Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 candidates, 1 role, smashed the interviews.. chances of success?

164 replies

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:10

I know this is a really difficult question to answer but it's very stuck in my head!

I'm applying for my dream job and have had two very promising interviews, nailed the task set for me and had very good feedback on what a strong candidate I am.

There are three other candidates in the pool and I don't know anything about them. What would you say are the chances of success in this scenario if all members of the interview panel loved your CV and performance in interview.

Is it likely this could happen across the board, or is it a sign you're a strong contender?

My stomach is in knots waiting for the outcome, so please humour me with what your view is on this one!

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 22/09/2023 16:54

Fingers crossed for you too, 7Worfs

CobraChicken · 22/09/2023 16:53

heyathere · 22/09/2023 16:47

I really wasn't trying to be bitchy but OP posted it as a question which I was trying to answer but couldn't... What kind of objective evaluation can one be expected to provide in answer to "every single thing went really well"? I think it's really worth congratulating fwiw, and offer my genuine congrats, but maybe it's less confusingly phrased as an "I'm chuffed but still really nervous about a possible spanner in the works! Please keep your fingers crossed with me" etc

Your reply wasn't bitchy in the slightest. None of the ones that were just saying that there's no way to know, were...

I'm referring to people saying stuff along the lines of "Hope you didn't come across as arrogant as in your OP!"

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 22/09/2023 16:51

I don't understand the snippiness of some posters to you OP and you're not coming across as arrogant to me, just supremely hopeful. Ignore the twats.

1 in 4 would be correct only IF there were nothing to choose between the four candidates. They may have done as well as you - or better - or worse. You have done your absolute best and are pleased that you gave a good account of yourself. You really can't ask more of yourself than that so be proud of your interview, come what may. You know that you can interview well and, should you not get the job, you will not be needing to go through the 'what if's' with yourself as you've done all you could.

i hope you get it. I was in the same position as you. Interviewed really well for a job that I really wanted - and I got it. It's awful waiting but, be calm and wait and see. I'm a firm believer that if the job is meant for you, you'll get it. I never believe that about men or relationships, that's bunkum but jobs - absolutely!

Great good luck that you'll hear soon. Star

saveforthat · 22/09/2023 16:49

Hope for the best but prepare for the worst. I had an interview a couple of years ago and the interviewer said "you would be a perfect fit for this role". I didn't get it! Clearly there was more than one perfect fit. There are too many unknowns especially around other candidates. I hope they don't keep you waiting too long.

Birdsongsinging · 22/09/2023 16:48

It sounds like you have a really good chance of getting it - I think if you felt it went really well then it probably did! Good luck!

OatsChoc · 22/09/2023 16:47

I think there is a high chance that you will get the job.

What were the interviewers like? Any bad feelings about any of them?

I was the strongest, by far, candidate in interviews last year, internal too, aced the task, did a great first part of the interview until one woman who's know to be a massive bitch started asking me questions and mad me trip up. In the end no candidate got the job and they had to advertise again. Lucky for me as I got a much nice job with nicer people as a result.

I hope you get what want but by the sound of it, you will!

heyathere · 22/09/2023 16:47

CobraChicken · 22/09/2023 16:44

I think @anyonegotacrystalball4 's mistake was posting in AIBU instead of chat. Nothing that she wrote was arrogant but this board always seems to bring out mega-bitchy responses.

I really wasn't trying to be bitchy but OP posted it as a question which I was trying to answer but couldn't... What kind of objective evaluation can one be expected to provide in answer to "every single thing went really well"? I think it's really worth congratulating fwiw, and offer my genuine congrats, but maybe it's less confusingly phrased as an "I'm chuffed but still really nervous about a possible spanner in the works! Please keep your fingers crossed with me" etc

InfoFreako · 22/09/2023 16:47

Good luck OP! It’s either yes or no. As others have said, it can come down to other factors besides role competence, e.g. personalities, physical characteristics, non-verbal behaviours or whether another candidate knows a panel member. Fingers crossed!

YouJustDoYou · 22/09/2023 16:46

Are you of a minority/"marginalised" group/LGBTQKJTSRF+? Then it's a shoe-in. Unless of course the other candidates are the same....

FernsInTheFire · 22/09/2023 16:45

Impossible to say! I know the agony though… I’ve not progressed in processes where the interviews went like a dream and been offered jobs after performances that left me kicking myself.

In my last experience on the interviewer side we ended up going not for the candidate who was clearly capable of doing the job from day one as they’d already been doing an equivalent for years but someone who could grow into the role as we wanted someone who’d do it for a while. There are all sorts of variables.

krustykittens · 22/09/2023 16:45

Dominoeffecter · 22/09/2023 16:42

And it’s no wonder that we are all so afraid to ever be proud of ourselves if you get labelled arrogant for a straight forward turn of phrase like ‘I nailed the task’ fgs

Right?! God forbid we ever say anything positive about ourselves or take pride when we do something very well!

