Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Comefromaway · 27/09/2023 10:42

The other issue is being a guarantor. I had to send in all kinds of paperwork (pay slips etc) and have a minimum income level to be able to guarantor my daughter in a shared house). Student halls you simply have to sign.

Some of the young people I know from perhaps single parent families or whose parents are on benefits due to ill health) would not pass these guarantor checks.

charlotte361 · 27/09/2023 10:38

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 09:51

The cheaper private room yr 2 and 3 is often not case. Again lots of parents at open days worrying and questioning this. My impression was Durham, Bristol etc you’ll struggle for accommodation and pay more than the halls.

In durham you will struggle to get self catering accommodation. Both my dc have my dc had to pay more than £300 per week . private house was about £150

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 10:37

vlo · 27/09/2023 10:24

I think it is actually a scandal

I had no idea about this and am absolutely shocked

Yes per week. Think minimum contract 40 weeks.

MargotBamborough · 27/09/2023 10:37

I live in the EU and my kids were born here. They are only very young but I am already having to think about whether to put them through bilingual private school, which is considered more or less essential if you want your kids to have the opportunity to do their higher education in an English speaking country, or just go with the local school system.

My eldest won't be university age for another 16 years and I'm already thinking, what's the point? Even without now having to pay international fees instead of home fees, the cost of going to university in the UK would be unaffordable so why even take that possibility into consideration?

charlotte361 · 27/09/2023 10:34

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 22/09/2023 07:51

Well, they are adults with limited earning capacity, but I think this should mean more loan money to anyone who wants it and not parental support.

where from? The magic money tree?

Comefromaway · 27/09/2023 10:31

Some students are on wait lists and just have to take what they can get regardless of cost or bathrooms

Another young person I know applied to a Manchester area based uni through clearing. There was NO accommodation available in the entire area. There are various facebook groups devoted to people finding student rooms in the area and they are full of scams or expensive studios. Students are literally waiting for people to drop out then trying to take whatever becomes available no matter what.

vlo · 27/09/2023 10:24

Comefromaway · 27/09/2023 10:20

But now the gap between even just the cost of accommodation, before you've factored in any other costs whatsoever, and the maintenance loan is just astronomical. I literally don't understand what students whose families can't afford to just subsidise them to the tune of thousands of pounds a year are supposed to do. The sums just do not add up.

We were helping/advising a very talented young person from a single parent family as he was applying to study the subject my husband teaches. He found a great course in Brighton but the cost of accommodation in that area completely outweighed his maximum loan so he ended up applying to Sheffield instead.

I hear similar stories where young people are not applying to expensive cities such as Bristol or Durham regardless of their grades etc.

I think it is actually a scandal

I had no idea about this and am absolutely shocked

vlo · 27/09/2023 10:22

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 09:47

These were UCL (London) prices from their open day.
Kings (London) had some cheaper rooms but those are for those eligible for their affordable accommodation scheme eg contextual and care leavers.
I’m not saying London is be all and end all but you can understand why parents with teens getting min loan of under £5000 won’t even let teen look.

per week!!!

Crikey… the last time I was renting in a shared house was in a relatively expensive part of Manchester in 2017 and was £350 per month

Comefromaway · 27/09/2023 10:20

But now the gap between even just the cost of accommodation, before you've factored in any other costs whatsoever, and the maintenance loan is just astronomical. I literally don't understand what students whose families can't afford to just subsidise them to the tune of thousands of pounds a year are supposed to do. The sums just do not add up.

We were helping/advising a very talented young person from a single parent family as he was applying to study the subject my husband teaches. He found a great course in Brighton but the cost of accommodation in that area completely outweighed his maximum loan so he ended up applying to Sheffield instead.

I hear similar stories where young people are not applying to expensive cities such as Bristol or Durham regardless of their grades etc.

MargotBamborough · 27/09/2023 10:04

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 09:51

The cheaper private room yr 2 and 3 is often not case. Again lots of parents at open days worrying and questioning this. My impression was Durham, Bristol etc you’ll struggle for accommodation and pay more than the halls.

I went to one of those unis and seem to remember that living in a shared house was, for me, more expensive than halls, particularly given that it was a 12 month contract whereas the hall fees were charged per term. For me the really striking point is that rents appear to have more than doubled, perhaps even tripled, since I was a student, whereas the minimum maintenance loan has not significantly changed.

For example, in my second and third years I paid around 350/month for a room in a shared house, and that was on the expensive side. There were cheaper options available. Even back then my rent alone was more than my entire maintenance loan, and then of course I needed money for food, books, clothes, transport, student activities etc. I did work in all the holidays but even then it wouldn't have been nearly enough without a generous contribution from my parents which they were able and happy to pay.

But now the gap between even just the cost of accommodation, before you've factored in any other costs whatsoever, and the maintenance loan is just astronomical. I literally don't understand what students whose families can't afford to just subsidise them to the tune of thousands of pounds a year are supposed to do. The sums just do not add up.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 09:51

The cheaper private room yr 2 and 3 is often not case. Again lots of parents at open days worrying and questioning this. My impression was Durham, Bristol etc you’ll struggle for accommodation and pay more than the halls.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/09/2023 09:47

These were UCL (London) prices from their open day.
Kings (London) had some cheaper rooms but those are for those eligible for their affordable accommodation scheme eg contextual and care leavers.
I’m not saying London is be all and end all but you can understand why parents with teens getting min loan of under £5000 won’t even let teen look.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?
Zwicky · 27/09/2023 08:19

DD went as insurance and got a shared room. No one else wanted it.

Ds went as insurance and got a 1 bed flat. His “choices “ were the 5 cheapest shared kitchen and shared bathroom places. His university doesn’t allocate until after results day and theoretically insurance students stand as good a chance as firm ones as getting what they want.

Lots of uni halls now are owned by private providers. If I was in the student housing business I would build a huge block on en-suite rooms where the slight reduction in numbers of tenants (maybe 10%) would be offset by the increased rent charged for en-suite versus shared bathroom (maybe 30% more). The idea is to make money - not ensure that the children of the squeezed middle can manage their budget effectively. It’s big business but the 18yo caught in the middle are mocked for being precious when in reality their choices aren’t really choices at all.

GellerYeller · 26/09/2023 20:48

@Dixiechickonhols well said. We had an offer from York, and the accommodation we were directed to at open days-‘premium’ had been talked up by staff and student ambassadors before we saw it. ‘Oh it’s not the cheapest but it’s so good’.
And I’m sure there’s some marketing strategy to manipulate you into the prime accommodation. The cheaper halls we were shown at another uni hadn’t been cleaned or tidied. Of course the kids are going to want the nicer rooms. We all need to accept that these are businesses and base our decisions accordingly.

TizerorFizz · 26/09/2023 20:36

Most firm pre A level results. Then they do get a choice.Obviously not guaranteed but it’s the better halls that go first quite often. The vast majority are not going as insurance or clearing students who have had issues with accommodation for many years! What percentage do not get a cheap hall if they apply for the cheaper ones when they should? Again it’s anecdotal hearsay and no figures. DD went as insurance and got a shared room. No one else wanted it. The vast majority get uni accommodation everywhere and no one was talking about y2/3 where there’s cheaper areas for many to consider. The bigger issue is they don’t want to.

DHs dad worked in a factory and mum worked part time in an office. Decades ago they were expected to make a contribution. This is not a new situation.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 26/09/2023 19:43

How many actually are being disadvantaged by parents not finding enough money? How many take expensive halls when they don’t need to? Do we truly know? Huge numbers on MN won’t share a bathroom at uni but they do at home.

@TizerorFizz You do know that access to halls or student houses is extremely limited in many areas. Some students are on wait lists and just have to take what they can get regardless of cost or bathrooms. Naturally the more affordable halls get snapped up early on usually by those who have firmed offers pre A levels. Most move into shared homes in year 2/3, which is another bun fight with students queuing outside agents or snapping up rentals as soon as they are released online without even visiting the place.

TizerorFizz · 26/09/2023 17:11

@Mytholmroyd Thats really splitting hairs about Imperial. It’s always been one of the best unis in the world.

Comefromaway · 26/09/2023 10:41

It is very common for students from my son's old school regardless of grades to apply to Keele or Staffs only, if they are very ambitious they might consider Manchester or Man Met.

Dixiechickonhols · 26/09/2023 10:30

Parents have contributed in the past but not in the same league of the current levels.
A couple on a joint income of £26,000 stops a student getting a full loan in England. They are a low income household. A couple on £30,000 each mean child is on min loan - most people wouldn’t class them as extremely high earners.
Students ‘find a way’ by compromising on where they go. They don’t even look as it’s so far out of their reach.
For some living at home and getting train or bus to UCLAN is fine. But what about the ones with 3 A star and big ambitions. Yes law course is same UCAS code but there’s virtually no chance of city law or bar if student opts for that over her UCL London or Durham offer as her parents can’t or won’t pay the £5000 a year.
We aren’t all thick up north and unless everyone has same access to top courses it’s not a level playing field. We need STEM graduates and lots of the top universities for those students are London.
Yes there’s ways around it, gap year etc but that relies on parental support too. Don’t be silly love you can do exactly same course and live at home.
These aren’t imagined scenarios I know students who are told to live at home group or stay locks.
Lancaster is very popular as it’s commutable (where largest number go to from dc’s state grammar) Not knocking Lancaster it’s a great Uni but if you have 3 A star then you should be able to at least look at unis that are Russell group or top 10 for your course.
We are in England my DC will get under £5000 a year maintenance loan. If we were in Wales she’s on just under £12,000 loan.
The unis seem to have the expensive en-suite accommodation now. I went back to my old Uni room last year - it was being remodelled to have an en-suite and is self catering now. My husband was in a double share that option doesn’t exist any more.
Yes some might opt for expensive but all the accommodation talks I’ve sat through this year were limited low price prioritising certain categories, no guarantees, take what you you can get. It stops people applying. London might be doable if you get the £180 room allocated but £250 no chance, why risk it.

Comefromaway · 26/09/2023 10:30

This is exactly the attitude I see in my area mytholmroyd!

Mytholmroyd · 26/09/2023 10:21

As part of my role as our Department's First generation scholar lead/support (as one myself), I have gone into schools in our region from where we traditionally don't get applications to speak and I have been told they would not consider applying or suggesting students apply as they just don't think they'd get in/it's only for posh people etc so I think there are still lots of barriers perceived if not real. And the horrors of such a huge debt do put a lot of working class people off even considering it.

We have foundation years, lower offers for disadvantaged students/widening participation, we run Sutton Trust summer schools etc etc but we are still near/at the bottom of league tables for this despite being one of the 'aspirational' universities in northern England

That said, I don't think university is the best place to teach many subjects - am reminded of the essay written (can't recall the famous writer off the top of my head) complaining vociferously about the proposal that medical colleges should be brought into universities in the ?19th century because they taught practical skills not academic ones! Must dig that out!

Mytholmroyd · 26/09/2023 09:57

TizerorFizz · 26/09/2023 07:50

@Mytholmroyd Imperial became a university in 1908. However some of the colleges should have stayed as HE providers. That genie won’t get back in the bottle!

Imperial College didn't become a university in its own right and award its own degrees until 2006. Prior to that it awarded University of London degrees. It is a post-1992 university.

Fififafa · 26/09/2023 09:23

Excuse the typos. It was early.

bridgetreilly · 26/09/2023 09:10

YABU because adults can be dependents. It’s a different category.

Disturbia81 · 26/09/2023 09:03

I was still dependent on my parents at that age, 18 is very young. And so many loans never get paid back, I never have and many of my friends haven't.