Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Sunshinenrain · 22/09/2023 10:00

The loans are there so that disadvantaged children have the same options of education as better off children.

University is a choice at the end of the day.

Children from well off families can choose whether they go to uni or not.
Children from poorer families wouldn’t have that choice.

However, I do think it’s a bit unfair as not all parents are willing to help with costs, even if they’re will off.

I don’t know what the income threshold is but if it’s £30k and you’re expected to pay £6k+ a year for your children’s accommodation etc then it’s a lot to find on top of your own rent and bills.

I think perhaps a better idea would be having a bursary that you don’t need to pay back if your parents earn under a certain amount.
But if they earn over the threshold then they should get the full loan but just pay it back.

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 09:50

I wouldn’t want to see parents absolved of all financial responsibility for their children as soon as they turn 18. In my view, those that can easily afford it should be at least encouraged if not made to contribute to some extent.

sleepyscientist · 22/09/2023 09:43

Supporting them post 18 is normal however that should be an extra on top of the loan not mandatory.

It would be better if everyone got slightly less and had to work part time or the repayment threshold was lowered and repayments for longer.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/09/2023 09:39

CalistoNoSolo · 22/09/2023 07:50

Dd will be my dependant until she can support herself. That's probably 4 or 5 years away as she's just started university. It's what I signed up for when I decided to have a baby. I think you are responsible for your children until they can support themselves.

So if your child decides they want to keep studying until they're in their 40s, you're ok totally financially supporting them? Or if they come out of school and decide they want to travel the world for 5 years and then that work isn't for them? Or their heart is set on writing a book which takes a decade? You're ok paying for everything?

redskytonights · 22/09/2023 09:33

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 09:26

Sorry but it simply isn’t true that the offspring of wealthy families aren’t taking out student loans. Many people of all income bands are of the view that if a student doesn’t think the cost of studying is worth paying for themselves then they shouldn’t be doing a degree.

A lot of wealthy people got there through hard work and personal responsibility and are keen to ensure their offspring do the same.

And parents who won't pay for their children even if they can afford it is one of the reasons why student loans shouldn't be means tested on parental income.

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 09:26

Sorry but it simply isn’t true that the offspring of wealthy families aren’t taking out student loans. Many people of all income bands are of the view that if a student doesn’t think the cost of studying is worth paying for themselves then they shouldn’t be doing a degree.

A lot of wealthy people got there through hard work and personal responsibility and are keen to ensure their offspring do the same.

CorylusAgain · 22/09/2023 09:20

CorylusAgain · 22/09/2023 09:15

What's worse is that truly independent young adults without the prospect of university and the long term likelihood of higher earnings, are deemed to need less financial support from benefits than those a few years older.
That outrages me.

young adults without parental support just trying to live are penalised for not being 25!!

And lower rates for national minimum wage based on age!

IncompleteSenten · 22/09/2023 09:17

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 09:04

They are considered to be adults for everything else though. Why is the students loans process different?

£££££

CorylusAgain · 22/09/2023 09:15

What's worse is that truly independent young adults without the prospect of university and the long term likelihood of higher earnings, are deemed to need less financial support from benefits than those a few years older.
That outrages me.

young adults without parental support just trying to live are penalised for not being 25!!

Spendonsend · 22/09/2023 09:10

I dont understand the argument that they arent really adults if they go to university, they are still dependents.

Its a choice they make as an adult. There are lots of options that arent going to university.

The system makes parents responsible for their adult childs choice. What if I think my son is better off working than doing a degree in a random subject, from a low rank uni, with poor entry grades. He either ends up struggling if I refuse, or i end up supporting something i thinks a waste of time. Which is a bit of conflict.

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 09:08

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 08:39

Otherwise you risk low paid taxpayers subsidising the choices of wealthy 18 year olds whose families can easily afford to fund it themselves.

Except wealthy families are probably not having to worry about student loans.

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 09:04

IncompleteSenten · 22/09/2023 08:13

Yes they are legally an adult but let's be honest - how many 18 year olds are actually adults in their behaviours, their views? They're still kids in most cases. More so these days. I don't think I've met an 18 year old I would consider an adult in at least the last 20 years.

Maybe what should happen is raising the age of legal adulthood to 21.

But this whole parents contributing thing is the government trying to save money. It's got nothing to do with whether they think an 18 year old is a child.

They are considered to be adults for everything else though. Why is the students loans process different?

EuphemiaFuckaduck · 22/09/2023 09:00

I agree with you, @Drdoomish. It's bloody ridiculous.

The worst off are, as always, the "squeezed middle" - they can just about manage to pay their own bills, and are then expected to fund a student or two while they're at it.

However, a lot of this has come about as a result of T. Blair and his 'getting 50% of all young people into university' agenda. It was better when fewer young people went to university, and had grants. It would have been better if his government (or any government) had worked on making alternatives to university seem more appealing. University is not for everyone.

