Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Zanatdy · 22/09/2023 08:11

I assume it was brought in as many students don’t repay the whole amount and someone (tax payer) has to pick up the bill otherwise. So by asking for a parental contribution it reduces the cost to the tax payer.

This does need to be communicated to parents though as most find out they are expected to contribute 5/6k a year just a year beforehand when they start looking into it. As you’d think a loan is a loan and you get the whole amount. So often means some parents can’t (or some won’t, see that plenty of times) contribute and student ends up working loads of hours which makes it much harder studying for their degree. In the US parents start a college fund at birth, I think U.K. parents need to start doing it but obviously don’t know.

Even worse is when mums boyfriend’s salary is taken into account, he won’t contribute and poor student ends up working all hours to fund it. Meanwhile dad’s salary is nothing to do with it as it’s household income only.

collester · 22/09/2023 08:08

YANBU OP - I've often thought this. I had the dilemma I wanted to go to university but my parents - well my mum particularly had been abusive - so overall I didn't want to go

junbean · 22/09/2023 08:04

Anything to enrich the rich

MidnightOnceMore · 22/09/2023 08:00

YABU in that you misrepresent the situation. If your child is genuinely independent - i.e. they live on their own - then they don't need to report parental income.

But your child isn't independent - presumably they come 'home' in holidays?

Whether the loans system overall is right is a different question.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 22/09/2023 07:57

A married 19 year old would declare their household i.e. theirs and partner's income, so no, it wouldn't count.

I think the ridiculous thing is that live-in partner income (of the parent) is taken into account even if they moved in when said child was 17.

Fififafa · 22/09/2023 07:57

I’m with you OP! 18 year olds are adults in every sense of the word, so why is parental income a factor when they take out student loans? These are loans, not grants. The parents shouldn’t be factored in full stop. They aren’t factored in if the 18 year old decides to take out a bank loan.

The other issue is the government expects the parents to make up the shortfall without making this clear to parents. Some parents can’t afford to make up the shortfall, so the student suffers. Many have part time jobs but even then aren’t earning enough to support themselves.

OlizraWiteomQua · 22/09/2023 07:57

Yabu because the vast majority of loving parents who have any capacity to do so at all will help their kids with whatever they can (my eldest is only 14 but I have been putting £50pm into a university fund for thr last 14 years so the money will be there when it's needed, divided appropriately).
Obviously the students from the poorest families cannot be supported by their parents in this way so need more support from the state.

Your proposal that all 18yos should be treated as independent from their parents is ridiculous. You would have to combine it with a total ban on wealthier parents giving any extra to their 18-21yos for the system to be fair. That's not going to happen is it?

ForbiddenColour · 22/09/2023 07:52

It does make sense when you consider that not all loans are repaid so by limiting the amount that can be borrowed the government is reducing the amount that it funds. All the time posters on here make the point that it’s a ‘graduate tax’ not a loan, so what is it?

Though if they keep changing the repayment terms and more repay the total amount then that argument goes away.

That said the system is rubbish and everyone should have access to the same amount.

StoatofDisarray · 22/09/2023 07:52

We did complain about it but history is written by the winners, innit?

DustyLee123 · 22/09/2023 07:51

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:48

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

It is stupid, yes. But we've all gone "that's the way it is"

It's ridiculous and flies in the face of everything else.

DD considered putting down that she lived with her Dad as it meant she'd get more loan (note not even grant, loan). She didn't, as I didn't raise her to lie, but how many others would. Because of this ridiculous means tested on parents income rule for an adult.

My friend married age 19. Would parents income count then?!

People did complain about it, but it fell on deaf ears. I’ve had 3 go through this system.
What are you going to do about it to change it ?

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 22/09/2023 07:51

Well, they are adults with limited earning capacity, but I think this should mean more loan money to anyone who wants it and not parental support.

CalistoNoSolo · 22/09/2023 07:50

Dd will be my dependant until she can support herself. That's probably 4 or 5 years away as she's just started university. It's what I signed up for when I decided to have a baby. I think you are responsible for your children until they can support themselves.

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:48

DustyLee123 · 22/09/2023 07:23

It’s been the same for years, no point complaining now unless you are going to do something about it.
And they don’t look at debt, just income, it’s stupid.

Why did no one complain about it when it was brought in, except Martin Lewis? What do you suggest I do?

It is stupid, yes. But we've all gone "that's the way it is"

It's ridiculous and flies in the face of everything else.

DD considered putting down that she lived with her Dad as it meant she'd get more loan (note not even grant, loan). She didn't, as I didn't raise her to lie, but how many others would. Because of this ridiculous means tested on parents income rule for an adult.

My friend married age 19. Would parents income count then?!

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 22/09/2023 07:46

It makes no sense to me either. Its a loan.

Unless it keeps rents lower or something because richer families would take out the full loan and top up anyway, but now they just top up to the amount of the full loan.

pastaandpesto · 22/09/2023 07:37

I understood it more when students had grants - it made sense that they would be looking to reduce the overall cost of grants by means testing the family.

But now it is all loans-based with pretty high interest rates, why make them means tested?

NotTerfNorCis · 22/09/2023 07:32

Because most parents will be financially supporting their kids at uni.

I do know one case years ago, back in the days of grants, where a girl from a well off family was being refused support from her abusive dad. She wasn't entitled to a grant. This was at a time when most students didn't work, and loans were comparatively tiny. Tuition fees were paid by the government.

In the end, an aunt bailed her out.

DustyLee123 · 22/09/2023 07:23

It’s been the same for years, no point complaining now unless you are going to do something about it.
And they don’t look at debt, just income, it’s stupid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread