Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 candidates, 1 role, smashed the interviews.. chances of success?

164 replies

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:10

I know this is a really difficult question to answer but it's very stuck in my head!

I'm applying for my dream job and have had two very promising interviews, nailed the task set for me and had very good feedback on what a strong candidate I am.

There are three other candidates in the pool and I don't know anything about them. What would you say are the chances of success in this scenario if all members of the interview panel loved your CV and performance in interview.

Is it likely this could happen across the board, or is it a sign you're a strong contender?

My stomach is in knots waiting for the outcome, so please humour me with what your view is on this one!

OP posts:
SurprisedWithAHorse · 22/09/2023 16:10

With only this information to go on, your chance is one in four. I'm sure you did smash it but that doesn't have any bearing on the likelihood of all the others smashing it too...and anyone who's in the final 4 will be a strong candidate.

Good luck.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:10

Fahhgedaboutit · 22/09/2023 16:06

You’ve got this! And if it doesn’t work out how you hope, something better is just round the corner.

Thank you so much, I really need to channel this! ☀️

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:09

NineToFiveish · 22/09/2023 16:04

The waiting is the worst. I was job hunting earlier this year and its exhausting, running over the interview in my mind afterwards, refreshing my emails, jumping when my phone rang.

I'd say if you feel you did well, you probably did. Which gives you as good a chance as any. But there are so many factors outside of your control, it's best to leave it in the lap of the interview gods and try not to worry. Easier said than done, I know.

I like that terminology- very good idea.

I'm the same, answering my phone to all sorts of spam calls that I'd usually ignore, just in case!

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:08

Spookymormonhelldream · 22/09/2023 16:00

I do a lot of interviews and I would be amazed if 4 consecutive candidates all smashed it. I'd say the panel have probably already whittled it down to 2. Fingers crossed one of them is you!

I recently interviewed myself and of the 3 candidates we interviewed only one was strong. So I guess this is also feeding into my mind the same!

OP posts:
Fahhgedaboutit · 22/09/2023 16:06

You’ve got this! And if it doesn’t work out how you hope, something better is just round the corner.

NineToFiveish · 22/09/2023 16:04

The waiting is the worst. I was job hunting earlier this year and its exhausting, running over the interview in my mind afterwards, refreshing my emails, jumping when my phone rang.

I'd say if you feel you did well, you probably did. Which gives you as good a chance as any. But there are so many factors outside of your control, it's best to leave it in the lap of the interview gods and try not to worry. Easier said than done, I know.

crimsonlake · 22/09/2023 16:04

As already said although you feel you did very well you have no idea how well the other interviewees did. It has happened to me a couple of times, came away thinking it went great and the panel liked me, then the job went to someone else. Fingers crossed for you though,

Clymene · 22/09/2023 16:02

Spookymormonhelldream · 22/09/2023 16:00

I do a lot of interviews and I would be amazed if 4 consecutive candidates all smashed it. I'd say the panel have probably already whittled it down to 2. Fingers crossed one of them is you!

Exactly. I have never interviewed candidates where they've all aced the tasks.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 22/09/2023 16:02

It sounds like you stand a strong chance! Shamrock

Spookymormonhelldream · 22/09/2023 16:00

I do a lot of interviews and I would be amazed if 4 consecutive candidates all smashed it. I'd say the panel have probably already whittled it down to 2. Fingers crossed one of them is you!

AllyCart · 22/09/2023 16:00

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:27

Why are women so mean on this forum? At no point have I said I think I'm gods gift or better than anyone else. Just to make that very clear. Actually I'm full of anxiety and low self esteem, and came here for support. I thought women were meant to lift each other up, not tear each other down. I think I'll bow out of this thread now. Wow.

It's a shame you decided to leave the thread, OP.

I think people are just being honest. It's a 1 in 4 chance unless you know the other 3 didn't do well.

Clymene · 22/09/2023 15:59

determinedtomakethiswork · 22/09/2023 15:39

Some people on here are very strange. You don't sound arrogant at all. It sounds as though you represented yourself really well. I really hope you get it.

Hard agree.

There are a lot of women who enjoy bringing other women down, who are bitter and jealous of other women's success.

Good luck OP. Definitely sounding really positive. When will you find out?

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:59

Tarantella6 · 22/09/2023 15:57

It's a useful skill to be good at interviews so that's good that they told you it had gone well.

But you've got to look at the team fit and if someone else does just as well as you but for whatever reason they think it'll work out better (let's face it, probably an illegal discrimination reason!) then that's out of your control and not a reflection on your performance.

And if that's the case it isn't your dream job - so if you don't get it, you keep looking, because you don't want to work somewhere that for whatever reason you don't fit in.

Thank you, very true. Its an industry they are trying to recruit more women into, so I'm hoping if they do discriminate it's in the direction of fulfilling that 😅 but for all I know, the other candidates could all be female too!

OP posts:
CharlotteBog · 22/09/2023 15:59

How niche is the role?

I went for a job which was pretty much a side ways move skills wise, and I was very confident that I would get it because it was a very specific skill.

Newgirls · 22/09/2023 15:59

op you did your best and whatever the outcome you made some good new contacts and presented yourself well. Be pleased with your interview skills, cv and getting there on time. Have you sent a nice short email saying you enjoyed the interview? You can’t do any more than that now.

I was in exactly this situation last week and they let me know they liked me etc but it went to someone with more drive (I learned from that they wanted someone who could bullshit better!). Since then two more similar jobs have come up so onwards!

