Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 candidates, 1 role, smashed the interviews.. chances of success?

164 replies

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:10

I know this is a really difficult question to answer but it's very stuck in my head!

I'm applying for my dream job and have had two very promising interviews, nailed the task set for me and had very good feedback on what a strong candidate I am.

There are three other candidates in the pool and I don't know anything about them. What would you say are the chances of success in this scenario if all members of the interview panel loved your CV and performance in interview.

Is it likely this could happen across the board, or is it a sign you're a strong contender?

My stomach is in knots waiting for the outcome, so please humour me with what your view is on this one!

OP posts:
CantFindTheBeat · 22/09/2023 17:52

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 15:24

I’d say your biggest risk here is arrogance. If you came across in the interview the way you’re coming across here, and these people have an eye for it, you may not get through.

Interviewed someone a few weeks back who was absolutely full of confidence (which was actually arrogance) and I’ve no doubt he thought he’d smashed that interview. Buzz words left right and centre, reiterating the interview competency framework back at us, never shut up. But it was all BS with no substance and we saw right through him.

Hopefully you’re not the same as him, and your skills and experience are genuine, but a bit of humility wouldn’t go amiss.

What a shitty post.

Are you so mealy-mouthed in real life?

OP - it's brilliant that you've interviewed for a job you'd love, and you're happy with the way the interviews went.

The absolute best of luck. It's always in the lap of the gods as there are so many unknown criteria you just don't have sight of, but you know you've shown you're a great candidate and that's all you can do x

CapEBarra · 22/09/2023 17:46

I’ve everything crossed for you and it sounds as though you’ve absolutely given it your best shot. The risks are more likely to be - another candidate is a friend of one of the hiring team/went to the same school/Uni as the big boss, one of them fancied one of the candidates (shouldn’t happen but it does)…that sort of thing. I went to an interview and was down to the last two - it was me and a man. I got the job but my male boss told me later he really wanted to give it to the man as they supported the same football team but he just wasn’t good enough at the final hurdle - you just don’t know what else is in play 🤷‍♀️

SurprisedWithAHorse · 22/09/2023 17:35

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 17:21

@SurprisedWithAHorse yes, I’ve taken pride, and been proud of myself before, but I tend not to say that to people. I let them make their own decisions on whether I’ve done something well.

As I said, it’s impossible to be a personal insult and I don’t know this person, but from my experience of interviewing people who think they’re doing really well and outwardly say so, that’s how it came across. If other people don’t think so, that’s fine. But trying to invalidate what is essentially someone else’s opinion is pretty ridiculous of a lot of the posters in here.

yes, I’ve taken pride, and been proud of myself before, but I tend not to say that to people.

But you will try to pull other people down for expressing the same positive feelings you have? Don't know why you think that's better.

Sunshinenrain · 22/09/2023 17:35

25%

I’ve smashed interviews before and been told specifically that I’m the strongest candidate they’ve interviewed.
But I still didn’t get offered the position.

One (TA position) was because they were looking for someone long term and as my experience/qualifications was more than what they was asking they couldn’t take the risk of me leaving after a short while.

Another one (teacher position in a PRU) was because the students were so challenging that they had a big turnover of staff. And they chose to go for a TA who hadn’t done their teacher training yet as they’d been in a PRU before, over me who was a qualified teacher and had lots of SEN and mainstream experience, because the TA was more likely to stay.

I got a job that I didn’t do great in the interview.
I was by far the weakest candidate when it came to experience and qualifications. The bud had also broken down and so I had to get a taxi and wait for it in the pouring rain and I slipped and fell face first in mud.
So I was soaking wet, covered in mud, mascara running down my face and I was late but I got the job because they felt my personality would fit in well and they’d rather that and train me up, than someone who’s personality didn’t fit but had the qualifications.

Good luck OP.
What will be will be.

ArcticLingered · 22/09/2023 17:33

It's not 25% though is it? They don't interview 4 people and then draw lots or run a raffle to see who to pick. They pick the one they want most. So it's either a 100% chance or 0%, depending on whether they want to give you the job or not. You can't read any more into it than that. There may be someone they know who was always going to get the job but they had to go through the motions of doing a "fair" process.

