Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
43ontherocksporfavor · 24/09/2023 09:09

DD1 has to repay as salary above £26k for 30 years but for those starting this September they start to repay around £21k for 40yrs.
DD2 has gone down the apprenticeship route now and I’m very glad. Earning and learning is the future.

LynetteScavo · 24/09/2023 08:48

The student loan system shockingly poor. When DS started uni we were more than happy and able to help him financially. He wasn't capable of having a part time job as well as study. I really, really felt for student whose parents weren't willing or able to help their adult children.

I think things have got even worse in the past few years with the cost of living going up, the cost of student accommodation going through the roof. There are so many parents in FB groups wondering who their adult child is going to survive on the maximum loan as they are unable to contribute financially.

It also seems unfair that my DC with their minimum loan amounts will have smaller outstanding loans than someone who took the maximum loan, but I guess life is unfair.

43ontherocksporfavor · 24/09/2023 08:46

Also k ow divorced couples where DF is a millionaire but child gets full loan as mum’s income is the only one taken into account. Know of self employed parents with canny accountants meaning they get full loan. It’s so unfair.

43ontherocksporfavor · 24/09/2023 08:44

DD has started earning above the threshold and got a sign-on bonus in her first month. SFE has calculated her loan repayment on this as her salary. They will continue to take double the amount for the next few months before rectifying but won’t refund it. She is earning well but paying high rent in London. How can the system not tell the difference between salary and one -off bonus?

CrapBucket · 24/09/2023 08:41

It is a bonkers system. I’m a single parent with one at uni and one planning it soon. How I will cope financially when they are both there is anyone’s guess. Luckily I like beans on toast.

Olderandolder · 24/09/2023 08:35

Topseyt123 · 22/09/2023 11:43

I left uni in 1988 and the current loans scheme was still at proposal stage then (we still had grants, though thankfully not tuition fees). Grants were also means tested on parents income but the difference is that they weren't repayable.

There were already protests about the proposed new loans scheme back then, long pre-dating Martin Lewis. The Margaret Thatcher and John Major governments ignored them and ploughed on ahead anyway. Labour promised to reverse the scheme if they got into power, but they never have either.

I do understand what you are saying and how frustrating it is, but student finance being based on parental income is far from new and pre-dates loans.

We are the squeezed middle too so I feel your pain and can't wait for the day when we no longer have to deal with Student Finance England, who I now just consider a bunch of government loan sharks anyway. That day cannot come soon enough.

They are impossible to deal with if anything changes or goes wrong (they couldn't cope at all with my DD's year abroad at all last year and caused major issues which our MP had to sort out).

DD is just about to start her final year at Cambridge now, so the end is hopefully in sight for our dealings with Student Finance England. I can't wait!

Edited

You will have paid it all back by next year? Ow, how will you not be dealing with them?

Your daughter’s Cambridge is worth it but most degrees are a scam to hide youth unemployment. The expansion has done what Tony Blair intended, end the graduate wage premium and therefore end the advantage of the class that had degrees.

junbean · 24/09/2023 08:28

VesperLynne · 24/09/2023 08:06

It's means tested. Just let that sink in for a minute.

I've been through this myself both as a student and for my child, what makes you assume I don't know how it works? My statement stands.

43ontherocksporfavor · 24/09/2023 08:08

Totally agree OP. Student accommodation at some universities is now higher than maximum loan.

VesperLynne · 24/09/2023 08:06

junbean · 22/09/2023 08:04

Anything to enrich the rich

It's means tested. Just let that sink in for a minute.

Allofthisisasimulation · 24/09/2023 07:59

OlizraWiteomQua · 22/09/2023 08:29

It's not supposed to. It's just supposed to cover the difference between the minimum loan and the maximum loan, which we will be able to do.

Even if it doesn't cover everything, it will cover/pay towards something, and thus will be a help to your child. Not everyone can save loads, or even anything at all, but saving something is a good idea. 😬

notanothernana · 24/09/2023 07:57

YANBU
Boils my piss this one. Helping our dd through uni is crippling us.

Daffodilwoman · 24/09/2023 07:55

Excellent post op. I agree with you.

Samlewis96 · 24/09/2023 07:52

Sunshinenrain · 22/09/2023 10:00

The loans are there so that disadvantaged children have the same options of education as better off children.

University is a choice at the end of the day.

Children from well off families can choose whether they go to uni or not.
Children from poorer families wouldn’t have that choice.

However, I do think it’s a bit unfair as not all parents are willing to help with costs, even if they’re will off.

I don’t know what the income threshold is but if it’s £30k and you’re expected to pay £6k+ a year for your children’s accommodation etc then it’s a lot to find on top of your own rent and bills.

I think perhaps a better idea would be having a bursary that you don’t need to pay back if your parents earn under a certain amount.
But if they earn over the threshold then they should get the full loan but just pay it back.

The threshold for getting the full loans a family income of 26k so yeah pretty low

DyslexicPoster · 23/09/2023 18:48

NotTerfNorCis · 22/09/2023 07:32

Because most parents will be financially supporting their kids at uni.

