Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DfE data: Only HALF of required number of trainee secondary teachers in England recruited

80 replies

sunnydaytoday0 · 22/09/2023 15:07

Only half of the required number of trainee secondary school teachers in England have been recruited as the academic year gets under way, analysis shows. Ministers are on course to miss their recruitment targets by 48%.

The DfE said there were a record number of teachers in schools, up by 27,000 since 2010. The unions point out, however, that the number of pupils in state-funded schools in England has risen at almost double the rate of the teaching workforce.

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/sep/12/only-half-of-required-number-of-trainee-secondary-teachers-in-england-recruited

But hang on, those glossy soft-focus Get into Teaching adverts on TV show so many wonderfully happy and satisfied teachers, and classes fully of quiet, attentive students? And the government claims teachers are paid so well. Shouldn't training courses therefore be stuffed full of highly qualified graduates who want to do the job? I'm assuming teacher retention rates must be excellent at the moment that it explains why the government wouldn't need to be concerned about a huge crash in new bodies being recruited. Right?

DfE data: Only HALF of required number of trainee secondary teachers in England recruited
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shinyandnew1 · 25/09/2023 10:22

Getting up and out to work Monday-Friday with absolutely zero flexibility absolutely does need a premium ££££ in this day and age.

I agree. Since Covid, particularly, there has been a huge change in the working lives of many of my friends and family. Lots now work from home much of the week (not necessarily all), they have the option to WFH if feeling vaguely unwell so have taken no sick leave, they can schedule appointments and deliveries around meetings (along with making dinner and bunging a load of washing in!) so they’re not coming home to a cold dark house and having to start from scratch every evening. My DS had a 4 hour commute each day which she now only does twice a month. She goes running, cooks home made meals, her house is sparkling and her (older) kids are coming home to someone in the house and she’s still doing a productive full week at workz

I feel I’m on a hamster wheel and I can’t get off-leave the house in the dark, get home in the dark, alway rushing, no time to do anything properly.

Tribevibes · 24/09/2023 13:49

I didn’t think of it like that in regards to a premium but it’s absolutely spot on. Getting up and out to work Monday - Friday with absolutely zero flexibility absolutely does need a premium ££££ in this day and age.

Too many Pollyannas in education mind. If people stopped working for free/good will the politicians would have to get their acts together to improve conditions.

sunnydaytoday0 · 23/09/2023 19:46

noblegiraffe · 22/09/2023 19:44

No ability to WFH is a massive issue post-pandemic. If you look at the recruitment stats in the OP they have plummeted and it's thought that grads are now far more likely to be looking for jobs with some WFH.

Grad jobs that require you to go into work every day will, at some point, have to pay a premium for that.

I agree, this is definitely a factor that's going to become an even bigger problem in future years. The major drop in recruitment as seen on the chart in the period since the pandemic has coincided with peoples' outlook and priorities changing. Graduates are rating work-life balance very highly, and teaching has to complete with other well paid jobs that can offer FAR more flexibility; flexible work schedule, flexible work location, working from home, four day week etc.

If the government doesn't recognise this as an issue (on top of all the other issues causing the recruitment/retention crisis) then I won't be surprised at all if those recruitment numbers continue to go into freefall.

OP posts:
Tribevibes · 23/09/2023 19:01

@Shinyandnew1

my sisters are nurses and once they go up the payscales they don’t spend their lives justifying it. Obviously they work to competency but they don’t need to perform daily miracles and they have job security. Their experience is valued.

Massamankind · 23/09/2023 18:59

Shinyandnew1 · 23/09/2023 18:51

It’s interesting that this seems to be isolated in teaching. Heads have a small set budget and need eg 12 teachers…it’s been far cheaper to hire a newly qualified teacher than one on UPS. (There is less different now they’ve flattened the pay scale, tbh.)

Is the structure different within an NHS ward/department where you have to have some Band 3, some 4, some 5 etc?

Yes it is. We are meant to have certain number of registered nurses on shift etc. Doesn’t always happen.

In fact we have an issue where new young staff are promoted too quickly and lack the experience.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/09/2023 18:51

Massamankind · 23/09/2023 18:09

The NHS is a public service that is also going downhill. Recruitment and retention issues. I work in it and am horrified by what I see.