Poppyseed14 · 22/09/2023 16:45

Good luck OP. My wee granny would have said if it's for you it won't go by you. 💚💚

heyathere · 22/09/2023 16:44

Really really really don't mean to sound catty but your initial post genuinely confused me too... I would get it if more nuance was provided, but the only info is that 100% of everything went swimmingly well. What would you expect to hear apart from this generic answer: high chances unless there are other factors (eg internal candidates / other candidates performing well / other mysterious factors), so it's really a toss up and no one can know? Like what other possible answer could there be? Kindly, if you wanted reassurance or congrats you could just state so directly - it's a life skill in a sense :)

Well done, truly, congrats!! And it's ok to be optimistic and hope for the best!

CobraChicken · 22/09/2023 16:44

I think @anyonegotacrystalball4 's mistake was posting in AIBU instead of chat. Nothing that she wrote was arrogant but this board always seems to bring out mega-bitchy responses.

HermioneWeasley · 22/09/2023 16:44

I think you’ve got a good chance - they’re sending you warm signals, and it’s very rare to have multiple candidates you’d be happy to offer to. Fingers crossed for you!

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 22/09/2023 16:44

Hope you get the position, OP. Good luck!

Mimmy352 · 22/09/2023 16:43

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:39

I know multiple people in the company myself. However absolutely didn't brag on this.

It’s not necessarily about name dropping or bragging, it’s about who you know within the company.

Do you know anyone connected to the role?

krustykittens · 22/09/2023 16:42

OP, I feel your anxiety! But look at it this way - you have a job you love, you are not desperate to start this job as you need rent money, so you are in a great position. The key thing is, if you don't get this job, try not to take it too personally, just keep looking for that dream job. I have got jobs when I have felt like I didn't show myself at my best, and not got jobs when I thought I smashed it. I know when you are anxious the temptation is to go online and research the shit out of what is making you anxious but no one can really tell you what the statistical chances are of you getting THIS job as we don't know all the variables. If you get it, celebrate, if you don't, deep breath and onwards and upwards. Do NOT let a rejection knock your confidence. Good luck!

Dominoeffecter · 22/09/2023 16:42

And it’s no wonder that we are all so afraid to ever be proud of ourselves if you get labelled arrogant for a straight forward turn of phrase like ‘I nailed the task’ fgs

Dominoeffecter · 22/09/2023 16:41

Good luck, no idea of your chances of getting it as I’ve thought I had it in the bag myself a couple of times only to find someone else had done even better! I don’t think you come across as arrogant at all and you should be proud of a successful portrayal of your skills whatever the outcome

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 16:41

@anyonegotacrystalball4 you may well be the least arrogant person in the world, but I was commenting on how you’ve come across in the few posts you’ve made. Comments such about how much you “nailed the task” and some of the tone have come across to me that way. I’m not being “mean”, you’ve asked a question and this is my answer. It’s not indicative of you as a person when it’s only based on a couple of posts, but equally it’s a possibility.

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:39

Mimmy352 · 22/09/2023 16:33

Recruiter here.
All external candidates doesn’t mean much - one or two could know someone in the company and that (unfairly) gives them an advantage.

Any one of them could have more experience or more knowledge, but they also could have less experience or knowledge. Unless you’re part of the recruitment process, you won’t know until you know.

Is the recruitment in-house or external?

I know multiple people in the company myself. However absolutely didn't brag on this.

OP posts:
Mimmy352 · 22/09/2023 16:38

Mistressanne · 22/09/2023 16:35

Hope you get it op.
However friends dh felt similarly about an interview and actually gave notice at his current employment.
He didn’t get the job and his employer wouldn’t take him back.
Keep your cards close to your chest.

So sorry he had to learn that the hard way! That’s why I, and many other recruiters, advise not to hand in a notice until you’ve got your contract signed and sent back, and you’re sure you’re happy with it all.

I’m surprised no one told him this tbh

AngelinaFibres · 22/09/2023 16:37

I really, really, really wanted a particular job 22 years ago. I really needed it too. I didn't get it. I was very disappointed. The chain of events that happened as a result of not getting my 'dream' job changed my life in a way I could never have imagined. The absolutely wonderful life I have now would never have happened if they had chosen me. If you don't get it ,then you will be understandably upset. That's fine, allow yourself a wallow. You never know what will come instead. Hope you get it though xxx

SurprisedWithAHorse · 22/09/2023 16:37

Mistressanne · 22/09/2023 16:35

Hope you get it op.
However friends dh felt similarly about an interview and actually gave notice at his current employment.
He didn’t get the job and his employer wouldn’t take him back.
Keep your cards close to your chest.

Why on earth did he give notice before he had an offer??