Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think an 18 year old is an adult -AIBU?

242 replies

Drdoomish · 22/09/2023 07:19

They can get married
They can live under their own steam away from parents
They can take out loans and get into exceptional debt
They can fight and die for our country
They can become an MP or councillor
They can legally get pissed in a pub
They can get their own tattoo
They can sit on a jury
They can leave education
And do all the things that adults can do...

So why, WHY, do the government use a parents income to decide how much living cost loan they will lend to an 18-24 university student?

YABU - An 18 yr old uni student is still a dependent
YANBU - An 18 yr old uni student is an adult in their own right.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
charlotte361 · 04/10/2023 16:35

There should only be university places for smartish kids say minimum AAB and only in subjects where a degree is needed such as STEM . we certainly dont need so many Humanities graduates and certainly not degrees like furniture design for example. These are better done through and apprenticeship and/or day release

TizerorFizz · 29/09/2023 16:16

@boys3 They could look at non degree nursing - as it used to be. No such thing as a degree nurse 40 years ago. So maybe we need more flexible training? Huge numbers of students want to be doctors. We just have to limit places due to training within nhs. Teachers: the students mostly do post grad work/study to become a teacher. Unfortunately they know the job well from many years of being a customer. It’s not very appealing but pays above the loan repayment minimum. We also know the more you earn, the less you pay off. So there is an inventive to earn highly.

boys3 · 29/09/2023 15:46

Now 45% plus.

Nope highest ever figure was 38.5%, now 37% in 2022 and its falling still further

There are two different things at play here. @TizerorFizz is referencing application rates for UK 18 year olds, whilst @Alexandra2001 is talking about acceptance rates.

Application wise, from UCAS

This puts the application rate for UK 18-year-olds at 41.5% compared to 43.4% in 2022 but up from 39.5% in 2020. This is mirrored in the number of total applicants (all ages, all domiciles) compared to last year - 596,590 this year, down from 610,720 in 2022 (-2.3%) but higher than 568,330 in 2020 (+5.0%)

Acceptance wise as above, although 37% is of course lower than 38.5% it remains the second highest figure ever. From the House of Commons Library paper

The higher education entry rate among UK 18 year olds increased from 24.7% in 2006 to 30.7% in 2015 and peaked at 38.2% in 2021. It fell back to 37.5%, its second highest ever level, in 2022.

How much the cost of living challenges, and the changes in the repayment terms (30 years to 40 years is a fair old jump, linked with a slightly less pronounced reduction for the income threshold where repayments start to kick in) will impact current and future years remains to be seen.

https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/second-highest-ever-number-uk-18-year-olds-apply-university-or-college-january-deadline#:~:text=This%20puts%20the%20application%20rate,in%202020%20(%2B5.0%25).

https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-7857/CBP-7857.pdf

The fairly stark regional disparities are also shown in the HoCL paper, and equally the rates by parliamentary constituency.

A couple of other interesting links

https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/79-uk-18-year-old-applicants-receiving-results-gain-place-first-choice-university

https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/uk-18-year-olds-make-record-number-applications-computing-courses

We probably should be more worried about not enough nurses and teachers as opposed to doctors and engineers.

79% of UK 18-year-old applicants receiving results gain place at first choice university

As hundreds of thousands of students across the UK receive their exam results, new UCAS figures show that 79% have gained a place at their first choice of university or college.

https://www.ucas.com/corporate/news-and-key-documents/news/79-uk-18-year-old-applicants-receiving-results-gain-place-first-choice-university

Alexandra2001 · 29/09/2023 14:06

TizerorFizz · 29/09/2023 08:17

@TheLightProgramme Everyone seems to forget the huge expansion of the uni sector too. Millions of DC would not have got a grant years ago because they would not have got near a university! In the 70s, around 10% went. Now 45% plus. There clearly had to be rationing of funds.

It’s an interesting scenario that parents don’t want to pay for their Dc to go to uni but are happy for those who didn’t go to uni and get the salary uplift to pay. I do believe we have to accept paying but being told much earlier about costs so decisions can be made in good time.

Nope highest ever figure was 38.5%, now 37% in 2022 and its falling still further. Soon we'll be moaning why we haven't enough medics engineers etc etc oh wait!!!

EU average is around 34%, yet do not have these sorts of rationing of funds.

Graduates tend to earn more and have more secure employment, so they pay more tax, they add to the countries pool of skilled workers, i don't really see how making people pay back 100k plus in fees and interest is a great idea, esp when all it really does is keep people poor.... maybe thats the idea?

