Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am being unreasonable, but what do you think anyway?

117 replies

iabuik · 22/09/2023 10:45

DP are in our 30s, have been together for 4 years, own a house and have a 1 year old.

But ever since we've been together, he's never made any effort for birthdays or Christmas, usually resorting to saying "let's not bother getting anything for each other this year", except he says that every year and always has done.

It doesn't bother me enough to cause any drama, but I am aware that he used to whisk his ex off for surprise weekend breaks, decorate the house, generally make a big effort. Sure, that was a different relationship and I'm sure the dynamics were very different, but it still doesn't stop me from feeling that I'd quite like to get something more than "let's not bother this year" when I'm supposed to be his person for life (his words, not mine).

I'm definitely being unreasonable to make comparisons but I'm still interested to know if anyone else would bat an eyelid in this situation.

OP posts:
IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 17:57

Shoxfordian · 22/09/2023 17:48

Probably, he found it too much work to keep up with her so he’s with someone easier who expects nothing

Also, I am sure that many of the men that women endlessly complain about on here buy presents.

So these presents mean absolutely nothing.

Buying a present takes no effort. Acting as a decent husband does.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 17:54

Shoxfordian · 22/09/2023 17:48

Probably, he found it too much work to keep up with her so he’s with someone easier who expects nothing

Well, I assume he must be ok otherwise the OP wouldn't be with him.

My husband is as perfect as I could ever wish for. If he did not want to buy me presents and weekends away it would not bother me.

Luckily I don't want them either, but if I did it would not be a deal breaker if everything else was great.

Shoxfordian · 22/09/2023 17:48

Probably, he found it too much work to keep up with her so he’s with someone easier who expects nothing

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 17:26

Shoxfordian · 22/09/2023 14:57

The ex had higher standards and expected him to act right but you’ve been letting him slide by on the bare minimum that’s why you get nothing from him. Expect better because you’re worth better

Higher standards? Is that why she is an ex?

Shoxfordian · 22/09/2023 14:57

The ex had higher standards and expected him to act right but you’ve been letting him slide by on the bare minimum that’s why you get nothing from him. Expect better because you’re worth better

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 14:46

saltinesandcoffeecups · 22/09/2023 13:59

The ex is neither here nor there. The only thing that matters is what you both want out of your current relationship. You clearly want to celebrate your Bday and Xmas. So tell him!

He’s not a mind reader. He asked you and you agreed to the ‘No bother’ thing. Tell him what you want.

When I first started dating my now DH he had to work on Easter, I had a lovely brunch with friends. After which I was damn near in tears that I didn’t have an Easter basket (First holiday away from family). While I was talking to him (poor guy called during my drama) he felt awful. I conceded he had no idea because I didn’t know that it was important to me but it clearly was important (even if it is silly).

Guess what I’ve had every year since that ill fated Easter?

The real question is why after 4 years with him do feel like you can’t be honest with him? I’m not saying LTB (especially since on the surface he’s done nothing wrong). But it’s really not normal in a healthy relationship to be so hesitant to bring up an issue.

But I think that he has made it perfectly clear that he does not want to do presents.

If she does, then she should do them.

Why should he be forced to do something he clearly doesn't want to do?

I assume that if she asked him then he would do it reluctantly but why should he?

saltinesandcoffeecups · 22/09/2023 13:59

The ex is neither here nor there. The only thing that matters is what you both want out of your current relationship. You clearly want to celebrate your Bday and Xmas. So tell him!

He’s not a mind reader. He asked you and you agreed to the ‘No bother’ thing. Tell him what you want.

When I first started dating my now DH he had to work on Easter, I had a lovely brunch with friends. After which I was damn near in tears that I didn’t have an Easter basket (First holiday away from family). While I was talking to him (poor guy called during my drama) he felt awful. I conceded he had no idea because I didn’t know that it was important to me but it clearly was important (even if it is silly).

Guess what I’ve had every year since that ill fated Easter?

The real question is why after 4 years with him do feel like you can’t be honest with him? I’m not saying LTB (especially since on the surface he’s done nothing wrong). But it’s really not normal in a healthy relationship to be so hesitant to bring up an issue.

Fallingthroughclouds · 22/09/2023 12:58

I seem to be of the few people that hates getting presents, so I'd be saying the same to mainly avoid that. Unless money is an issue, I don't see why you can't do a weekend away or something and I am guessing if you asked him to decorate the house together then he would. Lay down your cards, very possible he doesn't even know it bothers you.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:56

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:50

That makes sense. I do kind of get what you mean as I'm really not a huggy person but my partner is and I have to remind myself to give a little bit for his sake but it does drive me a bit mad.

on the other hand, i do feel this case here is a bit different because he’s apparently done these things for his ex in the past. So why not now?

perhaps, as a PP suggested, he does just feel more comfortable being himself with OP and she hasn’t demanded and therefore he’s just being his natural self.

Yes, I think that is exactly it.

My husband hated every moment of his life with his ex for many reasons including that she wanted him to buy her presents and surprise her etc.

