Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 candidates, 1 role, smashed the interviews.. chances of success?

164 replies

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:10

I know this is a really difficult question to answer but it's very stuck in my head!

I'm applying for my dream job and have had two very promising interviews, nailed the task set for me and had very good feedback on what a strong candidate I am.

There are three other candidates in the pool and I don't know anything about them. What would you say are the chances of success in this scenario if all members of the interview panel loved your CV and performance in interview.

Is it likely this could happen across the board, or is it a sign you're a strong contender?

My stomach is in knots waiting for the outcome, so please humour me with what your view is on this one!

OP posts:
Onelifeonly · 22/09/2023 15:49

You just don't know. The only job where I was 90% sure they'd give it to me was one where after the interview they said they really liked me but couldn't confirm yet because they had three more people to see. I still went to another interview later that day because I couldn't be sure. (I did get the first job as it happens)

At work recently we had a situation where there were 4 candidates, to be whittled down to 2 after day 1. One of the two who was not taken through to day 2 was shocked and disbelieving. He truly thought he was the best and boy did that show in the way he approached the various tasks etc. Actually he was the least favoured candidate.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:46

ntmdino · 22/09/2023 15:44

I've had this before - aced the interview, got on really well with them on a personal level, pointed out a couple of ways to solve problems with their product (if they had someone in the new role), and then been stunned when the decision came down as a "nope".

I don't mean to burst your bubble, but in my case I pressed them for a reason (because it really didn't make sense), and they basically came up with a whole new set of criteria that maybe one or two candidates in the entire country could possibly fulfil in combination with the original spec, and refused to give me a chance to interview on the basis of the new requirements (even though they hadn't asked me a single question relating to them).

Weirdly, it wasn't even a case of "We've found someone we prefer", which I could begrudgingly accept - they were still trying to fill the role six months later.

Ooof that doesn't sound pleasant but I feel like you dodged a bullet there! Sounds like their expectations don't really align with what they are able to offer candidates..

OP posts:
Notagains · 22/09/2023 15:46

Punkkitty · 22/09/2023 15:13

25%…..

This.
It's impossible to know how well the other candidates did, what their experience is and what softer skills the organisation is looking for.
You will just have to wait and try to stop thinking about it.
Good luck though

ntmdino · 22/09/2023 15:44

I've had this before - aced the interview, got on really well with them on a personal level, pointed out a couple of ways to solve problems with their product (if they had someone in the new role), and then been stunned when the decision came down as a "nope".

I don't mean to burst your bubble, but in my case I pressed them for a reason (because it really didn't make sense), and they basically came up with a whole new set of criteria that maybe one or two candidates in the entire country could possibly fulfil in combination with the original spec, and refused to give me a chance to interview on the basis of the new requirements (even though they hadn't asked me a single question relating to them).

Weirdly, it wasn't even a case of "We've found someone we prefer", which I could begrudgingly accept - they were still trying to fill the role six months later.

itsmylife7 · 22/09/2023 15:44

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:41

Thank you, I will do.

I'm not sure so I'm on the edge of my seat.. they haven't finished the interview process yet though so I know I need to be more patient!

You've done your best. if they don't choose you, it's their loss.

ActDottie · 22/09/2023 15:43

Punkkitty · 22/09/2023 15:13

25%…..

This

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2023 15:43

I am very good at interviews, and can build a really cracking rapport with interviewers.

It's still no guarantee - I had a great feedback chat with a woman who actually put me onto a role I later got, and she said that I was great, but they needed a particular personality fit, and I was too similar to her.

Since we spent an extra forty minutes chatting and ranting about other stuff, I couldn't argue!

MsFrost · 22/09/2023 15:42

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:39

That is the one thing I do know. It was an external only role. But maybe the best thing to do is not set my heart on it as it's less further to fall!

Oh well that gives you a fighting chance... but still, you dont know who the other 3 people are...

I guess what I'm saying is don't beat yourself up if you don't get it. Sometimes it's predestined from the application stage, e.g. someone has 20 years experience in the exact niche that they are looking for and it pretty much as their name written on it. They would have to do terribly at interview to not be offered it because their experience is worth so much.

It's great that you feel you did well in the interview though 💪Hope you get it.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:41

ploymus · 22/09/2023 15:40

Honestly... you've done it now. You have probably done incredibly well at interview.

But there's always the chance that, no matter how well you've done, the MVP could walk in behind you and smash the interview.

Just know that you did your absolute best! It's not about probabilities

That's very true. Either way I guess it's all good experience and helped prep if I decide to apply for any other roles in the future.

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:41

itsmylife7 · 22/09/2023 15:39

Ignore the "catty " remarks OP.

Sounds very positive and hope you get the job.
(when will you know )

Thank you, I will do.

I'm not sure so I'm on the edge of my seat.. they haven't finished the interview process yet though so I know I need to be more patient!

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:40

determinedtomakethiswork · 22/09/2023 15:39

Some people on here are very strange. You don't sound arrogant at all. It sounds as though you represented yourself really well. I really hope you get it.