TotalOverhaul · 22/09/2023 08:59

I don't really get your reasoning. Yes, 18 year-olds are adults. But if they are taking on a degree then they really can't be expected to live like a fully independent adult. At DC's unis they were kicked out of halls every holiday so the rooms could be rented out to conferences. So they had to come home. They are studying hard so can't jeopardise that with employment elsewhere except for part time, which doesn't bring in enough to live on. So they are still reliant on parents for funding and home until they graduate. That makes sense to me. they shouldn't get into more debt than they need, so parental income is taken into account.

redskytonights · 22/09/2023 08:50

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 08:39

Otherwise you risk low paid taxpayers subsidising the choices of wealthy 18 year olds whose families can easily afford to fund it themselves.

Wealthy 18 year olds are not taking out loans - their families are paying everything up front.

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 08:39

Otherwise you risk low paid taxpayers subsidising the choices of wealthy 18 year olds whose families can easily afford to fund it themselves.

ssd · 22/09/2023 08:39

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:48

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

It is stupid, yes. But we've all gone "that's the way it is"

It's ridiculous and flies in the face of everything else.

DD considered putting down that she lived with her Dad as it meant she'd get more loan (note not even grant, loan). She didn't, as I didn't raise her to lie, but how many others would. Because of this ridiculous means tested on parents income rule for an adult.

My friend married age 19. Would parents income count then?!

No one complained about it until it affected them personally, like you are doing here.

redskytonights · 22/09/2023 08:38

I don't think many parents realise until their children get to the upper end of secondary school what the threshold is for getting a maximum loan (hint - lower than you think) and that the loan (in England) hasn't risen for years so even getting the maximum loan is not enough to live on.

With many families stretched financially there are a lot of people that can't afford to sufficiently support their children at university. Yes, the child can work as well but there's a limit to how many hours they can sensibly work without affecting their studies.

There are an awful lot of students whose parents' income means they are only eligible for minimum loan but, even with working a part time job, they don't have enough to subsist on.

University is fast becoming the preserve of the rich (who can afford it) or the very poor (who will be eligible for more bursaries etc). Those in the middle are having to make hard choices. It's becoming increasingly common to both stay in your home town for university and to take a gap year purely with the intent of saving money to fund university.

If we (as a country) value education, then it should (IMO) be more accessible to all.

x2boys · 22/09/2023 08:35

But students at university are not really independent they are not fighting for their country or working full.time and paying tax most are reliant on their parents to.some degree
Big difference to someone in the armed forces or someone who.is living in a flat paying their own bills from full time employment..

OlizraWiteomQua · 22/09/2023 08:29

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 22/09/2023 08:16

Yabu because the vast majority of loving parents who have any capacity to do so at all will help their kids with whatever they can (my eldest is only 14 but I have been putting £50pm into a university fund for thr last 14 years so the money will be there when it's needed, divided appropriately)

Without loans that money won't even cover the first years tuition and living costs

It's not supposed to. It's just supposed to cover the difference between the minimum loan and the maximum loan, which we will be able to do.

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 08:25

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt @Zanatdy

When I split from DDs dad a few years back, I told her she was at 0% risk of a boyfriend moving in with us as it would cost her too much.

My life on hold too for years because of the ridiculous way this loan is calculated.

OP posts:
sparepantsandtoothbrush · 22/09/2023 08:16

Yabu because the vast majority of loving parents who have any capacity to do so at all will help their kids with whatever they can (my eldest is only 14 but I have been putting £50pm into a university fund for thr last 14 years so the money will be there when it's needed, divided appropriately)

Without loans that money won't even cover the first years tuition and living costs

Secondwindplease · 22/09/2023 08:15

When I applied to uni, 20 years ago, I had already left home for a couple of years (moved out at 16). I had to prove that I was ‘estranged’, which included getting letters from my parents saying they had disowned me (!) and providing my tenancy agreements, wage slips etc. It wasn’t the nicest process but I did get the full loan and grant amounts after that.

Tbh, if your child lives with you and is coming home at holidays, and you’re still parenting in a fairly active way, then they are not independent and you should be contributing to their uni costs in a means tested way. The alternative isn’t a bed of roses, I promise you.

IncompleteSenten · 22/09/2023 08:13

Yes they are legally an adult but let's be honest - how many 18 year olds are actually adults in their behaviours, their views? They're still kids in most cases. More so these days. I don't think I've met an 18 year old I would consider an adult in at least the last 20 years.

Maybe what should happen is raising the age of legal adulthood to 21.

But this whole parents contributing thing is the government trying to save money. It's got nothing to do with whether they think an 18 year old is a child.

Arrestedforit · 22/09/2023 08:13

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:48

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

It is stupid, yes. But we've all gone "that's the way it is"

It's ridiculous and flies in the face of everything else.

DD considered putting down that she lived with her Dad as it meant she'd get more loan (note not even grant, loan). She didn't, as I didn't raise her to lie, but how many others would. Because of this ridiculous means tested on parents income rule for an adult.

My friend married age 19. Would parents income count then?!

But people did protest, and I know for sure as my name change implies.