He couldn't easily leave as they had 3 small kids (she told he she was on the pill when she wasn't and he got a vasectomy after the 3rd when he realised she was lying) and he is a decent guy and didn't want to split until the kids were older.

Some people like buying presents others don't.

rentreenothanks · 22/09/2023 12:55

How do you know he did this with his ex? Does he tell you about it?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:51

pictoosh · 22/09/2023 10:58

He played the part until you were safely bagged and now he doesn't see the need.
Put the lazy bastard straight. No, I like a fuss and I want to be cherished on my birthday.

Lazy? He doesnt' want to do it. Why should he?

Unless there are other things that the OP doesn't like about him, then this is nothing.

Does he care about her? Does he treat her well when she is ill? Does he do his share of the chores and look after their child?

If he doesn't so those things, then yes, he is lazy.

Not wanting to buy presents in not lazy.

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:50

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:45

But I would hate to have to do that. I absolutely hate buying presents as I don't know what to buy.

I really don't think I could be with someone who wanted me to buy them presents and organise weekends away.

The OP likes doing that sort of thing, so she should carry on if she wants to but shouldn't force her OH to do it.

That makes sense. I do kind of get what you mean as I'm really not a huggy person but my partner is and I have to remind myself to give a little bit for his sake but it does drive me a bit mad.

on the other hand, i do feel this case here is a bit different because he’s apparently done these things for his ex in the past. So why not now?

perhaps, as a PP suggested, he does just feel more comfortable being himself with OP and she hasn’t demanded and therefore he’s just being his natural self.

Janieforever · 22/09/2023 12:49

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 12:44

I don’t think you’re unreasonable. It’s not unreasonable for anyone to hope that their partner will show them that they care about them, and treating/spoiling your partner is one way of doing this - portraying love and thoughtfulness.

What has your response been when he says it? If you seem to accept it happily I guess I can understand. While it makes sense to talk to him about it, I also think it completely defeats the object in this instance, the whole point of spoiling someone is because YOU chose to. Not because they had to ask you to do it. So I don’t think telling him to do it will make you feel any better.

Even without presents, he could make you feel special, cook dinner for you, make a fuss of you etc. I would be a bit upset too.

I think it’s about the individual. You like all that stuff , as the op does, and wants it, for me, I honestly am not bothered, I would find it a royal pain in the arse if my husband expected me to be cooking special meals, buying him gifts and whisking him away on weekends, just to show I love him, and I’ve no desire for him to do that for me.

if however he said I really need you to start buying me stuff and doing things for me to prove you love me, I’d be a bit eeked out. If he said let’s do something special this year, shall we plan it together, I’d be like sure and be all for it. So for me, she should say something.

everhone is different.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:47

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 12:44

I don’t think you’re unreasonable. It’s not unreasonable for anyone to hope that their partner will show them that they care about them, and treating/spoiling your partner is one way of doing this - portraying love and thoughtfulness.

What has your response been when he says it? If you seem to accept it happily I guess I can understand. While it makes sense to talk to him about it, I also think it completely defeats the object in this instance, the whole point of spoiling someone is because YOU chose to. Not because they had to ask you to do it. So I don’t think telling him to do it will make you feel any better.

Even without presents, he could make you feel special, cook dinner for you, make a fuss of you etc. I would be a bit upset too.

But you don't have to buy presents to show someone you care.

My ex would buy me cards and presents but was awful to me. It meant nothing.

You show love by being there for someone when they are ill etc.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:45

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:35

No you’re definitely right - I guess that’s why his ex is his ex. But I do believe this woman should get a bit of a fuss made of her for her birthday and a nice present on Christmas. Or a thoughtful card. Or it will lead to resentment on her side. And I think it’s ok to want to celebrate and be celebrated. It’s not childish or demanding.

I knew a woman (not a particularly pleasant one) who complained because her husband threw her a small party (30 people ish) and only bought her a bag (£5000)…. Now that is demanding.

wanting a card and a gift. Or the odd weekend away is not what I call demanding. It’s all different levels I guess.

But I would hate to have to do that. I absolutely hate buying presents as I don't know what to buy.

I really don't think I could be with someone who wanted me to buy them presents and organise weekends away.

The OP likes doing that sort of thing, so she should carry on if she wants to but shouldn't force her OH to do it.

Zenwey · 22/09/2023 12:44

I don’t think you’re unreasonable. It’s not unreasonable for anyone to hope that their partner will show them that they care about them, and treating/spoiling your partner is one way of doing this - portraying love and thoughtfulness.

What has your response been when he says it? If you seem to accept it happily I guess I can understand. While it makes sense to talk to him about it, I also think it completely defeats the object in this instance, the whole point of spoiling someone is because YOU chose to. Not because they had to ask you to do it. So I don’t think telling him to do it will make you feel any better.

Even without presents, he could make you feel special, cook dinner for you, make a fuss of you etc. I would be a bit upset too.

0lga · 22/09/2023 12:37

Id tell him exactly what you want

eg a weekend away in a nice hotel in the Uk m just the two of us ( he needs to arrange a babysitter)

If you are not specific you will get a £1 card and some petrol station flowers.

Give him ONE chance to get it right. If he doesn’t step up, arrange things on your own with your friends / family for every other birthday and Christmas.