Thank you I agree. These were there comments not my own. I'm just glad to not have to work with many people like this, thankfully we all support each other.

OP posts:
ploymus · 22/09/2023 15:40

Honestly... you've done it now. You have probably done incredibly well at interview.

But there's always the chance that, no matter how well you've done, the MVP could walk in behind you and smash the interview.

Just know that you did your absolute best! It's not about probabilities

Ilikeicecream · 22/09/2023 15:39

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:20

Well no I'm not asking what the success is prior to the interview. I'm asking that IF both the task and interview went as well as it could, whether those stats would likely change. I'm not thick!

Of course, it will change but without any details on other candidates, how well their interviews went, it's not possible to comment on your chances.

I would say you have pretty high chances of getting selected. When will you know the outcome?

itsmylife7 · 22/09/2023 15:39

Ignore the "catty " remarks OP.

Sounds very positive and hope you get the job.
(when will you know )

determinedtomakethiswork · 22/09/2023 15:39

Some people on here are very strange. You don't sound arrogant at all. It sounds as though you represented yourself really well. I really hope you get it.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:39

MsFrost · 22/09/2023 15:36

It's completely impossible to say if you don't know anything about the other candidates.

You could be amazing but if there's an internal candidate they want to promote then you are still unlikely to get it. This is my experience of interviews anyway. Good luck.

That is the one thing I do know. It was an external only role. But maybe the best thing to do is not set my heart on it as it's less further to fall!

OP posts:
MagentaRocks · 22/09/2023 15:38

I smashed an interview last year, but was literally just pipped at the post by another candidate. If that person hadn’t had been interviewed I would have absolutely got the job. You really can’t expect people to be able to answer your question. I have also interviewed people who were extremely confident and mentioned all the things in the behaviours but with no context or showing an actual understanding that probably thought they smashed it but were so far off the mark.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/09/2023 15:37

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:27

Why are women so mean on this forum? At no point have I said I think I'm gods gift or better than anyone else. Just to make that very clear. Actually I'm full of anxiety and low self esteem, and came here for support. I thought women were meant to lift each other up, not tear each other down. I think I'll bow out of this thread now. Wow.

This old chestnut again?

MsFrost · 22/09/2023 15:36

It's completely impossible to say if you don't know anything about the other candidates.

You could be amazing but if there's an internal candidate they want to promote then you are still unlikely to get it. This is my experience of interviews anyway. Good luck.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:36

Popsicle42 · 22/09/2023 15:34

When do you find out? I’m invested now and want to know if you get it. Best of luck. Hold your head high that you did the absolute best you could.

Thank you for being so sweet 😊

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman2 · 22/09/2023 15:35

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:20

Well no I'm not asking what the success is prior to the interview. I'm asking that IF both the task and interview went as well as it could, whether those stats would likely change. I'm not thick!

But we can’t answer that because, like you, we don’t know the variables.

I once went for a job I had absolutely perfect experience for and did what I thought was a great interview. The feedback was exactly that - unfortunately, I was up against someone who had virtually identical experience, but specifically in the exact same sector (my experience was from a related industry). On any other day I’d have got it, but I couldn’t legislate for the competition - and neither can you.

TeenDivided · 22/09/2023 15:35

Schrodinger's job offer.

Popsicle42 · 22/09/2023 15:34

When do you find out? I’m invested now and want to know if you get it. Best of luck. Hold your head high that you did the absolute best you could.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:31

Vanillalime · 22/09/2023 15:29

I would say 25% chance the job is yours. If there is an internal candidate you would drop to 0%.

Was the task something that showed you got 100% correct like an online test or similar? Just wondering how you know you nailed it?

I recently interviewed 4 people for a role and to be honest they probably all walked away thinking they’d done really well as the panel was warm, friendly, smiling, nodding etc. In the end I ended up hiring 2 applicants as there was only 1 point between them & I was able to justify the extra person. But it could have just as easily have resulted in no successful applicant at all. You just never know.

Good luck, I’ll keep my fingers crossed for you! 🤞

I was under no idea that I had nailed it at all until I was explicitly told so at the end. I've been fretting about it so much that I was convinced I'd fail but had a little pep talk with myself prior. I don't want to add any further context and detail as I don't want to risk outing myself given some of the unpleasant responses here.

But thank you - I guess it makes sense to consider everyone else could do just as good or even better and keep my fingers crossed and be patient.

OP posts:
Vanillalime · 22/09/2023 15:29

I would say 25% chance the job is yours. If there is an internal candidate you would drop to 0%.

Was the task something that showed you got 100% correct like an online test or similar? Just wondering how you know you nailed it?

I recently interviewed 4 people for a role and to be honest they probably all walked away thinking they’d done really well as the panel was warm, friendly, smiling, nodding etc. In the end I ended up hiring 2 applicants as there was only 1 point between them & I was able to justify the extra person. But it could have just as easily have resulted in no successful applicant at all. You just never know.

Good luck, I’ll keep my fingers crossed for you! 🤞