MargaretThursday · 22/09/2023 15:58

As others have said, you don't know other factors.
I have a friend who went for an interview he really wanted. Afterwards he was so despondent because while he was waiting to go in he could hear the interviewers laughing and joking and really getting on brilliantly with the previous candidate. He went in and described his interview as dry as a bone, didn't get even a smile out of the interviewers.
He was astonished to be offered the job, and yes, he was first choice.

Tarantella6 · 22/09/2023 15:57

It's a useful skill to be good at interviews so that's good that they told you it had gone well.

But you've got to look at the team fit and if someone else does just as well as you but for whatever reason they think it'll work out better (let's face it, probably an illegal discrimination reason!) then that's out of your control and not a reflection on your performance.

And if that's the case it isn't your dream job - so if you don't get it, you keep looking, because you don't want to work somewhere that for whatever reason you don't fit in.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:57

itsgettingweird · 22/09/2023 15:56

Fingers crossed 🤞 for you.

I get that feeling of really wanting g a job and get full of self doubt. You end up asking yourself a million questions you can't answer!

I went for a promotion at work. My top boss encouraged me to apply. I had some experience but there were outside candidates who had experience of the actual role.

I got nothing in interview. No feedback from interview or task. Was last one of the day. Got told I'd probably not find out until the following day as boss had huge meeting.

Thank god she rang that night because I was like you.

Self doubt and wanting self belief clash!

That's exactly what it is! I'm glad you didn't have to wait too long. I posted because I am so anxious and over thinking it, even though I know I shouldn't be! I'm actually quite baffled how it came across as arrogance - perhaps it was that fake it til you make it confidence I plastered on my face today 😆

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 22/09/2023 15:56

Fingers crossed 🤞 for you.

I get that feeling of really wanting g a job and get full of self doubt. You end up asking yourself a million questions you can't answer!

I went for a promotion at work. My top boss encouraged me to apply. I had some experience but there were outside candidates who had experience of the actual role.

I got nothing in interview. No feedback from interview or task. Was last one of the day. Got told I'd probably not find out until the following day as boss had huge meeting.

Thank god she rang that night because I was like you.

Self doubt and wanting self belief clash!

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:55

Curiosity101 · 22/09/2023 15:51

Agree with others it's 25% as for all you know all the other interviewees smashed it too. Maybe the hiring managers are going to be sat in a consensus meeting soon scratching their heads struggling to pick. 🤷

Good luck either way. And remember that even if you're not selected, you should take the feedback (positive and negative) on board. Even if find that you got literally pipped to the post, that's actually really great feedback to say you're a good candidate for the role so if you see something like that again (and have more experience by then) you should definitely give it another go.

Thank you so much for this. Your point is similar to others but I appreciate you made it more tactfully than some 😅 you are right though, it's still anyone's game to win and I can't influence anything any further at this stage anyway.

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:54

7Worfs · 22/09/2023 15:51

Good luck, OP! I’ve also had final interview today - one of three, I’m internal, no idea of the others are too. 😬
I really want the job!

Fingers crossed you get it! I really hope being internal means you're the strongest candidate.. I'll be wishing both of us luck 🍀

OP posts:
anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:52

Onelifeonly · 22/09/2023 15:49

You just don't know. The only job where I was 90% sure they'd give it to me was one where after the interview they said they really liked me but couldn't confirm yet because they had three more people to see. I still went to another interview later that day because I couldn't be sure. (I did get the first job as it happens)

At work recently we had a situation where there were 4 candidates, to be whittled down to 2 after day 1. One of the two who was not taken through to day 2 was shocked and disbelieving. He truly thought he was the best and boy did that show in the way he approached the various tasks etc. Actually he was the least favoured candidate.

Oh I'd never be like that, if I'm not successful I will leave graciously and thank them for the opportunity.. but I can't say I won't be hurt because I don't want the job so badly, but not because I think I deserve it. As others have said, it's likely many are just as or more qualified than I am which I just need to suck up 😅

OP posts:
Curiosity101 · 22/09/2023 15:51

Agree with others it's 25% as for all you know all the other interviewees smashed it too. Maybe the hiring managers are going to be sat in a consensus meeting soon scratching their heads struggling to pick. 🤷

Good luck either way. And remember that even if you're not selected, you should take the feedback (positive and negative) on board. Even if find that you got literally pipped to the post, that's actually really great feedback to say you're a good candidate for the role so if you see something like that again (and have more experience by then) you should definitely give it another go.

7Worfs · 22/09/2023 15:51

Good luck, OP! I’ve also had final interview today - one of three, I’m internal, no idea of the others are too. 😬
I really want the job!

GingerIsBest · 22/09/2023 15:50

I once went through an interview process for my dream job. Like you, SMASHED IT. Bonded with the various stakeholders who interviewed me, including the person who would be my boss. Clearly knew what I was talking about, had good ideas, and a good grasp of their very specific industry AND cultural challenges etc.

I didn't get the job. I think the recruiter was more annoyed than I was - apparently they told her they thought I was brilliant, clearly had the skill set, understood the business, got on well with the relevant stakeholders etc etc. BUT.... the big big big boss only wanted people who had done that exact same job for the exact same type of company before. Even though they had specifically told the recruiter, and me, that they needed fresh blood, fresh ideas and a little more diversity of thought as they were in the midst of major change (I also had experience in managing change and crisis communications for much bigger, badder organisations).

The man who did get the job, from basically their competitor, lasted less than a year. Then they hired another, almost identical man. At which point the boss who had interviewed me and wanted to hire me left. The second man did okay, I think, but the company subsequently got sold off and split up . So maybe I dodged a bullet?

Either way, good luck. That story was to make the point that sometimes, doing well doesn't mean anything because there are other factors at play.