I do know one case years ago, back in the days of grants, where a girl from a well off family was being refused support from her abusive dad. She wasn't entitled to a grant. This was at a time when most students didn't work, and loans were comparatively tiny. Tuition fees were paid by the government.

In the end, an aunt bailed her out.

My parents earned too much for my sister to get a grant. She lived ofcsmash forca year. Just because parents have cash it doesn't guarantee they will pay the kids a penny. Dad was dilusion about how much money my sister could live on. My mum told everyone she was working to support her dd through uni but never paid one penny out.

Pumpkinpie1 · 23/09/2023 18:47

I think the government fails to understand that there are many young people who don’t have a traditional family to support them, in care , estranged, abused for whom the funding model excludes from education

Comefromaway · 23/09/2023 18:44

Drdoomish · 23/09/2023 16:38

Saw a friend today who's son started his degree aged 23. Even though he'd been living away from home for 5 years and he'd been working full time, her salary was still the thing that was used to calculate how much loan he could access.

She said the alternative to that was that she and he had to sign a piece of paper saying that he was disowned. She couldn't sign in good conscience, neither could he.

Absolutely bonkers

She must have been supporting him financially during that time then.

If he had been financially independent for the last 3 years he could have sent in payslips, benefit statements etc to prove this he would have been classed as an independent student.

Ahsoka2001 · 23/09/2023 18:27

You can't drive a lorry, fly a helicopter or adopt a child till you're 21 though, so...

Drdoomish · 23/09/2023 16:38

Saw a friend today who's son started his degree aged 23. Even though he'd been living away from home for 5 years and he'd been working full time, her salary was still the thing that was used to calculate how much loan he could access.

She said the alternative to that was that she and he had to sign a piece of paper saying that he was disowned. She couldn't sign in good conscience, neither could he.

Absolutely bonkers

OP posts:
jamimmi · 22/09/2023 23:31

Perhaps we should follow the system used in Wales in England ( might be N Irland) Eveone gets the same generous loan about £12000 but the amount. Of that what they have to repay is dependent on family income. I also believe if the pay off £50 in the fist year , that year is written off. DS is in Liverpool. Lots.of Welsh & Irish students. As an English student he is far worse off than both. He doesn't get max loan, we are a single. Income family with an additional ill health pension. His loan doesn't quite cover his halls and I send him.£200 a month to feed him . Its wrong. As for Scotland as a scot.seeing my Niece do a degree with no fees and free public transport, prescriptions etc makes me.very angry at the system ( not her) . At Glasgow they were very clear she told me.3rd students scot, 3rd other home nations and a 3rd foreign. Doesn't sound like too much of a disadvantage to me. DS say his course make up.is similar

titchy · 22/09/2023 23:25

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

Because the expectation of parental support has been the system since before ML was born....Confused

GellerYeller · 22/09/2023 23:23

redskytonights · Today 08:38

“There are an awful lot of students whose parents' income means they are only eligible for minimum loan but, even with working a part time job, they don't have enough to subsist on.

University is fast becoming the preserve of the rich (who can afford it) or the very poor (who will be eligible for more bursaries etc). Those in the middle are having to make hard choices. It's becoming increasingly common to both stay in your home town for university and to take a gap year purely with the intent of saving money to fund university.”

I totally agree with this @redskytonights.We had a friend whose son arrived at uni in this exact situation, lowest loan amount, needed to work, but his timetable made it very difficult. We have other friends who found it cheaper to go local, even buy a car and commute, or for the one who only had lectures two consecutive days a week an hour away, air B and B it, or use a budget hotel chain one night a week. It really does seem a nonsense at best, a bit of a racket really; holding kids and middle earners to ransom.

merryhouse · 22/09/2023 23:02

Would like to join the several posters who have pointed out that LOTS of us protested against the whole concept - even when it was being presented to us as a way to get away from depending on parental income, and especially when they back-tracked on that within the first few years.

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 23:00

DD is considering degree apprenticeships @CharSiu but there is a dearth of them in our area. DD sees the value of earning and studying, so is considering moving for the right one, just as she would for uni. They all seem to be in careers that she has no interest in though 😔 If the right one pops up, she's ready to pounce!

Having come from a hand to mouth childhood, I feel this quite keenly. University transformed my life prospects. I would never have gone as an innocent 18 year old if it meant incurring a £60k+ life debt.

I think the fairest way is not to use parental income to allocate the maintenance loan amount. All students should be allowed the maximum. Parents will always top it up if they choose to. The difference should be that those coming from poorer households can access significantly lower interest rates on their loan, and have the salary at which they start to repay heightened.

OP posts:
Daisymay2 · 22/09/2023 22:47

Parents not contributing to their student offspring is not a new phenomenon.
I went to Uni in the 1970s ( I am very old) before fees and grants were means tested, but they took into account some outgoings- siblings definately. I went after the age of majority decreased to 18.
I got a full grant which was enough to survive on, but I had friends whose parents would not top up lesser grants for their children, so they had to work, which was difficult with a lab heavy course.