That was he won’t be forced to do birthdays / anniversaries / Christmas /Mother’s Day if he doesn’t want to.

that’s assuming you want to stay with lazy selfish man who can’t do something relatively small to please you.

Raffington55 · 22/09/2023 12:37

iabuik · 22/09/2023 10:45

DP are in our 30s, have been together for 4 years, own a house and have a 1 year old.

But ever since we've been together, he's never made any effort for birthdays or Christmas, usually resorting to saying "let's not bother getting anything for each other this year", except he says that every year and always has done.

It doesn't bother me enough to cause any drama, but I am aware that he used to whisk his ex off for surprise weekend breaks, decorate the house, generally make a big effort. Sure, that was a different relationship and I'm sure the dynamics were very different, but it still doesn't stop me from feeling that I'd quite like to get something more than "let's not bother this year" when I'm supposed to be his person for life (his words, not mine).

I'm definitely being unreasonable to make comparisons but I'm still interested to know if anyone else would bat an eyelid in this situation.

You are not being REMOTELY unreasonable

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:35

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:23

Do you really think he wants to be with a demanding woman who forces him to do things he doesn't want to do?

Unless he is desperate, I very much doubt it.

No you’re definitely right - I guess that’s why his ex is his ex. But I do believe this woman should get a bit of a fuss made of her for her birthday and a nice present on Christmas. Or a thoughtful card. Or it will lead to resentment on her side. And I think it’s ok to want to celebrate and be celebrated. It’s not childish or demanding.

I knew a woman (not a particularly pleasant one) who complained because her husband threw her a small party (30 people ish) and only bought her a bag (£5000)…. Now that is demanding.

wanting a card and a gift. Or the odd weekend away is not what I call demanding. It’s all different levels I guess.

Toomanyemails · 22/09/2023 12:35

iabuik · 22/09/2023 10:55

I admit I've never told him I would like him to do something special for me, but he is very much aware that I'm a very thoughtful surprise kind of person by the kinds of gestures I've done for my parents and for his own 30th. He claims he's just not that sort of person, which would be fair enough as some people aren't, but it's the knowing he's previously been like that with someone else that makes it feel like a bit of a cop out. I just don't want to make the comparison and seem like I'm jealous of his ex.

OP my DP is like this, he struggles a lot with getting gifts for me and anyone else. It's genuinely stressful and difficult for him, and the fact that I (like you) am 'good at gifts' and gestures adds to the pressure.

What is your DP like generally? I don't mind the presents much because mine shows me he's thinking of me in other ways all the time, he does more housework/cooking on a practical level of care, is a huge supporter of my work and my personal goals, and is generally kind and thoughtful in his actions and words.

But with the presents, even if it doesn't come naturally, if you tell him it's important to you, he should make an effort. My DP does after I've told him it matters to me (and equally I make an effort to get better at doing things that matter to him, eg being tidier!). In fact we recently both ended up getting each other the exact same surprise present, for a small occasion I didn't think he would bother marking

Forget about the ex, that's not the important part. He may have felt pressured, or he may feel that your relationship is deeper so presents aren't important, or he may have had more time and been reckless with money when younger. Talk to him!

plumtreebroke · 22/09/2023 12:33

Isn't it the point that you do something you know your DP would like even if (or even because) it's not something you might usually do but it would surprise and please your DP. 'I'm not that sort of person', is a cop out of ever putting yourself out a bit for someone else.

Sunshineclouds11 · 22/09/2023 12:27

*Because he doesn't want to do it so of course he should decide.

There is nothing stopping her from doing it if she wants to.

Why should he be forced to waste his time when he doesn't want to.

He had enough with his ex and doesnt' want to start again*
*
I meant why's he deciding for them both.
Would be pretty sad if she was only to buy him and he got her nothing.*

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:23

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:21

Not unreasonable to be jealous and irritated by ex getting stuff and you not.

just ask point blank and say what made you do that in your last relationship? Then stare blankly waiting for an answer. If he acts like a teenager and strips off and deflects well….

if he says she was demanding just say well I’d like to demand the same treatment as I actually do like a fuss being made of me. Thank you.

short and sweet.

be prepared for it to bring up more questions than you’d like though

Do you really think he wants to be with a demanding woman who forces him to do things he doesn't want to do?

Unless he is desperate, I very much doubt it.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/09/2023 12:21

Sunshineclouds11 · 22/09/2023 10:53

Why is the he the one who decides to not do presents etc?

You say 'let's do presents this year'

Because he doesn't want to do it so of course he should decide.

There is nothing stopping her from doing it if she wants to.

Why should he be forced to waste his time when he doesn't want to.

He had enough with his ex and doesnt' want to start again.

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2023 12:21

Not unreasonable to be jealous and irritated by ex getting stuff and you not.

just ask point blank and say what made you do that in your last relationship? Then stare blankly waiting for an answer. If he acts like a teenager and strips off and deflects well….

if he says she was demanding just say well I’d like to demand the same treatment as I actually do like a fuss being made of me. Thank you.

short and sweet.

be prepared for it to bring up more questions than you’d like though