ForbiddenColour · 29/09/2023 13:22

Even if the loans are written off the amount the repay can we significantly higher that what you borrowed. The fact that it’s such a lottery re what you will pay/not pay is what I see as most unfair. If you have wealthy parents you have the opportunity after graduation to see what job you land and make a call (if they are willing to help) on whether it should be paid off early or not. These calculations are plan5, assuming maximum tuition/maintenance (60,024 graduating after3 years), salary growth 5%.pa:, 40 years

starting salary: 25k, repayment 56,217 - balance written off

starting salary: 30k, repayment 117,176 - balance written off

starting salary: 40k, repayment 98,812 - paid off in 28 years

Dixiechickonhols · 29/09/2023 12:06

The scheme has changed this year so more will repay though. It kicks it at £25,000 and is over 40 years.
@Drdoomish that article makes good point about low min wage for most students - trying to cover high rent etc on £7.49 hour min wage. I know some employers pay more but not all.

Olderandolder · 29/09/2023 08:33

TizerorFizz · 29/09/2023 08:17

@TheLightProgramme Everyone seems to forget the huge expansion of the uni sector too. Millions of DC would not have got a grant years ago because they would not have got near a university! In the 70s, around 10% went. Now 45% plus. There clearly had to be rationing of funds.

It’s an interesting scenario that parents don’t want to pay for their Dc to go to uni but are happy for those who didn’t go to uni and get the salary uplift to pay. I do believe we have to accept paying but being told much earlier about costs so decisions can be made in good time.

The uplift isn’t worth the cost anymore.

People don’t want to pay because it isn’t worth it.

Its good people are finding that out and alternatives are emerging.

We seem to be well ahead of America on recognising this.

TizerorFizz · 29/09/2023 08:17

@TheLightProgramme Everyone seems to forget the huge expansion of the uni sector too. Millions of DC would not have got a grant years ago because they would not have got near a university! In the 70s, around 10% went. Now 45% plus. There clearly had to be rationing of funds.

It’s an interesting scenario that parents don’t want to pay for their Dc to go to uni but are happy for those who didn’t go to uni and get the salary uplift to pay. I do believe we have to accept paying but being told much earlier about costs so decisions can be made in good time.

TheLightProgramme · 29/09/2023 07:35

But now it is all loans-based with pretty high interest rates, why make them means tested?

Because loads of loans don't get repaid, they get written off, at cost to the government. So no, we don't want to subsidise the offspring of rich parents at taxpayer cost

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 28/09/2023 23:11

I said it was in Brighton. I didn’t say it was Brighton a university itself. And even if it was you have to think about 2nd & 3rd year accommodation.

lightisnotwhite · 28/09/2023 21:44

Its incremental though. I was on £28K and it was pretty much the full loan minus a couple of hundred. which was made up for by a Uni bursary

@comefromaway there's 7 halls between 6 -7 K and one thats 5K

Our halls (brighton.ac.uk)

Our halls

https://www.brighton.ac.uk/accommodation-and-locations/university-accommodation/index.aspx

Dixiechickonhols · 28/09/2023 13:35

lightisnotwhite · 28/09/2023 07:17

The maintenance loan is income based on household so being a single parent is neither here or there.
The cost of accommodation in Brighton or elsewhere is the same for everyone working, student or unemployed. The £6k required for halls leaves £3k disposable income -£76 a week for the 39 weeks they study.
I take it the parent was reasonably well off so didn’t get the full loan?

A single parent on £26000 is enough to stop child getting a full loan. That’s not well off.
I understand the thresholds haven’t moved for years so previously more would qualify for full loan.
Meanwhile loan rates haven’t increased at same rate accommodation costs have.
We had done the save a bit every month from young age and dc will have £9000. I’d naively calculated £3000 a year would be plenty!

Comefromaway · 28/09/2023 12:15

When you say they didn't take it into account at first do you mean that they also took the income of the non resident parent?

SFE works on household income so a single parent might be a very high earner and so their child will get minimum loan, they may have an ex who is a high earner but that income won't count so their child will get a higher loan amount. They may have a new partner in which case the step parent's income will be included in the assessment (this causes problems for many as the step parent may or may not be willing to contribute which is a whole other can of worms)

CrapBucket · 28/09/2023 11:46

Being a single parent definitely makes a difference. I am a single parent and SFE didn’t take it into account initially for my DS, he queried it, they revised it and he gets a much larger loan now.

Comefromaway · 28/09/2023 08:05

No, the parent earnt approx 20k per year plus has a younger child and £6k accommodation is what he’s paying in Sheffield. Brighton was between £200-300 per week minimum (well over £8k per year). It was London prices without the London loan weighting.

lightisnotwhite · 28/09/2023 07:17

Comefromaway · 27/09/2023 10:20

But now the gap between even just the cost of accommodation, before you've factored in any other costs whatsoever, and the maintenance loan is just astronomical. I literally don't understand what students whose families can't afford to just subsidise them to the tune of thousands of pounds a year are supposed to do. The sums just do not add up.

We were helping/advising a very talented young person from a single parent family as he was applying to study the subject my husband teaches. He found a great course in Brighton but the cost of accommodation in that area completely outweighed his maximum loan so he ended up applying to Sheffield instead.

I hear similar stories where young people are not applying to expensive cities such as Bristol or Durham regardless of their grades etc.