Poblano · 22/09/2023 17:32

Unfortunately it can be really hard to tell, so your chances really are probably 25%.

I had an interview last year where I had great rapport with the interview panel, but I didn't get the job. I actually interviewed again for another role within the organisation and got that, despite feeling less rapport with the panel that time. I now work with 2 of the 3 that were on the first panel and we get on really well, so the rapport was really there, just someone else gave better answers than me.

Best of luck OP.

Pantspangles · 22/09/2023 17:29

It would think it’s yours @anyonegotacrystalball4! Sounds really promising and I will keep things crossed for you!

(other posters- of course nobody can tell really but OP sounds like she has done a brilliant job of the selection process and if she was my real life friend I would be just as positive as the first bit of my post- @anyonegotacrystalball4 deserves some support.)

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 22/09/2023 17:28

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 17:21

@SurprisedWithAHorse yes, I’ve taken pride, and been proud of myself before, but I tend not to say that to people. I let them make their own decisions on whether I’ve done something well.

As I said, it’s impossible to be a personal insult and I don’t know this person, but from my experience of interviewing people who think they’re doing really well and outwardly say so, that’s how it came across. If other people don’t think so, that’s fine. But trying to invalidate what is essentially someone else’s opinion is pretty ridiculous of a lot of the posters in here.

Since you don't know the OP, why make the comments that you did? Completely unnecessary and it really does speak volumes that women are not ever allowed free rein of their feelings for fear that some other woman will slap her down.

Roselilly36 · 22/09/2023 17:27

Aww good luck I hope you get it. I can remember those days, the limbo while you are waiting for news. Keeping everything crossed for you OP. But if you don’t, something else with come up, that will be an even better fit. Because that’s life. Good luck.

DoubleTequilaSunrise · 22/09/2023 17:27

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 16:34

The difference is I'm not in a big rush to leave my job. It's perfectly fine. It's just an opportunity to do my dream job which is my same job at a particular company that's come up.

If I don't get it, I'm not in a rush to randomly start applying to jobs. I really want to make sure I'm applying to jobs I truly want, otherwise I'm happy to stay put where I am a while longer.

wow, I was trying to be nice. I sympathised because waiting for an answer is painful.

No one is asking you to "randomly" apply to everything and waste everybody's time.

If you want me to be clearer: if you come across as desperate or too confident it's in the bag, it's not a good look either. If you are happy where you are, you don't need the job, it doesn't matter anyway does it?

Hopefully the role will go to the candidate who is the most motivated and best at it.

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 17:21

@SurprisedWithAHorse yes, I’ve taken pride, and been proud of myself before, but I tend not to say that to people. I let them make their own decisions on whether I’ve done something well.

As I said, it’s impossible to be a personal insult and I don’t know this person, but from my experience of interviewing people who think they’re doing really well and outwardly say so, that’s how it came across. If other people don’t think so, that’s fine. But trying to invalidate what is essentially someone else’s opinion is pretty ridiculous of a lot of the posters in here.

TopOfTheCliff · 22/09/2023 17:17

I once applied for a job with 300 applicants and got through to the last four. There were two posts. I didn’t get offered one. When I asked for feedback they said blithely “ you ranked second after ms X but we wanted a male and a female so mr Y got the second job”
Nowadays I would have slammed them with a sex discrimination case but in the 1980s I just sucked it up.
Sometimes there are factors at work you cannot see. Fingers crossed they work in your favour. Good luck!

HarlanPepper · 22/09/2023 17:15

Waiting for news is such torture! I can understand why you'd want to somehow quantify your chances of success, that's exactly the sort of thing I do. But it totally depends who else is in the running and other factors beyond your control. I really hope you get it, and at least you smashed the interview.

WonderingWanda · 22/09/2023 17:09

Good luck op but I'm not honestly sure you can tell from just having a good interview. I recently got my dream job and I felt certain I'd messed it up in half the tasks and the interview ( 4 tasks in total). I can only assume they could see through my nerves and from what I'd outlined in my application that I was the right person for the job. In my opinion the other 3 candidates seemed equally good and much more confident than me.

PyongyangKipperbang · 22/09/2023 17:07

I had one recently. I knew I fulfilled all the criteria and the reason I know I did well at interview was that they told me so in the feedback. I was second choice and they offered it someone who had more experience within the sector than I did. Apart from that there was very little in it. She did say it was difficult to chose between two very strong candidates.

Gutted wasnt the word but at least I know I did well and I didnt imagine it when I walked out thinking I had nailed the interviews!

Keeping everything crossed for you!

ManateeFair · 22/09/2023 17:06

anyonegotacrystalball4 · 22/09/2023 15:25

Absolutely not. I'm the least arrogant person and do nothing but doubt myself. These are the comments that the interviewers made, hence what I'm repeating here. But as I'm actually so full of self doubt, this is why I'm asking the question.

I don't think you sound arrogant at all, OP! We've all had that feeling of knowing an interview went as well as it possibly could have done and sitting there on tenterhooks waiting to find out the outcome. Even though we can't really tell you what your chances are, I've certainly got my fingers crossed for you.

Henryhover · 22/09/2023 17:04

Awww OP I wouldnt worry about how shitty other people are, some are so jealous 🤣🤣

You sound anxious not arrogant and that's completely normal! If you don't get it then it's their loss as I'm sure you're a great person! 🤞 soo good luck to you and your dream job! ❤️

HikingforScenery · 22/09/2023 17:04

That’s usually when you find your dream job, when you’re alright where you are and not desperate for the one you’re interviewing for! Good luck!

ManateeFair · 22/09/2023 17:01

Without knowing how good the other candidates were, nobody can tell what you what your chances are. If there are four candidates and you all did equally well, then obviously you've all got the same 25% of success, but of course we don't know that.

NeedToChangeName · 22/09/2023 16:57

I was once told that I was the successful candidate, brought in for training, shown where I would sit, introduced to the team...... and they STILL went and offered the role to someone else ! Completely bizarre and highly unprofessional

But, the joke's on them as I now earn twice as much elsewhere and love my current role

I hope you are successful. But if you're not, it'll all turn out fine in the end

TheGoodBanana · 22/09/2023 16:57

Well OP I for one really hope you have got it, it sounds like you have done well so I foresee good news in your future!

My fingers are crossed for you. Good Luck!

heyathere · 22/09/2023 16:57

CobraChicken · 22/09/2023 16:53

Your reply wasn't bitchy in the slightest. None of the ones that were just saying that there's no way to know, were...

I'm referring to people saying stuff along the lines of "Hope you didn't come across as arrogant as in your OP!"

Maybe some were malicious but I guess I can understand that perspective. If you're asking for an objective evaluation but then just say 100% of everything went well, it can come across as a bit arrogant. Not to try and mind read OP, but I learnt years ago that it's ok to ask straight up for reassurance or congrats, rather than fish, and I feel it's a handy life skill sometimes.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 22/09/2023 16:56

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 16:41

@anyonegotacrystalball4 you may well be the least arrogant person in the world, but I was commenting on how you’ve come across in the few posts you’ve made. Comments such about how much you “nailed the task” and some of the tone have come across to me that way. I’m not being “mean”, you’ve asked a question and this is my answer. It’s not indicative of you as a person when it’s only based on a couple of posts, but equally it’s a possibility.

Oh come on. You've never, ever taken pride in something you knew you did well? You think you're always shit at everything?

OatsChoc · 22/09/2023 16:55

I don't understand the snippiness of some posters

If a guy on a forum with men had posted that he 'smashed' an interview, the other guys would say great well done! But as women we must be meek an unconfident.

Too many women love to undermine other women.

Iheartpizza · 22/09/2023 16:55

Based on what you've said I think you have an excellent chance!

It's unlikely all 4 candidates smashed the interview and made a really good impression on the panel.

Good luck, I hope you get it!