Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
inloveandmarried · 22/09/2023 22:20

I had to wait until I'd married and was living with my husband so his income and not my father's income would be assessed for a grant.
I got a full grant that covered my living costs.

My father refused to declare his income or pay a penny towards a degree sadly. We were all girls. At least we were all treated equally.

It was a common thing in the 1980's.

totallyfedup · 22/09/2023 21:53

YANBU - I totally agree, if an 18 year old is by law an adult in every other way why are they still technically a child when it comes to tertiary education?? It all comes down to money.

Up here in Scotland there are no tuition fees yet a lot of Scottish young people are being rejected from the major universities, Edinburgh, Glasgow, St Andrews
i cannot remember the % but the majority of students in these universities are from England or oversees as they bring in more money. Unless they are from deprived areas of course, my own DD was asked if she was from a SIMD 1 or 2 area as it would up her chances of getting in! We are lucky in that my DC will be able to commute to uni if they choose to thus saving money, the only young person I know who actually moved to uni this year parent was a single parent and got a bursary. Most others are travelling in and out.

islandgirl21 · 22/09/2023 21:36

Spendonsend · 22/09/2023 07:46

It makes no sense to me either. Its a loan.

Unless it keeps rents lower or something because richer families would take out the full loan and top up anyway, but now they just top up to the amount of the full loan.

Well off families do a lot more than top up to the full loan. Topping up to the full loan would not leave much left for living costs when rent alone for halls is coming in at £7K+ .

lightisnotwhite · 22/09/2023 14:40

sleepyscientist · 22/09/2023 12:16

@lightisnotwhite so do you cut the amount for everyone so they all say get 5k which covers halls (cap the fee like tuition fees) then they work or parents pay living costs like when they are at college

Christ no. How is that fair that the poorer kids have to hold down a job in Tesco whilst the others swan about subsidised by mum and dad.

Perhaps the fairest would be poorer families could apply and get better loan rates or grants as well. Otherwise everyone else is entitled to a standard loan without parental disclosure ( universities give grants and bursaries for those in difficult circumstances),

Allergictoironing · 22/09/2023 13:21

sleepyscientist · 22/09/2023 12:16

@lightisnotwhite so do you cut the amount for everyone so they all say get 5k which covers halls (cap the fee like tuition fees) then they work or parents pay living costs like when they are at college

I don't think many Unis have halls for students after the first year. I deal with the bursaries for Care Leavers in my county, and the vast majority of those at Uni seem to be in private rentals of some kind e.g. bedsits or shared rented houses.

mondaytosunday · 22/09/2023 12:40

I just had to sign a release form so my 18 year old daughter could go on a day trip today. She not at school this is a FE college. She was insulted.

Honeychickpea · 22/09/2023 12:25

IncompleteSenten · 22/09/2023 08:13

Yes they are legally an adult but let's be honest - how many 18 year olds are actually adults in their behaviours, their views? They're still kids in most cases. More so these days. I don't think I've met an 18 year old I would consider an adult in at least the last 20 years.

Maybe what should happen is raising the age of legal adulthood to 21.

But this whole parents contributing thing is the government trying to save money. It's got nothing to do with whether they think an 18 year old is a child.

The 18 year olds whose parents have not infantalized them throughout their teen years tend to be adults. The spoon fed ones tend to operate on a much lower emotional and practical level.

sleepyscientist · 22/09/2023 12:16

@lightisnotwhite so do you cut the amount for everyone so they all say get 5k which covers halls (cap the fee like tuition fees) then they work or parents pay living costs like when they are at college

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 11:55

Having read all this I take it back, the current system looks to be unfair. I still don’t like the idea that wealthy people may end up being subsidised by lower earning taxpayers but I can see that the current system is making it very hard for some students / families.

Comefromaway · 22/09/2023 11:44

I agree.

I live in an area that has traditionally had a low take up of higher education, in fact education itself is not valued. I have seen many young people whose parents earn well (often in a trade) who refuse to support their children in further and higher education for whatever reason.

Then there are more complicated cases that don't fit estrangement but where the relationship is toxic.

I could cry for some of these young people.

Topseyt123 · 22/09/2023 11:43

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:48

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

It is stupid, yes. But we've all gone "that's the way it is"

It's ridiculous and flies in the face of everything else.

DD considered putting down that she lived with her Dad as it meant she'd get more loan (note not even grant, loan). She didn't, as I didn't raise her to lie, but how many others would. Because of this ridiculous means tested on parents income rule for an adult.

My friend married age 19. Would parents income count then?!

I left uni in 1988 and the current loans scheme was still at proposal stage then (we still had grants, though thankfully not tuition fees). Grants were also means tested on parents income but the difference is that they weren't repayable.

There were already protests about the proposed new loans scheme back then, long pre-dating Martin Lewis. The Margaret Thatcher and John Major governments ignored them and ploughed on ahead anyway. Labour promised to reverse the scheme if they got into power, but they never have either.

I do understand what you are saying and how frustrating it is, but student finance being based on parental income is far from new and pre-dates loans.

We are the squeezed middle too so I feel your pain and can't wait for the day when we no longer have to deal with Student Finance England, who I now just consider a bunch of government loan sharks anyway. That day cannot come soon enough.

They are impossible to deal with if anything changes or goes wrong (they couldn't cope at all with my DD's year abroad at all last year and caused major issues which our MP had to sort out).

DD is just about to start her final year at Cambridge now, so the end is hopefully in sight for our dealings with Student Finance England. I can't wait!

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 11:24

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 11:19

And that table makes it clear it's "up to..."

The figures I was shown during the college open evening last night make it clear that my daughter will be loaned £3500 less each year because she lives full time with me, the higher earner, and not her dad. That in itself is ridiculous.

Could she “move in” with her dad over the summer so she can get the higher amount? The system is unfair so I think you need to do what you need to do.

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 11:19

OceanicBoundlessness · 22/09/2023 10:02

A young person living at home needs considerably less to live on than one in other accommodation at uni (though curiously the table below disagrees). We can support our children to live at home, but will not be able to give them anything like the amount they would be able to borrow to live away.

And that table makes it clear it's "up to..."

The figures I was shown during the college open evening last night make it clear that my daughter will be loaned £3500 less each year because she lives full time with me, the higher earner, and not her dad. That in itself is ridiculous.

OP posts:
OceanicBoundlessness · 22/09/2023 11:11

WeWereInParis · 22/09/2023 10:30

It's just income. Other dependents are not taken into account.

It's possible we'll have two starting at uni at the same time even though they're two years apart in age as the eldest has taken a slower path to higher education than the other is likely to. Going off the chart I've posted we could be expected to find a spare 16,000 each year.

CharSiu · 22/09/2023 11:02

You can not go from 10% of people having a degree to Blair’s dream of 50% and socially engineer it perfectly within one generation. @EuphemiaFuckaduck so few people focus on the point we have both made. He was basically the catalyst in higher education that made it in to the utter shitshow it is today and I was glad I could retire early. It had to be funded somehow. Lord Dearing wrote the report that had been commissioned by the Conservatives and recommended fees but the Labour Party under Blair introduced student tuition fees, everyone conveniently forgets that.

It is just not possible to put huge numbers of young people through the higher education system for free unless you go back to much smaller graduate numbers. In theory a graduate should earn a lot more over a lifetime. That was very true for my generation, it isn’t now and there are not enough graduate jobs for all those fresh faced graduates.

My DS has grown up hearing about Higher education from the coal face as DH and I both work or worked in academia. We were both delighted when he chose to do a degree apprenticeship and was accepted on to one. One year in, no tuition fees and earning 27k per annum. He has saved us a lot of money, not just himself. I recommend this as a route but it’s more competitive than the regular route to a degree.

lightisnotwhite · 22/09/2023 10:48

Because they want better off parents to contribute to what is a limbo land between full time education and contributing to the economy?
Personally I ‘m torn on this. I get fed up filling out forms on my finances when like you say they are adults.
On the other hand giving 9k x3 to rich kids which will only be clawed back slowly will soon add up.

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 10:39

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 09:50

I wouldn’t want to see parents absolved of all financial responsibility for their children as soon as they turn 18. In my view, those that can easily afford it should be at least encouraged if not made to contribute to some extent.

There is absolutely no legal obligation on the parents to support the student. It is only implied but they don’t have to give them a penny.

bopbey · 22/09/2023 10:36

Another thing that clearly hasn't been taken into consideration, which affects more middle earners than higher earners, is the massive increase in the cost of living over the last couple of years

and the freezing of tax bands

bopbey · 22/09/2023 10:34

I think you are responsible for your children until they can support themselves.

lots of adults & oaps can't support themselves

WeWereInParis · 22/09/2023 10:30

Allergictoironing · 22/09/2023 10:25

There are a large number of parents who aren't willing or able to support their children at Uni, despite their income. Some don't plan for it, some don't care, some prefer to spend their money in other ways, there are many, many reasons.

Not having had children myself, I don't know exactly what's taken into account when they look at the parents income - do they look at salary/ investments/ business income purely or disposable income?

If it's the former, that would be totally unfair as the parents could have many commitments such as other children, large mortgages, debts, dependent parents, large costs of commuting/working clothing or equipment etc. You see parents on here with high salaries but still struggling because they have to live near to (expensive housing) and commute into (expensive fares) London, they have SEN children, they have previous debts, one parent is paying towards child maintenance from a previous relationship etc.

Another thing that clearly hasn't been taken into consideration, which affects more middle earners than higher earners, is the massive increase in the cost of living over the last couple of years e.g. My income is around 25% more than it was 2 years ago. I was comfortable then, I'm struggling from pay day to pay day now with if anything fewer outgoings. And this isn't for big ticket or optional items, this is absolute necessities like food, transport and mortgage interest. Parental income cut off for university loans I'm pretty sure hasn't increased by anywhere near that amount or even to allow for the high inflation over the last 2 years, if at all.

Yes I do understand that some very high income families may well be doing well out of this, but this government seems to believe in punishing all for the transgressions of a small minority - listen to their rhetoric around benefits for the unemployed as an example, suggesting that all unemployed are that way by choice, or the policies around disability because a very small number of people take the piss.

It's just income. Other dependents are not taken into account.

Oiyouoverthere · 22/09/2023 10:28

My parents didn't support me through uni, and because of their income I only received minimum loan and paid maximum fees.

It doesn't take in to account the number of dependents still at home either.

Meant my uni years were really quite shit.

Allergictoironing · 22/09/2023 10:25

There are a large number of parents who aren't willing or able to support their children at Uni, despite their income. Some don't plan for it, some don't care, some prefer to spend their money in other ways, there are many, many reasons.

Not having had children myself, I don't know exactly what's taken into account when they look at the parents income - do they look at salary/ investments/ business income purely or disposable income?

If it's the former, that would be totally unfair as the parents could have many commitments such as other children, large mortgages, debts, dependent parents, large costs of commuting/working clothing or equipment etc. You see parents on here with high salaries but still struggling because they have to live near to (expensive housing) and commute into (expensive fares) London, they have SEN children, they have previous debts, one parent is paying towards child maintenance from a previous relationship etc.

Another thing that clearly hasn't been taken into consideration, which affects more middle earners than higher earners, is the massive increase in the cost of living over the last couple of years e.g. My income is around 25% more than it was 2 years ago. I was comfortable then, I'm struggling from pay day to pay day now with if anything fewer outgoings. And this isn't for big ticket or optional items, this is absolute necessities like food, transport and mortgage interest. Parental income cut off for university loans I'm pretty sure hasn't increased by anywhere near that amount or even to allow for the high inflation over the last 2 years, if at all.

Yes I do understand that some very high income families may well be doing well out of this, but this government seems to believe in punishing all for the transgressions of a small minority - listen to their rhetoric around benefits for the unemployed as an example, suggesting that all unemployed are that way by choice, or the policies around disability because a very small number of people take the piss.

Teddleshon · 22/09/2023 10:05

Yes tbf, I’m not familiar with the income bands used and I totally agree that they shouldn’t be onerous in terms of affordability.

WeWereInParis · 22/09/2023 10:04

YANBU. I got the minimum loan, but no parental help at all. I was waved off on the first day of uni, and never moved back home.

OceanicBoundlessness · 22/09/2023 10:02

A young person living at home needs considerably less to live on than one in other accommodation at uni (though curiously the table below disagrees). We can support our children to live at home, but will not be able to give them anything like the amount they would be able to borrow to live away.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?