What I don’t see is this ‘managing out’ of expensive experienced staff. I am horrified this goes on in teaching. (Genuinely shit staff in my trust are hard to get rid of). Talk about shooting yourself in the foot 😐

It’s interesting that this seems to be isolated in teaching. Heads have a small set budget and need eg 12 teachers…it’s been far cheaper to hire a newly qualified teacher than one on UPS. (There is less different now they’ve flattened the pay scale, tbh.)

Is the structure different within an NHS ward/department where you have to have some Band 3, some 4, some 5 etc?

Massamankind · 23/09/2023 18:09

The NHS is a public service that is also going downhill. Recruitment and retention issues. I work in it and am horrified by what I see.

What I don’t see is this ‘managing out’ of expensive experienced staff. I am horrified this goes on in teaching. (Genuinely shit staff in my trust are hard to get rid of). Talk about shooting yourself in the foot 😐

viques · 23/09/2023 18:01

Don’t forget, recruitment is only half the story. Retention has always been an issue.

Add to that the number of teachers choosing to work part time, sprinkle in the number of teachers on maternity leave ( it’s a profession where youngish fertile women predominate and teachers maternity leave entitlement is a generous one) , and I think we are sailing into a perfect storm.

LolaSmiles · 23/09/2023 17:53

That sounds about right noble. I've never been an NUT member and can count on one hand the number of times I've been on strike.

noblegiraffe · 23/09/2023 17:06

We all went on strike in 2011, that was the big joint union Gove one. Think the others were NUT only? (NEU for latest).

Tribevibes · 23/09/2023 16:52

They do manage out expensive and talented teachers. They often replace them with cover supervisors who aren’t as talented but are definitely cheaper. It might sound “mad” but they need to balance the books somehow. Employing non qualified teachers makes sense financially and you can’t rub a magic lamp for extra cash. It’s not that hard to fathom why this happens. No one wins.

cardibach · 23/09/2023 16:30

@Fiiiish I’ve done a little research.
There was a strike in 1987, then one in 2008.
The next one I can find is 2014 (the one I missed).
Then the 2023 ones.
Are you perhaps counting individual strike days as different actions?

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/7367471
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-26729786

Thousands of schools shut by NUT strike

Thousands of schools in England and Wales closed for a day, as teachers joined rallies and picket lines in a strike over pay, pensions and conditions.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-26729786

cardibach · 23/09/2023 16:23

Fiiiish · 23/09/2023 16:13

In my 20+ years of parenting there have been at least 6 strikes that I can remember off hand and that's without considering the universities.

Not national ones there haven’t. And of course we aren’t counting universities as that’s not what this is about. I’ve been teaching since 1983. I went on strike early in my career, then again in the early 2000s. I missed a national strike while I worked in an independent school (meaning we weren’t involved as the matter was one in the control of the school) and again this last school year. I can assure you I have been on strike every time my union has voted for strike action.

Fiiiish · 23/09/2023 16:13

cardibach · 23/09/2023 15:55

And incidentally, - striking? Yes, there have been strikes recently. In a 35 year career they were only the 3rd set. Teachers don’t strike much at all.
they’re also relentlessly positive in the classroom as that’s the only way to get anywhere, so students don’t see the downsides so much.
You are really pretty ignorant about the whole set up, aren’t you @TizerorFizz ?

In my 20+ years of parenting there have been at least 6 strikes that I can remember off hand and that's without considering the universities.

noblegiraffe · 23/09/2023 16:05

Yep.

LolaSmiles · 23/09/2023 16:01

They don’t manage out decent teachers
They absolutely do!
Every teacher I know can recall stories of colleagues they know who were treated appallingly and managed out, especially when those colleagues were experienced female staff in their 40s and 50s on UPS and working part time.

PumpkinPie2016 · 23/09/2023 15:57

Sadly I'm not surprised.

I love teaching. I love leading my department. I do absolutely everything I can to keep workload manageable for my team, while also ensuring that we give the kids the best we possibly can.

My school serves a very disadvantaged cohort and most of our kids are genuinely lovely and want to do well.