The maintenance loan is income based on household so being a single parent is neither here or there.
The cost of accommodation in Brighton or elsewhere is the same for everyone working, student or unemployed. The £6k required for halls leaves £3k disposable income -£76 a week for the 39 weeks they study.
I take it the parent was reasonably well off so didn’t get the full loan?

boys3 · 27/09/2023 23:32

Paradoxically less well off students are potentially in a better position as they are eligible for full maintenance grant and potentially additional bursaries etc.

although far less likely to be applying in the first place; and probably not having seen any great benefit (apols for the sarcasm) from that low household income for the previous 18 years. With that base threshold for the max maintenance loan also unchanged since 2008. Likewise the upper threshold has stayed pretty much the same as well.

Added to that (in England at least) the max maintenance is now around £1500 lower than it would have been if raised over the past few years in line with inflation.

The fact that over a quarter of unis (and nearer 1/3 in the Russell Group) now have foodbanks tells it own sad story.

jamimmi · 27/09/2023 22:58

Ds just gone into 3rd year. He's in Liverpool and gone back to halls as at £143 a week it's cheaper than renting as no bills and he can walk everywhere. We are just over the cusp for anything more than the minimum loan. Dh retired due to illness health in his first year and is on an occupational health pension. I work in the NHS at a band 7 level so pay is reasonable but not megabucks. We have Dd at sixth form . Now needs 180 a t rem.to get her to college ( the closest one) and on top of that we need to help ds who's rent isn't even covered by his loan. He worked all summer 40 hour weeks and has gone back exhausted so he has to ask us for less. His flat mates from Wales similar. parent income get £12000. It's only English students who are effected this way

redskytonights · 27/09/2023 15:22

vlo · 27/09/2023 12:58

Although it’s not even just ‘less well-off’ students is it – it’s anyone without an enormous amount of surplus income to support students (if you’re looking at £1.2k per month for halls at some unis).

Paradoxically less well off students are potentially in a better position as they are eligible for full maintenance grant and potentially additional bursaries etc.

It's the children from middle income families who can't afford to meet the full short fall required (particularly if they have more than one child at university at the same time), particularly with cost of living increases, that are squeezed out.

My DD is in Year 13 and an awful of her year are planning gap years to save (I'm not saying that saving for university is a bad thing, but it's not something that has been quite as necessary as it is now until comparatively recently).

vlo · 27/09/2023 12:58

Although it’s not even just ‘less well-off’ students is it – it’s anyone without an enormous amount of surplus income to support students (if you’re looking at £1.2k per month for halls at some unis).

vlo · 27/09/2023 12:55

MargotBamborough · 27/09/2023 12:48

Logically you are right, I know, but I lived in the UK until past the age of 30 and it feels super weird to me that my kids are British citizens but will most likely never live in the UK. We have absolutely no good reason to move to the UK the way things currently are, and even though I think going to their other country to study for three or four years and having a fantastic time in London or Manchester or Newcastle could be brilliant, it just doesn't make any financial sense whatsoever, does it?

Not going by this thread! If it gives anyone hope at all, I do know people currently renting in houseshares in Manchester ranging from £270–£370 per month for a room.

I suppose even they decide to go elsewhere, it’s nice to have studying in the UK as an option for them!

Really shocking about halls prices, especially given the amount people pay in tuition fees nowadays. There should absolutely be rules preventing less well-off students from being priced out of higher education.

MargotBamborough · 27/09/2023 12:48

vlo · 27/09/2023 12:46

Not the point of the thread I know, but why would you bother anyway when there are so many excellent universities in the EU, many charging only nominal fees?

I think growing up in a bilingual household and with the general exposure to English people get generally living in Europe, they would be fine anyway.

Logically you are right, I know, but I lived in the UK until past the age of 30 and it feels super weird to me that my kids are British citizens but will most likely never live in the UK. We have absolutely no good reason to move to the UK the way things currently are, and even though I think going to their other country to study for three or four years and having a fantastic time in London or Manchester or Newcastle could be brilliant, it just doesn't make any financial sense whatsoever, does it?

vlo · 27/09/2023 12:46

MargotBamborough · 27/09/2023 10:37

I live in the EU and my kids were born here. They are only very young but I am already having to think about whether to put them through bilingual private school, which is considered more or less essential if you want your kids to have the opportunity to do their higher education in an English speaking country, or just go with the local school system.

My eldest won't be university age for another 16 years and I'm already thinking, what's the point? Even without now having to pay international fees instead of home fees, the cost of going to university in the UK would be unaffordable so why even take that possibility into consideration?

Not the point of the thread I know, but why would you bother anyway when there are so many excellent universities in the EU, many charging only nominal fees?

I think growing up in a bilingual household and with the general exposure to English people get generally living in Europe, they would be fine anyway.

RadishesForYou · 27/09/2023 10:45

To answer your question, because we always pick on the vulnerable ie. the young, the infirm, the elderly. It's way easier than doing the right thing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread