlines in the NHS (among doctors particularly) facing this abuse.

toomuchforonewoman · 23/09/2023 16:39

Vinvertebrate · 23/09/2023 16:37

Tell me what you would say to that child..those children

Leaving aside the fact that you are seriously projecting here, I would advise the parents to complain to the school and LA. Our interests are aligned - we both want my DS in specialist provision. Only one of us cares if he learns to read and write, and I won’t apologize for that.

Complaints go in every day because this child causes mayhem every day. Sending a child to school knowing full well they could and more than often will seriously hurt another child on the daily just astounds me.