All that said, as much as I love the job, it is hard work both physically and mentally. Last night, I could cheerfully have gone to bed at 8pm and couldn't find the energy to have a proper conversation.

Some schools are extremely challenging in terms of pupil behaviour and insane workload (my last one almost broke me).

I can absolutely see why people are put off.

cardibach · 23/09/2023 15:55

And incidentally, - striking? Yes, there have been strikes recently. In a 35 year career they were only the 3rd set. Teachers don’t strike much at all.
they’re also relentlessly positive in the classroom as that’s the only way to get anywhere, so students don’t see the downsides so much.
You are really pretty ignorant about the whole set up, aren’t you @TizerorFizz ?

cardibach · 23/09/2023 15:53

TizerorFizz · 23/09/2023 15:31

So “expensive” equals well paid? Yes of course they want experienced good teachers to stay and you’ve not been managed out. Possibly because you cannot be replaced? Plus because you are good. You should not work on marking in the summer holidays. Or anything else much. I agree and many teachers manage this in exchange for longer days in term time. Any school managing good experienced teachers out now is mad! Note my use of “good”. Some might need help to stay but most are fine these days.

It’s interesting how people don’t accept that being around miserable, complaining and striking staff puts new recruits off. It’s negative and to be avoided. Poor slts is another barrier to recruitment. Governors and slt (who were teachers) not understanding how to get the best out of people re job design and workplace culture is a huge issue. Maybe some slts should not be ex teachers at all? Perhaps others have a greater understanding of managing staff? Just floating that!

A state school tried to manage me out just before I became Head of English at an independent school. They absolutely do manage out good, experienced teachers because of cost.

sunnydaytoday0 · 23/09/2023 15:47

Do we have Michael Gove on the thread?

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 23/09/2023 15:34

So “expensive” equals well paid? Yes of course they want experienced good teachers to stay

You've literally no idea. And yet you keep pontificating. Why is that?

It's interesting how some people seem to suggest that talking about poor working conditions is the issue that affects recruitment rather than the actual poor working conditions.

TizerorFizz · 23/09/2023 15:31

So “expensive” equals well paid? Yes of course they want experienced good teachers to stay and you’ve not been managed out. Possibly because you cannot be replaced? Plus because you are good. You should not work on marking in the summer holidays. Or anything else much. I agree and many teachers manage this in exchange for longer days in term time. Any school managing good experienced teachers out now is mad! Note my use of “good”. Some might need help to stay but most are fine these days.

It’s interesting how people don’t accept that being around miserable, complaining and striking staff puts new recruits off. It’s negative and to be avoided. Poor slts is another barrier to recruitment. Governors and slt (who were teachers) not understanding how to get the best out of people re job design and workplace culture is a huge issue. Maybe some slts should not be ex teachers at all? Perhaps others have a greater understanding of managing staff? Just floating that!

ThrallsWife · 23/09/2023 13:22

People don’t want to teach because it’s described as “brutal” snd the holidays are spent planning and marking. Marking I would query

You would query marking in the holidays?

Lol. Most mock exams are taken just before a big set of holidays (usually Christmas and Easter) precisely because people can then spend their holidays marking.

I am a very efficient and organised person. I still have to work evenings, holidays and weekends, because that's just the nature of the job.

Having said that, I don't lift a finger over the summer holidays, one week over Christmas and the first week of Easter. But school get plenty of extra working hours out of me, amounting to double of what I'm paid for. Because when you're as expensive as me, you need them to really want you to stay.

Cupofteafortwo · 23/09/2023 12:04

I’ve just commented this on another thread. I gave up teaching before I barely started- the kids were great. The parents/staff room snipping/ paperwork was brutal. Now teach adults, 2-5 days WFH, more pay than I was teaching, and way less hours. Nothing would ever drag me back into a class room.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/09/2023 11:53

As for secondary schools specifically, the lack of guidance re pupils who say they are trans places teachers in a difficult position regarding their jobs. A career is less attractive if you think you could lose your job or promotion because of a comment being taken the wrong way, when no malice is intended.

I think the impact that has on potential or actual teachers is pretty negligible, tbh.